Reply to TransferUser
EcchiGodMamster said:
the mangaka should get the final say in what is and isn't shown in the adaptation of their work
the mangaka should get the final say in what is and isn't shown in the adaptation of their work
I don't think that's a good idea. Remember when Stephen King adapted one of his own books into a movie and it totally sucked?
Just because you know how to write doesn't mean you know how to make a good movie.
The original Spice and Wolf anime was a lot better because it deviated a bit from the novels. The team knew how to adapt it into an anime. They didn't just copy paste the story.
The same thing happened to the Youjo Senki anime. It's great. In the past, I started reading the Light Novels and they were... not that great. The team adapting that story did outstanding work.
About 20 years ago it was a real problem with studios butchering some source materials, because they wanted an ending when the source didn't have one, yet. And as it turned out people that are good at adapting stories into anime are kinda awful at writing endings.
My point being that you shouldn't let the author mess too much with an anime adaption. They are good at writing and should let the people that are good at adapting handle things. If the project is handled by a team that is bad at adapting, an author telling them what to do and what not isn't going to help.
| @TransferUser like i said, i as an artist, want the artist/creator to be happy with the result, cause even if the adaptation is a success, it doesn't necessarily mean the creator has to be happy with it and im not saying the mangaka has to help physically make it, im just saying, they should have the final say in what is and isn't shown or left out so theyre satisfied |
 |
| I Like it.. Saw all 12 episodes and it was a trip down memory lane.. I like the opening and ending songs Also I love nabiki.. They made her outfits sexier than the original series.. Nabiki in tank-top and her shorts are shorter and tighter than before.. But they made her face too round an her eyes less slanty and sharp which is a negative.. They also made soun tendo mustache too thick.. I don't know how they are gonna used the small mustache joke in the later parts.. Genma looks better than the original series.. Kasumi should have been more thicker.. |
| This just in guys no boobz and butt cheekz! now for the weather. |
coming soon |
| Crying about the censorship, but this is not the only problem. What is this 2cent animation?   |
Reply to finalfantasy7
Crying about the censorship, but this is not the only problem.
What is this 2cent animation?
What is this 2cent animation?
| @finalfantasy7 Comparing two still frames to judge animation. Cooool |
Reply to finalfantasy7
Crying about the censorship, but this is not the only problem.
What is this 2cent animation?
What is this 2cent animation?
| @finalfantasy7 I agree, the animation is awful and very cheap looking and flat colored. |
| So much scandal and outrage for such an insignificant detail. Two stupid dots above and one stupid line below. Are some really going to crucify this new version and will reject trying it for something so trivial? The ecchi was never the main driver of the series, contrary to what many make it out to be. Yes, there were boobs and butts, but these were always something occasional rather than an episode constant, many are seriously overstating this aspect of the series. And if they are not going to show nipples and butt cracks this time that doesn't mean the main spirit of the series and actual reason to watch it is being butchered, which is the characters' interactions and funny dynamics in a romantic slice-of-life comedy mixed with martial arts and a tad of fantasy. NOT the nudity and playing with sensuality. Ranma was never a real ecchi show and the tag the original series gets is both wrong and misleading. You're making a storm in a glass of water. And if this dumb censorship troubles you that much, well there's always the original series there to go and that's it, no need to wish for the studio in charge of this remake burn in flames either. |
| Well, I was afraid this might be the case so I've not really had any excitement after the announcement of the new anime. Ranma is one of my favourite anime and manga since my childhood, so I'm fine skipping on this twisted piece of garbage (unless they're gonna have an uncensored Bluray release). |
| @animegamer245 That doesn't sound very convincing to me. Especially when taking One Piece as an example as One Piece doesn't show anything in the manga either. But we'll see when/if they come out. Again, I'm not holding my breath for it. |
| Go watch porn if you want that. |
 |
davidyodo24 said: Go watch porn if you want that. Or people should just go watch ecchi anime with ass cheeks and nipples in it. |
 |
| There was no AT-X release scheduled, you would have to be an idiot to think there was any possibility of nudity on a non-parental lock station. Crying censorship is beyond dumb, it was never going to be feasible to make this uncensored with Japan's current nudity laws on broadcast television. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
More topics from this board
» All this pig crap is annoyingMegamiRem - Nov 23 |
39 |
by uiainu
»»
5 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Ranma ½ (2024) Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Nov 23 |
58 |
by Pramm7
»»
9 hours ago |
|
» Should I watch the OG Ranma 1/2?jcoleismyman - Yesterday |
8 |
by FreedomKME
»»
Today, 1:11 AM |
|
Poll: » Ranma ½ (2024) Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Oct 5 |
217 |
by Magame
»»
Today, 12:49 AM |
|
» List of manga chapter adapted so farshaftmajo - Nov 23 |
7 |
by _Sanchay
»»
Yesterday, 8:13 PM |