| No need for hype for this anime, remember famous author like Jun Maeda who made Angel Beats, you can see how their writing jump into the hills. There is also the studio will play a role. Recently, the studio have a good adaptation. No need hype or high expectation. Just my two cents. Edit: After seen comments, many people get offended, I apologize if you are offended, I didn't mean to force you to not get hype or have high expectation. This thread is just my two cents. |
restushJan 15, 12:17 AM
  |
| We know. So? Why telling us? By the way...expecting a talented person, with a good track record in the industry, to continue beeing talented isn't that crazy, no? xD It's like saying: "Just because LeBron is good at basketball, doesn't mean he will be in the future"....yeah, but...it's Lebron. He's good. |
Merve2LoveJan 14, 10:42 AM
 |
| op is the hype killer |
| Well that's true, but that won't stop me from watching an anime based on an author who has written one of my all time favorite works. |
 |
| who died and made you king? excitement and disappointment is all part of the experience, don't force your lame energy on others. useless thread. |
 |
deg said: op is the hype killer op is dumb not because he is necessairly wrong, but because he thinks his obvious statement is, for some reason, genius (?) if we were to think in an extremely objective way, then of course, him having written a good show before doesn't mean his next one will be good. but thinking logically, if he is skilled enough to get his books published, keep making money as a writer, and having the skills to write such a famous show that was hyouka, AND having this series of novels sell so well that it got an anime adaptation... this is all evidence to believe this anime is going to be good. we're not talking about some shovel underfunded anime adapting some shit fantasy light novel, after all. OP is thus a mere an attention seeker, and also very dumb. I bet he is North American. this type of post makes me really angry. why did I lose my time replying to this? |
| Read light novels! 2023 Update: Do NOT read light novels. Regular novels are better. Glory to Haruki Murakami!!! |
| After seen comments, many people get offended, I apologize if you are offended, I didn't mean to force you to not get hype or have high expectation. This thread is just my two cents. |
|
Reply to restush
After seen comments, many people get offended, I apologize if you are offended, I didn't mean to force you to not get hype or have high expectation. This thread is just my two cents.
| @restush I get where you're coming from. It’s just… the way you said it caused unnecessary misunderstanding. It’s okay if you just want to express your opinion. Well, have a nice day. |
| Well said. If anything its more likely to be trash. Rarely do authors manage to keep the same writing quality throughout different works. |
 |
| no romance or comedy tag, what is this just plain white bread anime school setting |
| this thread is funny as hell |
| Indeed, I dropped Hyouka after the first episode, it was so dull for me. |
 |
| I don't see that much hype anyway. Just some fans of writer's old work getting excited which is very normal. It's not like a lot of people talking about it. It's just that fans have been waiting for a hyouka sequel for some time which will most likely never come. So their happy that another work of the same writer is getting adapted as a replacement for that. |
| I do get what you're coming from but I don't see much hype for this series to begin with, it's just few Hyouka fans or people who are interested in an highschool anime |
 MAL is the perfect place to shit talk about people's opinions. |
| Okay, and the point of the post is...? I'm personally still looking foward to it, specially with how many staff from The Promised Neverland are returning to it. |
| Dunno why people are riled up by this common sense statement. It's not like it never happened before, that very good and renowned source material was butchered by bad adaptation. |
 |
| Your post is way off base. There isn't even that much hype around this anime to begin with. It's mostly just fans of the author's previous work looking forward to something new. Acting like everyone's losing their minds over this is ridiculous. Your "two cents" seem more like an attempt to rain on everyone's parade rather than offering any constructive criticism. Just because you had a bad experience with one author's work doesn't mean you need to come in here and try to kill any excitement others might have. If you don't want to join the hype, fine, but don't act like you're some genius for pointing out the obvious. Let people enjoy things without trying to drag them down with your negativity. |
 |
| Um, what? It’s completely normal to hyping a new work from the author of your favorite or simply popular work. Therefore, there is absolutely no need to literally discourage people in such a strange way, unless you really hate this title. |
 |
| Angel Beats is awesome, but this show's 1st episode bored me, hopefully it will get better, otherwise I might drop it. |
No, this isn't my signature. |
| lol. Did not even see the hype, and I don't even know Hyouka. If anything, this show made me interested to see Hyouka and check out the author's novels. |
| Wow, what a poorly aged post. If they keep the direction and quality of episode 1 this one will be a generational hidden gem. |
 |
| Bro you were right. This shit is mind numbingly boring |
| |
| I agree, the show is inferior to Hyoka. The best episode so far has been the stealing the Osanai cake one and that's probably it. |
| 「Self Aware Cringy Weeb」 |
| Honestly, I am enjoying this show so far. I think it's a very interesting way to present "normal" daily situations instead of supernatural elements, as suggested in its opening. However, I can understand that this kind of anime might be quite boring for many people, as nothing particularly interesting has happened so far and its storytelling is very slow compared to many other shows too. I never watched Hyoka yet, but definitely i am going to give it a try after finishing this one. |
 |
HajimeNozomiUwU said: Wow, what a poorly aged post. If they keep the direction and quality of episode 1 this one will be a generational hidden gem. Sweet Irony huh , this post now ended up aging poorly as well, c'est la vie. |
Reply to Cestlavie_
HajimeNozomiUwU said:
Wow, what a poorly aged post. If they keep the direction and quality of episode 1 this one will be a generational hidden gem.
Wow, what a poorly aged post. If they keep the direction and quality of episode 1 this one will be a generational hidden gem.
Sweet Irony huh , this post now ended up aging poorly as well, c'est la vie.
| @Cestlavie_ Did it? The recent episode was one of the stronger ones. |
|
| To the OP. Copy paste your first comment to all upcoming Anime in MyAnimeList, just change "Author" with either "Director" "Anime Studio" "Original Manga" "Voice Cast"... You'll be suprised how it'll make popular, beautiful, sex idol with both the girls and guys and recieve super saiyan powers.😆 |
| I still enjoy it immensely more than the likes of Gimai Seikatsu which I heard most others praising to high heavens and deeming as far superior but I personally found very tone-deaf compared to what I read in the manga and LN. At this point, idc if it doesn't have the kind of audiovisual quality that Hyouka had, it still has at least a good amount of the former's perks that made it so investing as a niche story. |
 |
Reply to Ryuseishun
I still enjoy it immensely more than the likes of Gimai Seikatsu which I heard most others praising to high heavens and deeming as far superior but I personally found very tone-deaf compared to what I read in the manga and LN. At this point, idc if it doesn't have the kind of audiovisual quality that Hyouka had, it still has at least a good amount of the former's perks that made it so investing as a niche story.
| @Ryuseishun me personally, I like Gimai Seikatsu more, maybe because it's more emotional and the direction is great. Still, Shoushimin is my no 2 favourite. Anyway, for all the haters of Shoushimin, look at episode 9. I can only imagine all of you dying in shame. |
| Coming back into this thread after finishing episode 9 (the second to last one), and honestly, this anime has been pretty "meh". I wouldn’t say I’m outright disappointed, but the whole experience has felt bland. Episodes 8 and 9 were the only ones that had anything worth watching. The rest of the season just felt like it was going through the motions. I’m hoping the finale, has something fresh or unexpected to offer, but I’m not counting on it. It’s the kind of anime I’ll remember a few years from now, not because it was terrible, but because it’s that weird mix of “I haven’t seen anything quite like this before” and “wow, every episode felt like the same thing on repeat”. |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shoushimin Series Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Aug 10 |
84 |
by Dartsy01
»»
Nov 19, 7:01 AM |
|
Poll: » Shoushimin Series Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jul 20 |
82 |
by bydazai
»»
Nov 17, 12:00 PM |
|
Poll: » Shoushimin Series Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Sep 14 |
161 |
by Hi_I_am_Ed
»»
Nov 10, 8:56 AM |
|
Poll: » Shoushimin Series Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Sep 7 |
87 |
by CrazyButNot4U
»»
Nov 6, 10:15 AM |
|
Poll: » Shoushimin Series Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Aug 3 |
68 |
by CrazyButNot4U
»»
Nov 6, 7:42 AM |