canders5 said: Okay, I am convinced you want to argue. But luckily for you I will comply to your childish retorts.
That is mightily adultish of you.
canders5 said: For one, will you for once read what I am saying before responding? If you read my statement, it was obviously based off of what has been shown as of yet. There were no future predictions or ultimatums said. Even at the end of your quote... it was in the context of of what I had already said... thus far. "I was merely pointing out the flaw in the plot wherein the entire anime thus far has been focused on an all-girls school settings, with nothing outside of school."
You are trying to point out a "plot flaw" that only exists in your head. They showed Riko at cram school this episode (and that she is extremely popular with guys, but only as "one of the guys"), so they aren't tied to only showing their school life. They have also gone out of their way to explain the family relationships of every girl, this also prepares for a transition out of school. We know that Sayori has a boyfriend already (who is remarkably similar to Suzune -who has a younger brother), that Natsuo has an older sister and a father who loves lingerie, and that Yukio has a deadbeat brother she obviously adores: that's more than we discovered in 2 seasons of "K-On" (not knocking K-On, just making a point). I am not "arguing" with you because there is nothing to argue. Your statement is patently false: they haven't trapped themselves into a "school" only show, they have laid a ton of ground work for when this show moves off campus. I am only pointing this out because you dissed the writing and plot development that has occurred up to this episode.
canders5 said: And your argument of going outside of school once is good, however, there needs to be substantial amounts of time outside of school in most cases (relationship wise). Without detracting from the comedic school atmosphere, I'm not sure how it can juggle both AT THIS POINT. You say "only" four episodes.. but in the context of this season, it is 33% of the season. I'd say that's pretty substantial.
Not at all, they spent 4 episodes developing the plot. They developed the characters in a way where they are now almost completely independent of school. Where school was what brought them together, we now know they are friends ready to assault the larger world. We know that Riko is friends with Natsuo who is friends with Yukio who is friends with Sayori who likes to torment Riko but is weak with Suzune who has a crush on Riko. To use K-on again as an example, it took 5 episodes before Yui could even try to play the guitar. So once again I want to point out that you are knocking a flaw that doesn't exist. You just need to pay more attention to what the writer is accomplishing.
canders5 said: Yes yes, a boy will be at school, we know, we know. Is he a student? No. Again, unless they cut time from the established comedy setting to focus on outside of school stuff in substantial portions, I'm not sure how it can actually work. My main point here is that from what I have been reading, people love the comedy aspect. Am I really the only one pondering about what will happen to that comedy if the established setting switches?
Why do you think they have to "cut the comedy"? The essence of situational comedy is that once you set you the characters and their relationships, you move them into situations that become funny because we already know the characters. Love Lab spent 4 episodes doing this, so why should we expect the transition to be a problem? Come on, use your imagination: Natsuo actually trying to impress a guy, Riko ending up as the "friend", Yukio competing with Natsuo, Sayori having fun with all three, and Suzune making Riko self-conscious about being "the wild one" .
canders5 said: I do not have a spacial fixation, rather I am a pragmatic person. I'm not even sure spatial fixation is the right term for what you are describing, but I'd rather not get into that.
Don't see why it doesn't apply. You seem obsessed that moving away from the "school environment" will transform this series. Don't worry, it won't. This show has been about characters, not their location.
canders5 said: Unless I am missing something here, the meat of this anime takes place in a school setting.
There you go with your "spatial fixation". Setting is not the story. No, the "meat" of this story is the relationship between the five characters, not that this occurs at school. They could have set these five at an office and still been funny. And if in the next episode the five of them went to the mall to try to "find a man", do you think that either the story or the comedy would suffer? Of course not.
canders5 said: Unless Love Lab becomes substantially more balanced in it's settings (one trip is nothing) I still don't see anything happening.
For someone who claims not to have a spatial fixation, you continue to bring it up over and over and over and over again.
canders5 said: And some advice for you, stop being so defensive and arrogant. Your points are valid, but your argument is not, in that you are arguing about something that was not even said... twice.
Advice to you, don't get your panties in a bind. As for my being mistaken, look in the mirror. I don't put words into your mouth. I pointed out your spacial fixation, and you spend 4 paragraphs, first denying it, and then the next three showing how obsessed you are with the "setting". I would say that this was highly ironic, but you don't have the self-awareness for it.
canders5 said: And it seems like you think I am anti-romance. To clear this up, I like romance fine and was simply expressing my opinion on what we have seen thus far. This is the point of a discussion board...discussion. I think you may misunderstand this concept
Never made a point about romance. You are projecting. And again I would say that it is "ironic" that you bring up the "point" of a board at the end of your post after you started it bitching about someone who challenged your "opinion" |