Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen 3rd Season Episode 5 Discussion
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| That's a special gift for Myne. She better keep it for good measures. Episode had an eerie feeling to it but it's good to see her earning so much trust among the community now. Funny how she still gets treated like a kid by some of the adults though. And lol, I see Myne isn't good at handling babies. |
 |
| From all the things this seemingly backward world may lack, geometry is definitely not one of them, all those perfectly placed houses in front of the cathedral. Funny like how Myne was almost the reason for all those hard working people in the book making industry, to lose their jobs lol, good on you blue haired priest. Also, see Jenni ? Some people still play the instrument, while you suck a cock, tough life ain't it. |
 |
| We've heard of Main's Devouring...but Devouring soldiers? That's new. Sylvester has more work to do, and so does Ferdinand, while Main continues to do her business secretly to the benefit of those beneath her authority who's taking care of her. More like...Main's asking people to do things that she likes, like toys and paper stuff. Her workshop is quickly becoming a printing press...that could potentially change history, and that if fallen to the wrong hands, could be a massive liability. The pendant that Sylvester gave her would be a life-saving tool in the future. Ferdinand going through the fine details of their books vs. Main's process, it's clear that what Main is doing will change the kingdom's book-making industry, and his warning to her couldn't have come at a critical time until she's adopted by Karstedt or wait 2 years until she turns 10, asking her to stay low is the only safe option. Also, Main's going home to her parents is a homecoming to see Effa's labor and newborn child Kamil, a joyous celebration. But Jenni's news about an incoming noble whom has vested interest in Main, I can only think of bad things to happen. |
 |
phantomfandom said: Myne was so surprised to know that her mother had many miscarriages before, but she should know that even with a cutting-edge technology, miscarriage still happen. So safely delivering a healthy baby is a very good luck. There was a lot of content cut around that scene (comparing to LN) so that miscarriage thing was put as preview part, but in LN |
| Great to have a slower set up episode after the drama of the last few weeks. Glad Kamil was born safely without any complications after all the miscarriages their mom’s been thru. Looks like the peace will be short lived with the noble coming to the cathedral next week. Wonder if he’s got anything to do with the attack from last week seeing as he’s looking for someone with the devouring. |
 |
| I can't help but give my feeling Sylvester insist a bad person. But not that might chance, especially given his intro, its wait and see at this point! I do feel the need to show this however for all the Main haters ;P https://imgur.com/a/xIzL785 |
 To have you, Id give a billion lives A-Chan best girl |
| That illustration at the end of the episode was lovely, it is a shame Myne will only be able to enjoy for only two years with her family and more specifically with her just born younger brother. Ferdinand taking the right decision, Myne is a force of nature that could bring revolution with her knowledge, she needs to lay down for a bit not only to stop increasing the price on her head but also to give some time to all the people whose livelihood would be in danger with her progress on books. |
| Well they're right modernity is killing employment so it's hard to make a choice... Finally the baby is here and everything went fine! It's lovely to see the family together with the baby! |
 |
| It seems like Myne's ignorant ways are going to continue. For being a "book worm," she sure knows a lot about the books themselves but not what they contained. She seems to know a lot, as expected of a college level student, but she can't really apply it to reality. For instance, she knows about things like vested interest and what happened on earth when the printing press was introduced, but failed to predict similar things would happen there. Especially with the combination of a caste system which holds a monopoly. I predict that something will happen to her family soon. I'm waiting for next week's episode with baited breath. |
“We all have our time machines, don't we. Those that take us back are memories... And those that carry us forward, are dreams.” β H.G. Wells, The Time Machine  |
| Ferdinand telling Myne not to stick her nose where it doesn't belong is laughable. After what he did. The miscarriage part of the preview completely threw me for a loop. I hope the new baby doesn't die. |
AnimeJunky said: oh wow I didn’t know what you guys were talking about until I went to the end of the episode. Crazy. So if Myne (permanently) died from the devouring, I guess Tuuli would’ve been an only child for a while. I guess it harkens back to those old days when some kids didn’t live for very long.Ferdinand telling Myne not to stick her nose where it doesn't belong is laughable. After what he did. The miscarriage part of the preview completely threw me for a loop. I hope the new baby doesn't die. |
Dreystah said: This is getting old. I view them as adult midgets now instead of children, when is Myne going to grow the hell up? you mean grow up physically to be like a teenager in size ? Lol, I can answer that more precisely, but what I'll say for now is that's never going to happen in anime unless they do many more seasons of 12 episodes. |
 |
| Myne's reaction to the baby crying is just adorable. |
Dreystah said: This is getting old. I view them as adult midgets now instead of children, when is Myne going to grow the hell up? have in account tha she start at age 5, turning 6 in Season 1. Now she got bapticed in season 2 at the age of 7. this third season she's turning 8 in summer ... Adulthold in this world is considered at age 15... , so still 7 more years to catch up ... and the next episode will blow up many of you. (who haven't read th Novels)... |
EkunSjyMay 10, 2022 1:57 AM
|
| Wow that extra segment was nothing to laugh about . That was heavy ............ . kurizu said: There was a lot of content cut around that scene (comparing to LN) so that miscarriage thing was put as preview part, but in LN Damn i wish they had adapted it this way . Really would put how much myne cares about her family into light , which is one of the most beautiful aspects of this story .... |
TweedleDaneMay 10, 2022 5:34 AM
| i am seeing a lot of hype and you lot are honestly making me very anxious ..... Goddamnit should have binge watched it |
| I feel they actually did Sylvester a huge disservice by glossing over the tour and forest visit as much as they did. In the process they also failed to highlight one of the more disgusting parts of noble society. In the novel, Myne is worried about Sylvester visiting the orphanage since the blue priests in the temple have a history of only going there for flower offerings. (Which is a euphemism for forcing grey shrine maidens to have sex with them.) When she asks him about his intentions, Sylvester reacts with outright disgust over it. They also didn't really address the whole "Brother Syl" thing like at all nor that he actually seemed fairly fond of the orphans after the forest trip. They also failed to have him show his confusion about why the orphans have it as good as they currently do. That latter bit showed an important distinction between commoners and nobles. Even the good nobles tend to be totally out of touch with how commoners live their lives. Sylvester came around after Myne explained things to him though, which showed that he's actually a fairly reasonable guy all things considered. Ferdinand's description of him in an earlier episode ("he has a terrible personality but somewhere deep inside he's a decent guy") is actually a very apt descriptor for Sylvester, though his terrible personality makes more sense later on as well. phantomfandom said: Myne was so surprised to know that her mother had many miscarriages before, but she should know that even with a cutting-edge technology, miscarriage still happen. So safely delivering a healthy baby is a very good luck. In the novel she even chews out the midwife and other women helping with the birth for being too unhygienic and mentally goes over the fact that historically, the extremely high infant mortality rate is responsible for historical life expectancy being so low. There was a lot more to that part of the novel and they really didn't do it justice here. I'm also note sure since it's been awhile since I last reread these parts of the novel but I think they skipped over an important thing, I would assume they moved it to another location in the flow of things but it'll make it seem like there's less time involved between when it actually happens and when things come to a head. Though they also did that a bit with Kamil's birth. (Though the novel also did that to a point. In the novel it's implied there's some amount of time between Myne coming home and Effa giving birth but the exact timeframe is indistinct there as well.) |
Alice3173 said: I just want to talk about how fricking strong Effa is. I've only been watching the anime, so that's what I'm going by. Based on what her dad said, Effa has suffered AT LEAST THREE child deaths. THREE. And she is still holding strong. She still keeps herself together and does her part in the family, being an emotional support to all three members of her home. I get that the mortality rate of infants is low in their world so they are probably used to it and expect it, but I highly doubt that matters to the average mother who just lost their baby. Yet here comes Effa, soldiering on for the good of her family. I vote her to be one of THE strongest mother characters in anime. Also, that art at the very end of the episode is so freaking wholesome. I loved how beautiful it was.I feel they actually did Sylvester a huge disservice by glossing over the tour and forest visit as much as they did. In the process they also failed to highlight one of the more disgusting parts of noble society. In the novel, Myne is worried about Sylvester visiting the orphanage since the blue priests in the temple have a history of only going there for flower offerings. (Which is a euphemism for forcing grey shrine maidens to have sex with them.) When she asks him about his intentions, Sylvester reacts with outright disgust over it. They also didn't really address the whole "Brother Syl" thing like at all nor that he actually seemed fairly fond of the orphans after the forest trip. They also failed to have him show his confusion about why the orphans have it as good as they currently do. That latter bit showed an important distinction between commoners and nobles. Even the good nobles tend to be totally out of touch with how commoners live their lives. Sylvester came around after Myne explained things to him though, which showed that he's actually a fairly reasonable guy all things considered. Ferdinand's description of him in an earlier episode ("he has a terrible personality but somewhere deep inside he's a decent guy") is actually a very apt descriptor for Sylvester, though his terrible personality makes more sense later on as well. phantomfandom said: Myne was so surprised to know that her mother had many miscarriages before, but she should know that even with a cutting-edge technology, miscarriage still happen. So safely delivering a healthy baby is a very good luck. In the novel she even chews out the midwife and other women helping with the birth for being too unhygienic and mentally goes over the fact that historically, the extremely high infant mortality rate is responsible for historical life expectancy being so low. There was a lot more to that part of the novel and they really didn't do it justice here. I'm also note sure since it's been awhile since I last reread these parts of the novel but I think they skipped over an important thing, I would assume they moved it to another location in the flow of things but it'll make it seem like there's less time involved between when it actually happens and when things come to a head. Though they also did that a bit with Kamil's birth. (Though the novel also did that to a point. In the novel it's implied there's some amount of time between Myne coming home and Effa giving birth but the exact timeframe is indistinct there as well.) |
| A new innovation always leads to a disruption that will change history. There are bad and good things that will happen once that happens like internet :) |
| - Mal-Badge - Level 25 Ranked 1135 Last update : 27.02.2022 at 05:50 My Candies :   |
on 
| So Myne was actually the 4th one huh... I'm glad she can finally be with her family again but I'm still curious about the "devouring soldiers"... |
| It's not that I dislike this genre but... to add unnecessary fan services to/in/for heroines and ultimately destroys her character and personality; their purity tarnished because of it, is the only thing I hope to not happen to them. For that sole purity is my fan service. |
| Can Mine's family not visit her after she's adopted/ she visit them?? I really hope somehow she is able to have a relationship with her little brother beyond two years :'/ Her mother and sister do help with creating a lot of products, so maybe she can officially hire them as an excuse to see them more? I mean she does have the workshop and still does business with Benno and all, is she expected to distance herself from that when she gets adopted as well? Also she needs to use the time she has to prepare a plan for book production in the future. Like perhaps she could make contracts with those that earn a lot of money from book production to have them work with her and maybe assist with distribution. She can employ them for creating new items that the mass production of books will involve, such as an actual printing press, bookshelves, leather and engraved book covers, illustration and font design, etc. Plus she can share the knowledge of different ink production with the ink guild and have them make it for her, if she can weed out all the a-holes first. |
| Nothing much to say about Sylvester, always felt like a nice normal guy to me. Though just two more years for Myne to be with her family and even with the newly born, Kamil, can't help but feel that hesitant feeling she's been going through for sometime now. |
 |
damn, this eps is lovely af <3 -- this bitch... how dare her even after Myne already kind to her and other orphans  -- calling FBI, LOL  |
Roch2001 said: I can't help but give my feeling Sylvester insist a bad person. But not that might chance, especially given his intro, its wait and see at this point! same hahaha, I was already thinking that pendant would brainwash her xD We shall see! |
 |
TweedleDane said: i am seeing a lot of hype and you lot are honestly making me very anxious ..... Goddamnit should have binge watched it hehehe, π you stil can do it after it finish. I did 2, first with Season 1, then both, S01+Season 2 ... And plant to do it again just Season 3 ones it finished ... and then may be again after Dub released. hehehehehe Workshop our Lady BOOKWORM Myne!!! BANZAII !!! |
|
| I love the chemistry between Sylvester and Myne. Always great to see how Honzuki creates these relationships so well. A brilliant episode and the ending was just beautiful. Anime of the year again? Brilliant art by Ame at the end. |
| "Even if it has good reviews, if I don't like it then it is shit" -Some random anime character |
| Well, Jenni is a spiteful witch now isn't she? |
| Oh boy, getting a special "for emergencies only" pendant that needs her blood to activate? That certainly won't be needed later :') Ferdinand quickly recognized the revolution brewing in her workshop, and forced her to put that game-changer on hold until she had enough political power to not be executed by the nearest noble that it would affect. I like it when a series gives you enough information to correctly follow the logic when you understand it enough, because I immediately knew that was what he was thinking when he was looking at all those orphans learning to read, write, and create mass-produced books. And I loved that he even asked how her world responded to that change. Meanwhile Delia's still in an awkward position, being led on by a jealous/spiteful gray robe that she has a (actually zero) chance of improving things by attracting the disgusting gaze of a powerful pervert... |
| wait Is Benno gay? This explains why he is single. |
 |
He's not. I don't recall if it was covered by this point in the light novel (though I think it was) so I won't elaborate just in case but there is a solid reason he's still single. |
Alice3173 said: He's not. I don't recall if it was covered by this point in the light novel (though I think it was) so I won't elaborate just in case but there is a solid reason he's still single. I do believe they did, but also I could say at which point. but yeah, definitely it has not ben adapted, and I doubt it will be... |
|
They've already explained why he's single. He explained that the woman he loved and wanted to marry died when he was still busy raising his sister, and that he has no intention of marrying someone else because they're no match for the woman he loved. Myne, who is on his shoulders at that time, even pat him after that. |
|
| This ending reminded me how fucked up the world can be and it’s crazy how the show is kinda lighthearted then BAM, a pedo is coming to town |
| This is what I have been stressing since season 1, ideas from memories of her past but more advanced world are disruptive to this less advanced world, she actually mean well but she has not realized the potential repercussions until Ferdinand explicitly points it out to her, it might not be the same outcomes as her old world's history but it is change nonetheless, change that is feared by the ones on top who wants to preserve their current world order and retain their status, power, and wealth. |
| You see there's no need to wonder where your god is, Coz he's right here! ...and he's fresh out of mercy. |
tofei said: This is what I have been stressing since season 1, ideas from memories of her past but more advanced world are disruptive to this less advanced world, she actually mean well but she has not realized the potential repercussions until Ferdinand explicitly points it out to her, it might not be the same outcomes as her old world's history but it is change nonetheless, change that is feared by the ones on top who wants to preserve their current world order and retain their status, power, and wealth. yep, but in this other world, the amount of "mana" one possesses give the upper estatus in "Society", so no commoners can do anything agains the nobles, who fill the earth with their mana, which in turn give better corps. = No mana equal to a poor and unfertilised lands, = equals to NO CORPS and starving people, as show in the last episode in season 2, when She performs the "Rejuvenation" ceremony after the "Torombe Extermination". filling the land whit her mana. So not even the more educated commoners being, can take a rebellious against the power (order?) of nobility. Ferdinand is and Acrh-Noble, Shhikikoza, was a Med-Noble (in the bottom line with the Lay-Nobles), ands Damuel is just a Lay-Noble. that's why he have to obey Shikikoza. |
EkunSjyJun 11, 2022 8:26 AM
|
| Nice to see more scenes about inventions.. ;P Like these scenes the most.. ;P Hm?.. What is that scene at 15:30.. Looks as if from previous life.. Her love for books in the previous life hurt her family in some way?.. |
Gendolfas said: Hm?.. What is that scene at 15:30.. Looks as if from previous life.. Her love for books in the previous life hurt her family in some way?.. Yes, it's her Japanese mother from previous life. I won't said she "hurt" her previous family, but what she did was neglected her family relationship a bit (too much?) when she was immersed reading, ...up to the point that her mom has to urge her to eat, as seeing at the beginning of season 2, when Ferdinand was "reading her mind" with the magic tool. |
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen 3rd Season Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 6, 2022 |
94 |
by jasutin_hoshi
»»
Sep 23, 2024 12:51 AM |
|
Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen 3rd Season Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 16, 2022 |
51 |
by ToleratedToast6
»»
Sep 16, 2024 6:10 PM |
|
Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen 3rd Season Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Jun 13, 2022 |
198 |
by NimbleBard48
»»
Aug 31, 2024 11:29 AM |
|
Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen 3rd Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - May 30, 2022 |
60 |
by Rexnihilo
»»
Aug 8, 2024 6:34 PM |
|
Poll: » Honzuki no Gekokujou: Shisho ni Naru Tame ni wa Shudan wo Erandeiraremasen 3rd Season Episode 7 DiscussionStark700 - May 23, 2022 |
48 |
by Rexnihilo
»»
Aug 8, 2024 6:23 PM |