Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Asahi deserves happiness even in this time loop. I like how she chooses what she wants and refuses to submit to this. Out of the Amagami sisters, she's the most selfless imo. But yeah, the vibe of this episode still had positive vibes. Interesting to see Karen showing up too. |
 |
| If only it was this easier. I mean no way they would’ve escaped the loop just by ditching the race and going for the tanabata festival instead. Also tbh, that conclusion would’ve made for the most basic conclusion ever lol. Btw hey, the people who voted for the most popular girl really didn’t know what they were doing, did they? I mean Yae should’ve clean-sweeped right? Asahi’s win feels like a biased decision because we’re in her arc so… she gets to win xD I’m not sure about all of these original scenes with Shirahi tbh though. If they’re genuinely planning to adapt her arc in this season, which I highly doubt they would, there’s simply no reason to waste screen time on her. I mean her character is sooo one-note and is something which just exists in the manga, so yeah, I’d rather have if they just focus on sisters instead. Hated her in the manga, so yeah, the less the better. These two better go back asap tho, I mean you can see Asahi is losing herself lol, and those aroud her as well... what cliffhanger( ͡~ ͜ʖ ͡°) |
 |
| Ah yes, how could we not have guessed it already, it was right there in front of our eyes from the beginning, the key to escape the time loop, is for two high school girls to have some quality alone time together. Also this was like the funniest episode. |
 |
| Asahi is just so adorable she really is the standout of the Amagami sisters. |
Pouty Yae is best Yae. Uryu may be used to getting called out practically daily but damn, Yomiko really knows how to cut deep lol. And ngl before she pointed it out, I was ready for the reveal for the cause of the loops to be either Asahi or Uryu's unfinished homework. |
| That scene with the festival was so intense lol wasn't expecting the showdown to end like that there was definitely some tension when Karen went to visit Asahi at her home felt like something was about to happen at any moment wtf the progression between the characters was really strong nice |
 |
| Fairs perhaps I was too harsh on Asahi. Really coming around on her during this arc. Still don’t ship it because of the age gap, but I just like her as a character a lot more now. No way they have stan meet and greets at the shrine. Lmao I’m not even mad, that’s a great way to make money, but just the thought of some lonely dudes going “that’s my oshi” to a fucking shrine maiden is killing me I knew Uryu’s childhood friend would eventually become part of the harem, but I like how they set up why she fell for him. What’s cool about this story in comparison to something like 100gf for me is how Uryu’s harem feels earned. He’s a smart ambitious dude who really puts himself on the line for others so it’s no shock people would fall for him. There’s also a nice comparison in this ep between Asahi’s de facto best friend Karen and Uryu’s childhood friend Shirahi. They both look up to Asahi and Uryu respectively, but whereas Shirahi is a bit more open with it, Karen struggles to admit how she feels about Asahi. She really loves and idolises her, but is too awkward to say it. Going back to Uryu doing anything for those he cares about, he also has a tendency to do what HE thinks his best for people rather than listening to what they really want. Not an evil thing at all, but it’s a flaw he could work on and clearly one this loop is pushing him towards improving. But the lady who raised the girls seemed a little too knowledgeable about things.. I wonder if she knows about some of the supernatural stuff in this series. |
Marinate1016Jan 21, 10:19 AM
 |
| WHY THE FUCK IS SHIRAHI HEREEEEEEEEEEEEEE AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH those changes are so unnecesary :/ |
 |
| Tie my ass. I call voter fraud against Yuna for plot convience. Man Asahi is such a troll  So even being at Hanabata didn't solve the loop. Really feel bad for Asahi, she would be under so much stress and anxiety. Balancing her dream, family, goals is really hard for her. Hope she comes out of this mess happily. Yomiko burned Uryu real bad there, huge emotional damage. But soon he discovered joy of Yuri. This nosebleed was totally worth it. Amazing scene😭😭 |
WaterMageJan 21, 11:27 AM
Marinate1016 said: Still don’t ship it because of the age gap So you don't ship Yae either right because of similar age gap. |
| It's a shame that the loop with Asahi in the festival did not allow for both her and Uryu to escape it so I wonder if it has more to do with Asahi's running rival since she showed up both in the festival loop and then in the most recent loop. Btw the ending with her rival on top of her and Uryu getting a nosebleed was both surprising and hilarious. |
Man, what I feared the most happened—they couldn’t escape the loop even after participating in the festival. As far as I know, she wants to be with Uryu, but maybe Asahi wants something else, and we just don’t know it yet. I can’t wait to see how they’re going to get out of this. |
WaterMage said: Marinate1016 said: Still don’t ship it because of the age gap So you don't ship Yae either right because of similar age gap. Oh. Brother here go the lolicons. |
|
Reply to Marinate1016
WaterMage said:
So you don't ship Yae either right because of similar age gap.
Marinate1016 said:
Still don’t ship it because of the age gap
Still don’t ship it because of the age gap
So you don't ship Yae either right because of similar age gap.
Oh. Brother here go the lolicons.
| @Marinate1016 nice denying the reality and facts with buzz words. |
Yes, because I’m not arguing with a kiddy enjoyer. Go argue with the wall. |
|
Reply to Marinate1016
Yes, because I’m not arguing with a kiddy enjoyer. Go argue with the wall.
| @Marinate1016 I did that with two replies. Yes should stop wasting my time. Thanks Wall. |
| I wonder who wished to be 1000m tall. Asahi really screwed Uryuu over with the "secret relationship". Yuri voyeurism kink activated in Uryuu, sealed by nose bleed. |
| Lord Cruelty V "But my Dreams they're not as empty, as my conscience seems to be" |
| Dam as much as I want to shit on this show. This arc about Asahi trying to dictate her path in life is endearing. The tension she feels trying to balance those opposing dreams is unfortunate considering the weight each dream bares. On one hand she can focus on the Shrine. Following in the steps of her sisters, but feel guilty for letting her track potential go to waste.( "You alone carry the strength to spread your wings in za worldu!" ) Even so, on the other hand she can focus on track to hone that potential to be great just at the cost of her family. Because Track would keep her far from her sisters and to busy to check in. Causing her to drift further and further away. Even worse she seems to be under the impression that those dreams epitmize her as a person. Her identity to the world even though she recognizes what path she chooses wouldn't be her authentic self. Due to what it costs in the end... All in all, props to the author and the team. This was a well directed episode. Edit- The second hand embrassment for Uryuu after getting called out by the head priestess on the phone. ☠️😭😭 |
HellNope said: @Marinate1016 Technically the age gap between Yae to Uryu is the same from Uryu to Asashi, so that person have a point. Except Uryu is above the age of consent and 18 whereas Asahi is like 14. So no they don’t. Uryu is an adult and she’s a child. Have y’all even watched the show lol Sources: https://amagami-sister.fandom.com/wiki/Uryuu_Kamihate https://amagami-sister.fandom.com/wiki/Asahi_Amagami Yae is 20. https://amagami-sister.fandom.com/wiki/Yae_Amagami So a 2 year age gap for an 18 and 20 year old or an 18 and 14 year old. |
|
HellNope said: @Marinate1016 In the first chapters of the manga it state that Uryu is 17, Yae 20 and Asahi 14, the age in the fandom is probably counting Uryu age in the lastest chapters, either way, the characters will only get married once they are adults anyway, so Asahi will be at legal age by that time. Even at that age difference Yae and Uryu would be cool since he’s at consenting age and about to finish high school, whereas Asahi is a middle schooler. If you’re 17 dating a middle schooler you’d get clowned dawg like what. Sure they’ll get married as adults but I can’t see a child as a prospective romantic partner. The lack of maturity and Sorry if you’re one of #them but none of that over here. We like adults. |
|
HellNope said: @Marinate1016 It's more a matter of where you live, in america I believe you can even find some people that would be against a 20 years old dating a 17 years old, since the age of consent in america is 18 in most states, meanwhile in places like europe and asia you may find people that would be accepting of a 17 years old dating a 14 years old, the world is big and human culture isn't homogeneous, so morality differs among ethnic groups. Sure, morality is subjective however my comment was in reply to a dude who said they were the same age gap which is not true and doesn’t tell the full story because of the emotional and mental gap between a middle schooler and a dude about to graduate hs. Yae and Uryu are much closer than he and Asahi. |
|
| Watched the DUB from 2 ago. Confirming that I still like the previous OP and ED better than the new one. |
| Lord Cruelty V "But my Dreams they're not as empty, as my conscience seems to be" |
| I was wondering why there was a slight jump in posts for this episode, an interesting little debate took place looks like lol. But besides that, yeah I had a feeling sticking around for the festival wasn’t gonna break the loop, that would have been too simple, but it is once again a shame that such a good time was undid, I know the true route will probably lead to the best outcome for Asahi and her friend/rival Karen, but my opinion is that whoever is causing this, be it the gods or something else, is kind of a dick lol. But there have been some great Asahi moments to come from it, I always liked her but she’s been especially great in this arc. And poor Uryu man, he’s trying his best to help but he got cooked by Yomiko lol, his reaction was hilarious, but really Yomiko is right, he wasn’t considering what Asahi truly wants, but with Karen appearing at their doorstep (and causing quite the spicy scene lol) we’re about to see what the real solution is. But if it’s true that Asahi isn’t racing at her best, then does this mean she would absolutely smoke Karen if she put her all into it? Guess we’ll see lol. |
| I don't know why Asahi's so selfless, and she's already tried to balancing her dream and goals, also her family tho. |
| How I love the moments when you sincerely try to help a person in response to their complaints or desires, but in the end you are accused of toxicity and selfishness. @Marinate1016 Typical hypocrisy. A man instantly gets blamed for dating a younger girl, even if it was her initiative, but when an older girl shows attention to a younger guy, it is considered normal and even desirable. |
 |
RobertBobert said: How I love the moments when you sincerely try to help a person in response to their complaints or desires, but in the end you are accused of toxicity and selfishness. @Marinate1016 Typical hypocrisy. A man instantly gets blamed for dating a younger girl, even if it was her initiative, but when an older girl shows attention to a younger guy, it is considered normal and even desirable. Yap yap. Again if you’re one of #them and like little girls that’s your business. I said what I said and explained literally why that’s not ok. Like there’s no way you’re arguing for a 17/18 year old to date a middle schooler dawg |
|
Reply to Marinate1016
RobertBobert said:
How I love the moments when you sincerely try to help a person in response to their complaints or desires, but in the end you are accused of toxicity and selfishness.
@Marinate1016 Typical hypocrisy. A man instantly gets blamed for dating a younger girl, even if it was her initiative, but when an older girl shows attention to a younger guy, it is considered normal and even desirable.
How I love the moments when you sincerely try to help a person in response to their complaints or desires, but in the end you are accused of toxicity and selfishness.
@Marinate1016 Typical hypocrisy. A man instantly gets blamed for dating a younger girl, even if it was her initiative, but when an older girl shows attention to a younger guy, it is considered normal and even desirable.
Yap yap. Again if you’re one of #them and like little girls that’s your business. I said what I said and explained literally why that’s not ok. Like there’s no way you’re arguing for a 17/18 year old to date a middle schooler dawg
| @Marinate1016 You have every right to have your opinion. But passive-aggression and attempts to immediately label a person who disagrees with you will only devalue your opinion, no matter what it is. |
|
RobertBobert said: @Marinate1016 You have every right to have your opinion. But passive-aggression and attempts to immediately label a person who disagrees with you will only devalue your opinion, no matter what it is. Doesn’t really matter what devalues my opinion. Its value is only important to me. Again you can like whatever you want idc, I can not and will never get with the ship because I do not like children. You and several others took exception to my saying that and starting bringing up Yae(which no one mentioned prior) and trying to debate me on morals. |
|
Reply to Marinate1016
RobertBobert said:
@Marinate1016 You have every right to have your opinion. But passive-aggression and attempts to immediately label a person who disagrees with you will only devalue your opinion, no matter what it is.
@Marinate1016 You have every right to have your opinion. But passive-aggression and attempts to immediately label a person who disagrees with you will only devalue your opinion, no matter what it is.
Doesn’t really matter what devalues my opinion. Its value is only important to me. Again you can like whatever you want idc, I can not and will never get with the ship because I do not like children. You and several others took exception to my saying that and starting bringing up Yae(which no one mentioned prior) and trying to debate me on morals.
| @Marinate1016 Technically, Uryū is still a child himself, only 2-3 years older than Asahi. This is not an American show, so American original age morality doesn't interest me. I was answering about Yae because the person above mentioned that of those who were confused by their age difference, never ever mentioned their age difference with Yae. Although, unlike Asahi and Uryu, she is literally an adult. |
|
RobertBobert said: @Marinate1016 Technically, Uryū is still a child himself, only 2-3 years older than Asahi. This is not an American show, so American original age morality doesn't interest me. I was answering about Yae because the person above mentioned that of those who were confused by their age difference, never ever mentioned their age difference with Yae. Although, unlike Asahi and Uryu, she is literally an adult. He’s not a child. I listed the sources for his age. He’s above consenting age and is an adult |
|
Reply to Marinate1016
RobertBobert said:
@Marinate1016 Technically, Uryū is still a child himself, only 2-3 years older than Asahi. This is not an American show, so American original age morality doesn't interest me. I was answering about Yae because the person above mentioned that of those who were confused by their age difference, never ever mentioned their age difference with Yae. Although, unlike Asahi and Uryu, she is literally an adult.
@Marinate1016 Technically, Uryū is still a child himself, only 2-3 years older than Asahi. This is not an American show, so American original age morality doesn't interest me. I was answering about Yae because the person above mentioned that of those who were confused by their age difference, never ever mentioned their age difference with Yae. Although, unlike Asahi and Uryu, she is literally an adult.
He’s not a child. I listed the sources for his age. He’s above consenting age and is an adult
| @Marinate1016 He is a minor high school student. According to the law of any country, especially the USA, he is still a teenager. Who, again, is only 3-2 years older than Asahi. If Yae were a man, and Uryu was a girl (if they were both girls, people will ship them without thinking about anything), then the moral guards would instantly call him minor in the first place. |
|
RobertBobert said: @Marinate1016 He is a minor high school student. According to the law of any country, especially the USA, he is still a teenager. Who, again, is only 3-2 years older than Asahi. If Yae were a man, and Uryu was a girl (if they were both girls, people will ship them without thinking about anything), then the moral guards would instantly call him minor in the first place. He is literally an adult according to Japanese law as he’s reached the age of adulthood https://japan-forward.com/japans-legal-adult-age-is-now-18-from-20-8-things-that-change-4-that-stay/#:~:text=Turning 20 used to mark,in Japan on that day. Idk what you’re arguing. Like the maturity gap between a high school senior and a first/2nd year college student is substantially smaller than a senior in hs and a middle schooler like what 😭 it doesn’t take a morality expert to know that. I’m a little concerned you’re struggling with this. It’s not a raw numbers issue but a mental maturity issue too. Like a 25 year old and 20 year old is a fine gap even though it’s 5 years but a 17 and 12 year old wouldn’t be. In your logic, “they’re the same!” But clearly not because of the phases of brain development. For instance I was a freshman in college at 17. So I legit could’ve dated a Yae. But you do have a loli avi so I’m gonna leave it alone. Have a great one |
|
Reply to Marinate1016
RobertBobert said:
@Marinate1016 He is a minor high school student. According to the law of any country, especially the USA, he is still a teenager. Who, again, is only 3-2 years older than Asahi. If Yae were a man, and Uryu was a girl (if they were both girls, people will ship them without thinking about anything), then the moral guards would instantly call him minor in the first place.
@Marinate1016 He is a minor high school student. According to the law of any country, especially the USA, he is still a teenager. Who, again, is only 3-2 years older than Asahi. If Yae were a man, and Uryu was a girl (if they were both girls, people will ship them without thinking about anything), then the moral guards would instantly call him minor in the first place.
He is literally an adult according to Japanese law as he’s reached the age of adulthood
https://japan-forward.com/japans-legal-adult-age-is-now-18-from-20-8-things-that-change-4-that-stay/#:~:text=Turning 20 used to mark,in Japan on that day.
Idk what you’re arguing. Like the maturity gap between a high school senior and a first/2nd year college student is substantially smaller than a senior in hs and a middle schooler like what 😭 it doesn’t take a morality expert to know that. I’m a little concerned you’re struggling with this. It’s not a raw numbers issue but a mental maturity issue too. Like a 25 year old and 20 year old is a fine gap even though it’s 5 years but a 17 and 12 year old wouldn’t be. In your logic, “they’re the same!” But clearly not because of the phases of brain development.
For instance I was a freshman in college at 17. So I legit could’ve dated a Yae.
But you do have a loli avi so I’m gonna leave it alone. Have a great one
| @Marinate1016 It says 18 years old, not 17. Moreover, Asahi is only 2 years younger than the age of consent (and will only be a year younger when he turns 18). Let's put aside the persistent attempts to make this personal and attempts to be a moral guardian from a man who, just last week, unequivocally sexualized the friendship of two 14-year-old girls on another show and answer me one simple question. If their age difference is only 3 years, then what's stopping them from simply remaining chaste until Asahi turns 16 or even reaches 18 herself, given the small age difference? P.S. Loli avi? What are you talking about? |
RobertBobertJan 22, 9:09 AM
|
| Wtf am I reading on this thread... |
| よろしく！ |
Queen_Vania said: Wtf am I reading on this thread... Damn fr I just wanted some shit posting about the Endless Eight |
 My biggest regret: Reading all 200+ chapters of Kanojo, Okarishimasu |
Holy projection and you’re a bot account. Please explain to the class how EYE am a creep for not shipping the MC with a little kid. |
|
| No matter what they do the loop isn't fixed... but it's true that Uryuu is deciding what Asahi wants even though it should be the contrary and her taking her own decisions... |
 |
| I was so excited to see what people thought about best girl Amagami Asahi arc so far, and instead the moral grandstanding in this thread gave me a massive headache. Some people really aren't going to like future events because they refuse to accept her as an "acceptable" romantic option for Uryuu + refuse to understand that the story also accepts her as such, but that's none of my business, I guess. My favorite Amagami deserved better than this... Anyway, on a more positive note, I'm really happy that Drive is doing her arc justice in the show; I can't wait for next episode~! |
 I'm okay now... At least... I want to be able to say that. ✧✧✧✧✧✧ profile ✧ watching ✧ reading ✧ art credit |
Reply to Remocracy
Queen_Vania said:
Wtf am I reading on this thread...
Wtf am I reading on this thread...
Damn fr I just wanted some shit posting about the Endless Eight
| @Remocracy I feel like rewatching Haruhi now |
| よろしく！ |
| @RobertBobert @Marinate1016 In almost every country, there are exceptions to the age of consent (16) when both parties are close in age and considered to be on equal footing. This makes sense; otherwise, romantic relationships between two middle schoolers wouldn’t be possible. Canadian law states (Japanese law is similar): Close in age exceptions A 14 or 15 year old can consent to sexual activity as long as the partner is less than five years older and there is no relationship of trust, authority or dependency or any other exploitation of the young person. This means that if the partner is 5 years or older than the 14 or 15 year old, any sexual activity is a criminal offence. There is also a "close in age" exception for 12 and 13 year olds. A 12 or 13 year old can consent to sexual activity with a partner as long as the partner is less than two years older and there is no relationship of trust, authority or dependency or any other exploitation of the young person. This means that if the partner is 2 years or older than the 12 or 13 year old, any sexual activity is a criminal offence. https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/other-autre/clp/faq.html The age difference between Asahi and Uryu is exactly 2 years, 2 months, and 18 days.. |
More topics from this board
» Slightly UnderratedPrfpnd_179 - 5 hours ago |
6 |
by FreedomKME
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Amagami-san Chi no Enmusubi Episode 19 DiscussionStark700 - Yesterday |
21 |
by LuisSV23
»»
4 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Amagami-san Chi no Enmusubi Episode 17 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 4 |
33 |
by Itto_x_Ei
»»
5 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Amagami-san Chi no Enmusubi Episode 16 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jan 28 |
53 |
by Magicmist
»»
Yesterday, 5:55 PM |
|
Poll: » Amagami-san Chi no Enmusubi Episode 7 DiscussionStark700 - Nov 12, 2024 |
40 |
by dspr
»»
Feb 17, 7:13 PM |