| Is is another mid show like every season or is it actually worth watching |
XypheronOct 3, 6:57 AM
 |
| Why not just give it a try and see if it's something worth watching like I'm doing? This series doesn't have a comedy genre but feels like there is some considering the plot etc. Will drop it though if I lose interest, which you should do as well, if you lose interest. |
| "You only realize the real value of something you discarded when you get the chance to pick it up again." - Rudeus Greyrat |
Reply to Azuchi
Why not just give it a try and see if it's something worth watching like I'm doing?
This series doesn't have a comedy genre but feels like there is some considering the plot etc.
Will drop it though if I lose interest, which you should do as well, if you lose interest.
This series doesn't have a comedy genre but feels like there is some considering the plot etc.
Will drop it though if I lose interest, which you should do as well, if you lose interest.
| @Azuchi I don’t have much time cause of work, so if I have to give a try to each anime of this season to see which is worth, its not possible for me. If i start an anime, I gotta be sure it's something I will actually finish. |
|
Reply to Xypheron
@Azuchi I don’t have much time cause of work, so if I have to give a try to each anime of this season to see which is worth, its not possible for me. If i start an anime, I gotta be sure it's something I will actually finish.
| @Xypheron Understandable, however, everyone's taste is different. They might like it but not you when you watch it. I myself don't have time to watch much but I'd rather lose sleep and social life than possibly skip a good anime :) I recommend sticking to your favorite genres, check the plot and do a little bit of research instead of hoping it might be good just because someone said it. |
AzuchiOct 3, 8:42 AM
| "You only realize the real value of something you discarded when you get the chance to pick it up again." - Rudeus Greyrat |
| It takes 24 mins to watch it man it’s not that much of a time commitment lmao |
 |
Reply to Marinate1016
It takes 24 mins to watch it man it’s not that much of a time commitment lmao
| @Marinate1016 looooool people here are hilarious |
 |
Reply to Prfpnd_179
Marinate1016 said:
It takes 24 mins to watch it man it’s not that much of a time commitment lmao
It takes 24 mins to watch it man it’s not that much of a time commitment lmao
lol. even funnier thing is people can just look at ratings and decide for themselves if it's worth it for them but they've to ask obvious questions
| @Prfpnd_179 Ratings is hardly a good source to judge a series on. Unless people universally rate something above a 9 or below 2, the ratings could be all over the board and if there are some that rate it a 4 but others rate it like 7 or 8, guess what? The average ratings will be in the middle. The OP is just asking those who have read the manga for a little more input than just a rating score. And people are calling the OP lazy for not wanting to watch a 24 minute first episode? Y'all being lazy for saying "just look at the rating" How long does it take for one to just write a line saying why they liked it or didn't like it? |
  |
| seinen + romance + manga score > 7.5 = W |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
| If you're a romance fan, I would definitely recommend that you give it a try. It's very heartwarming and sweet. I also found it very funny, particularly when they lean into the introvert MCs weird personality quirks ("I love maps!"). When reading the Manga, I felt like it was something that was sure to get a live-action adaptation - it already had (on Amazon Prime, so no one saw it). |
RyoHazuki224 said: @Prfpnd_179 Ratings is hardly a good source to judge a series on. Unless people universally rate something above a 9 or below 2, the ratings could be all over the board and if there are some that rate it a 4 but others rate it like 7 or 8, guess what? The average ratings will be in the middle. The OP is just asking those who have read the manga for a little more input than just a rating score. And people are calling the OP lazy for not wanting to watch a 24 minute first episode? Y'all being lazy for saying "just look at the rating" How long does it take for one to just write a line saying why they liked it or didn't like it? In the time it takes to make a post and wait for feedback he could’ve been watched the episode. It’s really not that deep. If you have time to make a post on here asking if it’s good you have time to watch the ep. |
|
Reply to MonX94
I've read the manga ages ago, I'd say it's OK, but maybe anime won't adapt enough material for the plot to get going.
| @MonX94 Considering the manga is long finished, if they don't adapt it all it would be bad... Anyway from the pacing of 1st ep, they may very well adapt it all... |
| bruh |
| The manga is quite enjoyable and stands out from typical romance stories. If adapted well, this could be a one of the better ones to watch this season. |
RyoHazuki224 said: @Prfpnd_179 Ratings is hardly a good source to judge a series on. Unless people universally rate something above a 9 or below 2, the ratings could be all over the board and if there are some that rate it a 4 but others rate it like 7 or 8, guess what? The average ratings will be in the middle. The OP is just asking those who have read the manga for a little more input than just a rating score. And people are calling the OP lazy for not wanting to watch a 24 minute first episode? Y'all being lazy for saying "just look at the rating" How long does it take for one to just write a line saying why they liked it or didn't like it? People are not calling OP lazy. someone just said that 24 minutes a week is not that much of a time commitment if you're even a little bit interested in an office romance anime. |
  |
| Short answer - yes. Long answer - yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees~ P.s. also highly recommended - The World God Only Knows, by the same author. |
| The manga has its strengths, especially for readers that can appreciate character with thorough intricacies of being genuine introverts. The anime? So far it looks dog shit ngl |
 |
| As someone who likes the manga, I think reading the manga is the way to go. The adaptation is like Insomniac after school or Blue Box : cliché and boring direction, subpar animation, intrusive music and voice acting without personality. We're very, very far from the adaptation quality of Too Many Loosing Heroins, Apothecary Diaries or Heavenly Delusion. |
| Think the manga's good, but the anime's been very flat and underwhelming so far in how everything is presented and executed. Pretty disappointed in it so far admittedly. |
| yes especially if you like slice of life romance |
 |
Reply to Prfpnd_179
Marinate1016 said:
It takes 24 mins to watch it man it’s not that much of a time commitment lmao
It takes 24 mins to watch it man it’s not that much of a time commitment lmao
lol. even funnier thing is people can just look at ratings and decide for themselves if it's worth it for them but they've to ask obvious questions
| @Prfpnd_179 Rent a girlfriend has a higher rating as compared to Shikimori or Kyokou suiri... now it's yours to decide |
Reply to vanetz
Short answer - yes.
Long answer - yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees~
P.s. also highly recommended - The World God Only Knows, by the same author.
Long answer - yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees~
P.s. also highly recommended - The World God Only Knows, by the same author.
| @vanetz ??? who is this classics bro who suddenly woke up from 2007, to just vouch for the most mediocre and forgettable romcom adaption on earth lmfao edit: love u tho, no disrespect |
GreatAideOct 16, 12:26 AM
| |
Reply to GreatAide
@vanetz
??? who is this classics bro who suddenly woke up from 2007, to just vouch for the most mediocre and forgettable romcom adaption on earth lmfao
edit: love u tho, no disrespect
??? who is this classics bro who suddenly woke up from 2007, to just vouch for the most mediocre and forgettable romcom adaption on earth lmfao
edit: love u tho, no disrespect
GreatAide said: woke up from 2007, to just vouch for the most mediocre and forgettable romcom adaption on earth Excuse YOU, TWGOK is a top-tier fantasy/supernatural harem with an all star cast, banger soundtrack, with character designs by the dude who worked on the Monogatari series, and animated by a reputable studio that did Samurai Champloo and Ergo Proxy (defunct in 2015, sadly) also it's 2010 but whatever, I wish someone'd put me back into 2007, God that was a good year They did fumble season 3 by skipping like a third of the story though, but the manga is still great Back on-topic (kind of): there was also a live action TV adaptation in 2002 titled Map For The Wedding, it's 10 episodes and it's on Amazon. Haven't watched it yet (I'm not paying for Prime, eww) but I've heard good things. |
| As for ep 3 I am now worried. New answer to the question is, if they pick up the pace and adapt it all, hell yes it is worth. If they gonna half adapt this hell nah. I'll update this in 3-4 eps or when they adapt chapter 38 (as of now they adapted 15 chapters in 3 eps, out of 110) |
| bruh |
| well the manga is great and definitely worth it, this adaptation is just okay. |
 |
| op is not wrong for asking it I used MAL ratings to decide the shows I'm watching this season, but I don't want to leave any out because it might be a hidden gem Also watching a 24 minute episode of like 30 shows just to decide what I'll watch is way too much wasted time, so I'd rather ask people who might know more |
More topics from this board
» How much will be adapted?mccreepyy - Oct 4 |
20 |
by billybub
»»
13 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Kekkon suru tte, Hontou desu ka Episode 8 DiscussionStark700 - Yesterday |
40 |
by billybub
»»
2 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Kekkon suru tte, Hontou desu ka Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Nov 14 |
50 |
by MegamiRem
»»
Yesterday, 3:02 AM |
|
Poll: » Kekkon suru tte, Hontou desu ka Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Oct 17 |
69 |
by mycroft67
»»
Nov 19, 12:54 AM |
|
Poll: » Kekkon suru tte, Hontou desu ka Episode 6 DiscussionStark700 - Nov 7 |
45 |
by MegamiRem
»»
Nov 18, 7:56 AM |