Another

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

I'll keep this review short, do not fear.

The first thing I would like to say is that this novel is very clever, absolutely perfectly planned out, and its story is told very well.

Story: 10/10

This novel is one with a dark atmosphere, as it is about a chain of deaths which occur once Kouichi Sakakibara transfers into the school.

I became hooked as soon as I started reading it. Sure, the beginning may be slow at first, but as you progress deeper into the story, all of the pieces come to light and connect together beautifully. Everything is so well connected, as I said earlier, and ... the story is played out amazingly, with the mysterious, dark atmosphere drawing you in.

Art: ?

Well in this novel, there was no literal art, but the scenes described were beautiful and matched the story's mood, so I'll give it a 10/10. The deaths were particular and nearly unreal, adding to the atmosphere.

Character: 10/10

The characters were very interesting and unique. They have incredible memories, as they can remember just about everything they hear or witness. I think that their abilities add to the story's mystery, because they are trying to solve the mystery.

Enjoyment: 10/10

I enjoyed this story very much. It isn't very much of the "horror" genre, but it is a very good, dark, mystery novel.
I loved the way the story developed and becomes more intense as the story progresses.

Overall: 10/10

I recommend this story to anyone who likes reading dark mystery novels which are slightly "horrific" but focused more on the mystery, and are very well developed, well told, and have a great dark atmosphere.

I enjoyed it very much, and I hope others will enjoy this story as well.

"Another" is that kind of work that has several of the most different adaptations, so you probably already heard of the anime, the manga or the live action.
Here I'll talk a little bit about the work that originated all these different versions of the story: the original novel written by Yukito Ayatsuji.

The story starts with a series of events leading our main character to be transferred to a school in the countryside. Because of some complications he had to start the classes a month after their beginning, and that's how things will start to go downhill not only for Koichi, but for all ... the members of the class 3-3.
To begin with, his school is surrounded by many horror stories, but they're all just stories, and no one really believes in it. The only one that everyone feels a shiver down the spine is the story about the class 3-3: a frightening ghost story with his roots in the past, exactly 26 years ago, where a picture of the group was taken, and "someone", the ghost of a dead classmate, that shouldn't be in the picture, was there; followed by a lot of strange deaths involving the class 3-3 in the next years, leading everyone to believe a curse had fallen upon the group after the death of this classmate.
Some years after the phenomenon started, they discovered that the "curse" can be avoided if someone "don't exist", or at least if they pretend someone of the class don't exist. Around this we still have a very important question, the question that can end with this phenomenon, but the hardest to be answered, "who is the another?", "who is the dead?", the extra classmate, the one that came back from death and is infiltrated between the other students.
With all those mysteries, the important figure of Mei Misaki enters in the scene, she was already someone that had a very strange meeting with Koichi in the beginning of our story, and he meets her again in class 3-3. Mei is a very interesting character, mostly in the first part of the story, she is an existence that you don't really know what it is. It intrigued me the whole first part who and what Mei was, but only in the second part and in the last chapters we start discover who this girl really is. A thing we can say for sure is, Mei is probably the only one Koichi can trust, and she will play a very important role in the story together with our main character.
In the beginning we might feel very confused because the story show us lot of content, it feels like there is a lot of mysteries and you might caught yourself trying to associate every information that is given. This is very important actually, because lot of things will only make sense in the last part of the story, so all the details matter.

As for the story, what you need to know is that it's divided in two parts besides the chapters; these parts have important questions that will be solved during it. The first one is "What?....Why?" and the second one is "How?....Who?". Well, only saying it you can almost imagine about what which part is about. The first one is mostly regarding the doubts of Koichi about what's happening in the class, why these things happen and why his classmates act the way they act. As for the second part, it has relation with how to break the events of the phenomenon, and who is the dead.
What really called my attention, talking about the narration of the story, is that it's told in the first person, with Koichi being the one telling all the events. I personally thought it was a very interesting way of writing because like this we can see HIS point of view of the story, and not by an external narrator, it also feels a little bit more like a "horror" story, like, sometimes you see Koichi is really nervous when his hearing about something and you start feeling his nervousness too.

The characters are mostly very interesting, there are some I would like to know more, like Izumi, which, for me, had a very short role in the story, but mostly the side characters are very interesting and we get to know more about the ones that are close to Koichi, which is a good amount of characters. Of course Mei and Koichi get the special treatment, Mei being the highlight, as I said before, she's a very enigmatic character and you get yourself questioning her existence a lot in the first part of the novel. Koichi feels kinda like the our everyday main character, but I got to see a little bit of me in him, especially the "bookworm" personality, and we get to see his true emotions in many parts of the novel, so it feels like a very realist portrayal.
A thing that can be noted too is that all characters are important. You might think "it's just a side character", but he or she will definitely do something important in the story, so pay attention to every single character while reading.
Another thing about the characters is that we get to see MANY deaths in this novel, some of them (ok, most of them) are very crazy, so crazy that it feels kinda unreal. Well, I guess one of the things about this story is that all the events are already unimagined, so even the deaths need to be unimaginable coincidences or accidents, but the only thing I know is that while I was reading, I started questioning myself: could this weird death really happen in the real world?

Overall, I think "Another" was a very good reading; I really liked the mysteries and the way they were shown, as well as the narrativ., The characters have interesting roles during the story and they fit the atmosphere created by the author. All the questions he makes in the beginning and the way he starts answering them during the story, everything leading to an unimaginable ending. It's the kind of story that even if you start reading and don't like it, you'll at least finish because you just can't stop without knowing who is the culprit, or in this case, who is the dead.
I would totally recommend it for fans of mystery, not really horror fans, because I can't say this novel gets to the point of being classified as horror, but it's a very good mystery novel that will give you some shivers and make you question everything.
So, what are you waiting to start reading "Another" and discover who the dead is? But better read now, or will forget about everything when the phenomenon ends.

„What?…………Why?“
- Another, volume 1, introduction chapter, page 1, line 1

Why indeed... why have I picked this up even though I hated the series? Maybe some hope that perhaps the novel is actually is good, maybe it’s just the series that sucks. I mean, it could be the case… it is not the case.

I’ll try to not go into specifics to let you go through the disappointment without spoilers. If you don’t count it being disappointing a spoiler by itself, of course.

Another feels almost insulting. The story doesn’t attempt to get you interested in the setting or the story. It’s boring the whole time until ... the plot actually kicks off, and then it’s boring some more. If I find myself asking “Why should I even care about any of this?”, then the author has failed. More so if this question comes up throughout the reading experience and is never met with answer.

The characters are divided in victims, the mysterious token girl and the main character. The main character is in reality more of a designated witness – a character you know isn’t going to dying and through his eyes you can see the victims. Should any Another fan disagree, I have a simple riddle – describe to me the personality of the protagonist. I’m eagerly awaiting your answers. Which is to say, the characters also do nothing to draw in the reader’s attention, beyond the powers of mysterious high school girl.

The mystery feels like the author didn’t really know the solution from the start and as such just threw in random some random mysteriously sounding bullshit that might seem like hints but are just misdirection, a sleight of hand designed to convince you the story makes any sense, until the novel size text volume is reached. Then, what has to be one of the worst asspulls I’ve ever witnessed in a fiction is slapped at the end.

I honestly can’t find any part of Another that I could say I liked. Really the only thing that is saving it from being rated 1/10 is that I’ve read some even worse stuff. But really, that was completely unenjoyable experience.