The manga should've stopped after Chapter 116.
Everything that happens after Chapter 116 should've been a spin-off.
I would given the manga a solid 9, if it wasn't for the post-116 chapters.
Chapter 116 was a great ending and should've stayed that way.
Now for everything before chapter 117...
[SPOILERS]
...
Alternative TitlesSynonyms: To You, the Immortal Japanese: 不滅のあなたへ More titlesInformationType: Manga
Volumes: Unknown
Chapters: Unknown
Status: Publishing
Published: Nov 9, 2016 to ?
Demographic:
Shounen
Serialization:
Shounen Magazine (Weekly) Authors:
Ooima, Yoshitoki (Story & Art) Statistics Ranked: #3242 2 based on the top manga page. Please note that 'R18+' titles are excluded. Popularity: #136
Members: 106,284
Favorites: 4,047 Available AtResources | Reviews
Filtered Results: 35 / 40
Sort
Your Feelings Categories Dec 3, 2016
When originally writing this, upon seeing that this very interesting manga had no reviews I couldn't resist posting one. I'll try my best to not reveal too much information as you have to read for yourself to find the reasons this manga is unique.
Story: (8/10) Basically some sort of magical object made by some over powered being takes form of other objects in its surroundings. I know, it's weird at first to think about but hear me out. What if this object takes the shape of a human? What if this inhumane immortal being learns to become a human? Well, of course he does. The main ... Sep 10, 2017
[MINOR SPOILERS] Chapter one and general story-line.
-------------- -------------- -------------- -------------- The Main character is immortal and can transform into others. His existence is a mystery. ------------------------------------------- STORY: (9/10) ... Dec 6, 2021
This might contain light spoilers.
I was initially motivated to read this manga because I saw it got an anime adaptation that looked pretty interesting. The story started off strong; I was drawn into the world + the characters and watching how the immortal protagonist developed as a result of the events and people around them. But it went downhill after a particular arc with one of the main antagonists... and then it just kept going downhill because the author decided that antagonist should have decedents that continually harass the protagonist throughout the ages and the protag is like: "Hm, this is kinda weird and uncomfortable ... Dec 30, 2016
*This review contains only spoilers of the first chapter of the manga, also, english it's not my native language, so I apologize for the mistakes.*
''Fumetsu no Anata e'' it's, easily, one of the most weirdest mangas I have ever seen, and I don't tell that because it's something weird in a bizarre or crazy way, no, I'm talking about something with a premise and plot so... new, that it's so fascinanting to find. History starts with someone sending this thing on Earth, and the Thing takes with the time, the form of objects like a rock, moss, and even a wolf. When the thing transforms ... Feb 22, 2020
This review might contain light spoilers.
For some reason, I have a hard time liking Ooima Yoshitoki's works. The details in To Your Eternity are beautifully drawn (although I'm not a fan of her art style), and she is able to immerse you into her story's interesting world, with her many diverse characters, but I don't think this is my kind of story. I feel like she's overusing tropes that bring sadness and emptiness into the readers. There's nothing wrong with a story that makes you cry and think deeply about life; in fact, I love them, but, to me, this kind of story where the ... Apr 28, 2017
Hello, this is my first review. So far, I've made it to chapter 22. Hopefully, my review won't have spoilers.
(POSSIBLE SPOILER? HEADS UP ON WHAT YOU CAN EXPECT) First, some heads up on what you can expect. Heavy tragedy, more of storytelling through pictures, but that's only because of main character as he/she/it doesn't talk much. IMO, this manga is kind of like a collection of one-shots that come together. So do keep in mind about this, it's like there are several mini arcs. (POSSIBLE SPOILER? DONE) Story 8/10 The story was a bit slow at first, but what kept me gripping on was wondering what ... Jan 8, 2024
Its really good, the only people who are saying it falls off or thinks the rest as filler; don't like it because it changes tone and pace after reaching the climax and cant follow the rest of the narrative and realize that its actually still telling a story and isn't finished... that its only leading into the final arc. It's not perfect and can be a bit corny at times, but its really good and doesn't try and take the same boring bleak overdone attitude of eternity and life that other story's and themes do.
The Art is great. The Characters are amazing. And as an adventure manga ... Jun 20, 2017
It's another potential masterpiece from the creator of Koe No Katachi!As a disclaimer, this is my first review.
First of all, the story starts off with a clear and simple concept which is later developed and becomes more and more intricate with more details explained. As a weekly reader, I can honestly say the story is interesting and leaves you wanting more and more... Though, I have to warn you it has it's fair load of feels as it is a tragedy. The story is suspenseful and emotional although it doesn't rely heavily on plot twists, when they're used they're logical. The story itself is moving ... Jan 29, 2021
A pretty good manga if you end it at around chapter 100 (Modern day arc) would have given it a whopping 8-9/10 even if art was somewhat flimsy.
Story 5/10 The story by itself is fantastic - drama(check), supernatural(check),seinen(check),shounen(sadly a check here too). Originally it's a shounen manga but while it contained and contains naivety it's started out as mysterious dark and grimm (would not expect from shounen), scenes of violence and etc. Some philosophical inducing questions are questions and are arisen. Development of the story goes on without the end, you just don't see it stopping for the reader idle moments are usually time skipped (time ... Sep 3, 2020
I absolutely loved A Silent Voice, so when I saw this manga, I just had to read it. After I caught up to the recent chapters, I felt so many emotions, happiness, excitement, satisfaction, worry, curiosity, and many others. While my life was feeling so grey and boring, this manga filled it back with colors. I love all of the characters, every single one of them. The art is phenomenal and has so much detail, and the story never ceases to amaze me. There were several times where the plot progression was slow, but it kicked back into overdrive in a few chapters. If you're
...
Sep 1, 2021
This manga is the exact definition of spreading yourself too thin.
The first chapter was like: WOW The next chapters were like: good The current chapters are like: ok.. Fumetsu no aiba to me is a very weird manga. It starts off super strong and then just kind of dwindles down over time. Seriously, few chapters in any manga have made me cry as much as the first chapter, but its all downhill from there. So what are the manga problems. First, the theme. Youve got an immortal who can never die and can bring people back to life. Once that is set, its hard to feel sad when any ... Mar 1, 2018
As expected of Yoshitoki Oima, author of "A Silent Voice", her current work is a moving and emotional story that's quite unlike anything else. It's story full of tragedy but it isn't without its share of laughs and heartwarming moments. If you want to read a fantasy that doesn't feel like something you've already seen before, do give this manga a try!
The story follows the life of Fushi, an immortal that we don't fully understand yet. It tracks its growth and development, and the questions it asks itself the more it learns. What sort of actions will a being that imitates humans take when ... Dec 23, 2020
Review mainly consists about the first 116 chapters.
I should start off by saying that this is my first published review on this site and it won't be the most detailed. (Spoilers ahead) Story, first arc only aka until chapters 116. (9/10) We can call it the first chapter charm. The first chapter was beyond perfect and it reflected exactly what it wanted. We follow the story of a form that was sent to earth. It is able to be anything it wants given enough stimuli. It's a sad, bittersweet story focused on existentialism, grief and emotional growth. As the story goes we are ... Apr 27, 2021
This review will just be whether or not you should read this manga. Other reviews go over the plot and whatnot a whole lot better than I do, but I want to address what you might have seen about chapters 116 and beyond.
There the story takes a huge shift in setting and characters. Having read up to the most recent chapter I could find, chapter 141, I can say that I can still thoroughly enjoy this manga as it continues on. Now there is a lot of stuff going on that is a bit difficult to understand, but that's sort of part of the ... Jan 4, 2018
Before you read this manga, you need to know why you want to read manga.
If you simply want to be entertained and expect a good laugh, this manga is DEFINITELY NOT for you. On the other hand, if you want to know the importance of life and values with a bunch of ANNOYING ONIONS in nearly every chapter then this is DEFINITELY FOR YOU. The best indicator of you loving or hating this manga will solely be based on the "1st chapter" 1) LOVE IT? Keep reading 2) HATE IT? Stop reading 3) LOVE IT, but hate the fact that you just cried on the first chapter? I don't know ... Jun 19, 2023
Look buddy, listen up pal, I don’t want to hate it. I really don’t. I actually quite liked it for 100 chapters or so. But then, the bad times came. Never have I read something that instantly made me hate it as much as this did. It just becomes shit. Full on stinky, smelly, wet, sloppy dog shit.
If you have the misfortune of reading this manga, please stop before chapter 119. Please. The only reason it gets a 2 is because I liked the first part. Without spoiling, it manages to completely lose all stakes, embrace a bunch of shitty tropes, and overall lose ... Dec 27, 2018
Recently while reading manga, I start thinking of what I would score it as I read.
For this, it would be something like this: Chapter 1: easily 9/10, unique premise, interesting sense of otherworldiness yet realistic/natural-feeling - can't wait to read more. The narration is interestingly fitting instead of offputting, and helps set the tone of the chapter. Even as a one-shot it is an amazing chapter. 2-30+: easily continues to 9+/10, really grasps me with with the story, character development, interactions, feels and unpredictability. Has me truly invested in and worried for the wellbeings of the characters. The character growth of the immortal Fushi is amazing, but ... Jan 12, 2018
I have been pleasantly surprised by reading this. At first, it was because it was the work of author of Koe no Katachi, and I just came across of it by accident. But the storyline really drew me in and so I have read.
The first chapter itself is very unique and it shows the aura, the pace and what type of story it will be: filled with loss and tragedy, but also becoming human and learning how to be one. Because, you see, our main protagonist is actually a sphere that's adaptating to it's surroundings. First, it was an orb, then it became rock, then ... Apr 20, 2021
About the period between chapters 1 - 116:
This is art. Fushi's learning process about what is the world around him, about what are the living beings that make up this world and what is in fact a living being is beautiful and very well told. The bonds he forms with humans that become important in his journey are bonds that become part of the reader, especially when Fushi realizes that they are all passengers and that he must draw some conclusions from them that will influence his development as a person and not merely be a mere living being. This manga period ... |