DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Reply to deltahalo241
Pretty good first episode, rather slow paced but a good introduction to the main characters.
Hana and Mizuki already have pretty great chemistry so I can't wait to watch that go absolutely nowhere
Hana and Mizuki already have pretty great chemistry so I can't wait to watch that go absolutely nowhere
| @deltahalo241 Chemistry between people is not just romantic. And of course, not all people who match well should necessarily become a romantic couple because of this. @Tongmuan Yuri bait from Hibike has nothing to do with this. Not even because there is essentially no yuri-bait here, but because most of the yuri-bait in Hibikу was the creation of Naoko Yamada and her decision to shift all the emphasis of the original book in favor of female bonds. @Narizor |
RobertBobertJan 8, 9:34 AM
 |
| The first episode is an impressive start, weaving an emotionally charged narrative with striking visuals. Its blend of beauty and intensity sets it apart from the usual fare, though it might feel a bit heavy for some viewers. With compelling characters and a story that hints at deeper themes, it has the potential to be something special. If you’re drawn to dramas with emotional depth and artistic flair, this one is definitely worth watching. |
  |
| The visuals are beautiful, really fond of this art style. The poems did feel a bit too vague and heavy at first glance, possibly a charm lost through translation too, but hey that's how artistic scribbles tend to be, a little distant, allegoric. Either way, liking this theme, the visuals, the laid-back atmosphere so I'll keep watching. |
 |
| Nice ed and op! I really like the visuals. Hana is so cute lol! And the setting of Hana living on an island is interesting. Well Hana has a great voice. I really wonder how the manga was like since it did not have sounds... The theme is novel. Looking forward to Ep2! |
| One of the reasons I decided to watch this was because I like the studio behind this, Studio Bind, and also because it's a seinen anime. Having said that the synopsis sounded ok and after watching the first episode I'm mostly intrigued to see where this goes. |
| I just finished the first episode and wow the part where Hana recited on the beach literally gave me chills! Also, the visuals and the OP/ED are wonderful while the theme is really intriguing. The only thing is that I feel like the pacing was a little fast, but maybe it's just me. In general, it looks promising so let's see how this will go!! |
| I was pleasantly surprised, I think it will be one of the things I look forward to most each week. |
 |
| SHISHAMO OP, peak |
| nice visuals. as long as this doesn't turn out anything like hibike, this will be good. |
 |
Reply to ryzxgum
nice visuals. as long as this doesn't turn out anything like hibike, this will be good.
| @ryzxgum Depends what you mean by Hibike. |
|
Reply to RobertBobert
@ryzxgum Depends what you mean by Hibike.
| @RobertBobert lots of drama and crying which i got tired of. i'd like it if this was a more chill SoL, focusing mostly on the reading and her growth into it. something like act-age or akane banashi, but for the broadcasting club. |
|
Reply to ryzxgum
@RobertBobert lots of drama and crying which i got tired of. i'd like it if this was a more chill SoL, focusing mostly on the reading and her growth into it. something like act-age or akane banashi, but for the broadcasting club.
| @ryzxgum At the moment it's more of a hobby story about a school club than anything else. But this is just my feeling. |
|
| Storytelling/reading anime! cool! Hana's complete switch up got me invested, that was amazing. I first thought this was yuri, tho eupho author so probably not, either way its interesting. |
| This looked promising but it was way better than I imagined. Studio Bind usual cooking the recitation of "I am Asura reincarnate" looked fabulous. Hana's VA did an amazing job too. If they continue making recitation this peak everytime it will be too good. Probably the best opening episode so far and the best OP as well among the seasonal I watched. Hana deserves the best, she will slowly keep getting more confidence. If anything happens to her smile I swear..  |
| Easily my favourite first episode of the season, so far at least. It subtly sucks you in, and then gives you that beach scene. |
| And with this, Studio Bind will further downgrade the quality of Mushoku Tensei. Already happened once with Onimai. I lost faith in Studio Bind actually giving a shit for the series they were even created for. If only Mushoku Tensei was handed over to a different studio that would prioritize that series. |
Ronninn said: So this is why the Mushoku Tensei S2 looked so inconsistent Which is why I despise Onimai and now this series. Studio Bind ain’t big enough to handle multiple projects yet still maintain the same quality. Just hand MT to a more capable studio, preferably one that isn’t focusing on yuribait |
NezuSwallowtail_ said: studio bind never fails to amaze me with their adaptations. great first ep, OST, voice acting, animation, everything is great. Mushoku Tensei S2 failed to amaze many people, myself included, so I completely disagree |
Animillion said: NezuSwallowtail_ said: studio bind never fails to amaze me with their adaptations. great first ep, OST, voice acting, animation, everything is great. Mushoku Tensei S2 failed to amaze many people, myself included, so I completely disagree Light novels are difficult to adapt in a way that will satisfy readers of the original source. For me how they adapted Mushoku S2 was really good but not perfect I can understand that. |
| The Broadcasting Club. I quite liked the first episode and I liked Hana and Mizuki quite a lot. I will definitely keep watching it, very good 1st episode. The opening and ending are very good.      |
| Well, that was the best debut episode of the entire season so far. I was not expecting that. I went in almost completely blind. I think I had read the synopsis at some point, but I didn't remember it at all. Anyway, love Mizuki's character already. Hana is fine, I guess. Hopefully, she gets solid development. I'm obviously hoping for yuri vibes throughout, but I'm cool with it either way. The animation, particularly the beach scene, was very nice. I like the art style, as well. Interesting premise that is familiar, but adds the unique recitation angle. The VA work was also really nice. I pretty much loved everything about this episode. The initial MAL score for this is baffling. MALiens have such questionable taste sometimes. |
 |
| Incredible, simply incredible. I was somewhat worried about how her performance would go after the first two but they nailed it. Super beautiful visuals and pretty decent slice of life. Bit of a curious decision to assign an, essentially, completely new VA to Hana but she did great. Super looking forward to the next episode |
 |
| Quite pleasant 1st episode with powerful scenes visualizing the experience on listening/reciting a poem. Also, throughout the episode I more than once thought that this Mizuki girl reminds me of Hiodoshi Ao. Went to check the staff list and got a "this explains a lot" moment: the manga artist (and the anime character designer) Musshu is actually the same person who designed Hiodoshi Ao, lol |
| really like the first episode... can relate to the protagonist... I mean, in this scenario I also would feel awful if the ferry guy had to work late just because of me ^^' and, not gonna like, the scene of her reciting in the beach gave me chills |
| yaaawn, dropped... |
DesuMaiden said: Nobody resembles me physically because I don't even physically exist. |
Reply to gorkthe134th
I was enjoying the episode, but it seemed a bit too fast.
Around half way through, I switched to .75x speed.
It was at this moment, that the episode got a lot better.
And once Hana started reciting "An Asura in Spring", I fell in love with the series. (Yes, I did get emotional.)
I've now watched that scene twice in 1x speed and twice in .75x speed, I'd take .75x any day!
There are some disadvantages to this approach, like the occasional audio glitch, but I think it's worth it.
3/4 is still not ideal, 4/5 may be better; I don't have the the luxury to try many precise speeds.
Either way, I'm happy with my choice and I will probably be watching the whole anime that way!
(Even the OP and ED sound better at .75x speed!)
Around half way through, I switched to .75x speed.
It was at this moment, that the episode got a lot better.
And once Hana started reciting "An Asura in Spring", I fell in love with the series. (Yes, I did get emotional.)
I've now watched that scene twice in 1x speed and twice in .75x speed, I'd take .75x any day!
There are some disadvantages to this approach, like the occasional audio glitch, but I think it's worth it.
3/4 is still not ideal, 4/5 may be better; I don't have the the luxury to try many precise speeds.
Either way, I'm happy with my choice and I will probably be watching the whole anime that way!
(Even the OP and ED sound better at .75x speed!)
gorkthe134th said: An Asura in Spring gorkthe134th said: "An Asura in Spring" Hi, the same thing happened for me, after hear the poem recited. Do you know if it is a real poem or just written for the anime? If real, do you know of any way to read the poem in English? I would appreciate it. |
ejleonJan 14, 2:20 PM
Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.  |
| Wow, what a cute series. Thankfully, and currently, there has yet to be yuri things—but if it does, instant dropped. |
| It's not that I dislike this genre but... to add unnecessary fan services to/in/for heroines and ultimately destroys her character and personality; their purity tarnished because of it, is the only thing I hope to not happen to them. For that sole purity is my fan service. |
Reply to ejleon
gorkthe134th said:
An Asura in Spring
An Asura in Spring
gorkthe134th said:
"An Asura in Spring"
"An Asura in Spring"
Hi, the same thing happened for me, after hear the poem recited.
Do you know if it is a real poem or just written for the anime?
If real, do you know of any way to read the poem in English?
I would appreciate it.
| @ejleon I seems like it is a real poem written by Kenji Miyazawa (宮沢 賢治). I don't know if it is a well known poem in Japan (If someone knows more I would appreciate it if you added some details). With a quick search you can find some sites selling a book with poems from the collection, both translated and in Japanese.  Other than those I did find a site with a personal translation, which also links to the original Japanese Text: fieldomoss.com The passage used in the show is under the title "Spring and Asura (mental sketch modified)". From reading that part alone, I'm not sure if I personally like the translation, though my opinion could change if I read more. (For example, I don't know why "akebi" was translated to "chocolate".) Keep in mind, I'm not well versed in either Japanese poetry or the language itself. I suggest doing some research of your own if you are interested. |
Reply to gorkthe134th
@ejleon I seems like it is a real poem written by Kenji Miyazawa (宮沢 賢治).
I don't know if it is a well known poem in Japan (If someone knows more I would appreciate it if you added some details).
With a quick search you can find some sites selling a book with poems from the collection, both translated and in Japanese.
Other than those I did find a site with a personal translation, which also links to the original Japanese Text: fieldomoss.com
The passage used in the show is under the title "Spring and Asura (mental sketch modified)".
From reading that part alone, I'm not sure if I personally like the translation, though my opinion could change if I read more.
(For example, I don't know why "akebi" was translated to "chocolate".)
Keep in mind, I'm not well versed in either Japanese poetry or the language itself.
I suggest doing some research of your own if you are interested.
I don't know if it is a well known poem in Japan (If someone knows more I would appreciate it if you added some details).
With a quick search you can find some sites selling a book with poems from the collection, both translated and in Japanese.
Other than those I did find a site with a personal translation, which also links to the original Japanese Text: fieldomoss.com
The passage used in the show is under the title "Spring and Asura (mental sketch modified)".
From reading that part alone, I'm not sure if I personally like the translation, though my opinion could change if I read more.
(For example, I don't know why "akebi" was translated to "chocolate".)
Keep in mind, I'm not well versed in either Japanese poetry or the language itself.
I suggest doing some research of your own if you are interested.
| @gorkthe134th Wow! Thank you so much for taking the time and providing this amount of info. I really appreciate it at lot. I also don't know the Japanese language or their poetry, but was interested in reading this poem after hearing in the show. My if send a friend request? |
| Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
Reply to ejleon
@gorkthe134th Wow! Thank you so much for taking the time and providing this amount of info. I really appreciate it at lot.
I also don't know the Japanese language or their poetry, but was interested in reading this poem after hearing in the show.
My if send a friend request?
I also don't know the Japanese language or their poetry, but was interested in reading this poem after hearing in the show.
My if send a friend request?
ejleon said: Of course! I just sent you one.My if send a friend request? |
Reply to gorkthe134th
@ejleon I seems like it is a real poem written by Kenji Miyazawa (宮沢 賢治).
I don't know if it is a well known poem in Japan (If someone knows more I would appreciate it if you added some details).
With a quick search you can find some sites selling a book with poems from the collection, both translated and in Japanese.
Other than those I did find a site with a personal translation, which also links to the original Japanese Text: fieldomoss.com
The passage used in the show is under the title "Spring and Asura (mental sketch modified)".
From reading that part alone, I'm not sure if I personally like the translation, though my opinion could change if I read more.
(For example, I don't know why "akebi" was translated to "chocolate".)
Keep in mind, I'm not well versed in either Japanese poetry or the language itself.
I suggest doing some research of your own if you are interested.
I don't know if it is a well known poem in Japan (If someone knows more I would appreciate it if you added some details).
With a quick search you can find some sites selling a book with poems from the collection, both translated and in Japanese.
Other than those I did find a site with a personal translation, which also links to the original Japanese Text: fieldomoss.com
The passage used in the show is under the title "Spring and Asura (mental sketch modified)".
From reading that part alone, I'm not sure if I personally like the translation, though my opinion could change if I read more.
(For example, I don't know why "akebi" was translated to "chocolate".)
Keep in mind, I'm not well versed in either Japanese poetry or the language itself.
I suggest doing some research of your own if you are interested.
| @gorkthe134th I don't know much Japanese yet. But here's what I found: https://www.tanoshiijapanese.com/dictionary/entry_details.cfm?entry_id=77330 木通 (akebi) noun 1. chocolate-vine (Akebia quinata); fiveleaf; fiveleaf akebia 2. fruit of the akebia From the link you gave, it uses the term 'chocolate-vine.' From Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akebia_quinata), it's called 'chocolate-vine' because it gives off a chocolate aroma. |
| The main girl sounds a lot like Bocchi. So much that I thought she is voiced by the same voice actress (Aoyama Yoshino). But she also sounds a bit like Kumiko every now and then. So far this looks pretty promising, and not like yet another slice of life anime doing cookie cutter CGDCT characters we usually get every season. Really natural and sincere, without any abuse of over-the-top cliches. |
Reply to patkarunungan
@gorkthe134th
I don't know much Japanese yet. But here's what I found: https://www.tanoshiijapanese.com/dictionary/entry_details.cfm?entry_id=77330
木通 (akebi)
noun
1. chocolate-vine (Akebia quinata); fiveleaf; fiveleaf akebia
2. fruit of the akebia
From the link you gave, it uses the term 'chocolate-vine.'
From Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akebia_quinata), it's called 'chocolate-vine' because it gives off a chocolate aroma.
I don't know much Japanese yet. But here's what I found: https://www.tanoshiijapanese.com/dictionary/entry_details.cfm?entry_id=77330
木通 (akebi)
noun
1. chocolate-vine (Akebia quinata); fiveleaf; fiveleaf akebia
2. fruit of the akebia
From the link you gave, it uses the term 'chocolate-vine.'
From Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akebia_quinata), it's called 'chocolate-vine' because it gives off a chocolate aroma.
| @patkarunungan Thanks for the info. I see that the plant is very common in Japan, so for someone living there the term 'chocolate-vine' makes sense. Personally, I would have translated it as 'akebia' or 'akebia-vine' to make it less confusing for non-natives. It may be even better to change the plant to something more common in the west. But, it does fit the poem pretty well, it is a vine that grows uncontrollably drowning the clouds of positive emotions. As anxiety grows thicker and thicker, the akebia-vines become thorny rose bushes and a humus swamp of dark thoughts now dominates. Devious flattery is overwhelming the mind and amber is entrapping the body. From anxiety to resentment to anger. The dark side of April's light blooms... Grinding my teeth, I, am Asura incarnate!!! This is my interpretation of the passage btw, the drowning feeling of anxiety transforming into a dark feeling of rage. There are many ways to express that and here I've chosen one of my favorites: continually rising intensity and a calm moment before the explosion. One of the reasons I recommend .75x speed for the anime is that they tried to do something similar with a fast piano background music, yet, in my opinion, there was not enough build-up for that approach to work well, which is why I extended the passage for my interpretation. But if you slow down the scene, the now slower piano gives more emphasis to the sadness, while still being fast enough for the anxiety to build up. I recommend watching at least this scene at .75x speed, I believe it's a lot better that way. (The other reason for recommending .75x speed is that the dialog is generally a bit too fast (.75 is still a bit too slow, though I prefer slow over fast).) |
| came with low expectations. But I enjoyed it a lot. Hana has a powerful voice, that can move people. She just need to have more confidence. also nice that her mother is supportive, also the ferryman is nice enough to agree on changing the schedule. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Hana wa Saku, Shura no Gotoku Episode 3 DiscussionStark700 - Today |
13 |
by ejleon
»»
54 minutes ago |
|
» Is this yuri?Dragevard - Dec 4, 2024 |
27 |
by Startrick666
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Hana wa Saku, Shura no Gotoku Episode 2 DiscussionStark700 - Jan 14 |
38 |
by watsym
»»
8 hours ago |
|
» How good is its production compared to Mushoku Tensei and Onimai ?LampWork - Yesterday |
3 |
by Han_17
»»
Yesterday, 5:50 AM |
|
» How is this Seinen? ( 1 2 )Aesethyr - Jan 7 |
53 |
by Sid
»»
Jan 15, 1:30 AM |