Laid-Back Camp
| 8-bit are a good studio, but I'm not a massive fan of the new character design in the new visual personally, hoping it grows on me, what are your thoughts on it? |
 |
| That's a huge disappointment for me Of course it could have been worse, 8bit isn't a bad studio, but the news still hits me like a truck |
| Very disappointed. 8bit may be a good studio, but there's no point in changing something that works already. C-Station adaptation was the best. I wonder what's the reason behind this |
| I like the character design. Though i'm really scared of the studio after what i saw with Blue Lock with the LOVELLY RUNNING CGI. I don't mind CGI, just DO NOT MAKE IT LOOK HORRIBLE. |
| I wonder how the music might be, so far it's been bangers |
My candies:  |
Reply to Dransyo
The designs are practically indistinguishable to the other seasons
| I could've accepted a change in art style, but the characters look straight-up completely different, they're more childish and Shimarin's hair is completely different. People say it looks closer to the manga, I still have to read it (and now I have one more reason to do it), but I can't see the resemblance. They also got rid of Asaka, apparently. It's almost like the studio purposely tried to disappoint as many fans as possible. Shimarinbros, I don't think I'm gonna recover from this. Dransyo said: The designs are practically indistinguishable to the other seasons My eye doctor is quite good at his job, you should book an appointment |
| I believe in Shimarin supremacy |
| the difference is too big im very disappointed    |
| Why they changed the studio behind? |
 |
| I know it's strange to see characters look different from one season to another season. Dagashi Kashi also did that for Season 2, since they made the characters in Season 2 of Dagashi Kashi look more like how they did in the manga. |
 |
| Based on the replies, I was expecting something utterly horrifying when I watched the teaser. It was fine. It looks more like the manga style. Animation looks fine, too! Of course, I'm still going to miss the previous style. But I'm alright with this, as well. |
| Im honestly not sure what to think. The designs look too... Simplified. Like they removed a bunch of detail. It looks flatter, and is lacking a lot of the warm and fuzzy feeling from before. I do have the manga, and while I have read only a bit of it so far, I honestly wouldnt say from that trailer that the new artwork matches the manga better than the old. Especially the hair looks much closer to S1-2 in the manga, while maybe their eyes and other facial features look a bit closer to the new design. |
| Not sure why some are saying it's closer to the manga, it really doesn't look anything like the manga. It looks like they tried to make Rin's face look closer to her adult appearance in the movie, with a sharper chin and smaller pupils. However this makes no sense, as no time has passed between season 2 and 3. For comparison movie adult Rin:  Latest Yuru Camp preview showing Rin:  They've definitely changed her design to look more like the movie instead of being consistent with season 2. |
| My main concern is that the characters look a lot more same face-y now. Definitely not opposed to it overall, it still looks beautiful, but C-station really made each of them feel so much more distinct. |
 |
| I don't see much difference, maybe there's a slight resemblance to Rimuru now but that's not a bad thing. Rimuru is one of the most breedable characters in all of cartoon. |
| I don't really care so much. I'm pretty sure the atmosphere will remain same along with the characters and their personalities. |
 |
| Just went to a cinema for a first three episode preview. I didn't like the new character design when they showed it at first glance, but actually it's not that bad. It's even kind of closer to manga, I think. I only don't like some new Nadeshiko expressions, but otherwise not bad. The TV premiere scheduled on April 4th, and will be releasing on Thursdays. From a plot side, (minor spoilers ahead) it follows the events of the 2nd season, 2-3 weeks passed or so. The overall graphic quality stays on the same level, soundtrack also the same. Atmosphere is perfect and very close to a 1 and 2 season (movie seemed a bit off for me, but the 3 season looks promising so far). I also liked the opening sequence very much, it's very catchy. Visual style is vary close to a second season's OP, which includes animation style and one-color images (don't knot how to properly call it, but I'm sure you understand). On the other hand, I didn't like the ending this time. While the song is OK (song by Asaka), the visuals are a bit lazy. |
Gigas001Feb 24, 2:48 AM
| Don't like it. Plus the director change too. I'm disappointed but I'll still take more yuru camp |
  ┏────  ────┓WHY Is HoneyComeBear so Underrated? ───────── ┗─────────┛ |
| My most anticipated show of next season. Let's hope it will be good as always. |
| I need somebody who can love me at my worst No, I'm not perfect, but I hope you see my worth 'Cause it's only you, nobody new, I put you first And for you, girl, I swear I'll do the worst If you stay forever, let me hold your hand I can fill those places in your heart no else can Let me show you love, oh, I don't pretend, yeah I'll be right here, baby, you know I'll sink or swim |
| I'm currently rewatching Yuru Camp and finally actually saw the PV and new key visuals for the first time, man they look... bizarre. Might need time to get used to it but in anime form, I'm not much of a fan of the new changes from first impressions, they look a lot more different and in my opinion, weaker than before (original anime's designs had it just right by being a bit cute but normal enough to not be a moeblob turnoff visually since I don't like those in general). I know that these designs might be closer to the manga but that doesn't mean that I like them more that way. I'll see how it actually turns out in the anime though, a shame that the new studio opted for these designs than something similar from the earlier seasons instead. Not like this means that season 3 is a complete failure already and will be doomed, in fact it still has a reasonable chance of being a good and comforting anime again. But I don't know, somewhat not feeling this right now at least at this moment. |
| Can someone tell me important staff (other than director) who work for animation or background music whether they change or not? Honestly i'm worried about this studio, director, and character design replacement |
shiro-seishunMar 4, 2:55 AM
|
Reply to SixofQueens
The way I see it, if the situation were reversed and the first two seasons had been done by 8bit in this art style (assuming all other things remained equal) and then C-Station had taken over the 3rd and done it in their style, then people likely wouldn't like the C-Station style. People just generally don't like changes to things they like. Also, don't bother listing examples of times a mid-way studio change was seen as a general positive, I'm well aware there are counter-examples but their existence doesn't invalidate the point.
I just hope the feeling remains mostly the same, the slower tempo, allowing the splendor of the landscape to passively be the central focus when appropriate, character interactions, music, etc. As has been pointed out, 8bit were the studio behind Encouragement of Climb, so that's a plus, but the actual staff includes basically nobody from that production and this iteration sure doesn't look much like EoC from the PV, either.
That being said, as long as they don't play up the CGDCT angle too much (insomuch as not falling back on tired tropes of that genre which the original seasons didn't really do that much, e.g. nobody is actively jealous of Aoi's breast size or gropes her from behind asking how her they got so big, etc.), don't try to amp up action or stakes (S2 came kinda close to doing that a few times, especially with music design), don't COMPLETELY change the atmosphere of the music, don't turn it into a blatant vehicle for tourism advertisement (the original series of course did this to an extent but it felt like more of a natural consequence of the girls researching where they were going so it fit and wasn't distracting), and don't shift the focus too far away from the girls and their journeys/interactions to becoming more focused on being a camping education show (like how Dagashi Kashi is just a thin narrative designed mostly as a vehicle to deliver history and fun/interesting facts about candy and snacks), then I think there's every chance that this next season will be just fine.
That is a lot of "don't"s, though...
I just hope the feeling remains mostly the same, the slower tempo, allowing the splendor of the landscape to passively be the central focus when appropriate, character interactions, music, etc. As has been pointed out, 8bit were the studio behind Encouragement of Climb, so that's a plus, but the actual staff includes basically nobody from that production and this iteration sure doesn't look much like EoC from the PV, either.
That being said, as long as they don't play up the CGDCT angle too much (insomuch as not falling back on tired tropes of that genre which the original seasons didn't really do that much, e.g. nobody is actively jealous of Aoi's breast size or gropes her from behind asking how her they got so big, etc.), don't try to amp up action or stakes (S2 came kinda close to doing that a few times, especially with music design), don't COMPLETELY change the atmosphere of the music, don't turn it into a blatant vehicle for tourism advertisement (the original series of course did this to an extent but it felt like more of a natural consequence of the girls researching where they were going so it fit and wasn't distracting), and don't shift the focus too far away from the girls and their journeys/interactions to becoming more focused on being a camping education show (like how Dagashi Kashi is just a thin narrative designed mostly as a vehicle to deliver history and fun/interesting facts about candy and snacks), then I think there's every chance that this next season will be just fine.
That is a lot of "don't"s, though...
| @SixofQueens SixofQueens said: if the situation were reversed and the first two seasons had been done by 8bit in this art style (assuming all other things remained equal) and then C-Station had taken over the 3rd and done it in their style, then people likely wouldn't like the C-Station style. People just generally don't like changes to things they like. You closed the topic. The new design isn't bad, it's just different, and people are mad at it because it looks different. |
| "If someone says it's wrong to hope, I'll tell them they're wrong every single time." |
| With EP 1 out, I knew something felt different. Mainly with Chiaki's glasses. |
| I like 8bit, they're a nice studio, but I was really used to the old character designs, so these feel a bit off for me. Hope I come to like them with time. |
| I wouldn't call it ugly, but somehow it's weird and uncomfortable to look at, likely because I'm just not used to it yet. |
| I don't mind it, it's still the cute and relaxing show that I'm familiar with so a bit of animation change doesn't bother me at all! |
| desu desu binches |
| I cant' see a difference, maybe since it's been a while since I watched the previous season. However, they did bring back my favorite pine cone who says "hello" every now and then. Awesome. |
| "You only realize the real value of something you discarded when you get the chance to pick it up again." - Rudeus Greyrat |
| Mostly a bunch of hot air, the change is so minimal that it almost feels trivial. Or maybe it didn't matter that much to me originally, what I enjoyed the most was the atmosphere the show created. I also agree with the reverse hypothetical situation with the studios lol, some people really hate change and are naturally dubious when hearing about it. "Soulless", a buzzword I'm getting a little tired of hearing about, even if I've probably used it in the past admittedly. |
| It looks so good too. I think they intentionally made the trailer different. Sensei is cuter this time too. I'm waiting for Nadeshiko's sister screentime. |
| i was thrown off when the episode started but quickly got used to it. the style has barely even changed, and since the quality and atmosphere seems consistent with previous seasons so far, i don't really mind it. |
Reply to SixofQueens
The way I see it, if the situation were reversed and the first two seasons had been done by 8bit in this art style (assuming all other things remained equal) and then C-Station had taken over the 3rd and done it in their style, then people likely wouldn't like the C-Station style. People just generally don't like changes to things they like. Also, don't bother listing examples of times a mid-way studio change was seen as a general positive, I'm well aware there are counter-examples but their existence doesn't invalidate the point.
I just hope the feeling remains mostly the same, the slower tempo, allowing the splendor of the landscape to passively be the central focus when appropriate, character interactions, music, etc. As has been pointed out, 8bit were the studio behind Encouragement of Climb, so that's a plus, but the actual staff includes basically nobody from that production and this iteration sure doesn't look much like EoC from the PV, either.
That being said, as long as they don't play up the CGDCT angle too much (insomuch as not falling back on tired tropes of that genre which the original seasons didn't really do that much, e.g. nobody is actively jealous of Aoi's breast size or gropes her from behind asking how her they got so big, etc.), don't try to amp up action or stakes (S2 came kinda close to doing that a few times, especially with music design), don't COMPLETELY change the atmosphere of the music, don't turn it into a blatant vehicle for tourism advertisement (the original series of course did this to an extent but it felt like more of a natural consequence of the girls researching where they were going so it fit and wasn't distracting), and don't shift the focus too far away from the girls and their journeys/interactions to becoming more focused on being a camping education show (like how Dagashi Kashi is just a thin narrative designed mostly as a vehicle to deliver history and fun/interesting facts about candy and snacks), then I think there's every chance that this next season will be just fine.
That is a lot of "don't"s, though...
I just hope the feeling remains mostly the same, the slower tempo, allowing the splendor of the landscape to passively be the central focus when appropriate, character interactions, music, etc. As has been pointed out, 8bit were the studio behind Encouragement of Climb, so that's a plus, but the actual staff includes basically nobody from that production and this iteration sure doesn't look much like EoC from the PV, either.
That being said, as long as they don't play up the CGDCT angle too much (insomuch as not falling back on tired tropes of that genre which the original seasons didn't really do that much, e.g. nobody is actively jealous of Aoi's breast size or gropes her from behind asking how her they got so big, etc.), don't try to amp up action or stakes (S2 came kinda close to doing that a few times, especially with music design), don't COMPLETELY change the atmosphere of the music, don't turn it into a blatant vehicle for tourism advertisement (the original series of course did this to an extent but it felt like more of a natural consequence of the girls researching where they were going so it fit and wasn't distracting), and don't shift the focus too far away from the girls and their journeys/interactions to becoming more focused on being a camping education show (like how Dagashi Kashi is just a thin narrative designed mostly as a vehicle to deliver history and fun/interesting facts about candy and snacks), then I think there's every chance that this next season will be just fine.
That is a lot of "don't"s, though...
SixofQueens said: That being said, as long as they don't play up the CGDCT angle too much (insomuch as not falling back on tired tropes of that genre which the original seasons didn't really do that much, e.g. nobody is actively jealous of Aoi's breast size or gropes her from behind asking how her they got so big, etc.), don't try to amp up action or stakes (S2 came kinda close to doing that a few times, especially with music design), don't COMPLETELY change the atmosphere of the music, don't turn it into a blatant vehicle for tourism advertisement (the original series of course did this to an extent but it felt like more of a natural consequence of the girls researching where they were going so it fit and wasn't distracting), and don't shift the focus too far away from the girls and their journeys/interactions to becoming more focused on being a camping education show (like how Dagashi Kashi is just a thin narrative designed mostly as a vehicle to deliver history and fun/interesting facts about candy and snacks), then I think there's every chance that this next season will be just fine. That is a lot of "don't"s, though... I mean, but none of that will happen. It's not like the third season is changing the source material and the anime original content has been so far in tone with the rest of the series. The show is trying to be quiet all the time so it's not going to amp up stakes in a very significant way, it won't really be much more of a vehicle for tourism advertisement than it already is, and it would actually be very absurd if the girls suddenly obsess about Aoi's breast size after having it shoved in their faces for two seasons without any big reaction (the only time it's even mentioned in the show is when Nadeshiko finds out that Akari is impersonating her sister). After watching the first episode though, I do like the new character designs and how they look in motion. With Rin and Chiaki I'm a bit torn, they don't fully work for me compared to their previous designs, but it's not like they look any bad, the characters are still fully recognizable and they seem to allow for more fluid character animation (which is one of 8-Bit's strengths). The thing I'm missing a little from C-Station so far is the set design, which was detailed but not plain photorealistic and added a bit of filtering and lighting that generated a recognizable atmosphere to the whole show, one that I sadly found a bit irregular in this first episode. |
| Rin's design threw me off a little; I think she looks a little younger in this style. It took me a bit to realize that the part with her trying to start the fire the same way her grandpa did wasn't another flashback. |
| Nothing biggie but yeah the previous studio did better design. This one just doesn't hit the same (so far). |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Yuru Camp△ Season 3 Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 9 |
74 |
by Kristiwazhere
»»
6 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Yuru Camp△ Season 3 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 20 |
91 |
by bushman66
»»
Nov 20, 1:49 PM |
|
Poll: » Yuru Camp△ Season 3 Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 13 |
57 |
by bushman66
»»
Nov 20, 1:47 PM |
|
Poll: » Yuru Camp△ Season 3 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 6 |
56 |
by bushman66
»»
Nov 20, 1:45 PM |
|
Poll: » Yuru Camp△ Season 3 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 30 |
69 |
by bushman66
»»
Nov 20, 1:44 PM |