Report curvedtree's Profile

Statistics

All Anime Stats Anime Stats
Days: 184.5
Mean Score: 5.60
  • Total Entries1,554
  • Rewatched13
  • Episodes11,106
Anime History Last Anime Updates
Bleach: Sennen Kessen-hen - Soukoku-tan
Bleach: Sennen Kessen-hen - Soukoku-tan
Nov 18, 4:12 AM
Watching 7/? · Scored 9
Iya na Kao sare nagara Opantsu Misete Moraitai ver 3.0
Iya na Kao sare nagara Opantsu Misete Moraitai ver 3.0
Nov 15, 8:27 PM
Plan to Watch · Scored -
Buttobi!! CPU
Buttobi!! CPU
Nov 14, 3:05 PM
Plan to Watch · Scored -
All Manga Stats Manga Stats
Days: 58.4
Mean Score: 6.19
  • Total Entries330
  • Reread1
  • Chapters9,530
  • Volumes623
Manga History Last Manga Updates
Chikarawaza no Sister
Chikarawaza no Sister
Yesterday, 3:52 PM
Reading 45/? · Scored 7
Hitori Kagome
Hitori Kagome
Yesterday, 5:56 AM
Completed 12/12 · Scored 8
Chainsaw Man
Chainsaw Man
Nov 20, 4:32 AM
Reading 184/? · Scored 5

All Favorites Favorites

Anime (6)
Manga (3)
Character (10)

All Comments (35) Comments

Would you like to post a comment? Please login or sign up first!
Adnash Nov 13, 2:58 AM
I have heard about Lovecraft and Cthulhu, but that's it, I'm not very familiar with the concept. Is it like one book? A series of books?
He primarily wrote short stories. Some of them were about Cthulhu, 'cause while H.P. Lovecraft is most famous for his contributions to the Cthulhu Mythos, he wrote many other stories that don't directly involve cosmic horrors or ancient gods.

Going back to the Cthulhu stuff, long story short, Lovecraft created the Cthulhu Mythos, and his literary successors expanded it even further.

If you'd like to give it a try, then for starters I recommend picking up "The Call of Cthulhu" short story. :P

Where did I say that? lmao
Ayy, I'm terribly sorry... When I'm writing a longer reply, I just write it in a text editor. I find it more comfortable to do it that way. At the moment I was writing that reply, my friend sent me one of his early 3D models and asked for an honest opinion. So I wrote the reply in the text editor, copied it, and sent it to him. Unfortunately, I forgot to delete it from the file that was dedicated for the reply. xD I apologize for causing confusion, haha. It surely must've looked random as heck.

It was supposed to look like this:


Nowadays I would have done the same thing, back when I watched Game of Thrones I still used to think I should watch the whole season to make a valid criticism. Today I think I am just wasting my time and I could invest that time in experimenting something else, or just watching something I enjoy.
It's already been many years since I applied such "doctrine". Years ago I had more free time to spend on checking out shows that didn't look that much interesting to me, out of rather timid curiosity, or continuing watching shows that didn't feel fun to watch in the slightest. These days I'm just either not giving such shows a try, or drop them early on. I don't buy "it gets better after episode 200 bro"; if something feels dull from the start, then I'm not willing to waste my time on finding out whether it's gonna improve, remain the same, or get worse later on, lol.

Netflix tried to compete with HBO back in 2014 with a high production series too called "Marco Polo", do you know it? I loved it, so unique, but they did a terrible job promoting it. Worst thing is that they ended the series in a cliff hanger, I mean wouldn't Netflix know they planned to axe it?
Hmm... I think I might've heard about this one around the year you've mentioned, but that's it. I forgot about its existence pretty early on, after reading about it for the first time. I had no idea its production quality was high enough to be a show rivaling famous HBO series.

It seems that Netflix really failed at advertising it, at least in my country. I don't remember any friend of mine ever mentioning watching that series when we talked about more and less popular stuff we had been watching. Too bad it got axed in such way (I hate when a series ends with a cliffhanger and is not continued later, from one reason or another), but like you said, they did a terrible job promoting it if it was to be one of potential hits rivaling such a giant as HBO.

I started the original HxH a long time ago and dropped it, people say the 2011 (or something) version is better. As for Code Geass, I thought it was okay, I don't understand why it is so popular, even as a teen I don't think I would have enjoyed it as much. But who knows? I remember watching Gundam Wing when I was younger and I loved it, I tried re-watching and I kept cringing.
I've always found Code Geass's synopsis a bit off-putting, to be honest. It just didn't spark my interest enough. Or rather at all. Reading random comments about the plot and characters only confirmed my initial impression. I doubt I'd enjoy it, especially considering its 25-episode length. While it may not seem like much, it's too long for a show that doesn't immediately captivate me.

As for Hunter x Hunter from 2011, the bright art style was a major turn-off. I'm not a fan of chibi-looking protagonists. My friend suggested trying the older version with its darker, grittier aesthetic, but naah, it did not convince me too. HxH from 2011 adapts more from the manga than the older version, no? I heard it's a more complete adaptation, even if the manga is still ongoing.

Anyway, I guess I'm just quite picky when it comes to anime, heh.

If you didn't like the manga, I don't think the anime would improve your opinion.
I heard that the anime is very faithful to the manga, so yes, I think I wouldn't like it. I saw people recommending the anime over the manga due to brilliant voice acting, music, overall atmosphere, etc., but I also heard complaints about how the anime messed up the pacing in several moments, which those who complained about it saw as something completely unnecessary. This manga isn't a dynamic one, but woah, is that true that one short chapter about Tenma and that kid (I forgot his name) looking for fuel was stretched to one full episode? ;p

BTW I don't think there are a lot of productions that improve from one media to the other, I do think that Mushishi is an exception, the OST adds a lot the environment.
Is Mushishi good? I'm not planning to watch it, but truth be told, I don't know much about this anime.

We were introduced to Apollo, wouldn't it make more sense to make it about him? And only then about Zeus? Or would Kurumada use Apollo in this series like Hypnos and Thanatos? BTW funny how we would see twin gods being used again.
I think we will see Athena and Bronzies regaining their memories first, and what will happen later? Hard to tell. Same goes with Apollo. He surely is a potential villain candidate, but at this point I can't imagine ND's Apollo to be someone like that. He is pretty neutral, his judgement was fair, Athena and Bronzies complied and accepted it. Rebeling against him would be a dumb move from Athena, proving that she and her elite warriors have always been selfish troublemakers. Unless a significant threat emerges to befall on humanity and put the whole planet in danger, Athena's rebellion against Apollo's judgement seems unlikely. That is, if we assume Athena being wide, responsible and judicious. ;p

About the threat itself, maybe Chronos will make a move? I remember he was mentioned years ago in Hypermyth. More, he was originally presented as the series' final villain. But it was just one of original ideas, a mere concept that hasn't made it to the main storyline's manga. Yet, perhaps, hahaha. However, hard to tell if it will be ever implemented. It's uncertain if Kurumada-sensei hasn't changed his mind over all those years and still intends to use him in this way. It's been years since Hypermyth got released, after all. We'll just have to wait and see. I wouldn't mind seeing him like that. The next story arc will be the perfect opportunity to return to that said original idea. And perhaps finalize Saint Seiya's main storyline with a definite ending.

Sorry you had to read the lore to "understand" a brainrot meme hahaha

Oh, it was not a big deal. Just basic info about who was the dude screaming that line, what is the One Piece, and some information about other stuff I found interesting (mostly characters and their abilities). I liked Chopper the most. Cute and original character design, variety of transformations, impressive powers. ;D

The person that noticed it, and mind you they did it like 10 years ago or something, was completely right. Their devil fruits as numbers theory was right, but it wasn't a new devil fruit user in the crew, but rather the crew learnt Luffy's devil fruit real name.
So it wasn't known by the crew from the start?

Also reminds me of The Fable, I started watching the anime, the animation was so ass it reminded me of Record of Ragnarok, so I gave the manga a try. Wasted potential, it has amazing action scenes, but the animation didn't translate them properly in anime.
I saw people joking about poor animation quality in The Fable.

I also heard how the Record of Ragnarok manga has a brilliant art style, full of dynamic and detailed sequences. I can confirm it looked good on random panels that a friend of mine showed me. As an anime-only viewer, I enjoyed Record of Ragnarok anime. But yes, it would've benefited from more sakuga moments trying to translate the art level during action scenes known from the manga into the animated format.

Do you have other examples of adaptation you were disappointed?
Hmmmm... "Saintia Shou" comes to my mind first each time I think of such disappointing adaptations. Bad animation, comical-looking character designs (too big heads, weird proportions) appearing way too often (even in the opening, lol), and the story that was not given enough justice. Heck, even half of it was not adapted. xD What a shame. It could've been a good show if it had received a decent anime adaptation. Saintia Shou mixes well classic shounen tropes with shoujo themes. As someone familiar with the manga, it was simply sad to watch the story that could've attracted new people to the franchise and satisfied Saint Seiya veterans, ending up with such an atrocious anime adaptation.

Seems like originally it was a Youtube campaign from a channel called Critical Role, but with some crowdfunding they managed to create two episodes, Amazon liked it and bought the idea, so they made a whole season.
Interesting. I didn't know that. Nice that such a grassroots project was noticed and was turned into a regular show.

Netflix? Damn I watched the first season, it looked so good, but I found the dialogue so ass. Would you say it still is the same thing as the first season, at least dialogue wise?
As for the original Castlevania show (the one with Trevor), I say the dialogue has remained pretty much the same quality in all four seasons, perhaps improving with each season a little, but not to the point of saying "A-ha! Now that's a change!". Nocturne (it's about Richter) presents rather similar quality, but I found it similar to the last seasons of the original Castlevania show in terms of dialogue lines' quality. Perhaps they improved; at least that was my impression.
ame Nov 8, 6:55 PM
honestly, i haven't seen any of Guillermo's show either- i remember watching his movies and THEY ARE SO WELL CRAFTED, SO BEAUTIFUL AND SUCH HEAVY MESSAGE !!!!

ONE PIECE LIVE ACTION ??? lmao i might finally watch it if its under 100 eps then...let's see

however did you also stop to consider why does Johan want Dr Tenma to kill him so much?

not really, atleast not so far- he is definitely a sociopath? psychopath? like he is not a normal human to me and i cannot empathise with him like at all.

i see the religious fanaticism - lol interesting and cliche i think, watched too many media with similar trope... trying to "make a statement"

Tenma is a likeable character despite my personal disdain against people who suffer from dilemma where one choice can literally SAVE PEOPLE but well i can understand why it is so difficult for him, doctors' oath is literally the first thing a doctor takes so i empathise with him but Johan (i know people like him so much, he is the like top 10 manipulators of all time) i just find him...shallow i dont know- im in ep 38 and i literally dont find 1 SINGLE THING ABOUT HIM MEMORABLE maybe thats why i am getting pissed like "KILL HIM ALREADY LIKE WHAT?" ...Nina is good....she is proactive despite her own trauma.

im yet to meet this famous Grimmer so let's see..

btw I think I always end up enjoying more side characters than main characters
same cuz they have so much more untapped potential that i would pay to see

in the end i think, i have already consumed a lot of media dealing major themes that we see in Monster and i kind of find it okay...like im watching just so i can say yeah IVE WATCHED MONSTER...i like getting into the psyche of psychos and criminals, MINDHUNTER does a great job, the killing dilemma of the good guy over the bad guy has been very cliche to me (cliche, not bad) - well, im still optimistic about Monster...hope by the next half tables turn for me or not- its a good show just not the one for me.
ame Nov 8, 6:22 AM
thanks!!

HOLY COW ?? fr ?? omg just checked it out - i was unaware of that....lol i really thought it has so much more potential as an HBO show, i kind of love the human facial expression, the acting...in this kind of dark themed shows...it just makes everything so appealing also I LOVE GUILLERMO..he is a goat i truly hope he picks it up someday...someday i wish

I am completely biased towards Monster, what didn't you like about it?
99% people are...its a cult classic but the cult is 99& audience..i am not like "NOT LIKING IT" it just isnt gripping me...like i get it... hes a bad guy youre doc you cant kill...idk im not connecting with characters...moreover may i need to give more time...
Adnash Nov 7, 3:23 AM
I get you, but here I go applying logic on something that isn't supposed to. You used the same logic I considered with the whirlwind, but notice how you said "that's hard to escape from", it isn't impossible to escape. Uzumaki on the other hand is impossible to escape, it feels like everyone that was there was supposed to be there, even those that came from the outside and the spiral was - or rather needed - complete only after Kirie and Shuuichi "gave in". And as the episode ended we have seen that a new cycle started with the same things happening again. So, unlike the whirlwind, the spirals in Uzumaki are impossible to escape. But I digress, trying to applying logic to something that isn't supposed to.
Yeah, that's how elements of inevitability and logic intertwine in pretty much the majority of cosmic horrors. Some otherworldly situation is bound to happen no matter what, and even if it somewhat seems to look or feel familiar (here: spirals, snails, whirlwinds; all those elements are easy to imagine and are relatively common, not that hard to be encountered in real life), it ends up as something totally uncanny, distorted, only borrowing the original grounded element to use it as a mere tool to proceed with what the cosmic horror story is about (here it is the curse of spirals).

Uzumaki is far, far less refined and detailed than H.P. Lovecraft's stories about Cthulhu. Are you familiar with them? If not, then I recommend checking them out. I think you will enjoy them, as they are more than just "shocking and bizarre stuff mixed with randomness". They also provide deep lore behind all things that are happening in them. All of them allow to be put into the boundaries of logic at first, only to become overwhelming enough to not fall under logic anymore. Everything feels natural, organic and realistic, unlike in Uzumaki's case, where many things seem to just happen and where logic is usually inapplicable if one wants to describe or explain them more than just on a surface level.

So yeah, it's only natural to apply logic even to the craziest cosmic horrors. However, as they vary in terms of refinement, some might feel more logical than the others. Uzumaki belongs to the latter group, I guess, haha. The general concept behind Uzumaki can be at fault as well, because refined or not, putting silly moments right next to unsettling ones, and coating everything in uncanny craziness doesn't have to do much with whether a story is refined or not. It's obvious that many people might end up not liking it that much, especially after hearing about how brilliant Uzumaki's story is.

Oh, about "that's hard to escape from", I meant whirlwinds. The spiral curse works differently, even if it resembles at times well-known elements.

He has always reminded me of a hybrid of a sloth and a bear.
Good point! It genuinely felt like an allegory to reincarnation, with the wheel of life turned into the wheel of spirals, repeating the cycle of the spiral curse fairly regularly.

I still didn't watch Breaking bad because of that lmao, I did, however, watch Game of Thrones, but I didn't enjoy season 1, it felt cramped with content, but at the same time they didn't develop enough? Have you ever watch any of those? Or maybe had an experience with anime with that? For instance, I never watched Sword Art Online.
Haha, I see we have similar experience with some popular TV series. :D I saw two episodes of Breaking Bad, but I did not like them, so I decided to pass on that show. It was unfortunate, because months before it I read an article about Breaking Bad, and its content (as presented in that article, at least) seemed to be interesting. Sadly, the show itself happened to be boring to me. I don't mind slow-burn series, but the first episodes I saw were dull enough to make me lose all my interest. Welp, I can be picky about shows, even after giving them a try. :P

As for Game of Thrones, I didn't watch it when it aired, and I don't plan to give it a try. Not my cup of tea. I mean, I enjoy good fantasy, no matter if its dark or high or both, but each person who claimed to be a huge fan with whom I talked about GoT was overly excited about its sexual scenes or depiction of violence. To each their own. It's not a problem at all for me; I'm not a prude, but I prefer when a show offers something more than that. Unless it's dedicated to such stuff, like slasher movies. If it is not, then it might feel too pretentious to my taste. ;D
My only contact with it was through memes that some of my friends or random people on the Internet used to post frequently back then, to be fair. I of course acknowledge the fact that GoT's main series represents high production quality and the whole franchise has gotten a lot of fans over the years thanks to it, but as for me, I don't feel motivated enough to watch it.

About similar anime, I mean very popular ones that are well-received (which can be seen when checking up their mean scores), I never watched Hunter x Hunter or Code Geass. I thought about starting watching Monster anime, but nah, the manga did not impress me (I dropped it at some point), and I think I wouldn't enjoy the anime adaptation.

Kurumada must love fans like you, the real deal.
Haha, thanks. I consider myself a huge fan of the franchise, but truth be told, there are way, way bigger fans than me in countries in which Saint Seiya is popular and stands strong as a franchise, like i.e. in South America. You can find there more merchandise that's relatively easy to buy (like, just by ordering it online or by going to the store, without having to order it in a foreign shop or something) than in countries in which Saint Seiya isn't as popular. As for my country, I think the general popularity of this series here is hmm... very low. Perhaps abysmal, even. I very rarely encounter any person from my country who has ever heard about Saint Seiya, and once in a blue moon it's a person who had any contact with it in the past. In real life, the chance to meet someone who has heard about this series is even lower. The last time I encountered someone like that was, hmm... So long ago I don't remember, lmao.

BTW did you see the new special chapter that will be released? Something like "Saint Seiya THEN: Flower of Ruins" a sequel to Next Dimension. More info on Weekly Shonen Champion that will be released in November 14th.
Yup, I've heard about it. I'm excited, but I still try to tone down my expectations to not be disappointed in case the sequel manga won't be the fabled Zeus Arc, but something else. ;D

I considered it might have a reason because some authors go above and beyond when creating their stories and some of those "backstage" material are only "released" when the author does a Q&A and people ask a very specific question. For instance, (I had to check your profile and I've seen you dropped one piece, idk if you will give it another chance, so I will mark as a spoiler, so if you don't care about spoilers or if you won't give One Piece a chance, give it a read), someone once asked Oda in a Q&A about Devil Fruits in One Piece (...)
Yeah, I dropped One Piece pretty early on, though I read about its lore a little, mostly to understand all those "the One Peace is real memes" and due to the fact that, well, most of One Piece fans I ever encountered were kind of toxic in how they expressed their love for the series. In example, in most of the cases during which I mentioned that I was not actively consuming any piece of One Piece media, I got flooded with random names, places, intentional spoilers, and edgy, unhinged texts about "the rite of passage in case I ever want to watch or read OP", lol. I checked some of them out of curiosity, 'cause why not, haha. My friends who are One Piece fans explained some stuff I was too lazy to check on the fandom Wiki, lol.

Going back to the backstage material, I like that kind of stuff. It expands the lore without ruining the flow of a story. Of course, it mustn't end up as a conventional substitute meant to fill all obvious gaps that could've been dealt with in a regular way (so directly in the story), no matter why they appeared. That's what I call lazy writing. Enhance the lore, elaborate on something, explain it - all's fine, as long as it doesn't dominate the main storytelling.

Anyway, I don't mind One Piece spoilers, so I read that one that you've mentioned. :) Interesting. Perhaps some inspirations or symbolism behind various things in manga are intentional, and some are unintentional, but still rooted in subconscious connotations coming from mangakas personal experience, popular culture's influence, etc.

It saddens me to learn that mediocrity from others is the reason adaptations from his works end up being "bad".
Indeed. It's always a bummer to see a relatively good work receiving an adaptation of any kind that doesn't give enough justice to the source material.

By the way, on a side note, do you like DnD stuff? I was watching a series on Amazon that might be of your interest, it is called "The Legend of Vox Machina", well at least I think you might find their sense of humour to your taste.
Hmm... I'm not a huge fan of the DnD universe when it comes to video games, but I don't mind watching a solid DnD-themed or directly DnD-centered animated series. I heard a little about "The Legend of Vox Machina", but nothing more than the fact that it's an animated series with a fantasy setting (I didn't even know it was a DnD animation, haha). I almost started watching it some time ago, but I was busy back then and well, later on, I lost my motivation. ;D But I think I will give it a try one day. Preferably in the nearest future, before Castlevania: Nocturne's second season is released, hehe. Thank you for your recommendation!
Adnash Nov 2, 3:03 AM
It seems that videos shows different moment from each episode released, so I for certain don't understand what the baloney people were talking about when they said the anime didn't follow the manga to the letter haha
Maybe they were that type of viewers who mistake faithfulness to the source material with other elements, like visuals, for example. The former was alright in my opinion, while the latter had a lot to desire in general.

Oh... I didn't mean like it could have a happy ending, I mean, the protagonist could have left with her boyfriend and both of them would still be in a tragedy considering how her parents were took away by a hurricane and her brother became a snail-person (that never appeared again in the anime) and her boyfriend's parents went insane, even if they escaped that village, could we really consider that a happy ending? They would still be traumatised for life and left alone in the world.
I guess they were doomed no matter what. The curse in Kurouzu-cho prevented anyone from leaving the town. If someone somehow managed to get in it, like those people of various professions that arrived to the city after that disastrous typhoon hit it, then they couldn't leave. The mechanism was similar to whirlwind. You can get destroyed while trying to reach it, but if you manage to go near it as close as it is possible, then you may be "swallowed" by it inside the spiral that's hard to escape from.

Besides, we don't have to look in fiction for a horror that there's no way out, real life is pretty much like this πŸ˜‚
Haha, true. ;D Life is unpredictible, and on top of that it has one specific point that every human is cursed to reach one day.

Now that I think about it, perhaps that was the intention behind Uzumaki? I know it's a cosmic horror, but the presence of an element describing inevitability that cannot be escaped from and that leads only to death, so spirals and the whole curse, could've been intentional; a peculiar parallel to human existence. It can really feel very uncanny for a person who, let's say, is young, full of vigor, and in good health, but despite that starts pondering on it for too long.

Understandable, sometimes I harshly criticise productions and I end up not enjoying them as much as other people do. I felt like the same happened with the latest Saint Seiya production. I also try to find logic in the stuff that I watch and if it lacks logic, I most likely will end up disliking it.
Yeah, I have a specific taste when picking up shows. I can also be perhaps overly harsh towards stuff I don't like, no matter if it's highly praised by the majority of people who experienced it, or not.

While I acknowledge that subjectivity is inherent in any form of critique, I strive for objectivity in my assessments. This means I might be harsher or more lenient than others, but always based on the technical aspects of the work.

For example, if I dislike something, I may focus on its flaws more than others. Conversely, if I enjoy it, I might highlight positive elements that others overlook. All within the boundaries of the technical side of things I'm talking about, of course.

I can't just turn off my brain and enjoy stuff haha
Luckily, I can do this myself, but only for things that somehow grabbed my attention in a positive way. Good visuals, music, plot, likeable characters, etc. All those things, preferably combined (depending on a medium; books don't have soundtracks playing from their pages by default, lol), can make me just turn my brain off and enjoy what I'm watching or reading or whatever, as it is.

As for the live-action Saint Seiya movie, I enjoyed it for what it was. I don't feel like watching it again, but once I just focused on action and some other aspects I found interesting (i.e. Cloth designs), and tried to forget I'm watching something belonging to the Saint Seiya franchise, the movie felt fine. Nothing big, but nothing terrible either. Just fine. ;p

I found them quite nonsense, I was truly trying to understand how their homeroom teacher became a snail-person just by stepping on the eggs. When I saw him there I was sure he would become a snail-person, quite obvious, but I would still question myself: why does someone becomes a snail person? Why the beautiful girl had the spiral on her forehead? Why the protagonist had her hair in spirals? Was this also random? Or did Junji Ito had a reason for each character transforming in a specific spiral aberration? Did you ever stop to consider that?
Yeah, Uzumaki is full of such plot elements. Or I should say "plot conveniences", not to use the word "asspulls". They are okay, even if surreal and bizarre, to the point you realize that all of them were basically "wacky and random spiral-themed stuff appearing out of nowhere".

As for giant snails, people turned into them because of the spiral curse and them moving slowly, like snails. Y'know, they walked slowly, or were thinking slowly, or were doing whatever they were doing slowly, so they turned into snails, that are also slow creatures. And have, in most of cases, a spiral-shaped shell, lol. The first individual to turn into a snail was that kid who was slow in general, exhibiting slowness and sluggishness combined, both physically and mentally (slow movements, slow thinking, etc.). The homeroom teacher perhaps was slow in some way, or perhaps the sole contact with those eggs turned him into a snail person. I also found it irrational, but in a silly way. At some point I got used to those elements when reading the manga, so I wasn't bothered by them in the anime, but I understand anime-only viewers who weren't impressed by them, but rather annoyed or confused on how that highly appraised horror story is just a bizarre shitshow at so many times.

About a reason for each character transforming in a specific spiral abberation, I think it was not completely random, but it wasn't also completely complex and refined. There were obvious cases of spiral curse affecting certain people in a certain way because of a certain reason (like the kid who turned into a snail), but I can't find or think about any explanation to any symbolism behind curly hair turning into spirals, or local thugs turning into whirlwind surfers, lol.

This whole story is basically about weird spiral-related stuff happening to everything. I guess it's all about uncanny atmosphere and cosmic horror elements I mentioned earlier implemented into it, less about the story or its characters if they are not related to the world of spirals in any way. If it's a specific type of humor, then well, it appeared in most of works created by Junji Ito that I have stumbled since picking up Uzumaki, haha.

That's definitely one of the ways to describe an animation. So, I wonder if the "curse" behind Junji Ito's anime production are limited to "bad" adaptation. Whenever I hear "curse" I imagine something more dark behind it, not that the work environment for people creating anime is the best to be anyway.
It's certainly eerie to see the horror stories of Junji Ito, renowned for their disturbing and unsettling nature, receive less-than-stellar anime adaptations. But the reasons are more grounded and prosaic, I guess, and also mixed with bad luck to have studios or crews not delivering a top-notch show from various reasons (lack of time, small budget, too low skills... there are many possibilities).
Adnash Oct 30, 2:57 AM
Really? I had the impression that the producers changed the original material from the few reviews I read, so I assumed the "low" rating was because of that. So if they were loyal to the original work, I don't understand what people were complaining about.
I read Uzumaki long ago and didn't compare its manga with the anime adaptation; however, I recalled a lot of scenes when I saw it in animated format. I checked, out of curiosity, whether my feeling of familiarity was correct, and yup, it was. Those scenes really looked as if they were manga panels turned into animated format.



I don't know what people complained about either, I mean in this particular aspect. I can totally understand complaints about the overall visual quality of this anime, but in terms of faithfulness to the source material, it was good, even if it perhaps omitted some minor elements here and there to look better as an anime, so it didn't adapt absolutely everything 1:1, which is completely normal for animated adaptations of various works, not only manga. If one wants a 1:1 adaptation, then perhaps looking for a motion comic can be a better idea than watching the anime adaptation.

Even that wacky episode 2 was faithful to the manga, lol. Sure, it failed in terms of visuals and direction, but its content was faithful to the manga (albeit poorly animated and slightly chaotic at times).

I don't know about the other stories, but Uzumaki feels so pointless to me. Sure I understand the whole spiral metaphor going on, but it lacks an objective, there's no moral, people are doomed to do those things over and over and there's no way to break the loop - unless there's a sequel that is about that, so I would take it back.
I also don't think the nonsense thing is a bad thing, I just disliked how pointless it was.
Yeah, that's the main intention behind pretty much every cosmic horror story. To make people experiencing said story feel as if no matter what the characters do, they will always end up in the place, and their story won't end with a happy ending; as if everything was pointless, brutally inevitable, with a higher being, or at least way more powerful than humans power guarding that whole gloomy situation and allowing it to take place. Not everyone likes that kind of horror stories, haha. Perhaps they are not your cup of tea? I like them myself, but I see why many other people might not like them, or simply find them dull and pointless, due to this genre's core elements I mentioned before.

That's nice to know, it will most likely annoy me too, but I will still give it a try, there are at least two stories that I am interested in reading.
Have fun! I hope you will like it. I don't want to sound like someone trying to make you negative towards the manga before even starting reading it, but I need to admit I found the moments you mentioned as annoying or dumb, less annoying and dumb in the anime format. ;p

Can you share some of those comedy moments that you liked in Uzumaki?
My sense of humor is specific, so what I found funny may not apply to the majority of viewers, heh. I found moderately hilarious the whole situation with Toshio, Shuuichi's dad, but the funniest bits were scenes with snail people. Like, all of them, kekw.

Wouldn't it be a case of yet another Junji Ito production that was cursed? Besides, he isn't a nobody, why doesn't he intervene more on the creation of the anime? I wonder if having a bad anime doesn't harm his branding.
I have no idea how those adaptations affect him as a manga author, but yeah, I've been often hearing that the anime adaptations of Junji Ito's works are underwhelming compared to the source material and its brilliant art. For sure, anime episodes with censored gore, or having it radically toned down, take away a huge chunk of uniqueness one can find in Junji Ito's manga. But in some cases, I don't think that it's the main problem. I saw the movie adapting "Gyo" by Junji Ito. It was bizarre, and after some quick research upon finishing it, I read it omitted a lot of stuff from the manga or changed it. Was it true? I can't tell; I never read that manga. However, I also read it treated faithfully the most important themes and atmosphere, despite weird-looking CGI that felt off sometimes... So faithfulness to the source material and CGI aside, maybe the story about cyberfish mutants and humans turning into reeking, farting cyborgs, wasn't actually "peak cinema"? ;D

Isn't it short? I might give it a try to see if there are any differences, would have been a different case if Junji Ito had one long manga and the anime was based on that and was that bad, then I would just dropped, but since there are several stories, I might find one that I enjoy, who knows? At least his artstyle is pretty.
Yes, it's relatively short, although it's longer than many stories created by Junji Ito that I heard about in the past. Even if I didn't read them, I mostly saw compilations of one-shots instead of one series dedicated to one specific plotline. Anyway, Uzumaki manga consists of 3 volumes, 19 chapters in total. There's also one one-shot manga, Uzumaki Tokubetsu-hen: Ginga, that you can also give a try. It did not appear in the anime. That I'm sure of without double checking.
Adnash Oct 29, 3:22 AM
Hey, hey!

Many people say that anime adaptations of Junji Ito works are mostly bad, mediocre at best. While I'm not an expert, as I haven't read many of his stories, I kinda disagree with it. Sure, these animated adaptations often fail to capture the detailed and expressive art style of Junji Ito's manga. Lacking such visuals in a body horror story can significantly impact the overall experience. However, if we focus solely on the writing and narration, these adaptations are acceptable. Many scenes follow 1:1 the manga content, treating panels as storyboards and staying extremely faithful to them. At least I can say it after checking out random moments from that show and comparing them with the exact scenes from the manga.

It felt like I was watching something more nonsense than horror itself.
Yeah, it really felt like that. To be honest, most of the stories written by Junji Ito felt like that for me. Interesting ideas, brilliant depiction of body horror, but kind of ruined many times with wacky elements ruining the mood. I don't mind hilarious additions to add more variety to the story; I also get it is a part of Junji Ito's unique style. But I don't think it works every time. And surely, for many people, those kinds of scenes can simply spoil the moment. That's why you can find people who did not become Junji Ito's fans after checking out some of his works. Enjoying the detailed art style and body horror is one thing, but the most frequent critique I've heard about Junji Ito's style were complaints about "stupid moments that felt off", "scary things interrupted by random humor", "gallows humor-tier comedy turning horror stories into dark comedy all of a sudden".

I guess for most people it's "love it or hate it" type of content. For me, like I said before, it depends on what kind of story is being told and what type of comedy we're talking about. Sometimes it can work out well; sometimes it can ruin the mood. As for Uzumaki, I enjoyed most of those silly moments, lol. I agree that at least when talking about Uzumaki, the majority of them looked and felt more like shitposts than "creepy and spooky stuff". Some of them, like the gang members surfing on whirlwinds, were kinda dumb. Like, a lot. Even if they served their role of adding more bizarreness to the whole situation that city happened to be in.

Going back to Uzumaki, in my opinion the biggest con of this adaptation was that awful quality drop in ep. 2. In terms of adapting the source material, even if my memory regarding that manga is blurry (it's been a while since I read it last time), I say it was proper. The last two episodes were better, but so what? They were still inferior to the very artsy ep. 1. Worsened art and animation, chaotic direction, awkward change of the general feeling... It's a pity, really. The worsened art, chaotic direction, and awkward tonal shifts were disappointing. Uzumaki had the potential to be truly special, but it's likely to be forgotten after this season. The quality drop, after years of anticipation for just four episodes, will be remembered for a long time.

I recommend giving the source material a try. Although I think, after reading what you didn't like about this show in particular, that your opinion about the story itself won't change much. The core is the same as it was presented in the anime, after all.
Adnash Oct 28, 12:02 AM
Uzumaki · Watching 3/4 ・ Scored -
What are your thoughts so far about this show?
Okeanix Oct 22, 8:19 AM
Your taste is horrible.
Adnash Oct 8, 12:30 AM
Oh, interesting. Perhaps she meant CGI KotZ's Poseidon arc? There have been various rumors floating around here and there for some time. They mentioned the potential 2D Saint Seiya anime project, one mentioned several planned projects, although no anime was announced. Not yet, at least. I had hoped for a ND anime announcement back when that manga was close to its final chapter, but now

I think the next Saint Seiya anime may be most likely CGI KotZ Poseidon-hen. But I wouldn't mind Next Dimension anime. Or even better, both shows to be announced, haha.
Adnash Oct 8, 12:23 AM
Damn... I thought it was just an affair or something, what a terrible thing he did.

Agreed.

I dropped the CGI version, wasn't really my cup of tea. At least for those that like there was that hint for Poseidon saga, right?
Yes, there was a post-credit scene hinting the Poseidon arc. I enjoyed Battle for Sanctuary, so I have fingers crossed to see the next arc, preferably done by the same crew or by a crew consisting of a lot of people who worked on the both parts of Battle for Sanctuary.

You are right, since we only get to see the Gold Saints, Saori and Aiolos's testament, we didn't see any "new" content so it could be anything.
With each day we are closer to Vol. 16's premiere. November is so close... Extra pages would be great, but I have fingers crossed more for seeing the official announcement of the Next Dimension's sequel. xD

I remember hearing about that Preludio de Pegaso a long time ago, will give it a watch some time, thanks for reminding me of it!
You're welcome! It's a really good-looking and entertaining fanmade movie.

(Sorry for a late response! I was offline for the whole last week, so I couldn't reply faster.)
Adnash Sep 27, 3:49 AM
Nasty things? I read that he had an affair with a fan, what else did he do?
Apart from having an affair a fan, he also physically abused said fan during an argument and forced her to get an abortion. You can read more here: https://www.ign.com/articles/voice-actor-toru-furuya-resigns-from-one-piece-following-affair-scandal

Well, that's good then, tbh I was checking Toru's Mal page and I saw Omega, so I assumed he did Hades too, but it seems Masakazu Morita that did it. So the baton was already passed, it won't be such a traumatic experience for fans then.
Yup, definitely! I already got used to his voice years ago.

Now that ND is over, wouldn't it be easier to be animated though? Or maybe Toei is just interested in the Knights of the Zodiac? And we won't ever get an animation like the OG again? Man... that would be sad.
No idea. I hope we will eventually receive the Next Dimension anime that would be closer to the original anime series than CGI KotZ. And I'm saying it as someone who enjoyed the latest seasons of KotZ quite a lot (I'm talking about both parts of Battle for Sanctuary).

Yeah, I've seen that image, I hate those mysterious posts, they are just to tease us, give us the real deal!!! haha
We need to be patient, I guess. It can be extra papes for the last chapter, a spin-off, or a sequel manga. I hope it will be the sequel to Next Dimension, naturally, haha.

I've also seen that a Brazilian amateur production is working on a fanfilm for Shiryu, due to release late 2024 early 2025.
That live-action one? If yes, then I heard about it. Looks cool, however, I prefer animated stuff, so I'm more excited about Saint Seiya stuff that Hakuren is currently working on (Preludio de Pegaso and its spin-off Crónicas Celestes; first episode of each work can be watched on YouTube).
Adnash Sep 26, 3:57 AM
Yes, I read about that shocking and awful scandal. I read he stepped down from his iconic roles. No matter whether it was his own decision, or if many companies simply decided to lay him off. I'm not surprised something like that happened as a consequence of him doing so many nasty things. What a shame to see the career of this iconic voice actor, who has been voicing so many iconic characters for decades, basically getting ruined, with his legend tarnished. And all of that at retirement age. Welp, he's the only one to blame. It doesn't take much to be a decent person.

As for Pegasus Seiya, fear not! Masakazu Morita had proven many years ago to be a great replacement, and over the next years cemented his position as Seiya's voice (and have been voicing him a lot, on top of that). To be honest, if the Zeus arc ever receives an animated adaptation, I'd prefer to hear Masakazu Morita voicing Seiya than Touru Furuya. Even without that nasty scandal with Furuya, I think the more dynamic voice of Seiya, coming from a younger voice actor, could feel and sound better in a hypothetical Zeus arc anime. But well, firstly we need to see Next Dimension animated, hehe.

Speaking about the Zeus arc, have you seen one of the latest news posted on the official Kurumada Production website? The one with a mysterious image posted by Izo Okada is powerfully exciting to see. :D I didn't expect anything to appear so soon, I mean before November (the last ND volume is gonna be released on November). Link: https://kurumadapro.com/column/article_130.html
almightybismarck Sep 23, 8:10 PM
Hell Arc has yet to be serialized. It's most likely going to take 5 years until it get animated.
almightybismarck Sep 23, 7:29 AM
How about Seiyuu of the Bleach character I forgot name of? Captain Unohana was her name I guess. She have the similar vibe. Also, never seen the alternative poster of 1989's film.
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login