almarue said:Futari_no_Ossan said:Er... so what really happened to Igogusa-chan? Is she dead or alive?
At first she was presumably dead --> Tsukijima killing his daddy --> Tsurumi fabricated lie to tell him that she was alive --> Tsukijima serving in the army for 9 years --> someone from his village told him she was indeed dead --> Tsukijima lashing out at Tsurumi --> Tsurumi admitted he did all that to keep Tsukijima alive and save his life --> at the end it looks like that soldier is in cahoot with Tsurumi. WAT?
Why going through all this trouble to deceive Tsukijima a 2nd time? He would've served Tsurumi obediently after knowing Igogusa was alive somewhere in Tokyo... this is what I don't understand...
Igogusa's fate is still in question but it doesn't matter anymore as Tsukishima has made up his mind to remain loyal to Tsurumi.
First, let's say that we believe in the first story that Tsurumi told about Igogusa-chan married to someone and currently living in Tokyo.
Tsurumi stated that he needed subordinate who spoke Russian and the military would value that person in order to prepare or the upcoming war and that man would be Tsukishima.
But was that enough to get Tsukishima out of jail? (According to Tsurumi, the answer was no)
So Tsurumi made a stage, tricking everyone in the village that he found Igogusa's remains buried under Tsukishima's father's house so that people would perceive that he deserved to meet his brutal demise, that Tsukishima was justified to kill him, thus making it easier for him to be released from prison.
But why didn't Tsurumi tell Tsukishima about this? It's probably that he didn't want to burden Tsukishima for more. Besides, Tsurumi's goal of making Tsukishima find back his will to live has been accomplished.
The soldier who told Tsukishima that Igogusa-chan was indeed dead was clearly ordered by Tsurumi. But why did Tsurumi think he needed to do so?
Tsurumi stated that he needed men who would do dirty jobs and ready to plunge into the depth of hell (men who would do terrible things that got nothing left to lose). Even after 9 years, Tsukishima was still tied with Igogusa's memory as he still kept Igogusa's hair. Maybe Tsurumi wanted to test his loyalty and bind him even more by letting him know how much effort he put in to get him out of jail. Even after knowing the story from the soldier, Tsukishima didn't lose it, though he got mad and demanded an explanation. Tsurumi knew right away that Tsukishima would be a great use of him so he tried to keep him alive by throwing him while Tsukishima tried to protect him, resulting in Tsurumi losing his frontal lobe.
Later, Tsurumi told Tsukishima that it was all an act to make it easier for getting him out of his death row and Igogusa-chan was alive and well with her family in Tokyo. And at that moment, Tsukishima believed this. What's left of Tsukishima now? First, he was grateful that Tsurumi saved his life but now that he learned how Tsurumi risking his position (by lying about Tsukishima's ability of speaking Russian) and the length he would do to get him out of his death row (by putting on an act) then saving him again by throwing his body which just happened, how could one not feel highly indebted?
Why did the letters stop coming? Was Igogusa alive or dead?
Why did Tsukishima's father spread the rumor about his death?
Did Tsurumi really dig up Igogusa's remains?
In the first place, was the story about Igogusa married and living in Tokyo really true?
WE DON'T KNOW. And Tsukishima doesn't either. They may be truths mixing up with lies and lies and lies until it doesn't matter anymore.
Tsukishima threw away Igogusa's hair as a symbol of leaving his past. Did he regret this? YES, HE DID. If you paid attention to how this story started, it began by Tsukishima warning Sugimoto not to lose his control or he would regret it in the future then a flashback of Tsukishima throwing Igogusa's hair. So, did Tsukishima learn the truth? Yes and no. It will be another story in the future.