The Asterisk War (light novel)
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| So the Festa's finally here. Ayato and Julis' battle was done so fast, sasuga. Still gotta love Kirin. Those puppets were pretty terrifying though, talk about strong. Great episode. |
  |
| nicely done ep, even though ayato-julis battle just too easy and way too fast ow also allekant's puppets, they're really strong and i hope ayato-julis met them soon |
 |
| Pretty good animation this week, actually liked how the first round was fodderized quickly. Robot's comedy took me by surprise but it worked well. Pretty fast episode imo, but one of the better setups. Looking forward to next weeks. |
| Big Order (TV):great anime or greatest anime? |
| Finally, it has begun! The Festa "tournament" xD It seems that the director of the festa created some new rules so that Aloqunt school can cheat.... The girl that was in jail and is now fighting is probably very strong.. Can't wait for the next episode! |
"There is no such thing as an Anime elitist. You watch Anime, therefore, you are trash by society's standards." |
Seepos said: How i got the feeling like using those puppets were kinda like cheating? Were that whole festival idea to get to know which school have strongest fighters, and then you put machines to fight. at least he kept his promise on not moving for a min lol |
 |
| Good episode, finally the struggles of Festa begin, I was eager to see the quality of adaptation about the battles, but I enjoyed of the fights, Ayato and Julis begun demonstrating superiority, but strong opponents already have been shown, I want to see how this adaptation will continue .. |
  |
| The female puppet is cuter than when i have imagined her while reading the LNs... :) Pls don't show Ayato's powering up scene for every episode.... Kirin <3 |
 |
| Have a feeling that vampire girl is just going to be that annoying crazy chick who seems super strong to anybody who doesn't know about her abilities and she gets all cocky and shit and has that attitude that only cares about fighting and bloodlust. Good to see CR is still spelling Allekant as Arlequint. Oh well, it's not like they're paid to be smart...or good at their job. |
| Not bad for the start of the Phoenix. I enjoyed the first fight for Ayato, and loved how they swapped the exposition of their Festa tactics for a conversation (though it sounded weird since it was a convo between themselves... like they were suppose to have already discussed it all way beforehand... would've been better as a flashback convo IMO). Ardi and Rimsi were great! I loved their Seiyuu voices, I was expecting Ardi to be a bit more comically deadpan but I'll take it. Rimsi's voice and attitude was perfect, just what I expected whilst reading the LN. Oh and yes Irene's introduction was good as well. We'll see enough of her in the next episode for sure. And the subbers really should go check up on the LNs. It's not really hard to find the correct names for every character and school. Reading the subs really rubbed me the wrong way. |
HESTIA   APPROVES |
Ryuutobi said: Jonesy974 said: I can forgive them for that, but not for the Galahadworth part. After all, unlike the other schools, Garrardworth's name was written on-screen in big latin letters in the first episode.Good to see CR is still spelling Allekant as Arlequint. Oh well, it's not like they're paid to be smart...or good at their job. Christ, forgot about that one too. Just like last week too they mentioned the Gryps festival and straight up changed it to Gryphon IIRC. They are literally butchering the shit out of these subs. It's funny, I'm watching Shinmai Maou too, and every episode has had a shit ton of spelling and grammar errors. Which I'm totally ok with, because I get that they're trying to sub it as fast as possible. And even though they may forget to put a space between words or leave out a letter or something, they always manage to get the terminology right. Like oh, they spelled "battle" as "battel" on accident. Ok, well at least they aren't misspelling names, places, weapons, spells, etc. CR dropping the fucking ball with this one. And there are so many sources to check from too. If anything they're actually making their job harder my coming up with some made up fucking word for the translation rather than using the correctly spelled word right from the source material. |
Jonesy974 said: CR dropping the fucking ball with this one. And there are so many sources to check from too. Don't blame CR, it's not their fault. Aniplex is responsible for TL as Asterisk is being simulcasted on both Crunchyroll and Daisuki. The thing is, Aniplex doesn't really care about quality. Daisuki has bad video and terrible font. It doesn't apply to CR, but they can't do anything about TL. |
SchwingBoner said: Oh yeah, finally the Festas. First fight ended way too quickly. Second one was definitely more interesting. Looking forward to seeing them fight the puppets.  These puppets talk too much. |
| god that episode was bad.... funny overpowered robots that are going to be destroyed in two episodes....no thanks |
 |
| is it just me or do the fighting scenes feel short? is it just strictly following the manga or A-1 saving money? i just want to see claudia ENFIELD fight please |
 |
ANA1979 said: is it just me or do the fighting scenes feel short? is it just strictly following the manga or A-1 saving money? i just want to see claudia ENFIELD fight please I'm not surprised that the fight scenes are short, considering that the tournament only just started. The later rounds and especially the last 32 should have much longer battles. =D The puppets have an amusing chemistry together, but Aldy's shield must be ridiculously tough if it can shrug off a powerful twister attack like that. Kirin was adorable once again, with her receiving a head rub from Ayato. Saya was fortunate enough to get a head rub as well, but her motto though, "Bigger is better.", just screams out MANY sexual innuendoes. My mind must be a little bit perverted today. >_< Looking forward to the next battles, hopefully involving Saya and Kirin. =D |
| Those puppets seem interesting, I want to see Yabuki and Claudia fighting. Too bad theyre not taking part. Still prefer Rakudai but glad Gakusen is finally showing its meat. (So did those guys die then??) |
| The episode becomes interesting when the Showdown on opponents' moves, before the narrative is a bit redundant showing the same old things, however, the pair Kirin and Saya remains one of the best. Overall the CG and the designs are as good as beauty, but you can do even better. The narrative is usable but there is still so much potential that can be exploited; the two puppets are fun, I would like them to stay as long as possible in the cast. |
terrablu2003Nov 29, 2015 8:27 AM
 |
| So the rumoured Festa began. Not bad for its first episode. The vampire girl is intriguing. Not interested in the robots. |
 |
| Not bad. Ayato seems to have a good plan in mind. But I wonder how long will it last. Not for very long i believe. Not a fan of the puppets. But i love that they have unique personality. Very intresting. And what the hell is up with that shield it is so damn hard. Can't wait for the next episode. |
 |
| I actually like the Robots and the side characters more than Ayato and the main cast. :/ |
| Those transparent things they were standing on during the speech are beyond retarded in design. I bet everyone was getting free upskirts of claudia |
 |
| Those puppets are quite powerful. I wonder if Ayato is going to be the one to take them down. ~Great episode!!! |
 |
| If Allekante can create puppets like that shouldn't Saya be able to do so too? Also, Saya best girl man damn. |
 |
| Hmm... Ayato defeats the enemy in seconds that his sword summoning thing is far longer than the battle itself. Kirin's cute scenes hnghh... Your weekly Kirin dose. Not too interested in the mecha robot guys. Too OP, but weird guys. |
 |
| wow I bet this can't get anymore generic than this episode. I already know how the next episode is gonna turnout. Well... FFS I even know how this is going to end... -_- I'm only watching this because of Kirin. Yet, I'm starting to think maybe it's not worth the time... It's pure averageness at most... |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Dragon_Slayer_X said: memphis23 said: wow I bet this can't get anymore generic than this episode. I already know how the next episode is gonna turnout. Well... FFS I even know how this is going to end... -_- I'm only watching this because of Kirin. Yet, I'm starting to think maybe it's not worth the time... It's pure averageness at most... Can you please enlighten people about how the next episode is going to turn out or how this is going to end? I mean it's easy to say "It's predictable lol" after seeing the episode itself so you really should say something in advance to show off your eliteness or stop making generic shitposts all together. Well... First of all, let me just say that I don't find predictability to be something 'genetically' bad. As long as the characters are done right, as long as the story and/or action is done right...even though you kinda predicted what was going to happen, you didn't spoil your own fun. Second of all, to respond to your question. The predictability in this anime is verified when you reach episode 9 and you realize that nothing substancial has really happened... So unless Gakusen pulls off what I call as a 'School Days', unless all the cast or story does a 360º flip in these last 3 eps remaining... You're just probably going to watch, at least, 2 out of the 3 eps filled with fights almost as boring as the ones in this episode(That's up to your own judgement ofc). Don't fool yourself... You already know who's gonna win. You already know that the end it's gonna turn out inconclusive (Like any other harem with a dense MC) with 0 confessions. Ayato is going to end up as the same OP White Knight shown at the 1st episode. And that's generic and average in my view. IMO, this show needed some spice in it, some actual development (especially on the MC himself and also his relantionship with all the girls). It needed something REMARKABLE (only Kirin is remarkable for me). But yeah, perhaps I was a bit harsh calling it "predictable" as I'm not a wizard from Ghana :) No one knows for sure, I would say this anime has a 0.001% possibility of surprising me... Maybe 'guessable' would fit better. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
memphis23 said: Well... First of all, let me just say that I don't find predictability to be something 'genetically' bad. As long as the characters are done right, as long as the story and/or action is done right...even though you kinda predicted what was going to happen, you didn't spoil your own fun. Second of all, to respond to your question. The predictability in this anime is verified when you reach episode 9 and you realize that nothing substancial has really happened... So unless Gakusen pulls off what I call as a 'School Days', unless all the cast or story does a 360º flip in these last 3 eps remaining... You're just probably going to watch, at least, 2 out of the 3 eps filled with fights almost as boring as the ones in this episode(That's up to your own judgement ofc). Don't fool yourself... You already know who's gonna win. You already know that the end it's gonna turn out inconclusive (Like any other harem with a dense MC) with 0 confessions. Ayato is going to end up as the same OP White Knight shown at the 1st episode. And that's generic and average in my view. IMO, this show needed some spice in it, some actual development (especially on the MC himself and also his relantionship with all the girls). It needed something REMARKABLE (only Kirin is remarkable for me). But yeah, perhaps I was a bit harsh calling it "predictable" as I'm not a wizard from Ghana :) No one knows for sure, I would say this anime has a 0.001% possibility of surprising me... Maybe 'guessable' would fit better. allow me to preface by just establishing that this is a super wishy-washy and obscure response. (this also applies to most complaints about this show being generic or whatever) i mean you didnt respond to dragon slayers question, even after saying "to respond to your question". did you realize you literally went off on a red herring and arrived at your original "predictable!!!!!!!!111111" claim through a circular argument? did you not realize that the animes current position is in the preliminary rounds of the tournament? i mean freaking duh theres going to be more fights its a fighting tournament genius. your prediction was just stating the obvious omfg everything you said was so obscure like "oh something i think is boring will happen". what? how about "saya and kirin will face the ais and win". you dont want to commit to any concrete predictions because you acknowledge that asterisk isnt predictable. ayatos not even that op btw he only won against kirin because he practically tricked her. she could beat him any time and reclaim the #1 ranking at seidoukan. isnt that enough to furnish the prospect of maybe them facing each other later on in the tournament and maybe even ayato and juliss defeat also stop throwing around "generic" and "average" too i feel like everyone speaks at the third grade level on this website because they just regurgitate what other people say. like i get how this show can seem predictable or "guessable" lol but come on, really? at least have a basis because its really obnoxious and inconsiderate to people who actually enjoy asterisk and look beyond its superficial shortcomings. youre just exacerbating the issue of bandwagon because EVERYONE calls this show "generic", to the point that attributing that term to this show is more of a trope than the actual ecchi. |
yuiyuigahama said: allow me to preface by just establishing that this is a super wishy-washy and obscure response. (this also applies to most complaints about this show being generic or whatever) i mean you didnt respond to dragon slayers question, even after saying "to respond to your question". did you realize you literally went off on a red herring and arrived at your original "predictable!!!!!!!!111111" claim through a circular argument? did you not realize that the animes current position is in the preliminary rounds of the tournament? i mean freaking duh theres going to be more fights its a fighting tournament genius. your prediction was just stating the obvious omfg everything you said was so obscure like "oh something i think is boring will happen". what? how about "saya and kirin will face the ais and win". you dont want to commit to any concrete predictions because you acknowledge that asterisk isnt predictable. ayatos not even that op btw he only won against kirin because he practically tricked her. she could beat him any time and reclaim the #1 ranking at seidoukan. isnt that enough to furnish the prospect of maybe them facing each other later on in the tournament and maybe even ayato and juliss defeat also stop throwing around "generic" and "average" too i feel like everyone speaks at the third grade level on this website because they just regurgitate what other people say. like i get how this show can seem predictable or "guessable" lol but come on, really? at least have a basis because its really obnoxious and inconsiderate to people who actually enjoy asterisk and look beyond its superficial shortcomings. youre just exacerbating the issue of bandwagon because EVERYONE calls this show "generic", to the point that attributing that term to this show is more of a trope than the actual ecchi. Since I don't particularly wanna do a whole review on this, I'm going to try saying what I think about this anime as brief as I possibly can. Let's divide this by parts... PREMISE: high school students compete with eachother, there's a ranking system, some ecchi/harem in it, yatayatayata.... It has been done inumerous times, it's a default premise, standard/average. But has I already said somewhere up the replies ^^^, something that starts off as 'generic' doesn't mean it's bad, otherwise I wouldn't have even bothered watching the very 1st ep. Generic, imv, means something vague. So eventually it's all about the paths that the anime chooses to take... Gakusen didn't even took the most critical/important 1st path: developing properly it's fkn Main Characther! And this is REALLY necessary in a action/fighting anime or movies. No one is properly developed. I don't hate this anime but I don't particularly like it, so it's average for me... 5/10 But I'm not going to drag this anymore, maybe I'll right a review on this, maybe not... Just let me say that a good way to try understand what I'm talking about is comparing Rakudai Kishi or even Highschool DxD to this anime. The 'foundations' are almost identical (in the case of Rakudai they are the same) YET those two did a way better job at 'glueing' me to the screen. And btw, I always have my own reasons to dislike or not dislike an anime. Didn't read a single review on this yet... I'm not a sheep broski :) |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
memphis23 said: Let's divide this by parts... PREMISE: high school students compete with eachother, there's a ranking system, some ecchi/harem in it, yatayatayata.... It has been done inumerous times, it's a default premise, standard/average. But has I already said somewhere up the replies ^^^, something that starts off as 'generic' doesn't mean it's bad, otherwise I wouldn't have even bothered watching the very 1st ep. Generic, imv, means something vague. So eventually it's all about the paths that the anime chooses to take... Gakusen didn't even took the most critical/important 1st path: developing properly it's fkn Main Characther! And this is REALLY necessary in a action/fighting anime or movies. No one is properly developed. I don't hate this anime but I don't particularly like it, so it's average for me... 5/10 But I'm not going to drag this anymore, maybe I'll right a review on this, maybe not... Just let me say that a good way to try understand what I'm talking about is comparing Rakudai Kishi or even Highschool DxD to this anime. The 'foundations' are almost identical (in the case of Rakudai they are the same) YET those two did a way better job at 'glueing' me to the screen. And btw, I always have my own reasons to dislike or not dislike an anime. Didn't read a single review on this yet... I'm not a sheep broski :) okay i have a really big problem with how you managed to disregard most components of my argument? also no im not fond of comparing shows to each other because it makes no sense. were not talking about rakudai or dxd; were talking about asterisk. this entire time youve been criticizing asterisk but you know theres this crucial fault in your argument: it lacks anything beyond a general statement. please consider what im saying. your claim is that there is no development for ayato. okay so what im saying then is that there is substantial development for him and im not gonna provide any evidence. without any examples from the anime i could literally say anything and insist that its the truth. i am going to provide proof of ayatos character development though. originally his intent in enrolling in seidoukan is ambiguous even to him but after meeting julis he decides that part of his purpose is to be there for her, which entails teaming up for the festa. hes also already really smart and adaptive in combat but constantly learns from people like julis and kirin regarding tactics (building on kirins example from when she destroys the core of the lizard creatures during his battle with the beast in the underground tunnels). its not substantial development because development isnt necessary for a character this is the thing that people dont get. static personality does not constitute a poorly written character. how would you want ayato to change if youre so set on "character development"? everything else youre talking about doesnt pertain to asterisk as an individual series either. youre like "another series glued me in this one didnt" okay so what????? this is infuriating. additionally you decided to break your response into parts and then provided a single part lol. you stuck with "premise" and didnt factor in animation art or sound. what the heck? |
| LMAO, Ayato spent more time taking out his sword than to win the actual fight. |
 |
| The puppets will make for a good fight. |
 |
| Meh, It started off pretty interestin g but I might drop this one. Next weekend's gonna be mighty boring. |
| Oh my god those 2 robots were hilarious! Why are people always griping with retarded specific expectations? So what if Ayato isn't well developed? Ayato isn't even really the "main character" he's the fulcrum for all the other actual main characters. |
❀桜舞う空〜 Cute is Power. 🔗CosmoGenesis Project “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.” “A truth seeker has no patience for BS.” I seek only to improve myself and others. |
| Saya again, being adorable this episode same with the cuteness of Kirin! Festa now starts and of course weak enemies turns into fodder. Allekants puppets are to damn OP! Why are they so freaking scared of the Lux of Ayato???!? is it beyond OP? 5/5. |
 |
| Those puppets were the best part of the episode. Aldy's VA was perfect. |
"Fortress Maximus has come himself. Okay! Then I shall get Fortress Maximus to fight me, huh huh huh!" |
| Need some one punch man up in there. Alright episode, not much to look forward to |
 |
| That opening felt like a cliff hanger. I guess they didn't have room to add it to the previous episode. Well, it was probably better this way considering the previous episode's many focus. |
| Give me at least 5 minutes to modify my post before quoting me. (refreshing page advised) |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Gakusen Toshi Asterisk Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Dec 19, 2015 |
203 |
by Neemesis_2
»»
Aug 22, 5:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Gakusen Toshi Asterisk Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Dec 12, 2015 |
119 |
by Neemesis_2
»»
Aug 22, 4:45 AM |
|
Poll: » Gakusen Toshi Asterisk Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Dec 5, 2015 |
111 |
by Neemesis_2
»»
Aug 22, 4:19 AM |
|
Poll: » Gakusen Toshi Asterisk Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Nov 21, 2015 |
117 |
by Neemesis_2
»»
Aug 21, 8:50 AM |
|
Poll: » Gakusen Toshi Asterisk Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Nov 14, 2015 |
123 |
by Neemesis_2
»»
Aug 20, 4:48 AM |