Monogatari Series: First Season
| I think you're confusing time spent on a show and enjoyment of the show. Someone can watch 100 episode of an anime because they enjoy it and they feel strong emotion while watching it, but if a 12 episode anime make you feel even stronger emotions, you basically enjoyed it more. And if the anime only has 12 episode, you basically finished 100% of the show, you cannot watch more. If you stop at episode 150 of fairy tail, because you got bored, you basically didn't enjoy it as much as the 12 episode anime, because you finished 50% of the show. |
| “I won’t rely on anyone anymore. I don’t care if no one understands.” – Homura Akemi |
Ulises1264 said: Well, yeah pretty much, I am saying that.So you're saying that naruto is better than every movie in existence. If you rate something a 5 after watching it then you would think it has a 5/10 in most categories such as characters, art, plot. Just because I drop a show after one episode doesn’t mean it’s a 1 it just means you didn’t enjoy it. I’ve dropped shows rated 7+ doesn’t mean I didn’t like it or I think all the rating are wrong it means I wasn’t in the mood or drawn into it at the time. Rating something from time spent is arbitrary it’s the same thing as a game I wouldn’t rate Call of Duty a 100/10 but I have spent 1000’s of hours on it since childhood it’s a 5/6 at best especially with the most recent ones things you spend 1000's of hours on, seems a lot better than the thing you dropped on ep 1 HAhahah????terpenes said: if the show is good enough to make people sit through many episodes to see it's ending, then it deserves a higher score than a random movie that no one rewatches.People want to see the end of it is it any more complicated than that if someone truly didn’t like something they would stop watching it if anything they say they “hate” it because it is so long and they wish they could see what’s going to happen instead of waiting for months for more chapters. Length should honestly have no input into rating at all if it does a good job of telling a story and wrapping it up then it doesn’t matter if it’s a 10 min clip or a 100 hour series handdog said: Good.gintama has hundreds of episodes and some of the highest ratins on MAL |
e, you completed Original Naruto and made it all the way into the 400's of Shippuuden. Congrats, Naruto appears to be your second favourite show, unless you've rewatched some stuffs. people like you always hate my rating system, because you know you're a HUGE Naruto fan. You expect people to believe you sat through 720 episodes just to make sure you finish everything. NOPE. Just lying to yourself and everyone around you.Lol, no. I just simply don't ever drop a show, even if I hate it, like Naruto. I understand that you are a kid, but plot holes are relevant. Because a show's quality depends in its structure. Writing some inconsistent stupidity is easy. Just because you have more math classes than histories, it doesn't mean that you like better math than history. Btw, if you remove my or others name, we won't get notifications about your stupid replies. |
I would never watch one piece again yet I would watch this movie hundreds of times. I think you lost the sight of what a rating is lmao I still rate this one movie higher than one piece your argument is stupid and irrelevant to the whole point of rating and I’m pretty sure as you can see from the comments you’re the only one who feels this way man take the L and learn how to actually rate something if you would watch that movie hundreds of times, we can do a simple calculation of 200 times 3 (episode count) and it will be 600 episodes long. This would easily put that movie up into the top rating if you followed my system so your point is irrelevant. One Piece is long enough that rewatches aren't neccessary as everything is highly rememberable, but still people rewatch that masterpiece cause it's amazing. terpenes said: this kinda just proves to everyone reading this how jealous you are of my cool rating system and realise you want honest factual taste like myself.This guys is so delirious he went and wrote an essay in his bio saying his way of rating is fact. man please just go watch a sitcom there’s plenty of episodes for you to enjoy |
| The only thing good in this trilogy is the last one. They stretched thinly one 180-page book in 3 hours for many of the quickest Us dollars, British pounds, Euro, Yen, Chinese Ruen in human history. And fuckyes, the 69th post. |
SgtBateManJan 26, 2023 3:26 PM
Help! I need somebody. Help! Not just anybody. Help! You know I need someone. Helpppppp!  |
if i really "LOVVVVED" your rating system couldn't i just follow it I mean its an arbitrary list with no actual meaning except run time lol all i'd need to do is google the minutes of each series and rank accordingly but theres a reason people dont do that. Its not even your taste its a ranking of runtime I think its just proof you cant come up with an actual taste for yourself it represents my taste as it shows which anime I dedicated the most time to, if you see something like koe no katachi higher rated than a 24 ep season, u can deduct how much I love that movie to rewatch it enough. |
BestListMAL said: I do not mean to be insulting, but I find people are very generous to this movie. I love the monogatari series but this movie is only 1 hour in length (3episodes), whereas I see people rating Naruto, One Piece and Bleach Very low ratings despite seeing hundreds of episodes. This isn't me complaining, I'm just wondering, what can be done within 3 episodes of time, that makes it so amazing? if people like X, I've a problem with it. if people don't like Y, I've a problem with it. Shut up, everyone has their own preferences that's why there's a difference in ratings |
| https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ [WATCH THIS^^^] |
| I don't agree with your reasonings, but I do agree this doesn't deserve the high score it has. |
 |
Ulises1264 said: let's test your theory, both Mcdonalds and the Fancy restraunt are free like anime is (well haha, only to some of us) and the amount of calories is identical in both foods. And for whatever reason you eat mcdonalds 500 times, but the fancy restraunt once, even tho it's free, it isn't going to hurt you and there are no negative consequences (in this theory) that would MASSIVLY suggest you prefer Mcdonalds and it's ridiculous to claim you prefer the fancy restraunt more.In media quality is always better than quantity. Its like comparing McDonald's with a good restaurant, McDonald's is cheap and you can eat it whenever you want to, but its far worse than the experience of a good meal. |
| Length isn't everything. One of my longest anime is Hello Jadoo which is garbage. There's some crazy long anime out there that drag on for a really long time. It's actually impressive to make something several hundred episodes long that's enjoyable the whole way through while something like a movie is easier to design as a piece of media to be enjoyable throughout its duration and potentially even be more memorable if it's made well enough. This all being said, I don't think Kizu was all that great of a movie series. It was nice to see the backstory of what happened before Bake, but the art style change as well as the emphasis on fights made it harder for me to engage with it than some other parts of the franchise. |
  |
| I think people are missing the point of what this guy said, yeah, he is being pretty extremist, but it kinda makes sense, since if you spend so much time in a series then you probably enjoyed it enough or even found something amusing even if it is just by hating all of it. His point makes sense, but it isn't how things work, since you can definitely enjoy a 12 episode anime as much as a 200 episode anime and vice versa. |
| Imagine comparing MonoGOATari to Putrid quality abomination such as Naruto, Bleach and One Piss |
| If you want to reply to my posts, come up with valid arguments instead of ad hominem HIGHER LEVEL THINKERS ONLY |
| longer show doesn’t mean better. what if i watch 600 episodes of some long running show and still didn’t enjoy it? sure it may have some good parts and bad parts but it really depends on everyone’s tastes and opinions. i watched naruto shippuden and rated it a 6 where i gave this movie an 8. simply put, i liked this more. |
Friends are nothing more than the people who you spend the fun, yet meaningless times with. When those times get rough, they aren’t there to support you. My Mushoku Tensei Review |
BestListMAL said: LostSpectre said: well that's how my ratings work and I have the best list on MAL.That is simply not how ratings work, but there's no point comparing a movie to a series spanning hundreds of episodes, that's pointless. it seems like you rate stuff based on how many episodes it has or how many times you rewatched it. people on mal rate things on personal enjoyment or other criteria, never seen someone who rates like this |
Friends are nothing more than the people who you spend the fun, yet meaningless times with. When those times get rough, they aren’t there to support you. My Mushoku Tensei Review |
Faxtual_Ghoul said: Why not?Imagine comparing MonoGOATari to Putrid quality abomination such as Naruto, Bleach and One Piss adeeb91 said: if you waste your time watching things you hate, I think you deserve to put it highly rated to to visualise your wasted time that you could have spent on a good show.longer show doesn’t mean better. what if i watch 600 episodes of some long running show and still didn’t enjoy it? sure it may have some good parts and bad parts but it really depends on everyone’s tastes and opinions. i watched naruto shippuden and rated it a 6 where i gave this movie an 8. simply put, i liked this more. it seems like you rate stuff based on how many episodes it has or how many times you rewatched it. people on mal rate things on personal enjoyment or other criteria, never seen someone who rates like this yeah I do, I'm the only one who does because I got the best list on MAL |
| I do rate Kizu I higher than Naruto and One Piece. The latter have more impressive parts, but also very disappointing lows. Kizu movies in general have superb animation, directing, character writing, symbolism and are very dense |
 |
| People are generous here, some consider 7 as average. Some people do hate watch including myself. Don't take rating seriously. |
  |
| It’s honestly amazing. By far my favourite monogatari arc. I’ve read the book aswell and think the same thing. Think about it like this: are longer movies necessarily better than shorter movies? Not at all. If you’re adapting a single book, 3 hours is a really good amount of time. Why is it weird that a trilogy with 3 hours of content can be rated higher than a series with hundreds of episodes? A 3 hour story can affect you much more deeply and be a lot more memorable than a 100 episodes series. |
DeaneJan 27, 2023 5:23 AM
BestListMAL said: The fact that people actually think like this is why the industry gets away with pumping out copious amounts of garbage shows instead of focusing on actually making something good.winkwinkwinkz said: realistically, yes. Assuming you don't hate watch, longer shows should be better as they can keep you entertained for wayyy longer. Unless of course, this movie is so enjoyable you rewatch it many times.more episode = more rating ? π© Shaft actually cared about the end product for not just Kizumonogatari, but throughout all of Monogatari, and the end result is incredible because of it. Pierrot cut corners to make shit faster and (despite having very talented animators and directors), it shows. People aren't being really generous with Kizumonogatari, it's just that some people actually have decent taste in media. Edit: bro you have a 7.90 rating average and you're saying people are being generous with Kizu? |
gekojayJan 27, 2023 7:35 AM
I can't even function as a human being anymore. |
| bros trolling us my guy made his account 2 days ago π just look at his favorites list |
 |
hiw can you do this to yourself, are you a masochist? i could never watch it 4 times i would mentally fall apart Because it is amazing.The fact that people actually think like this is why the industry gets away with pumping out copious amounts of garbage shows instead of focusing on actually making something good. my average score isn't high, it is way below the MAL average considering I've only seen like 260 animes.Shaft actually cared about the end product for not just Kizumonogatari, but throughout all of Monogatari, and the end result is incredible because of it. Pierrot cut corners to make shit faster and (despite having very talented animators and directors), it shows. People aren't being really generous with Kizumonogatari, it's just that some people actually have decent taste in media. Edit: bro you have a 7.90 rating average and you're saying people are being generous with Kizu? TheRookieCrusher said: my account is new, that is correct and most people love the anime in my favourites, at least most of thembros trolling us my guy made his account 2 days ago π just look at his favorites list |
| https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058796/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_2 I found this man's perfect show You won't mind the 5.2 IMDb rating becuase there are 14,700 episodes! Enjoy! |
| I can't even function as a human being anymore. |
BestListMAL said: Not buying it π also your statement that your mean score is low is inaccurate, the average mal user rating is 6.5 you silly boyhiw can you do this to yourself, are you a masochist? i could never watch it 4 times i would mentally fall apart Because it is amazing.The fact that people actually think like this is why the industry gets away with pumping out copious amounts of garbage shows instead of focusing on actually making something good. my average score isn't high, it is way below the MAL average considering I've only seen like 260 animes.Shaft actually cared about the end product for not just Kizumonogatari, but throughout all of Monogatari, and the end result is incredible because of it. Pierrot cut corners to make shit faster and (despite having very talented animators and directors), it shows. People aren't being really generous with Kizumonogatari, it's just that some people actually have decent taste in media. Edit: bro you have a 7.90 rating average and you're saying people are being generous with Kizu? TheRookieCrusher said: my account is new, that is correct and most people love the anime in my favourites, at least most of thembros trolling us my guy made his account 2 days ago π just look at his favorites list |
|
No, MAL average is 6.54. Compared to that, you are way higher. that is every anime on MA, whereas if you found the average for the shows I have watched, my average is lower than the communitys. Nice try but my factual lists provides the evidence once again.You can check some statistics here: https://anime.plus/s/globals gekojay said: You clearly don't understand my list as it's too complicated for you, but I don't rate based on the Total Episode Count, I base it on the Episodes I have watched, if that 14,700 episode show is so bad I drop within 2 episodes then it would be bottom, last place on my list.https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058796/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_2 I found this man's perfect show You won't mind the 5.2 IMDb rating becuase there are 14,700 episodes! Enjoy! |
BestListMAL said: Bro's either trolling or is high on bath salts or some shit cuz this is some of the most unintelligable shit I've ever readNo, MAL average is 6.54. Compared to that, you are way higher. that is every anime on MA, whereas if you found the average for the shows I have watched, my average is lower than the communitys. Nice try but my factual lists provides the evidence once again.You can check some statistics here: https://anime.plus/s/globals |
| I can't even function as a human being anymore. |
Bro's either trolling or is high on bath salts or some shit cuz this is some of the most unintelligable shit I've ever read yet again you are failing to understand pretty basic stuff. what is hard to get? the AVG MAL score is 6.5 but that is for all anime ever made, me personally I only mainly watch highly rated anime so if you check MAL's averages for only the shows I have watched, it would have a much higher average than 6.5, maybe about 8.1 if I guessed. Making my mean score below average. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kizumonogatari Part 1: Tekketsu-hen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Djidji - Jan 29, 2016 |
228 |
by WaterMage
»»
Dec 18, 4:07 PM |
|
» Should I watch this before the series?Rockyjams909 - Jul 10 |
46 |
by Phantomnocomics
»»
Aug 25, 12:53 PM |
|
» Disregarding the fact that the internal monologues were omitted, how good of an adaptation do the people who have watched the movie think it is?Mado_Mura - Jan 10, 2016 |
6 |
by IconoclastiCrow
»»
Mar 5, 7:00 AM |
|
Poll: » What would you do if you have your limbs chopped off, laying in the ground and no one notices you?TheRayquaza - Jan 22 |
16 |
by dicloflom
»»
Jan 23, 8:55 PM |
|
» Needs the gore tagRaltsPokemon - Dec 15, 2023 |
5 |
by RaltsPokemon
»»
Dec 18, 2023 10:40 AM |