Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (9) « First ... « 3 4 [5] 6 7 » ... Last »
Dec 21, 2010 3:24 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
360
Shelduck said:
I'm actually glad it's over.

I really liked this anime in the beginning. It's been a while since I've seen a slice of life anime with a brother and a sister as main characters WITHOUT blatant incest. I mean, I have nothing against it, but, you know. It gets old.

But after every passing episode, I came to hate Kirino more and more. I mean, seriously? She's a star athlete, a novelist with her own anime series, top of the class and a model, all without ever studying or practicing. Wut? Plus, she's a bitch. A complete, utter bitch who needs anger management for constantly beating up her brother for no fucking reason at all. She is not cute in any way, shape or form. Yet, she has friends and her brother is amazingly nice to her. Seh doesn't deserve them, not one bit.

The most annoying thing? If she were a boy, beating up her older sister like this, there'd be a shitstorm. But oh, since she's a GIRL, it's all fine and dandy, all tsundere and cute. GUH.

Well, I'm at least glad the siblings didn't end up together, that would've sucked. As it was, the ending... was really weird and random. I mean, wtf, America? Why? WHY was she too embarrassed to show that? Why didn't the parents see it necessary to inform her brother that she was leaving? WHAT.

Also, Kyousuke's face at the end scares me, truly. I mean, just yesterday he was complaining that the life counseling or whatever was going to continue, and now, suddenly, he's BLUSHING?

Eh. It was an okay series, and I really liked some character designs. Also, the first three episodes or so were great.

I'm going to watch the specials, because I'm curious, I admit.
^Best post.

If I knew Japanese, I would attempt to write in Romaji "There is no way 'My Little Sister' is better than a 4"

Of course, I will watch the specials myself, since I think there is a 1% chance that they might actually present a better story than the failure of a plot that this show tried to pull out of its rear end.

Kirino is a utter disgrace to anime fans. Never have I seen a character so clueless, cruel, and ungrateful for the people around her. If she were the villain of the show, and the show was about how society beats down on ingrates like her, we would have a much better story.

Anyone who rates this show higher than a 6 needs their head examined. Now.
Dec 21, 2010 4:09 PM
(Gamer)

Offline
Aug 2009
2792
Pretty normal ending...






Dec 21, 2010 5:12 PM
Offline
Nov 2010
235
Overall rated series about 7. At first gave an 8 but then realised it really doesn't have anything particularly memorable. A refined product that scored points in other places like OP changes etc, but writing is not as tight or smooth as it can be.

Don't believe a plot is absolute necessary in slice of life shows, or for that matter characters must change to be considered development. Relationship change is enough. (on a related note, in the typical shounen trash where the lead start off at 0 then ended up somewhat useful is NOT plot/character development) I tend to view inconsistencies in a character's behaviour as positives in story telling, after all it shows depth and people are not mathmatical forumulas. As long as there's a context so the behaviour is not entirely random.
Dec 21, 2010 6:11 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
360
The thing is, Kirino exhibits basically zero development. Nothing changes. She still is irrationally cruel to everyone around her, especially her brother who slaves away feeding her unhealthy anime obsession. Kirino's behaviors like telling her brother to get run over a truck, kicking him in the balls, and saying every other thing he does is gross has no logical purpose in this show. It's simply an extremely bad choice on the execution of the premise.
Dec 21, 2010 6:52 PM

Offline
Apr 2010
53
Yumekichi11 said:

8th_Sin said:
In the end, it really was a "Good End" (part of the title of this episode) where they both consciously realized that they like each other.

I think it was more a Good End because Kirino never went to the USA and thus she was able to be with everyone. That would make a "good" thing for her. Remains to see in the second season how Kirino will be when she would return from the USA.

That's a possible interpretation too. Either way, it was quite rushed but summarized the ending pretty well IMO, will be looking forward to the "True End" for more complete ending.


8th_Sin said:
The "True End" would probably where Kirino goes to the airport and Kyousuke chase her or even chase after her in America lol
If Kyousuke chases her in the USA, that would be epic but the problem is, how will USA take their relationship? Aren't the laws there in regards to incest more severe than USA?

I meant chase after her and drag her back.
Haven't read the light novel, but I didn't get the impression that this was an incest series in any way (though there were couple of mishaps lol). If this turns into incest in additional season or in alternate endings, I'm prepared to instantly reduce 3 points to my vote score -_-;;

De-JaY said:

wat?

ROFL! Translation gone really wrong. It was actually "Did your collection grow?"
Dec 21, 2010 7:01 PM
Offline
Oct 2010
213
This ain't Amagami. The Good End wasn't a "boy-gets-girl" ending. The True End won't be either.

Just a heads up.
Dec 21, 2010 7:02 PM
Offline
Aug 2010
132
good ending i hope they don't trash it with the other ending i hope the other ending has some definite kuroneko X kyuo-chan closer like a kiss best line of the whole episode was oh well i will be calling him some different soon... lmao
Dec 21, 2010 7:06 PM

Offline
Feb 2009
30
I like the end, but i think the "final problem" was solved to fast.
But i really liked the scene that the game says what Kirino want to say xD

Lelouch FTW
Dec 21, 2010 7:48 PM
Offline
Nov 2010
235
A2ZOMG said:
The thing is, Kirino exhibits basically zero development. Nothing changes. She still is irrationally cruel to everyone around her, especially her brother who slaves away feeding her unhealthy anime obsession. Kirino's behaviors like telling her brother to get run over a truck, kicking him in the balls, and saying every other thing he does is gross has no logical purpose in this show. It's simply an extremely bad choice on the execution of the premise.


I see different interpretations everywhere, and I'll simply state myside:

1. Kirino exhibited zero development, I agree there. Her kinder moment in the last couple episodes are temporiarly, nor I think the show is TRYING to convince people otherwise. What has changed however is the relationship between her and Kyousuke, because at least for Kyousuke there's better understanding of Kirino's feelings.

2. Kirino is not cruel to everybody - she certainly knows her place in front of dad, and she is a normal friend to Ayase/Kanako, and totally frank around Saori/Kuroneko. She is cruel to Kyousuke however not irrationally (note the magnitude is up to taste) since there's always a trigger, it is never random. Logic is irrelevant in inter-personal relationships, afterall to like someone defies logic/normal conventions. If your parents do things for you only because LOGICALLY they want you to look after them in retirement, how would you view the relationship thus?

Whether this show is incest or not depends on the interpreation of this term, which may vary from the legal interpretation. The show is never going to ended up with a penetration openly or implied. However does ultra-possessive behaviour or demand exclusiveness in each other's relationships classify as incest? To that end brocon/siscon show is more appropriate.
Dec 21, 2010 9:05 PM

Offline
Dec 2008
370
I'm silently laughing at the fact that people are raging over the inconclusive ending knowing full well that this isn't the actual end of it.

I was surprised that she actually chose to stay given how that last interaction in Kirino's room went. It's kind of a shame how big of a tsundere the whole family is since it pretty much messes up any effective communication between the members; Kirino and Kyousuke really need to be more honest and open about how much they value each other now, especially considering how much they've gone through over the last nine months (most of which wasn't animated IIRC). I would have liked to see what was in that album though.

When were the dates for the release of the True End? I haven't been this excited for another OreImo episode since the first three.
Will I fall in love someday? I wonder?


Dec 21, 2010 9:19 PM

Offline
Jul 2010
2286
I was even sure though but this episode confirmed it 100%.. Kyoske is mazo (masochist).. I feel sorry for Manami-chan.

Episode start was unexpectedly good until last few minutes when Yandere Sado sister start beating her Mazo brother and wanted him to stop her from going to america.

Poor Manami, you need to take classes from Isurugi Mio to get Kyo-chan from his not cute sister.
Dec 21, 2010 9:29 PM

Offline
Jul 2010
2286
A2ZOMG said:
Shelduck said:
I'm actually glad it's over.

I really liked this anime in the beginning. It's been a while since I've seen a slice of life anime with a brother and a sister as main characters WITHOUT blatant incest. I mean, I have nothing against it, but, you know. It gets old.

But after every passing episode, I came to hate Kirino more and more. I mean, seriously? She's a star athlete, a novelist with her own anime series, top of the class and a model, all without ever studying or practicing. Wut? Plus, she's a bitch. A complete, utter bitch who needs anger management for constantly beating up her brother for no fucking reason at all. She is not cute in any way, shape or form. Yet, she has friends and her brother is amazingly nice to her. Seh doesn't deserve them, not one bit.

The most annoying thing? If she were a boy, beating up her older sister like this, there'd be a shitstorm. But oh, since she's a GIRL, it's all fine and dandy, all tsundere and cute. GUH.

Well, I'm at least glad the siblings didn't end up together, that would've sucked. As it was, the ending... was really weird and random. I mean, wtf, America? Why? WHY was she too embarrassed to show that? Why didn't the parents see it necessary to inform her brother that she was leaving? WHAT.

Also, Kyousuke's face at the end scares me, truly. I mean, just yesterday he was complaining that the life counseling or whatever was going to continue, and now, suddenly, he's BLUSHING?

Eh. It was an okay series, and I really liked some character designs. Also, the first three episodes or so were great.

I'm going to watch the specials, because I'm curious, I admit.
^Best post.

If I knew Japanese, I would attempt to write in Romaji "There is no way 'My Little Sister' is better than a 4"

Of course, I will watch the specials myself, since I think there is a 1% chance that they might actually present a better story than the failure of a plot that this show tried to pull out of its rear end.

Kirino is a utter disgrace to anime fans. Never have I seen a character so clueless, cruel, and ungrateful for the people around her. If she were the villain of the show, and the show was about how society beats down on ingrates like her, we would have a much better story.

Anyone who rates this show higher than a 6 needs their head examined. Now.


Quote for Truth... Tsun Tsun sister do not deserve Heroine title but a villain/antagonist intead.. I really liked first episode and then BECAUSE OF KIRINO it got annoying and annoying. i'm also glad this series ended.

6/10 for Kuroneko, Manami and good music.
Dec 21, 2010 10:13 PM

Offline
Sep 2009
136
In the end OreImo really looks like harem.
I'm vote 4 AyasexKyosuke nya~
Dec 21, 2010 10:23 PM

Offline
Aug 2008
3391
Well wasn't that bad. At least the God Ending didn't contained blatant incestuous undertones -okay let's face is better to call them brocon or siscon flags- as I thought it would contain. Besides that "Life Counselling isn't over" and "Ok" response everythign else was pretty fine. First let's give his response an analysis.

It was an obvious happy reply. He was happy 'cause Life Counselling isn't really over yet. But why? Why he has that reply? 'Cause he's overjoyed he can still hang out with her sister and give her advices, which in the first place brought them closer. Of course this view can be branched into a pair of possibilities: 'cause he simply loves to have her attention and HELP her. Or the other, cause he LOVES her and is simply happy to be part of her life, thus him having a siscon. Of course all of this is subjective. We can't really have a decent answer to this question unless we ask themselves about it... Of course it's not possible so we should be okay with what happen. But I admit I was surprised by his expression.. and a bit grossed out...

That said I can move on with the rest of the episode n_n...Which wasn't bad either good... at least the last episode comedic scene did it pretty well... No idea why they needed to introduce it but it was a really nice way to work out the later dramatic scene.

It's good to see that Kirino changed a bit since then and is far more concerned about what everyone else thinks about her.... I do agree it was a rare view still show us that she was that caring attitude and that she can worry over her friends. She recognises them as so and really looks after them. Of course it's good to know that she cares a lot for Kyosuke.

The subsequent scenes of Kyosuke socializing with Ayase and having a phonecall with Saori were well, not entirely pointless since they were just to ask them what's up with Kirino and why she changed so much, but still felt fillerish, tho it was so cute to see Manami again... Wosh... I can't get enough of her! xD Seriously she's so cute! And acted like that around Ayase >< Lol at Ayase brushing off Kyosuke so harshly infront of Manami... Oh and Saori's call was awesome "Nyoro~~n" (LOL) and "You love your sis right?" Part so awesome xD

The whole go get me a midnight release siscon erogame was so funny starting with his reactions. "Are you serious that you're going to make me buy this thing!" "What about dad!" and the game's title "There's no way I'd still my brother's pantsu" are so damn funny. But definitely what got the spotlight in this episode was the incident in the line and the freaking cover of the Yaoi eroge. LOL at Kyo and Akagi getting the claps from the fujoshi ladies... I can't imagine what are they thinking... the irony is that they were arguing over that possibility hahahahaha.And the BL eroge Cover... WTF! Anyway you look at it it's so damn wrong... It's totally unbelievable... seriously... now that I had a while to stare at it and look into it's details I just couldn't believe it's existence... LOL I can't imagine what could that game be about... but it's worth a good loud laughs xD (Uber pumped up guys showing off and touching each other xD)

It was a really kewl way to start off the drama... Uneasiness to give him a call, instead receiving a call from him and looking out to see him waving a hello to you... It was kinda sweet. Yet the drama ensued from there on was pretty intense... from the let's play it together! to the hey I wanna show you something that's quite dear to me yet embarrasses me a lot and him discovering she's leaving to America. I wasn't really surprised but still was such a powerful news to Kyosuke that it really freaked him out a lot...

It was an okay reason... Hey after all you're the ace athlete of the team and your coach offers you a paid Coaching Abroad makes some sense. still it was so sudden that no one really knew beforehand... not even Ayase which doesn't surprise me that much. Still mom and dad knew... Well that's okay. But it really took Kyosuke off guard and the eroge givin out the flag was so funny... but hey Kyosuke is right. it's not something that should matter him plus it's her life so she should go whenever she wants and for whatever she needs to or want to. Doesn't matter to him, and can't do that much since the flight is on the morning! So his reply for her, imo, is obvious and there's nothing else you could do besides letting her go. She was asking for him to say to not go... But Kyosuke is not entirely stupid. He made the right choice

Yet after having her switch on dere, she violently snapped and turned into her tsun side! Dammit, we couldn't rest even an episode of her tsun side! Not even Manami's episode! she turned it on and beat the crap out of the poor Kyosuke... I do agree it's a Fall trend... Beating the male leads... First Tsukasa, now Kirino... WTH! xD She really beat him into a bloody pulp... poor Kyosuke. That head butt certainly made him chew his own tongue thus bleed like crazy like we saw on those tissues... dang it Kirino you bitch....

And so she decided to stay... Now I get why it's a good ending. 'Cause everyone knows of Kirino's hobby and everyone's alright with it and Kyosuke is still helping her out... Not such a bad closure still feels like something's missing. Seriously feel like something else could have happened... Plus Kuroneko hinting that she could call Kyosuke in a different way... Tsuntsun dad is tsun.... and oh my goshness! Kuroneko neko posses were so cute... but I couldn't help it and laughed hard at her little sisters... they were so embarrassed xD Good closure... for a fake ending...

Signs,
Green
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Dec 21, 2010 10:40 PM

Offline
Jul 2010
2286
rebwaters said:
It was an obvious happy reply. He was happy 'cause Life Counselling isn't really over yet. But why? Why he has that reply? 'Cause he's overjoyed he can still hang out with her sister and give her advices

'Cause he was overjoyed, so his sister can beat him with 4 punches, 2 kicks and 1 double flying kick in next Life Counseling.. Simple M need S. thats why he was very happy.
Dec 21, 2010 11:36 PM

Offline
May 2010
45
to be continued...
Dec 22, 2010 12:38 AM
Offline
Oct 2009
360
potplant said:
She is cruel to Kyousuke however not irrationally (note the magnitude is up to taste) since there's always a trigger, it is never random. Logic is irrelevant in inter-personal relationships, afterall to like someone defies logic/normal conventions. If your parents do things for you only because LOGICALLY they want you to look after them in retirement, how would you view the relationship thus?
What I should state is that logically speaking, Kirino's cruelty towards her brother is blatantly unnecessary and stupid. Take the times she constantly calls him gross. If it was a joke, the joke got old decades ago and simply isn't funny. If it was in some way trying to show some insight into the character, it didn't show us anything more than the fact that Kirino is stupidly irrational and clueless. Everything Kyosuke does is basically normal as hell. Do you truly expect me to say that it's believable that Kirino somehow doesn't get that? It's even more disgusting that Kirino never gives Kyosuke the chance to properly explain himself, and then she goes out of her way to seriously harm him.

Ore no Imouto shouldn't even be called a slice of life. It is so over the top irrational it really should be classified as fantasy or supernatural. Kirino's exaggeratedly flawed behaviors and the lack of any realization of those flaws really just has no place in slice of life.
A2ZOMGDec 22, 2010 12:42 AM
Dec 22, 2010 7:28 AM
Offline
Aug 2010
523
I'm waiting for the online caps.
Dec 22, 2010 8:07 AM
Offline
Nov 2009
1503
hope it doesnt end here :(
Dec 22, 2010 4:52 PM

Offline
Dec 2010
71
worst ending every im so sad i expected so much more from it.
- Marissa Chan!
Dec 22, 2010 5:06 PM

Offline
Aug 2010
3232
Not the ending I was expecting.

Meh, I am disappoint.
Dec 22, 2010 5:11 PM

Offline
Oct 2010
67
i enjoyed this episode although it did see a little generic but i cant figure out the reason why i think this. i think there is a great possibly of them making another half season running but i'm not an expel on this kind of stuff i just want the story to continue. to be honest this show is what got me interested in eroge so I'm glad i watched it.
Dec 22, 2010 5:54 PM
Offline
Aug 2009
173
Full on homo scene won best scene in anime that I've seen for the past year.
Dec 22, 2010 6:27 PM
Offline
Oct 2010
213
Guys, there's still the True End extra episodes. I assure you, it'll be much more satisfying than this one.
Dec 22, 2010 9:18 PM
Offline
Aug 2009
173
Maugomale said:
Guys, there's still the True End extra episodes. I assure you, it'll be much more satisfying than this one.

Those have no plans of coming out for another 6-7 months. 4 episodes on BD. Very long wait =/
Dec 23, 2010 4:34 AM

Offline
Oct 2010
9900
Citrix said:
Maugomale said:
Guys, there's still the True End extra episodes. I assure you, it'll be much more satisfying than this one.
Those have no plans of coming out for another 6-7 months. 4 episodes on BD. Very long wait =/
Not really , I heard it will be web-casted. Supposed to start around January 2011.

- BLOG - My Club- Easiest way to reach the rest of my thoughts!
Dec 23, 2010 7:46 AM
Offline
Oct 2010
213
Citrix said:
Maugomale said:
Guys, there's still the True End extra episodes. I assure you, it'll be much more satisfying than this one.

Those have no plans of coming out for another 6-7 months. 4 episodes on BD. Very long wait =/


Dec 23, 2010 8:43 AM

Offline
May 2010
644
well this ep was good enough, really loved kirino's reaction when playing an eroge LOL
enjoyed it all the way but i was slightly becoming sad when i realized there is no kuroneko and this is the final ep.. but all of a sudden i see the credit part and thought of the same as this one...........
Sartaj said:


I loved the credits too with the parents watching animu, and Kuroneko's neko poses in the mirror (anyone get a gif of that? It's glorious)

all in all great series, and kirino said "life counseling isn't over" so i dunno LOL
but more kirino and kuroneko would always be welcome together with all of em xP

and one things for sure, gonna have some times where i rewatch this ep just for the sole purpose of seeing those kuroneko poses again xP
PookxSumireDec 23, 2010 8:49 AM



~Nyaaa~


Dec 23, 2010 10:41 AM

Offline
Jul 2010
2286
by the way. last time i saw playing eroge together was tanaka and ohno from Genshiken. and tanaka was so embarrassed to play in front of ohno but he finally gave up.

I was wondering, what in the world a big brother can play a new Eroge with his sister, which he bought by himself. it completely seems from different genre, like something from aki-sora but oh well. Genshiken was great, atleast they had society morals, like Saki saying why Kousaka play eroge or Sasahra was afraid to open locker to check eroge or Oguie do not want to accept she like homos.
Dec 23, 2010 3:17 PM

Offline
Oct 2010
57
What began as a promising show about family relationships quickly devolved into a harem anime with all-too-familiar character archetypes. Thankfully, the last couple of episodes reminded me of why I originally loved this show. Overall, I wish it could have been much more, but it was a very entertaining ride nonetheless.
Dec 23, 2010 5:13 PM

Offline
Jun 2009
53
This episode had complete BS moments. I find it amazing that Kirino's mother and father never seem to make a big deal that she's model, novelist, and future anime show creator all while being underage. They know about her actions and the father does have some control over what she does, but their roles are very vague. The mother just makes fun of her kids while the father sits in his bathrobe all day reading the newspaper. Then Kirino's going to America and no one in the family bothers to talk about it? WHAT?!?! BS. I'm sure she asked her parents to keep it a secret from her brother, but that part of the storyline itself was too convenient.

Good show and I want a sequel, but it gets a plain 7/10 from me.
Dec 23, 2010 5:53 PM

Offline
Aug 2008
3906
Wow, I'm impressed.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Dec 24, 2010 1:57 AM

Offline
May 2008
4064
The Good Ending was good..
Kuroneko at the end was awesome.
Dec 24, 2010 2:03 AM

Offline
Mar 2009
1077
A decent "good ending", I can't wait for the BD eps!!

Urahara Out!!
Dec 24, 2010 3:21 AM

Offline
May 2010
101
She should've gone to America IMO. She should chase her dreams! She wouldn't be able to see her brother, bot that's not something you should stay for. Not if it's only temporary.
Though, maybe she didn't really want to go that badly in the first place and not getting along with her brother was one of her reasons to go... If that's the case, I guess she made the right decision.

Wonder how those "bad ending episodes" will turn out...
Dec 24, 2010 5:56 AM

Offline
Oct 2010
171
one of the best animes of the season, really touch me in a few ways.

Awesome series, deserves a 10 for me =)
Dec 24, 2010 2:15 PM

Offline
Oct 2010
152
A2ZOMG said:
potplant said:
She is cruel to Kyousuke however not irrationally (note the magnitude is up to taste) since there's always a trigger, it is never random. Logic is irrelevant in inter-personal relationships, afterall to like someone defies logic/normal conventions. If your parents do things for you only because LOGICALLY they want you to look after them in retirement, how would you view the relationship thus?
What I should state is that logically speaking, Kirino's cruelty towards her brother is blatantly unnecessary and stupid. Take the times she constantly calls him gross. If it was a joke, the joke got old decades ago and simply isn't funny. If it was in some way trying to show some insight into the character, it didn't show us anything more than the fact that Kirino is stupidly irrational and clueless. Everything Kyosuke does is basically normal as hell. Do you truly expect me to say that it's believable that Kirino somehow doesn't get that? It's even more disgusting that Kirino never gives Kyosuke the chance to properly explain himself, and then she goes out of her way to seriously harm him.


This how Kirino operates. She is very competitive, seeking to be to best at everything she does. That's why she is a star in so many aspects. But it also means that everything she faces is taken as a competitive challenge. So when Kuroneko first disparages Kirino's favorite anime, it triggers Kirino's competitive side. So Kirino retaliates just the same, and the rivalry is started. Kirino apparently also had thought for a long time that her brother didn't talk to her because he didn't like her. So naturally, she mimics the perceived attitude from her brother and tries to win that competition as well. She is full of pride.

Kirino calling Kyousuke "gross" is not a joke. It's just her acting like she thinks she's expected to act towards her brother. It's like the way young kids act like kissing is gross, or that the opposite sex has cooties, or that some classmates aren't cool because of their hobbies or because they try hard to do well in classes. For the most part, all the kids act that way because they feel social pressure from the other classmates to act that way. To do otherwise would subject them to getting their pride hurt.



Look at the way she acts towards Kuroneko. She has a friendly rivalry with her, both of them trying to ridicule each other to win some battle for dominance. But if Kuroneko ever gave in, for example by agreeing that Kirino's anime preferences really were better, Kirino would feel bad, and would start admitting some aspects she likes about Kuroneko's anime preferences.

Regarding the way Kirino acts towards her brother, she just feels she's supposed to act like her brother is just a worthless annoyance that she just "tolerates". It's a competition to see who can act more annoyed of the other. So when Kyousuke ever acts sincere and loving, she feels awkward because it's like he stopped competing, and she doesn't know how to react to that. It's uncomfortable for here to also put away her pride and "give up", so she hits or yells at him to put him back in "annoyed" mode.
TimofmarsDec 24, 2010 3:56 PM
Dec 24, 2010 3:11 PM

Offline
Jul 2010
2286
i like how fans trying to explain kirino's character and i wish if they get some ungrateful companion/sibling in real life, which call you "gross" when you try to help her, punch you on the face when you accidentally bump into her. she do something wrong like playing a porn game with high volume and when you say lower your voice, she call you a gross pervert. then i would really love to hear your explanations about her actions.

and I would also like to see a new anime called, "Ore no Otouto" where a younger brother beat out his big sister and kirino fandom reviews in episode discussion threads about how "cute" he is.
Dec 24, 2010 3:44 PM
Offline
Oct 2010
213
Tsuki-Hime said:
i like how fans trying to explain kirino's character and i wish if they get some ungrateful companion/sibling in real life, which call you "gross" when you try to help her, punch you on the face when you accidentally bump into her. she do something wrong like playing a porn game with high volume and when you say lower your voice, she call you a gross pervert. then i would really love to hear your explanations about her actions.

and I would also like to see a new anime called, "Ore no Otouto" where a younger brother beat out his big sister and kirino fandom reviews in episode discussion threads about how "cute" he is.


You're talking about "ifs" there, man.

The name of the show is called "Ore no Imouto". The plot's focus is on Kirino. Without her, it would make no sense. If you dislike her so much, why not just drop the anime and move onto the next one? No one is making you watch it!

And, if your reasons to keep watching are because you prefer another character, heck, then just grab a doujinshi and enjoy it. Nitpicking the main character's flaws is not gonna change the show's name, nor make your waifu's spotlight shine brighter.
Dec 24, 2010 5:48 PM

Offline
Jul 2010
2286
Maugomale said:
Tsuki-Hime said:
i like how fans trying to explain kirino's character and i wish if they get some ungrateful companion/sibling in real life, which call you "gross" when you try to help her, punch you on the face when you accidentally bump into her. she do something wrong like playing a porn game with high volume and when you say lower your voice, she call you a gross pervert. then i would really love to hear your explanations about her actions.

and I would also like to see a new anime called, "Ore no Otouto" where a younger brother beat out his big sister and kirino fandom reviews in episode discussion threads about how "cute" he is.


You're talking about "ifs" there, man.

The name of the show is called "Ore no Imouto". The plot's focus is on Kirino. Without her, it would make no sense. If you dislike her so much, why not just drop the anime and move onto the next one? No one is making you watch it!

And, if your reasons to keep watching are because you prefer another character, heck, then just grab a doujinshi and enjoy it. Nitpicking the main character's flaws is not gonna change the show's name, nor make your waifu's spotlight shine brighter.


I know its about a younger sister which supposed to be tsundere, but it turn out to be only tsun tsun, that's why i didn't liked her. and i know they are "ifs" but hope someone will get what i mean.

I have finished some shows where i hated main character the most but not the show itself, and thats the same reason i finished this. also i enjoy stuff which is related to otakus and i did like story concept, no incest brother/sister relationship and also other characters like kuroneko, saori, manami, ayase etc and that's the reason i rated it very fairly, otherwise it would have get 1/10 from me and now i come to think of it, after watching first episode i thought this is the most promising show of fall 2010. but after every episode kirino start to get on my nerve. (usually i don't hate tsundere chars, even if they hit the main character and sometimes i like tsundere chars, like misaka mikoto, hitagi senjogahara, heck even i liked ookami ryoko) but this is the most ungrateful, not cute character when she hit her brother or call him gross, i was hoping she will redeem herself in last episodes but there was a bucket full with tissues and blood of kyouske.

FYI. if the show was more than 12 episode, i would have dropped it after 7/8 episodes, when i start getting annoying and that's how i normally do.

And Still... I would like to see a new anime called, "Ore no Otouto" where a younger brother beat out his big sister and kirino fandom reviews in episode discussion threads about how "cute" he is.
Dec 24, 2010 6:20 PM
Offline
Oct 2009
360
Timofmars said:
This how Kirino operates. She is very competitive, seeking to be to best at everything she does. That's why she is a star in so many aspects. But it also means that everything she faces is taken as a competitive challenge. So when Kuroneko first disparages Kirino's favorite anime, it triggers Kirino's competitive side. So Kirino retaliates just the same, and the rivalry is started. Kirino apparently also had thought for a long time that her brother didn't talk to her because he didn't like her. So naturally, she mimics the perceived attitude from her brother and tries to win that competition as well. She is full of pride.

Kirino calling Kyousuke "gross" is not a joke. It's just her acting like she thinks she's expected to act towards her brother. It's like the way young kids act like kissing is gross, or that the opposite sex has cooties, or that some classmates aren't cool because of their hobbies or because they try hard to do well in classes. For the most part, all the kids act that way because they feel social pressure from the other classmates to act that way. To do otherwise would subject them to getting their pride hurt.



Look at the way she acts towards Kuroneko. She has a friendly rivalry with her, both of them trying to ridicule each other to win some battle for dominance. But if Kuroneko ever gave in, for example by agreeing that Kirino's anime preferences really were better, Kirino would feel bad, and would start admitting some aspects she likes about Kuroneko's anime preferences.

Regarding the way Kirino acts towards her brother, she just feels she's supposed to act like her brother is just a worthless annoyance that she just "tolerates". It's a competition to see who can act more annoyed of the other. So when Kyousuke ever acts sincere and loving, she feels awkward because it's like he stopped competing, and she doesn't know how to react to that. It's uncomfortable for here to also put away her pride and "give up", so she hits or yells at him to put him back in "annoyed" mode.
Think for a moment how ridiculously irrational of a character design that is. It's not even a question of naming qualities Kirino has. It's the fact it's all maintained for 12 full episodes and none of the characters seems to have a clue and just indulges Kirino for all of her bad behavior.

This isn't good storytelling. It's borderline fantasy, and it's washed up given how unrealistic the interactions are and how they just remain bad for the entire time. It's unacceptable when the setting is more or less one comparable to real life.

As corny as it sounds, a story needs a redeeming point, and it's something that Ore no Imouto fails to achieve with non-existent development and mind-bogglingly unreal character interactions. Your typical shounen has more realistic, relatable, and appealing characters and character interactions than Ore no Imouto, and that's not saying much given that there's only a few exceptional shounens.
A2ZOMGDec 24, 2010 6:30 PM
Dec 24, 2010 10:45 PM

Offline
Nov 2007
2086
This didnt feel much like an ending to me...but it was still a good episode and some dere Kirino moments were really, really hnnnnnnng inducing...

A good series overall 8/10

and now my review on it http://wp.me/pHKWD-t7
Dec 24, 2010 11:30 PM

Offline
Nov 2010
1310
You may know, you can see ending illustrations here at their official site. I thought these were drawn by laymen, but to my surprise, it seems they all are pros. Following addresses are their web sites I searched. Red ones are... over my threshold.
---
01 BunBun
02 Buriki
03 Na-Ga
04 Hidari (unfortunately no illustration found) --> book covers
05 MITSUMI Misato
06 AOKI Ume
07 UKI Atsuya
08 CHANxCO
09 Poyoyon Rock
10 ITOU Noizi
11 Wadarco
---
I became a member of MAL for this title , but the title was over and it is getting boring... I hope next term with tons of exciting titles (!?) would come soon. Maybe imouto would continue to be in a vogue for some time and it is welcome for me and Kirino.
Dec 25, 2010 12:30 AM

Offline
Dec 2010
17
Not quite satisfied with the ending =(

Oh well.. there's still 4 special episode coming soon to redeem themselves...hopefully the "true end" will be better...xD
Dec 25, 2010 12:38 AM

Offline
Oct 2010
152
A2ZOMG said:
Think for a moment how ridiculously irrational of a character design that is. It's not even a question of naming qualities Kirino has. It's the fact it's all maintained for 12 full episodes and none of the characters seems to have a clue and just indulges Kirino for all of her bad behavior.

This isn't good storytelling. It's borderline fantasy, and it's washed up given how unrealistic the interactions are and how they just remain bad for the entire time. It's unacceptable when the setting is more or less one comparable to real life.

As corny as it sounds, a story needs a redeeming point, and it's something that Ore no Imouto fails to achieve with non-existent development and mind-bogglingly unreal character interactions. Your typical shounen has more realistic, relatable, and appealing characters and character interactions than Ore no Imouto, and that's not saying much given that there's only a few exceptional shounens.


Hmm, I thought her character design (attitude) made total sense. It seems to be hit or miss on whether different viewers can relate to it. But for me, it came so naturally that I didn't have to think about it, and I was literally surprised to see people hating her. When people said they thought it didn't make sense that Kyousuke would continue to help her and take that abuse, my thought was why on Earth would they think he should stop? It may just be that I grew up with similar relationships.

I assume you guys are okay with the Kuroneko-Kirino relationship, right? Do you see that as a friendly rivalry, where both of them know not to take each others' insults to heart? Or do you see them as actually quarreling where it detracts from their friendship.



fancyfox said:
This episode had complete BS moments. I find it amazing that Kirino's mother and father never seem to make a big deal that she's model, novelist, and future anime show creator all while being underage. They know about her actions and the father does have some control over what she does, but their roles are very vague. The mother just makes fun of her kids while the father sits in his bathrobe all day reading the newspaper. Then Kirino's going to America and no one in the family bothers to talk about it? WHAT?!?! BS. I'm sure she asked her parents to keep it a secret from her brother, but that part of the storyline itself was too convenient.


The show is from Kyousuke's point of view. So the fact that Kirino's plans could be withheld from Kyousuke (and viewers) is easily believable. I just don't like how they didn't adequately explain what was going through Kirino's mind in the process. They didn't really show her beforehand trying to work up the courage to tell Kyousuke or anything. It's left to the viewer to guess. For example, I thought maybe she intended to tell him when she first asked him to come to her room, and then chickened out and said what she really wanted was a new eroge. And then there's the thing were she was going to show an embarrassing secret, the album, and then the plane ticket popped up. So... was that really what she wanted to reveal all along?

Regarding the parents not making a big deal about her, it was actually mentioned in the last episode how the father was mistaken for a pervert when he was trying to see Kirino working or something. Plus, not all parents are like that anyway. In my family, high grades and being a top athlete or anything you could do wouldn't get you praise. You know they're proud anyway even while they are modest about it.

It's sort of like how after Kirino thanks Kyousuke during the anime party, he says that he doesn't need or want to be rewarded with any thanks from Kirino. In other words, he knows his sister's thanks is already implied without needing her to say it or do anything in return.
TimofmarsDec 25, 2010 1:07 AM
Dec 25, 2010 1:47 AM
Offline
Oct 2009
360
I think the only reason Kuroneko and Kirino wouldn't take each others insults to heart is simply because of a mutual understanding of the complete lack of chemistry the two characters have.

There's a bunch of reasons why Kirino and Kyosuke's relationship is mind-bogglingly irrational. In the first place, Kyosuke in many ways really just doesn't give a damn about what Kirino does, so why does he suddenly care now? It's also frankly appalling how ungrateful Kirino is throughout the entire series. Then things like kicking him in the balls, asking him to get run over by a truck for the sake of research, and immediately accusing him of inviting his childhood friend over for sexual reasons was just so over the top despicable. It's just out of place and unreasonable how much empathy Kirino lacks around her brother.

It's also frankly baffling that Kirino plays games that even are supposed to represent the relationship she has with her brother, and yet it's as if she has no idea what's going on.

Honestly, Kirino's case is as simple as her having her cake and eating it too at the expense of others. She never shows remorse, or any sign of thinking outside of her own self interests. Now if Kirino was portrayed as a villain or anti-heroic protagonist where the majority of important characters acknowledge and appropriately react to her flaws, there wouldn't be as much of a problem. However this is not the case, and thus is why several people, myself included, consider her one of the worst characters in existence.
Dec 25, 2010 3:25 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
2555
Great episode! I was surprised that this was actually that good.

First 3 episodes were great, the middle was meh and the last couple of episodes were pretty fun.
This deserves a 7/10.
Kirino's still a bitch though.
But I don't hate her as much as before.
Dec 25, 2010 3:46 AM

Offline
Nov 2009
33
imo, the best anime of the season, i watched with great pleasure
so, i'm waiting for the blu-ray and an alternative ending :3
Dec 25, 2010 7:20 AM

Offline
Dec 2009
17
Disappointed. I want hentai OVA where Kyousuke went rampage, tortured kirino and all female chars except Manami. LOL!
Dec 25, 2010 9:19 AM

Offline
Oct 2010
312
THE ENDING EPI WAS NICE ! I hv nt read the manga. Can any tell me if there will be 2nd season to this anime .
Pages (9) « First ... « 3 4 [5] 6 7 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

» I love Kirino

EV222IL - Dec 2, 2016

3 by cjlouotaku416 »»
Nov 29, 11:21 PM

Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Kuro4735 - Nov 28, 2010

352 by PedroKarim64 »»
Nov 16, 3:00 PM

Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Kuro4735 - Nov 7, 2010

401 by PedroKarim64 »»
Nov 13, 2:13 PM

Poll: » Ore no Imouto ga Konnani Kawaii Wake ga Nai Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Kuro4735 - Oct 9, 2010

266 by shahzeb_hontouni »»
Oct 29, 12:58 PM

» The Otaku Perception

IssyBoy - Oct 10

11 by PatientPanda »»
Oct 17, 2:32 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login