DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- With Turn of the golden witch finished, next week starts Banquet. Out of the 4 games translated, Banquet of the golden witch is most people's favorite. |
 |
| wow this episode was a little scary for me especially maria pumpkin expressions thing but i was a little dissapointed how battler slammed beato face on the table scene was ommitted and dread of grave bgm was a little off(the vn was so much better) cant wait for the subs i can imagine all the battler fangirls faces right now when they saw him in his birthday suit lol |
| Eh? It's out? I demand a link. |
| Rosa Musou was short but still did a good job showing Rosa being badass. No denying that this episode was rushed but it was still good. |
| |
titanguy654 said: Eh? It's out? I demand a link. titanguy654 said: Eh? It's out? I demand a link. Here man http://say-move.org/comeplay.php?comeid=24785 |
MarthX said: Rosa Musou was short but still did a good job showing Rosa being badass. No denying that this episode was rushed but it was still good. Hey you are right with all gruesome scenes it might be my fav |
| It was a Nice Goat ending :D I really miss nighteyes at the "Battler, you're the wolf!" part. Beato's boobs got a lot bigger. Maria's faces are so ugly. Naked Battler FTW! I'm glad they kept that. The part with Kinzo and Battler being eaten was awesome. Rosa-musou scene was way too short but it wasn't bad. I really wanted to see her stab the goats with the fountain pen though. The Tea Party was a bit too rushed and they took out the "Rosa, Rosa why are you such an idiot?" part which was my favorite part in the Tea Party besides Battler smashing Beato's head into the table and they took that out too ;_; But it was still gross and funny like in the game and they kept Battler's line about eating Maria and the "Slice up your cow tits and make me a sandwich!" line. I didn't expect them to keep either line so I'm happy ^_^ the ???? was too short but it's good to finally see Lambdadelta. Her voice fits pretty well. And I'm glad they took out the This episode was still very entertaining and not nearly as bad as I expected it to be. Actually, it's probably my favorite episode so far. But it killed one of my theories D: I can't wait to see it subbed. |
hirahira said: I really wanted to see her stab the goats with the fountain pen though. this. but I still like DEENs Rosa-musou(worldenddominator ftw), I watched the scene twice xD The tea party was...okay. Marias laughing face didn't fit...I always imagined her with an sad look, I need to read the whole second arc again... This Ep was rushed, but they handled this good, and this is still better than a rushed Episode 3^^ and..Lambda <3 I'm giving this Episode a 5/5 |
Kyu-chanSep 10, 2009 1:12 AM
     |
| Dread of the grave. |
Despite a good ending, I hope that Banquet has a better adaption, Turn had much more flaws than it should have had. |
| A fun flash game to celebrate Rosa Musou. http://ww3.tiki.ne.jp/~ri-msx/zero/rosa.htm Z is shoot X is melee C is special when you have a gold bar |
| |
| For anyone who is interested, here is the ???? from the game and the Tea Party And here's how the Rosa-Musou scene happened in the game You guys should check out all the Umineko videos from this user: http://www.youtube.com/user/hitomi04 |
hirahiraSep 11, 2009 5:51 PM
| I just noticed....why the fuck do the goats turn into butterflies? |
| well, i also think it was quite rushed, but the scene where used Dread of the Grave was incrdible. MarthX said: A fun flash game to celebrate Rosa Musou. http://ww3.tiki.ne.jp/~ri-msx/zero/rosa.htm Z is shoot X is melee C is special when you have a gold bar Cool game, BTW |
 |
PlatinumHawke said: titanguy654 said: I just noticed....why the fuck do the goats turn into butterflies? That's how Beato's magic works. Everything is comprised of butterflies for her. I'm surprised at this episode for making Rosa a fair bit more emphatic than in the VN. I don't the she even think about dropping Maria for the gold. She just stood her ground. I don't remember that from the vn, though |
The butterfly thing is mentioned many times in the SN. When the Goat that turned into another fake Kanon died in the equivalent of this very episode, for example. |
 |
| I thought it was pretty rushed, but then again, every episode since 7 has been in my opinion. I am really upset that they skipped over Rosa and Maria getting eaten by the goats, but I guess it was time constraints. The ???? was WAY too short, but at least we got to see Lambda :) Also, I am mad they took out the "Ni-pah~" I was anticipating it... |
GarLogan78 said: I thought it was pretty rushed, but then again, every episode since 7 has been in my opinion. I am really upset that they skipped over Rosa and Maria getting eaten by the goats, but I guess it was time constraints. The ???? was WAY too short, but at least we got to see Lambda :) Also, I am mad they took out the "Ni-pah~" I was anticipating it... You thought 9 and 10 were rushed? They were the slowest episodes. Also.. it never shows Rosa and Maria being eaten. They're being surrounded and a cuts to black with "When the seagulls cry, no one survives" |
| |
| I would have preferred more at the end with Rosa and Maria if only because Worldend Dominator is my favorite track in the game. Felt a bit rushed but considering the next arc is my favorite from the SN, I'm looking forward to it. |
 Profile | Anime | Web | Natural-Selection |
MarthX said: GarLogan78 said: I thought it was pretty rushed, but then again, every episode since 7 has been in my opinion. I am really upset that they skipped over Rosa and Maria getting eaten by the goats, but I guess it was time constraints. The ???? was WAY too short, but at least we got to see Lambda :) Also, I am mad they took out the "Ni-pah~" I was anticipating it... You thought 9 and 10 were rushed? They were the slowest episodes. Also.. it never shows Rosa and Maria being eaten. They're being surrounded and a cuts to black with "When the seagulls cry, no one survives" Oh. I just assumed that since there were all the chomping sounds it was happening. =/ |
| With this episode, I smell even more S&M Battler doujin/fanart than when the game itself was out. I didn't expect Shannon's shield to looks so flowery. My only true complaint here is they should've given Lambda more screentime in the ??? party. Animation had its ups and downs again. The gore scenes were well done, I really liked how they changed Maria from an apple pie to a talking head on a platter. Rosa's crowning moment was a good length as well. I dd notice Rosa missing her crest a few times during the banquet though... still I'm satisfied. *waits for the usual bitching complaints from the hardcore SN players* |
KantarouSep 10, 2009 12:06 AM
 |
 Ahaha~ Battler, you make me laugh. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Best episode so far. |
| satisfying episode to say the lest, though i will have to get on the "it was rushed" train along with the other SN players. The biggest instance of which was when Battler left Rosa and Maria and went to the dining area... They didn't even mention how that happened! He was just suddenly in a different room, and not to mention they failed to mention how drunk he was. Which from my theories seems to be an important detail. And they made it seem like Rosa was captured at the end... Didn't the SN say she died, and the Tea Party took place in the "meta world" afterwords? The other parts were satisfying enough as an adaptation but of course fail to almost the highest degree when compared to the original work. Though that should be a given. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
HawthorneKitty said: Best Line ♥ Plus the lines of Battler saying that he'll eat Maria in 10 years shows his perverted side, nice to see that after the gore. Though no Beato facesmash, I liked the ep. Rosa's gourmet meal was disturbingly awesome, loved how they did maria's head, with her all rolling about. |
ElikaSep 10, 2009 2:05 AM
| Okay I'm seeing how this works now. If you've never played the VN before, you don't think too much about pacing because all these comments are making me go "What are you talking about? This was finely paced." -So if I was to want to draw somebody into the show with only a textbook definition of what it's about, I'd probably show a clip from this episode. This was the best one yet. The tension was at a high and the violence, while excessive, had the right effect. -When Maria got pinned by the furniture goat thing, I was like "GET THE HELL OFF!" -So I'm assuming Beato is into that stuff? :P -IT'SU PARFECTO! -"Slice up those cow tits and make me a sandwich." "Maria, it's ten years too early to be telling someone to eat you. But make sure you tell me that ten years from now okay? It's a promise" "Uuu~ I promise" Battler is win. -I hope we get explanations for the stuff they cut out later. Like when Beato was saying "I'll explain everything" then we get a commercial, or like at the end when it looked like an epic confrontation was about to happen, the episode ends. I could even tell "They're going to cut to commercial now I bet....yep, they did" |
 |
| Wtf did i just saw? What was that? I don't know if i should just drop it or just look at it as some crazy shit to watch just for the lol. And what happened to the two versions of Battler. Damn fucking shit they just throw whatever comes to there head in there. After seeing the Rosa eating scene i was also wandering how is it possible for an anime character not to act good. I guess anime characters need an acting school also. |
PsychFreak said: Monad said: Wtf did i just saw? What was that? I don't know if i should just drop it or just look at it as some crazy shit to watch just for the lol. And what happened to the two versions of Battler. Damn fucking shit they just throw whatever comes to there head in there. After seeing the Rosa eating scene i was also wandering how is it possible for an anime character not to act good. I guess anime characters need an acting school also. If you've seen Higurashi, you would know there is going to be a lot of "WTF did I just saw" moments in this show. So it's up to you to just go along with it and wait until it's explained, try to make sense of it (which would be hard), or just drop it because you don't have the patience for such things and you think it's just too horrible to watch. As for the Battler's, there are still two of them, but they both gave up to the witch. Piece-Battler was eaten by the goats in this episode as shown and Meta-Battler was just sulking in his defeat until he built up a new resolve to take on Beatrice again in her twisted game. No comment on your last statement, the characterizations can use a little work in this show. My problem isn't understanding. The "wtf did i just saw" was about the constant increase of crazy shit that in this episode went too a new high level. The problem with this show in contrast with Higurashi is that Higurashi started like some lame overly moe country school anime that became a horror killer loli fun, while this started like a nice supernatural mystery thriller and became "let's throw whatever the shit we like from quote head guys, S$M naked guys to little girl heads that speak and want to be eaten along with a whole gang of witches instead of just one and who knows maybe in the next episode we will have ogres gang raping everyone." |
Monad said: PsychFreak said: Monad said: Wtf did i just saw? What was that? I don't know if i should just drop it or just look at it as some crazy shit to watch just for the lol. And what happened to the two versions of Battler. Damn fucking shit they just throw whatever comes to there head in there. After seeing the Rosa eating scene i was also wandering how is it possible for an anime character not to act good. I guess anime characters need an acting school also. If you've seen Higurashi, you would know there is going to be a lot of "WTF did I just saw" moments in this show. So it's up to you to just go along with it and wait until it's explained, try to make sense of it (which would be hard), or just drop it because you don't have the patience for such things and you think it's just too horrible to watch. As for the Battler's, there are still two of them, but they both gave up to the witch. Piece-Battler was eaten by the goats in this episode as shown and Meta-Battler was just sulking in his defeat until he built up a new resolve to take on Beatrice again in her twisted game. No comment on your last statement, the characterizations can use a little work in this show. My problem isn't understanding. The "wtf did i just saw" was about the constant increase of crazy shit that in this episode went too a new high level. The problem with this show in contrast with Higurashi is that Higurashi started like some lame overly moe country school anime that became a horror killer loli fun, while this started like a nice supernatural mystery thriller and became "let's throw whatever the shit we like from quote head guys, S$M naked guys to little girl heads that speak and want to be eaten along with a whole gang of witches instead of just one and who knows maybe in the next episode we will have ogres gang raping everyone." Yes, everything becomes crazy. That's because Battler surrendered to the witch. So she can freely twist everything and anything as she likes (she's already did that before, but now is ten times crazier) As Bern said, this game is "one-sided", Beatrice's influence is overwhelming. |
| Awww, Lambda was just adorable ! And so was Bern at the mansion ! nyaa ~ |
     |
| Pretty much good closing for turn of the golden witches. It just the witches tea party that too short. For compliment, nice with the worldenddominator and Dread of The Grave !! yeah !! What I dissapionted in this episode is when Rosa runs from the goat isn't her wrist broken and couldn't carry the gold ? I couldn't see it here. Also on the tea party, the food were awesomely shown but not how they make it. I really wanted to see Krauss's blood sucked until dry. Lamda's voice is pretty much okay for me altough i didn't like it pretty much... Just see Virgillia and Ronove in the next episode... |
 |
| I just started playing episode 2, and it's already finished in anime :( Certainly the best episode, i was a bit surprised when Battler surrendered, but that was just for a moment ^^ So hmm, was Rosa the culprit this time ? That meal in the end really looked like a, punishment for her past actions... |
| lambda seems like Miyo when she was young... |
| She has the same seiyuu too. |
| Absurdly epic episode. Everything from the half of the ep onward was just fantastic, it was both ugly and totally over-the-top as I like. By far the best of the series till now. |
 In every age, in every place, the deeds of men remain the same. |
| Gore, cannibalism, and sexual innuendo? why not, it's a horror anime after all. |
4kicks said: Gore, cannibalism, and sexual innuendo? why not, it's a horror anime after all. I really enjoyed this ep, can't wait for the next arc, but I wonder how many witches will end up showing up by the end :S |
     |
| Fuuuck yeah. Lambda. |
| While I have no qualms since I haven't played the VN, I really want to see that scene that everybody's talking about where Beato's head gets smashed into a table. |
| |
| I don't think anyone has put EP2's Tea Party on Youtube yet :( |
| Too little Lambda and no Nipah~. Great episode otherwise. |
yakisobapanSep 10, 2009 10:33 AM
| so another game ended. its pretty interesting the way they made it. i suppose now it will be a totally awesome arc since bernkastel will go all out. |
     |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Umineko no Naku Koro ni Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Sii_Kei - Jul 8, 2009 |
313 |
by luxarking7
»»
Dec 8, 4:42 AM |
|
» I want to watch it but...cvbnm07 - Oct 12 |
8 |
by Artorias-
»»
Nov 24, 1:07 AM |
|
» A(No-Other) Psychoanalytic Take on Umineko no Naku Koro niAerghlis - Oct 13 |
0 |
by Aerghlis
»»
Oct 13, 7:06 PM |
|
» What is this and why do people say this is a sequel to Higurashi?Asudox - Nov 26, 2023 |
13 |
by Asudox
»»
Oct 10, 12:57 PM |
|
Poll: » Umineko no Naku Koro ni Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )antidentite - Jul 15, 2009 |
215 |
by BlackStar_24
»»
Sep 29, 4:25 PM |