I think it is never unworthy to say this, but people CAN actually like whatever they want. With that said, yes, this is garbage lol. I have no problem with people liking it, specially when it rellies so much in "shock factor", but we have to admit that this is objectively a bad show. I can't tell about the manga and how faithfull an adaptation it is. The truth is, it doesn't even matter.
On the technical aspects, I have to recognice it has a good soundtrack, nothing really remarkable anyway (except for the rap parts, obviously).
And I think that's all. Not even the animation was well executed, and this is the main reason I'm writting this. Never mistake originality with quality. Because this anime is, in many senses, really original, or at least it feels like that because of its unrestricited amount of violence and nudity, dreadful development and tragic ending. Certainly, it is far from "conventional" anime. But that doesn't mean, in any sense, it is well done.
Focusing on the visual aspect, it does look "different", and I'm giving it a point for that, but except for some battle scenes the animation itself is so stiff it makes me think this was all done in a week or something. The details in draw where just nonexistent whenever we didn't see a close-up of the characters. Aside from the proportions being completely messed up. You can say it is Yuasa's style... well... it is my nephew's style too. That's not an excuse for being unskilled (not saying Yuasa is unskilled, but in this case it is).
If we talk about characters, most of them have no personality defined and no development at all. And if any, it is easily disposed without any explanation. Last episode gave us great example of it. (Are you reading this without watching the whole show? Why?) With Miki's death, Akira decided to kill everyone near while screaming "Damn you, mortals"... Right after that he is on the human side... He literally saw everyone he loved die by "humans nature" (does anyone think this is an accurate representation of human nature?) and still, the next morning, he will fight for them... WTF?? If that's the best character in the show then there's nothing left to say.
I prefer not to talk about storytelling as I haven't read the manga, but I will say this. Tragedy, as well as originallity, is not a synonym of quality. You may like the shock of it, but, again, it doesn't mean it is a great work.
Overall, whilst I recognize how bold this show was and how original it looked, I'm giving it a 3/10... and maybe I'm being generous. |