I review anime based on rather,objective factors of storytelling.
Plot
Normal stories stick to their novel premise,Very episodic storytelling methods or linear story-lines.Basically "I can see the ending" .They stick to established "genre" tags.
Exceptional stories have strong overarching elements that make you have to watch till the end to see it unfold to have it happen or understand it.
I'm not really interested in realism on its own.Why would I want anime to be too equal to real life?. It defeats the purpose of the medium.I'm interested in logical consistency; things must happen for a good reason.The route must be treated with as much importance as the event.
Characters
Normal stories tend to be more informative and show "a lesson learnt" .Or dramatic for emotional fulfillment.
Exceptional stories tend to makes characters grow and change over the course of the story,With believable progression and development based on experiences, not just dialogue.
Proactive characters for the most part, are better than reactive characters.
Emotions forced or genuine?
Themes
Do you present a story with black and white morals?Or do you present grey ideas that people may question due to" outer status, power, image" absurdity but can stand cause its emotions and ideas are true to reality?
Jokes on you, the "poorly-written, illogical SOL" by Tamiki Wakaki have 6 volumes now and sold 100, 000 copies in Japan and worldwide. Pretty good for a "manga that will soon get axed" if you ask me. If you want to trash something because the mangaka doesn't cater to your preferences, at least make it objective.
i'm not sure what happened to him lol
how can the same person who wrote the best harem (even he completely destroyed his best work with a bullshit ending), write so many trash tier manga ...
maybe he ran out of ideas or maybe he is just too lazy to put any effort into his new works
yeah its been a long time :p
i heard about the new otome game anime , i don't think i will watch it because of the harem tag
when i was new to anime i watched some harems then after i realised when it comes to romance i can only enjoy one to one love story, now i really can't stand any romance with a harem or dramatic love triangle
i'm not really a big fan of shoujo but some of them have sweet/cute /heartwarming pure love stories
i agree the new shoujo manga are getting better and better in terms of art/characters
i hope you are enjoying watching the new otome game isekai anime :)
some shoujo manga have the kind of romance i enjoy
i still need to read more of them
that's a good news , this guy can write great stories
let's wait for more informations about his new work
btw , the most popular harem manga currently is 'The Quintessential Quintuplets'
and it have a heroine so similar to Tenri 'Miku' ,she is the most popular heroine in this serie
i really hope she wins so i can forget about Twgok ending
update: he deleted my comment on his profile, apparently others' reviews aren't the only thing he likes to censor ahah ^^
i said he deleted my review as well, claiming it was because i didn't provide reasons as to "why" i didn't like the show in my review even though i did.
i also said that i think he deleted them (mine and yours and prolly others' as well) because he wants to show MAL that he's doing something as a "review moderator".
not sure mentions work on this website or atleast wether they work by @<username> or not but i meant to tag you in a comment i made on Jack's profile regarding our reviews and him deleting them.
Unfortunately I don't even remember what your review was about at this point, apologies if you think your review was removed with malicious intent but I hope you have a good one!
tbh Mal rating / being old and the shoujo tag put me off everytime i try to watch it
there is a lot of visual novels where i can chose my fav girl so i don't care anymore if there is a harem where the best girl wins
i lost hope in that genre lol
All Comments (108) Comments
how can the same person who wrote the best harem (even he completely destroyed his best work with a bullshit ending), write so many trash tier manga ...
maybe he ran out of ideas or maybe he is just too lazy to put any effort into his new works
i heard about the new otome game anime , i don't think i will watch it because of the harem tag
when i was new to anime i watched some harems then after i realised when it comes to romance i can only enjoy one to one love story, now i really can't stand any romance with a harem or dramatic love triangle
i'm not really a big fan of shoujo but some of them have sweet/cute /heartwarming pure love stories
i agree the new shoujo manga are getting better and better in terms of art/characters
i hope you are enjoying watching the new otome game isekai anime :)
this is why it gets a lot of praise
yep i agree
i still need to read more of them
that's a good news , this guy can write great stories
let's wait for more informations about his new work
btw , the most popular harem manga currently is 'The Quintessential Quintuplets'
and it have a heroine so similar to Tenri 'Miku' ,she is the most popular heroine in this serie
i really hope she wins so i can forget about Twgok ending
i said he deleted my review as well, claiming it was because i didn't provide reasons as to "why" i didn't like the show in my review even though i did.
i also said that i think he deleted them (mine and yours and prolly others' as well) because he wants to show MAL that he's doing something as a "review moderator".
there is a lot of visual novels where i can chose my fav girl so i don't care anymore if there is a harem where the best girl wins
i lost hope in that genre lol
Poor reason to crossdress
No story reason to be there.
Merely fujioshi bait.
Poor motivation to cross dress
Shitty characters.
I really hate trapes >_<
I doubt it will be as good as Twgok ...