DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Umm.. It was such a pain to watch through this... Any other thoughts? |
 |
| If you disliked loli this anime is not for you, it was pretty okay. But WTF are they losing they power |
BlackbirdOct 7, 2010 6:24 PM
Nothing ventured, nothing gained (Girls und Panzer der Film ) / from Nishizumi Miho |
| They lost most of their powers. It's ok, I'll go through three episodes just to see how I'll like it, love the characters though, really cute and lively and the uniforms are very cute and unique, someone was thinking when they designed the uniforms. Those are some of the best uniforms ever in anime. 3/5 for all the cuteness |
 |
| Do you know if anyone's going to sub this? I was about to start watching the first episode, MY BODY WAS READY, but then I realized there was no subs available. I cried. |
| Derp. |
| i want subs...this anime seems soo cute(almost sounds like a detective version of lilpri...if that makes sense...art look similar...hmm) |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Otomen said: Do you know if anyone's going to sub this? I was about to start watching the first episode, MY BODY WAS READY, but then I realized there was no subs available. I cried. Same!!! Its one of the very few Im looking forward to this fall... T.T |
| ~Bokura wa deau tameni koko e umare ochita Toki wo tsumugu tashikana uta ni michibikare habataku yo~ |
| Is this Anime worth watching? rated 6.09 by 19 users-- dam this show is not very popular huh |
| I want to watch this show, but still no subs for it. >_> |
 |
| Now we have subs. Still not ure if I should watch it though. |
 |
| >One episode out >Already ratings that are low >Not giving the anime a chance to get a good start Can't anyone really wait until most or all of it's aired before they rate it? It's extremely illogically to do that. On a positive note. I found this very cute. Can't wait for the next episode. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I don't really understand what is going on, but I will keep watching because I want to find out who took their toys/why their toys vanished with the lightning. And I get this is a kid's show (it is, right?), but it is so unrealistic that all of the villains are posing as Milky Holmes' classmates and teachers. The only difference is clothing or a hat. It is ridiculous they are not recognized. I also don't understand the point of them infiltrating the school at all. Milky Holmes' is already a laughingstock within the school and the detective world, and Lady Arsene and co. can now steal anything they want and not have to worry about being stopped. So I don't see why she is putting in effort to screw or motivate Milky Holmes even after they have been defeated/put out of commission. I hope this anime ends up being one where with the power of friendship, they end up becoming great detectives despite NOT having powers, and learning they can do anything as long as they try their best and work together. But I really don't know what direction the show will go in. I had really high expectations for this show (I have no idea why), and this was not what I expected at all. |
| I didn't drink enough to finish watching this, i got passed the first 6 minutes tho. The art looks fine and the sound appears to be fine as well. The characters look like your stereotypical moe characters. Other then that it really looks childish, and i am wondering why i even picked this up. |
AversaOct 10, 2010 2:45 PM
| The Opening made me laugh also as it started it wasnt what i inetially expected Not really my type of anime r.r had some semi-good action the mystery wasnt that great Breakfast breakfast was kinda funny though good cast of characters |
 Behold of my awesomeness~ controversial and/or sensitive topics likely devolve into the same repetitive, derogatory, abusive, and harassing comments can no longer be posted. But my feels. |
billng said: Is this Anime worth watching? rated 6.09 by 19 users-- dam this show is not very popular huh If you are watching it for realism, deep plot, standard plot, or good comedy then no, it doesn't exist in this anime. Lilpri is much better if you want an anime that's cute and colorful, it does have a standard plot of sorts and excellent music. |
|
| i...ii...I liked it? What the fuck is wrong with me also all the chars seem to be recycled from other anime Sherlock "Sharo" Shellingford → Minette (Shukufuku no Campanella) Nero Yuzurisaki → Ryuuguu Rena (Higurashi no Naku Koro ni) Cordelia Glauca → Fate Testarossa (Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha) or Vivio (Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS) Hercule Barton → Tomo Yamanobe (Seikon no Qwaser) also, there's this Strike Witches spoof of Mio Sakamoto |
 |
| Well, this certainly was a train-wreck. Though I'll probably watch the 2nd ep to see if it can get any more absurd. |
| I am confused; this is rated PG right? I couldn't tell if this was intended moé service or not. I thought i would give it a shot, but meh. The only good thing about the episode was how cold hearted that bomb scene was. Unfortunately they didn't care about their picture as much as i thought. |
| In the first five minutes, I thought "Hell yeah, Needless with more moe!" like their toys are like fragments... but after that, it was a bit of a let down. No crying whatsoever about their first-case-picture being ripped apart. They were just too happy imho. Oh well, let's see what the second episode brings, I kinda hope they get their toys back FAST and don't take the whole season to do so. I want some action with it. |
| I didn't hate the episode, but in the future I think it will be hard to sit through an entire episode again. I may end up watching it, or dropping it later, I'm going to wait for more episodes to come out before deciding. |
Aversa said: Same here.wondering why i even picked this up. The blond dude is exactly like Daikiji from Ladies vs Butler. Enjoyed his scenes only. Milky Homes---> how ridiculous XD Not my type of show. *dropped* |
 |
Trollkastel said: >One episode out >Already ratings that are low >Not giving the anime a chance to get a good start Can't anyone really wait until most or all of it's aired before they rate it? It's extremely illogically to do that. On a positive note. I found this very cute. Can't wait for the next episode. I agree with everything you said. Hoppy said: If you are watching it for realism, deep plot, standard plot, or good comedy then no, it doesn't exist in this anime. Lilpri is much better if you want an anime that's cute and colorful, it does have a standard plot of sorts and excellent music. I think most people here on MAL don't know how to read synopsis or take a second look at the art style and characters. It doesn't have all that is why I find this anime very funny but I do really like this anime though. I was sold in the first 5 minutes lol. @Inarius I thought the same thing too with their character designs, not that I'm complaining. :) But I'm somewhat "shamed" that I didn't catch the Mio spoof though. : |
EtherSword said: I was sold in the first 5 minutes lol. In the first 5 minutes, I thought "Needless, now with an additional moe-topping!". :D |
| Eh...It's okay. Not really my cup of tea though~ >.< |
| They took one of my favourite themes/genres (detective), and turned it into one big moe blob. There was absolutely no reasoning or deduction done. If this was meant to be kids show; then they have too much sex themes (giant breasts on a scantily-clad high-schooler that looks like she's in her mid 20s to late 30s, and a a narcissistic exhibitionist? If I had kids, I'd rather theme watch power rangers or something with clowns (which I can't stand to death) than recommend this. If this is for young adults to adults...only the otaku pervs, the makers, the open-minded, people who like mindless trash, and people with no taste will like this. There's also better moe-blob anime out there. This however will most likely end up as a dried up cash cow. Detective Conan at least has bloody murder and humour, suitable for most ages. Arthur Conan Doyle would probably roll in his grave because of this. |
Estoy_GordoOct 10, 2010 7:29 PM
| Cute! I liked it. |
| Hmm. So far, this isn't my sort of thing. It looks like I'll have to watch a couple of episodes before making an informed judgment, though. Hopefully they'll start actually solving mysteries soon. |
| was not as good as i thought it would be o-oll |
     |
| Well, at least it's not the worst anime this season. Trollkastel said: How is it illogical? It's a rating based on the first episode, and if the anime improves people will adjust their ratings accordingly.Can't anyone really wait until most or all of it's aired before they rate it? It's extremely illogically to do that. |
| So far, this is probably the worst show I'm watching this season (based on the first episode, obviously). I r disappoint J.C. Staff =( |
| Had ALOT more plot than i was expecting. Reminds me of Yumeirro Patissiere in terms of cuteness. Ecchi ending was wtf for a kids show :o |
 |
| is this even worth watching? tell me please is it only moe lolis or does it have a plot? |
| i'm not really impressed so far. |
 |
llamaben said: Well, at least it's not the worst anime this season. Trollkastel said: How is it illogical? It's a rating based on the first episode, and if the anime improves people will adjust their ratings accordingly.Can't anyone really wait until most or all of it's aired before they rate it? It's extremely illogically to do that. Because that's not how the system here works on MAL, biasism and rageness hurts the rating more than it should. To properly rate an anime, you watch the whole thing then you rate it as it is, not it's pilot episode. And what kind of innocence were you guys expecting lol? You do realize JC Staff did this right? I *facepalm* for the future of MAL users. D: Oh yeah, the student council girl is probably my favorite so far. :) |
| This is like Shukufuku no Campanella...boring!!! It will be such a pain in the everywhere for me to watch this dammit... |
| I was pleasantly surprised and I think it has potential. We start off with some spoiled brats who are given special treatment and elite status because of their training under a legendary detective and they over-rely on their toys to solve cases. Now, their toys are gone, their special treatment is over, and their pedigree of training seems to mean squat. Now I expect that they will focus on what really makes a good detective: skills of observation and deduction. Or at least that would be the direction I expect. Honestly I see a good theme here as the show seems to be poking fun at all the super-tech policing done nowadays with 'toys' as seen on shows like CSI and the lack of old-fashioned flat-foot or gum-shoe style detective work. Maybe I'm reading a bit deeply into this, but nevertheless I think there's some potential to work with. I'll give it some more episodes and see whether they go in the direction I hope or whether it devolves into the typical moe-blob that everyone here seems to expect. |
| And our beloved loligod said:"This shall be fantastic." I didn't expect this season to get even better! |
| lol I'm amused by this guy called Twenty. and his nipples. XDD |
BlackMagic said: I was pleasantly surprised and I think it has potential. We start off with some spoiled brats who are given special treatment and elite status because of their training under a legendary detective and they over-rely on their toys to solve cases. Now, their toys are gone, their special treatment is over, and their pedigree of training seems to mean squat. Now I expect that they will focus on what really makes a good detective: skills of observation and deduction. Or at least that would be the direction I expect. Honestly I see a good theme here as the show seems to be poking fun at all the super-tech policing done nowadays with 'toys' as seen on shows like CSI and the lack of old-fashioned flat-foot or gum-shoe style detective work. Maybe I'm reading a bit deeply into this, but nevertheless I think there's some potential to work with. I'll give it some more episodes and see whether they go in the direction I hope or whether it devolves into the typical moe-blob that everyone here seems to expect. ^This. I'll give it another couple of episodes. Hope it won't disappoint. |
| Don't forget. Always, somewhere, someone is fighting for you. As long as you remember her, you are not alone. |
| Arghhhhhh. My bladder wasn't ready. |
| Schrödinger? Did your shorts get longer? |
| nearly that what I expected. The girls are cute, the setting is interesting as well as the way the plot took in this episode. But I think the Ending is a bit too sexy for this show |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| @EtherSword (off topic so in a spoiler) |
4kicks said: I'd rather theme watch power rangers or something with clowns (which I can't stand to death) than recommend this. If this is for young adults to adults...only the otaku pervs, the makers, the open-minded, people who like mindless trash, and people with no taste will like this. I wonder what that makes me, as I liked this episode :) I hope the open-minded :) that sounds better then otaku perv. I though it was very cute and fun to watch XD shadowsword said: This is like Shukufuku no Campanella...boring!!! It will be such a pain in the everywhere for me to watch this dammit... For me it isn;t like shukufuku at all First of this is way cuter And second: I didn't find this episode boring or slow, which I did find the first episode of shukufuku. Shukufuku is not my favorite anime at all, but I actually enjoyed milky holmes a lot. |
     |
| Who else here forced themselves to complete this episode? |
 |
GintokiSan said: Who else here forced themselves to complete this episode? Me dammit. Now I'll have to suffer these coming weeks because I don't drop anime... The art was horrible too imo. |
| i thought this was going to be more of a little kids show and not all ecchi... this isnt my type of anime so i might watch 1 more episode but im pretty sure im going to drop this |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Tantei Opera Milky Holmes Episode 10 DiscussionGar_Logan - Dec 12, 2010 |
31 |
by wildhood
»»
Dec 10, 2024 8:54 PM |
|
Poll: » Tantei Opera Milky Holmes Episode 6 Discussionsnowgreen - Nov 12, 2010 |
45 |
by wildhood
»»
Nov 14, 2024 10:46 AM |
|
Poll: » Tantei Opera Milky Holmes Episode 5 DiscussionNeetfriek - Nov 7, 2010 |
38 |
by wildhood
»»
Oct 25, 2024 8:20 AM |
|
» Any other anime that have similar comedy?Umbreon20 - Feb 24, 2024 |
0 |
by Umbreon20
»»
Feb 24, 2024 9:02 AM |
|
Poll: » Which Milky Holmes character do you like best?bronycon42 - Oct 24, 2023 |
2 |
by bronycon42
»»
Oct 25, 2023 6:02 AM |