Kumoiro_Shizuki said: Good, good, good. First of all, I must admit I've always admired One Piece's work. To manage to unite so many people around the globe, and to do so for over 20 years, is exceptional. This episode is the pinnacle of this sumptuous work. It richly deserves this adaptation. That's why my review is much more about the fans. One Piece fans are ungrateful spoiled brats. They have the immense privilege of seeing their anime evolve over time, gradually becoming one of the greatest anime series in history, accompanied by sumptuous animation. And, despite all this, they still manage to complain. So put down your knives - I'm not saying you have to like it, but you're not entitled to complain about the artistic direction of your favorite work. Don't be selfish and appreciate Toei's titanic work. I don't think you'd want One Piece to receive the same treatment as Blue Lock's catastrophic s2 or the horrible Uzumaki adaptation. So please, be a little humble. Ikr like srsly why is most of the Fandom so immature and insecure. They keep complaining and shaming on people for saying that they will watch the remake instead of the Toei adaptation like why can't these kids be mature and accept that the anime has its flaws and the adaptation isn't the best adaptation for the manga cuz of pacing issues. It's not about the number of episodes but it is about how they show Luffy struggle against some random Sumo wrestler for like half an episode even though the fight only lasted for 2 pages. They complain about everything and they are angry cuz the anime is on a break as if the break was not necessary. I don't remember the Fandom being this toxic back in 2015 or 2016 but now it's way too much. |
My 2024 Maloween candies:       |
| Thinly veiled attempt to suppress criticism. |
No, this isn't my signature-desu. |
OP in a nutshell: I guess it checks out, since One Piece is for children. |
Reply to TransferUser
OP in a nutshell:
I guess it checks out, since One Piece is for children.
I guess it checks out, since One Piece is for children.
| @TransferUser You just missed the point. Try again |
How did you even misinterpret such a simple forum post? Or are you just a hater trying to ragebait? |
Kumoiro_Shizuki said: accompanied by sumptuous animation If you think One Piece has "sumptuous animation" you really need to watch more anime. |
One Piece anime has copy paste low effort episodes like this:  Pretending that One Piece is overall anything but shit tier in the animation department is just lying to oneself. Of course, plenty of people are unable to even recognize the difference between garbage and god tier animation. Just like plenty of people can't tell the difference between 60Hz and 120Hz. Or Full HD and 4K. MP3 and FLAC. Etc. When people say that it does too much they mean it bites more than it can chew. If the result is the absolute garbage that most of its episodes are then it would be better to do less episodes. It's already too late for One Piece, though. You can't recover from hundreds of low effort episodes that have maybe 2min of content and 19min of trying to fill the time with nothing. If you like One Piece, that is okay. No one cares that you like an awful anime. But don't go telling people they aren't allowed to criticize this train wreck. As far as I am concerned the best thing would be to stop making the One Piece anime. Wait a couple of years. Then try again from the beginning. |
| Who are you? Why do I read about what you're apologizing for, what you're doing, what other people should be doing, in your opinion and your lecture about One Piece Fans + Bonus thoughts about a review you did and what you think of the Uzumaki adaptation? o.O You're a nobody who's seen a hundred Shows, in his Life. Shut up! xD One Piece Fans are not impressed. So deal with that fact and shut up about what you're up to. It doesn't matter. |
 |
| The anime still hasn't fixed fundamental issues. Fans have every right to complain about it although I'm hopeful the new season or run or whatever you wanna call it will be an improvement. |
| MEA·MENTVLA·INGENS·EST |
Reply to Cielord
How did you even misinterpret such a simple forum post?
Or are you just a hater trying to ragebait?
| @Cielord Thank you. I was beginning to wonder if I'd misswritten. Thank you, my friend. |
Reply to TransferUser
One Piece anime has copy paste low effort episodes like this:
Pretending that One Piece is overall anything but shit tier in the animation department is just lying to oneself.
Of course, plenty of people are unable to even recognize the difference between garbage and god tier animation. Just like plenty of people can't tell the difference between 60Hz and 120Hz. Or Full HD and 4K. MP3 and FLAC. Etc.
When people say that it does too much they mean it bites more than it can chew.
If the result is the absolute garbage that most of its episodes are then it would be better to do less episodes.
It's already too late for One Piece, though. You can't recover from hundreds of low effort episodes that have maybe 2min of content and 19min of trying to fill the time with nothing.
If you like One Piece, that is okay. No one cares that you like an awful anime. But don't go telling people they aren't allowed to criticize this train wreck.
As far as I am concerned the best thing would be to stop making the One Piece anime. Wait a couple of years. Then try again from the beginning.
Pretending that One Piece is overall anything but shit tier in the animation department is just lying to oneself.
Of course, plenty of people are unable to even recognize the difference between garbage and god tier animation. Just like plenty of people can't tell the difference between 60Hz and 120Hz. Or Full HD and 4K. MP3 and FLAC. Etc.
When people say that it does too much they mean it bites more than it can chew.
If the result is the absolute garbage that most of its episodes are then it would be better to do less episodes.
It's already too late for One Piece, though. You can't recover from hundreds of low effort episodes that have maybe 2min of content and 19min of trying to fill the time with nothing.
If you like One Piece, that is okay. No one cares that you like an awful anime. But don't go telling people they aren't allowed to criticize this train wreck.
As far as I am concerned the best thing would be to stop making the One Piece anime. Wait a couple of years. Then try again from the beginning.
| @TransferUser Once again, you haven't understood what I meant. Or maybe you didn't make the effort to read carefully. I'm not saying the anime is flawless. Of course One Piece's anime has many problems. However, it has to be said that the art direction and animation of this episode, as well as the latest arcs, remain of a high quality. Despite this, fans of the anime are complaining. They complain that the animation is so fluid and “too animated”. That's what I'm talking about, that's all. If this is hard for you to understand, there's nothing more I can do for you. |
Kumoiro_Shizuki said: @Merve2Love So, since you seem to be on edge at the slightest criticism, I'll try to be simple and kind so that you can understand without being offended by anything I say. First of all, what I denounce in my post is a specific part of the One Piece community, namely those criticizing the animation of this episode by declaring that it would be “too animated” and that it wouldn't look like One Piece. Just so you know, I'm not forcing anyone to like or dislike the anime I mentioned. I'm merely offering a critical view of this community, linking it to the animation. As far as Uzumaki is concerned, it has to be said that the animation has unfortunately undergone a downgrade, especially between episode 1 and 2. This is one of the reasons I mentioned it, so that people who understand and have enough hindsight can have a recent comparison. I could have mentioned 7ds or Ex Arm, it's the same thing. I'll end by saying, illustrious stranger, that even if I'm not an influencer, I have every right to express an opinion contrary to yours. We don't yet live in a fascist world. Not to mention that, even though I'm still an unknown, you took the time to read me, get angry and reply. You could have simply ignored, if you find this forum useless, you know PS. I've seen nearly 200 works. Does that mean I can't express myself? How many anime must I have seen to be legitimate to criticize anything, according to a random like you? You actually thought I would read through all that? o.O Your self-centeredness is your undoing, dude. |
|
Ability is not the problem :) I just don't want to sort through your ramblings. Sorry xD To Talk about humility, while expecting a stranger to give a fk about what you think, in such a desperate way, is hilarious^^ Peace out 😅✌️ |
|
Reply to Kumoiro_Shizuki
@Theo1899 Exactly. The anime itself has many problems, and fans have every right to complain. However, technically and visually, this episode was beyond reproach, and that's what I'm complaining about. Rather, it's what fans shouldn't complain about. It's as if JJK fans were saying that the fights aren't spectacular and well animated enough. That's being ungrateful, when anime like Hoshi No Samidare or Cestvs exist.
| @Kumoiro_Shizuki it’s not beyond reproach though. Art can stand up to criticism. Gratitude is good too, of course. You can have both. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Reply to Merve2Love
Kumoiro_Shizuki said:
@Merve2Love So, since you seem to be on edge at the slightest criticism, I'll try to be simple and kind so that you can understand without being offended by anything I say. First of all, what I denounce in my post is a specific part of the One Piece community, namely those criticizing the animation of this episode by declaring that it would be “too animated” and that it wouldn't look like One Piece. Just so you know, I'm not forcing anyone to like or dislike the anime I mentioned. I'm merely offering a critical view of this community, linking it to the animation.
As far as Uzumaki is concerned, it has to be said that the animation has unfortunately undergone a downgrade, especially between episode 1 and 2. This is one of the reasons I mentioned it, so that people who understand and have enough hindsight can have a recent comparison. I could have mentioned 7ds or Ex Arm, it's the same thing.
I'll end by saying, illustrious stranger, that even if I'm not an influencer, I have every right to express an opinion contrary to yours. We don't yet live in a fascist world. Not to mention that, even though I'm still an unknown, you took the time to read me, get angry and reply. You could have simply ignored, if you find this forum useless, you know
PS. I've seen nearly 200 works. Does that mean I can't express myself? How many anime must I have seen to be legitimate to criticize anything, according to a random like you?
@Merve2Love So, since you seem to be on edge at the slightest criticism, I'll try to be simple and kind so that you can understand without being offended by anything I say. First of all, what I denounce in my post is a specific part of the One Piece community, namely those criticizing the animation of this episode by declaring that it would be “too animated” and that it wouldn't look like One Piece. Just so you know, I'm not forcing anyone to like or dislike the anime I mentioned. I'm merely offering a critical view of this community, linking it to the animation.
As far as Uzumaki is concerned, it has to be said that the animation has unfortunately undergone a downgrade, especially between episode 1 and 2. This is one of the reasons I mentioned it, so that people who understand and have enough hindsight can have a recent comparison. I could have mentioned 7ds or Ex Arm, it's the same thing.
I'll end by saying, illustrious stranger, that even if I'm not an influencer, I have every right to express an opinion contrary to yours. We don't yet live in a fascist world. Not to mention that, even though I'm still an unknown, you took the time to read me, get angry and reply. You could have simply ignored, if you find this forum useless, you know
PS. I've seen nearly 200 works. Does that mean I can't express myself? How many anime must I have seen to be legitimate to criticize anything, according to a random like you?
You actually thought I would read through all that? o.O
Your self-centeredness is your undoing, dude.
Merve2Love said: Your self-centeredness is your undoing, dude. kinda ironic coming from someone saying "Why do I read about what you're apologizing for, what you're doing, what other people should be doing", if anything, you are more self-centered than him |
Reply to Ionliosite2
Merve2Love said:
Your self-centeredness is your undoing, dude.
Your self-centeredness is your undoing, dude.
kinda ironic coming from someone saying "Why do I read about what you're apologizing for, what you're doing, what other people should be doing", if anything, you are more self-centered than him
| @Ionliosite2 Me not agreeing with you, in other Threads, is not self-centered, tho^^ Sorry. Not what we're talking about right now. I get that you were angry at some point, tho. And that's okay. |
|
Reply to Merve2Love
@Ionliosite2
Me not agreeing with you, in other Threads, is not self-centered, tho^^
Sorry. Not what we're talking about right now. I get that you were angry at some point, tho. And that's okay.
Me not agreeing with you, in other Threads, is not self-centered, tho^^
Sorry. Not what we're talking about right now. I get that you were angry at some point, tho. And that's okay.
| @Merve2Love I don't remember talking to you in other threads, but I don't remember many people I talked to in forums and I'm not angry, you sound more angry than me in any case. |
Reply to Ionliosite2
@Merve2Love I don't remember talking to you in other threads, but I don't remember many people I talked to in forums and I'm not angry, you sound more angry than me in any case.
| @Ionliosite2 Yes you do. Only reason you're talking to me, right now^^ Seeya 😁👉 |
|
Reply to Merve2Love
| @Merve2Love The reason why I'm talking to you is because I saw a comment I found ironic in a thread after reading multiple posts, I don't know what you're talking about. |
Reply to Kumoiro_Shizuki
@Wyatt I totally agree with you. Of course this episode is not beyond reproach and can be openly and freely criticized. That's why I distinguish between people who have an opinion on it and those who criticize it without any basis in argument. However, as you quite rightly said, being grateful for Toei's work is also a good thing. You're absolutely right
| @Kumoiro_Shizuki Yeah we're on the same page. A lot of the negative reviews are just thoughtless bashing. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
More topics from this board
» let´s be honest. hype > quality....why? ( 1 2 )AkaiSanji - Nov 3 |
66 |
by LIVI___
»»
Nov 23, 9:06 AM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Fan Letter Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )IzanaSolos - Oct 19 |
281 |
by Shadow_the_shade
»»
Nov 23, 8:26 AM |
|
» I watched this and I liked it(I've never watched One Piece)utopia- - Nov 3 |
18 |
by AquaBlue-sama
»»
Nov 5, 2:02 PM |
|
» No, you shouldn't watch this around the Sabaody, or Marineford arc.Polatrix - Oct 26 |
10 |
by Zarutaku
»»
Nov 3, 6:49 AM |
|
» How caught up do I need to be to watch it?RizzardKing - Oct 24 |
28 |
by LilyVarbik
»»
Nov 3, 6:47 AM |