Do you guys agree with eren plan from beginning?

Genocide is never a good idea and shouldn't even be an option on the table.

@Dan_ALves Agreed. That was also the message that the story tried to convey. While many people got it right, you could still see some not right in the head edgelords, obsessed over the idea of massive genocide and destruction happening be it in a fictional world or even in our real world, considering it even as an option.

@Adnash That was really something. The amount of people on board with Eren´s idea is mind-boggling. The moment he said Rumbling, the immediate answer should be no. It´s like a reflex. But when a child with anger issues get´s a lot of power, these things can happen.
Zeke´s plan was less terrible, but it was like genocide in the long run. There really was no good solution here, it seems.

@Dan_ALves

Totally agree. There were no good options. Not doing any rumbling meant the Marley would be the ones doing the genocide. Zekes plan and the 50 year plan both had a bunch of faults even if they were more morally acceptable. The whole Chad Eren was a facade and most people who followed the story knew that long before the finale. Eren did everything for his people which was is still wrong but at the same time very in line with his actual true self.

I feel like he pulled a Khaleesi there!
Being a fighter for the freedom and the innocents, he ends up wiping out 80 % of the worlds poplulation!

Both him and Khaleesi went berserk! Thats the main thing I didnt like in both shows! they built up the characters sooo strong, sooo feirce only to end up like a total idiot!

Zeke's euthanasia plan was a lot better lol 🗿

Why not just "close" and protect Paradis as a place where all Eldians in the world would live in? I feel like if Eren managed to do that, at least for some time, Eldians would be safe from extiction and peace would exist for some time. They have the titans to protect themselves so I guess Marley wouldn't be able to win a battle against them.

@DarkBRl Then the history will repeat itself again, some eldian in marley will be like gabi again in some time in the future, hence another repeat of the tragedy. Plus, if eren did not do it now, there will also be battle inside the wall to determine who will leads and get the titan power as eren will die in 4 years.

At the same time, the politics inside the wall has started to collapse, so even if he closed the wall again, it will be battle from inside and sometime in the future, there will be enemies from the outside, which all lead to genocide again for all people in paradis island.

@OdoBean Well, the idea was to bring all eldians from Marley to Paradis. But I can see war building up from inside and outside Paradis in the recorring years. The power of the titans would be hard to control in a way that won't start wars.