| It's Sakamover. Lower your expectations and maybe you'll enjoy this. |
| tms is one of the greatest studios oat π€ i’m sure it won’t look like dog shit like their other stuff! |
| I can see that tad of Ex arm on the 3D scenes, but I think its still quite good, I like the textures They are the same guys that did Dr Stone and orange |
TyujgMay 27, 2024 7:33 AM
18927 said: It's Sakamover. Lower your expectations and maybe you'll enjoy this Nice alt account dude with Luffy avatar i don't remember the username You don't think this thread won't get nuked like the last one? |
 |
Reply to DigiCat
18927 said:
It's Sakamover. Lower your expectations and maybe you'll enjoy this
It's Sakamover. Lower your expectations and maybe you'll enjoy this
Nice alt account dude with Luffy avatar i don't remember the username
You don't think this thread won't get nuked like the last one?
| @DigiCat What? It's my main acc. I'd never use Luffy as my avatar. Mid piece sucks. I don't know what other thread you mean |
| First hate thread appears so fast. That means source material must be very good and it is worth to be hyped. |
 |
| TMS has a good track record. I'm optimistic that they will get the vibe right. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
| I thought the teaser trailer was cool. |
Reply to FMmatron
TMS has a good track record. I'm optimistic that they will get the vibe right.
| @FMmatron The director is someone that has only worked on kid shows with most likely no contacts in the industry. He won't be able to elevate the source material at all as you can see in the trailer already. The vibes will be there as you said with Taku Kishimoto as the screenwriter and character designs are faithful by Moriyama. It'll be average at best, but not something that will be big or better than the source material. I'm still hoping the best for SD because it's legit the best action packed manga in jump rn. |
   “You yourself have to change first, or nothing will change for you!” ' |
| Aw fuck sakes. TMS is the LAST studio you'd wanna entrust a fast paced manga to, prepare for an absolute snoozefest. Not even 2024 normie overhype will save this from disappointment |
| Yeah. Why even watch it, am I right? Forget about it. For a community that is plain stealing 90% of the stuff that we supposedly love and enjoy we sure as hell are critical as fk. Even if there's not even an Episode out for us to illegally snatch^^ We don't care. We shit on it, anyways xD Proud of you, guys. |
 |
| ok nah from the trailer it looks really nice imo, so many haters out here |
  me candies:        |
Reply to Peenutz
It’ll look average with above average moments. I don’t think judging it based on this teaser is entirely fair but at the same time I also don’t think the trailers will be that much better
| @Peenutz gonna assume its gonna be average/above average moments too, the trailer looked nice to me, they need to put out some more trailers though |
| me candies: |
| Really. TMS who make Conan more than 25 years is mid studio. What a nonsense. |
 |
| And here we go, it's already started. First doomposting thread with people doomposting about how it's gonna be mid and how this show is (pardon my repetition) doomed already, 7 months before the show is even out. All off of a minute long trailer btw. MAL never ceases to amaze me π I will say though, that I'm being cautiously optimistic with my expectations right now simply because Sakamoto will probably fall victim to the same issue that plagues the anime for MHA: the art of the manga is so detailed and sharp that it'll just be impossible to perfectly recreate certain panels 1:1 for the anime (which we might just have to suck up and accept tbh), so that'll be a source of criticism for those who have read the manga. Anime-onlies might not care but manga readers definitely will notice the difference. |
thebrentinator24May 27, 2024 4:49 PM
| People on MAL refuse to actually enjoy watching anime. Your taste in anime isn't a personality trait. MAL is literally just anime Twitter as its own website lol. |
Reply to OvergrownRover
Don’t know why so many people are making assumptions on the staff when only the director has been announced, the rest of the staff don’t contribute to the animation quality, but tbf the director is pretty mediocre
| @OvergrownRover Series Composition and character design have also been confirmed. And character designers specially are some of the biggest contributors to animation, not only because of they having to imagine how those designs will translate to animation, but depending on who it is, they have enough power to call people they worked in the past to help with production. With You Moriyama as character designer, there is a chance he could bring some staff from Megalo Box to help, like Takashi Kawaguchi. |
| bait used to be subtle |
| peak doomposting from alt accounts classic modern anime "fans" missing the netflix doompost to complete the set(which is semi confirmed) |
| reiwa weebs will unironically tell u they want a remake or sequel but when they get it ,its suddenly souless and a cashgrab cause they dont like the thing anymore and cant fathom they grew out of it and must mean the show somehow became bad |
Reply to OvergrownRover
Oongbuh said:
@OvergrownRover Series Composition and character design have also been confirmed. And character designers specially are some of the biggest contributors to animation, not only because of they having to imagine how those designs will translate to animation, but depending on who it is, they have enough power to call people they worked in the past to help with production.
With You Moriyama as character designer, there is a chance he could bring some staff from Megalo Box to help, like Takashi Kawaguchi.
@OvergrownRover Series Composition and character design have also been confirmed. And character designers specially are some of the biggest contributors to animation, not only because of they having to imagine how those designs will translate to animation, but depending on who it is, they have enough power to call people they worked in the past to help with production.
With You Moriyama as character designer, there is a chance he could bring some staff from Megalo Box to help, like Takashi Kawaguchi.
Lmao with your logic then OPM S3 will be Kyoto Animation level because one of the CDs worked for KyoAni for years, CDs don’t matter much, great character designs can be fucked over by the animation (Record of Ragnorok and Baki) and bad character designs can still be used for great animation (Kaiju No.8)
| @OvergrownRover You're just putting words in my mouth. Character designers very much matter, otherwise there'd be no point in having them and studios would just trace the manga designs as they are. great character designs can be fucked over by the animation (Record of Ragnorok and Baki) You do know it was the animation that got fucked BECAUSE of the designs, and not the other way around, yeah? It was a deliberate decision to attempt to mimick their respective source materials' design instead of actually making them workable in the context of animation, which was a major reason for them being reduced to glorified slideshows. Same for series like Blue Lock and Dr. Stone. On the other hand, you have examples like Oshi no Ko having an excellent designer like Kanna Hirayama, who not only makes beautiful designs in general, but is notable for working extremely quickly and being able to correct a huge amount of cuts fast. Mob Psycho 100 having someone like Yoshimichi Kameda for the same seasons as Kanna. Or even the change in approach in JJK, from Tadashi Hiramatsu to Sayaka Koiso resulting in way less linework snd more flexibility for the animation staff. and bad character designs can still be used for great animation (Kaiju No.8) Kaiju does NOT have bad designs, people still being pissy over this shit? |
| Chillll, give it a chance before writing it off. |
| The studio is fine. Not sure about the director. I usually cope but thinking about how even David Fincher started out making garbage. |
| MEA·MENTVLA·INGENS·EST |
Reply to SideCharacterKal
@FMmatron The director is someone that has only worked on kid shows with most likely no contacts in the industry. He won't be able to elevate the source material at all as you can see in the trailer already. The vibes will be there as you said with Taku Kishimoto as the screenwriter and character designs are faithful by Moriyama. It'll be average at best, but not something that will be big or better than the source material. I'm still hoping the best for SD because it's legit the best action packed manga in jump rn.
| @SideCharacterKal Well, so you haven't seen what he's capable of with a shounen like Sakamoto Days. To say that it won't be good based on a very brief initial trailer is jumping the gun. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
FMmatron said: @SideCharacterKal Well, so you haven't seen what he's capable of with a shounen like Sakamoto Days. To say that it won't be good based on a very brief initial trailer is jumping the gun. I don't remember saying that it wasn't going to be good, but average. there's clear examples in the trailer where they just take perspective and angle of the manga panel and change nothing about it. He doesn't have the experience of an action director, but his experience in directing should be good enough to get it done with no issues besides that. I'm hoping for the best for Sakamoto days π |
| “You yourself have to change first, or nothing will change for you!” ' |
Reply to SideCharacterKal
FMmatron said:
@SideCharacterKal
Well, so you haven't seen what he's capable of with a shounen like Sakamoto Days. To say that it won't be good based on a very brief initial trailer is jumping the gun.
@SideCharacterKal
Well, so you haven't seen what he's capable of with a shounen like Sakamoto Days. To say that it won't be good based on a very brief initial trailer is jumping the gun.
I don't remember saying that it wasn't going to be good, but average. there's clear examples in the trailer where they just take perspective and angle of the manga panel and change nothing about it. He doesn't have the experience of an action director, but his experience in directing should be good enough to get it done with no issues besides that. I'm hoping for the best for Sakamoto days π
| @SideCharacterKal You said it will be average at best. There's more to an adaptation than how manga panels are animated. Besides, many first trailers/teasers only show static images or some panels, that doesn't mean much. Let's at least wait for the final trailer and even that one won't be as telling as the actual episodes. |
One Piece episode 914 & 915 & 1027 were a mistake and 957 brought the salvation - FMmatron |
Reply to luvcalv
i know this is bait but undead unluck was pretty good π€·π»βοΈ
| @luvcalv UU was made by different studio. Sadly it's not bait, but true facts unfortunately. Given recent TMS' works and director's works, having Sakamoto in their hands doesn't fill me with joy. |
18927May 28, 2024 12:46 PM
Well the director and staff seem to be passionate. So I'm kinda hopeful π€  |
Reply to GYATyoruichi
yg said:
tms is one of the greatest studios oat π€ i’m sure it won’t look like dog shit like their other stuff!
tms is one of the greatest studios oat π€ i’m sure it won’t look like dog shit like their other stuff!
mid rage bait. 3/10
| @GYATyoruichi "GYATyoruichi" aight bro |
| Personally, I thought it wasn't that bad. |
   |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )IzanaSolos - Feb 1 |
101 |
by Merve2Love
»»
4 hours ago |
|
» Ending title song is bugging me can't stop thinking bout itAvamarie316 - Yesterday |
21 |
by Chiken666
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )IzanaSolos - Jan 4 |
274 |
by eaticia
»»
10 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )anime-prime - Jan 25 |
115 |
by beeftoki
»»
Today, 3:17 AM |
|
» whatβs up w the grain?yg - Jan 11 |
43 |
by M-T_S
»»
Today, 12:34 AM |