| Hello everyone! I watched this so overrated anime called "clannad" few months ago and i dropped it after ~15 episodes. But i've been wondering - what makes this anime so horrible? :| Here's my list of things, that made me vomit in crapnad: 1) Mix of realism and.... Hm - "phantasy"? I mean have anyone ever seen a ghost-girl wandering the school and making "wooden shurikens" while at the same time lying in hospital in a coma? Stick to realism [or at least try to be as close as possible] (battletech) or make "miracles" common in the whole universe (star wars) for goodness sake! 2) Jokes and "funny" situations - i couldn't bring myself to laugh even once :| Making comedy that's not funny but irritating is one hell of the epic fail imo. 3)Drama without... drama :| *similar to #2* 4) Characters!!! What is this Suckagami doing there (except for stealing some time and kicking the most irritating person i've ever seen in anime)? Why was she even introduced? Well i don't know (maybe that's becouse i have't watched the "show" until the end?) :P Also the #1 rule of the harem genre is working here - the worse the main characters personality is, more of the girls are attracted to him - (again :P) have anyone seen that work in reality? I don't think so :P And finally... Nagisa... She's so helpless, it's a miracle that she breaths all by herself! 5) Kotomi arc... Ending of it to be precise. From what i remember briefcase with the teddy bear and the letter travelled whole world until it was finally brought to Kotomi. OK... So here's some questions for ya! - How come the teddy bear wasn't stolen? Can every single person read japanese? (if i'm right the letter was written in japanese...), Why the briefcase had to travel for so long? If the people are so bright so they can read japanese, then why anyone hadn't brought it to japanese embassy!? And that's everything i've remembered... :] Post your opinions as well so we can bring all of crapnads flaws, nonsenses etc to light! (let the flamewar begin! :D) |
| You're obviously a fucking dipshit. You have no life, or it sucks, and you just put your anger onto Clannad. I accept the fact that there are people who dislike clannad out there, but it was truly a magical, great show. It was filled with important morals, friendship, and love. Since you have none of that, you just hate on Clannad. 1. This show was a change, because most animes focus on sex/violence to get viewers. This good-hearted show gets viewers by focusing on how great life can be. And i'm sorry it wasnt a harem! BOOHOO! Haven't you had enough of harem? And it was an honestly good show. Sorry there wasn't enough porn. 2. Being immature and spelling their names with words like "suck" and things like that show your immaturity level. 3. Don't hate on Nagisa. There are people in the world like her, with disabilities, and aren't strong. Nagisa is like them. 4. Shurikens... Really? Were you even listening to the story? 5. Why don't you like magical things and miracles, and saying the don't exist!!! People with fucking cancer and diseases are dying out there, and when they live through it it is called a MIRACLE. Magical things can be a magic trick, or even as far as love. If you know what love is, whether for family, or girlfriend/boyfriend, you will know it's one of the few things worth living for. Yes, it was unrealistic that fuko was there when she was in the hospital. But, again, that wasn't the point. 6. Why would somebody steal a teddi bear? And, there are some good-hearted people in this world. In clannad, they could have gotten one of their friends, or even friken Google translator to read the letter! They could have been touched by it, and felt they should pass it on. And why point that out!? That wasn't the point of the Kotomi arc! The point was friends helping each other, and the wonderful love of parents and child! 7. Some people found this show to be funny. Well, yep. Yeah. |
 |
| To be honest, where you dropped off I would have hated this series too. I hated the whole first season. I still hate Sunohara. I dropped that show several times in the first season but over the course of a few months I finished it. I still have no idea what possessed me to finish it. Then I watched ~After Story~ Wow. I... umm... there aren't words for it. It truly is an amazing last 15 or so episodes. The only trouble is going through that beginning. >__> |
| There's a better way to tie shoelaces: http://www.fieggen.com/shoelace/ianknot.htm http://lifehacker.com/ |
| clannadrezz = simple troll @Skarmory gz - i'm not that patient :D |
| If your not that patient, just forget about this series. =D Go watch something more manly, like Tengen Toppa Gurren Laggan. If you can handle Dubs it's on Hulu: http://www.hulu.com/gurren-lagann |
| There's a better way to tie shoelaces: http://www.fieggen.com/shoelace/ianknot.htm http://lifehacker.com/ |
| I have to say that I do not Clannad as much as I like Clannad ~After Stroy~ but to call it truly bad? Let me post my opinion of the points you found the Anime lacking: 1. Well I didn't really like that character as well but it does have a large impact on the characters. Mainly Tomoya and Nagisa. They become stronger through the hardships of this little girl who is wandering around trying to make her sister happy. Especially Tomoya starts to become more caring. 2. Well I also didn't really laugh out loud but it was funny enough to cheer me up when I was down or make me smile at times. 3. Well the drama part only kicks in after the first 15 episodes though it doesn't really come out just right. The best part is the ~AS~. if this does not make you crie you are just a bastard. 4. You really need to look better at Tomoya. He is a caring, trutsworrthy friend. He may look like a bastard but that is only his outward apearance. He has become this way because of his father, who is neglecting him. 5. Well it seems that the message was transfered verbally. If it has Japense markings on it it doesn't mean that it is form Japan right? And to be honost apart from me about no-one in my direct inviroment would recognize any of those markings as Japanese. |
Simple troll... Anyways, I actually liked the first season. But the second series was amazing. You should watch it. Take muffer and skarmory's advice. |
|
| You have not made one vaild point whatsoever, you basically just big'd the show up.... you have to six fingers, webbed feet, be a relation of George W. Bush AND have no taste whatsoever to not enjoy Clannad You make me sick |
| I watched both series and I really don't like it. I don't like characters, don't like the plot. And don't tell me 'rewatch it and say something then'. Go die in hell ! I watched it one time and this is more than enough for me. It's just overrated. this anime sucks at all - for me. I can have my own opinion, do I? so stop yelling around and act like a babies. bye (: |
 |
| Clanned is just a bad and boring "moe" series. |
| i dont think moe is the right word...harem maybe? but all i have to say is people will think it's good, people will think it's bad. it's a mix of realism and magic, however most people don't get how the magic works, it takes analysing to get how the ending works unless your quite clever, however i couldn't get into the series at the start either, but im patient, i watched it, the ghost part with fuko was there for character introduction basicly besides that it was pointless apart from the main points made about friendship etc cos they forget her. after that though it gets better, especially in afterstory. it goes beyond most anime instead of stopping at school it goes well past that and into ever-day life, i think they tried to put stereotypical people of all sorts in such as the nerd, the delinquent, the nice, the clumsy, the sporty, the annoying, etc but thats what made it work showing how people can all be connected. if your 2 impatient 2 watch the series watch the movie, it's old but it will show u the main messages of it and it leaves out fuko and most of the magic aswell...otherwise watch the re-cap episode at the end of after-story. on the downside i really couldn't find anything but the semi-annoying parts with robot tomoya and ushoi or watever. it really only gives depth...and the slow start im being biased here though cus i love clannad since it gave a clear view of what emotions they're feeling and nearly brought tears to my eyes at some stages. the humour. everyones humour is freak'n different....i like the harmless humour and witty humour for example, but some1 else might like humour where bodily gasses are emitted in small enclosed spaces and everyone chucks a fit... plot: basicly 2 star-crossed lovers cursed characters: stereotypes of different people, all having their own troubles and goals, hidden or revealed. i say any1 that likes anime where the characters struggle and in the end pull them selves out of it and has a happy life would like this, but those who are full into the pure reality, or pure fantasy, romance only as a side-dish type anime probably wont like this as much... yay for a long pointless post that won't change any1's ideas to waste time =D |
| "I come for all who grow, crawl, and walk. I am the perfect hunter. In the end, I am the victor." |
Skarmory said: To be honest, where you dropped off I would have hated this series too. I hated the whole first season. I still hate Sunohara. I dropped that show several times in the first season but over the course of a few months I finished it. I still have no idea what possessed me to finish it. Then I watched ~After Story~ Wow. I... umm... there aren't words for it. It truly is an amazing last 15 or so episodes. The only trouble is going through that beginning. >__> this is pretty much my opinion on it too.lol. first season is rough. (and half of second season) honestly i watched it and i was like... i don't understand the hype.. it's an average anime at best. (plus it's so disorganized... and transitions are messy...) but i did hate the ending of AS because it was so random (until i read the VN anyway) oh right. and i hated fuuko because of her random appearances out of nowhere in clannad. they weren't funny. and they were just annoying. I liked her in her own arc but she really needed to stay in her own arc. it messed up the sadness of her ending after she started randomly appearing. (honestly a "wtf" moment for me in clannad) I hated a lot of characters too. Kotomi... Sunohara.. Fuuko.. Nagisa...Ryou... But AS is quite amazing. (second half) and i'm fairly sure i've pretty much converted after the Visual novel. i mean hello, i have a dango for my avatar lol. that should say it all.. VN is much, much, much MUCH better than the anime. (yes, both series). It actually explains why the ending is like that in detail, fleshes out the characters like they should have been and since it's split into routes there are no "awkward transitions." Basically the Visual Novel was the 10/10 masterpiece that I was seeking for. Thank god i found it. I was pretty much dried eyed throughout the entire anime. and I definitely shed some tears for the Visual Novel that's how much more moving it was (i didn't actually think it was possible, but...! i'm glad they made the impossible possible) Also, about Clannad being a "Harem" Well... I could see how it is.. but... it's adapted from a visual novel -- where you're supposed to choose between a number of girl characters.. so with that into consideration, what else do you expect it to be? but i think it does its best to try to stay away from being labelled in that genre despite its parameters. Even if I'm still like w/e about Nagisa (I still like Dangos but liking Nagisa is a whole different story) since I hate her type of character in general, but Ryou became more tolerable with Kappei. I've gotten used to Sunohara's humor and I like Kotomi even if she speaks a little slow and frustrates me once in awhile. |
appleadayAug 31, 2010 11:36 PM
| disclaimer: i don't own any of the graphics/pictures. |
| For all the praise season 2 gets for it's more 'serious' nature, I really can't help but wonder how can people take it so seriously when they all look so superficial and ridiculous. It's an obnoxious style that came from laziness. |
 |
| What I don't like about the series is the fanbase that overtly praises it as the best of the Key series and say negative things about either Air and/or Kanon. From my knowledge of the series, it is far from perfect. |
| Crapnad XDD Great name :] |
  |
| I don't even know how I completed the first season of Crapnad Dropped Crapnad After Shit after about 17 episodes. Don't know how I made it this far. I think it was my determination at the time to refuse to drop anything. I began dropping anime when I watched this garbage show. |
| my avatar is the bus driver from Rosario + Vampire |
Rezzeku said: You're obviously a fucking dipshit. You have no life, or it sucks, and you just put your anger onto Clannad . Rezzeku said: I accept the fact that there are people who dislike clannad out there You just contradicted yourself "Someone doesn't like my favorite cartoon so that must mean they have no life!" Nice job... Clannad sucks for many reasons. If I could enter any anime world, I would go into clannad with a fully automatic machine gun and just kill everyone. No, scratch that, I'd force Tomoya to kill Ushio while Nagisa watches, No wait, first I'd rip out her intestines and torture her a little. Maybe I'd just hire Alucard to come in there and fuck everyone up. Saves effort Oh yeah. The reasons. Well, I could spend hours writing and essay about it, but I'm too lazy. It just sucks |
 |
Cupquake said: Rezzeku said: You're obviously a fucking dipshit. You have no life, or it sucks, and you just put your anger onto Clannad . Rezzeku said: I accept the fact that there are people who dislike clannad out there You just contradicted yourself "Someone doesn't like my favorite cartoon so that must mean they have no life!" Nice job... He only said that because OP made no reasonable points to hate Clannad. |
| Something deep. |
Clasic said: Cupquake said: Rezzeku said: You're obviously a fucking dipshit. You have no life, or it sucks, and you just put your anger onto Clannad . Rezzeku said: I accept the fact that there are people who dislike clannad out there You just contradicted yourself "Someone doesn't like my favorite cartoon so that must mean they have no life!" Nice job... He only said that because OP made no reasonable points to hate Clannad. You hate an anime because you didn't like it. All of op's points explain why he doesn't like Clannad. How are they unreasonable? his response was also overly hostile. Muffer-Nyan's post is an example of what Rezzeku should have done. |
MushmallowJan 15, 2014 3:18 PM
|
| for the people who come here to defend clannad what the fuck do you expect when the club is called Anti-CLANNAD |
| RRRRRRRRRR |
Rezzeku said: -_- yes some people not me. or anyone who like good comedy7. Some people found this show to be funny. Well, yep. Yeah. i haven't watched it but i think you don't have a point. oh and this shit doesn't fall under my ptw because i won't watch this light heart-ed shit. that doesn't even make sense. i watch a review so i am good. bye :3 this show is not funny. |
| anime with cute girls is my thing. |
| It seem it's just trying to live off the merits of the ending alone. |
| "After I finish fucking you. I am going to kill you." |
More topics from this board
» Why? (ooo i can post here :0)Silence_Suzuka - Feb 14, 2015 |
6 |
by genesic123
»»
Apr 14, 2015 1:32 AM |
|
» Who thinks this anime should have never existed?jammydodger63 - Feb 24, 2014 |
3 |
by _Dazzle_
»»
Jul 29, 2014 10:29 PM |
|
» Who is the shittiest Clannad character and whyMushmallow - Feb 12, 2014 |
2 |
by UTSANOMIKO
»»
Feb 12, 2014 10:56 PM |