No.6

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

The No. 6 manga is the only thing from what I've encountered so far that I've been able to give a 10 to. I'll do my best to refrain from any spoilers or summarizing the plot.

Story. (10/10)

The Good: the plot is excellent and I thought it was extremely well paced. From the very first page you're transported into the fake world of No. 6. You're then taken for a crash course on reality in the Western District. You're swept away by the every line, every detail on the page.

When I first saw the anime, I was jaded. When I read the light ... novels, I wept. It wasn't until I read this manga that everything felt complete. The execution of the plot was perfect. There was never a dull moment for me and I couldn't stop reading. In the end, everything came together in a way that exceeded every hope and every desire I could have had.

The Bad: I spent quite some time trying to come up with something to complain about when it came to this manga, something-anything- that irritated me. I found...nothing, much to my own amazement.

Art. (10/10)

Wow, that art. What can you really say? The art was simply mesmerizing. You weren't just reading a manga. You were there. You were living it. Facial expressions, body language, backgrounds, panels, and bubble placement- it was all perfect and easy to follow. More than that- the art of the characters themselves were flawless. More often than not I found myself taking quite some time per page just to really appreciate the beauty of the characters and the fantastic details. I can't find a single thing about the art that I'd change.

Character. (10/10)

This is where the manga shines brightest. The struggles of these characters are real. They've all been shaped by their experiences, and oftentimes not for the better. You end up at the edge of your seat with baited breath watching as these characters are forced to make decisions and how those decisions are going to effect their personalities. The more you learn, the more you eagerly wonder what will happen next.

With that said:

This manga does feature two 16 year old boys who are romantically attracted to one another. It is this relationship, this friendship, this bond that makes the story great. This manga is not about a gay couple having gay sex (which they don't, by the way). It would work just as well if Nezumi or Shion were a female. I love that it doesn't stereotype gay relationships. It shows two people who find each other against all odds and dares to take charge of their own lives.

Quite frankly, I don't think people should freak out over Nezumi and Shion's relationship. If you chose not to read the manga because of that, I certainly can't stop you, but if you like an amazing dystopian manga with lots of action, and character development that makes you think, then this isn't one you should skip over lightly.

This is about two boys, as different as night and day, who form a seemingly impossible bond and change everything. In their own lives and in the world around them. It's a story of personal growth. To be a ignorant or to be knowledgeable. To be conquered or to be the survivor. To be human or to be...something else. It's a plot driven by characters evolving and it's utterly amazing to behold. In light of that, so what if two boys like each other? It's their relationship that makes the plot all the more worth while, and every decision they make so much more intense because of how they force each other to change.

4. Enjoyment. (10/10)

I am enthralled with every single aspect of this manga. It glides effortlessly through the pages, engulfing you in a world of horror, action, despair, and hope where hope should only be done while dreaming (if even then). It makes you question what you'd do if you were in any of the characters' positions. How far would you be willing to go for someone else? How much horror can you see, hear, smell, touch, before it becomes a part of you? How deeply can you change, before you lose yourself completely?

You are put on a roller-coaster of emotion and the ride doesn't end just because the manga is over.

5. Overall. (10/10)

This was, quite simply put, a very outstanding and unforgettable manga. In fact, the only thing bad about it is that it ends.

Not gonna lie, this manga is doing me a little cognitive dissonance moment. You see, I have quite enjoyed the novel. The manga however, not so much. What made me not enjoy the manga so much despite liking the source material?

When reading a novel, a lot can actually depend on the reader’s imagination. The manga however is obviously a more direct approach – unsurprisingly, as a visual medium. It chooses which parts to accent, what to focus on and how to portray a world. So instead of a gritty world with serious vibe more akin to western dystopia works that existed in my imagination which ... mostly ignored the BL subtext of the story, the manga does the opposite.

There’s no futuristic city, the drawings don’t portray anything unique, just a very generic town setting with a slum problem. There is hardly anything indicating a dystopian vibe in the arstyle. The characters themselves too are mainly designed as bishounen characters as the BL now undoubtedly takes a main role in the storytelling. The disaster is portrayed as more of a way to get the pairing together rather than that being a byproduct of an emergency situation.

Emergency and stakes are another big problem in this adaptation. They are mostly gone. The pacing is terrible and the manga doesn’t seem to be sure if it wants to be have a serious story or goofy situations. This is unlike the juxtaposition of cuteness and seriousness in works like for example Girls' Last Tour. I don’t sense author intent in No. 6, just tone-deafness.

Those downgrades combined make No. 6 manga nothing more than very average young adult dystopian storyline, just with non-heterosexual main pairing. Or maybe the novel wasn’t that good in the first place and it’s just the fact that I have read it almost a decade ago that could solve the mystery of me no longer enjoying the story that much. But for confirming that I’d have to reread it, and I’ll pass for that.

Anyway, to summarize - if the boys love elements were your favourite parts of the novel, your experience with the manga adaptations will likely be the exact opposite of mine, so go ahead and pick this up. And if you’re unfamiliar with the novel, set your expectations on a YA literature level.

Neck Bees: the Manga series.

If the prospect of reading a (gay??????) scifi story about a bipolar jerk (Eve/Rat), a confusingly determined piece of paper (Shion), and bees coming out of people's necks appeals to you, then I can recommend it.
To start, there's nothing particularly bad about the premise, I mean having bees erupt from people's necks is equivalent of a disease that kills people in a horrifying way. It's silly and dumb, but most anime is and I just found myself laughing about it anyways.
The characters are decent at first, Shion being a levelheaded guy who just wants the best for his friends and Rat ... (oh god that name) is a cold, heartless guy. But then they don't really go anywhere. The character progress resets sporadically and you'll have to sit through the same scene 4 different times. This happens with many different scenes, such as: Rat and Shion fighting but then resolving it, Rat and Shion monologing about how much they saved each others life, and Rat and Inukashi having their spat among a bunch of other types.
If you found this manga because you heard about it's mains being the best couple evar, you'll be met with Rat tossing Shion around half the time like a 6-year old with a pinata bat. Rat kicks the crap out of Shion on several different occasions and professes his hatred for the guy. They kiss like twice, but then don't ever address it. They don't even address homosexuality at all. Yeaaah, it's a far stretch to call it romantic. There's a reason why it's not listed as Shounen-ai in the genre tags.

It's a waste of time as an action dsytopian scifi romance (?), because it doesnt know what it's going for and it keeps repeating itself, getting nowhere with the characters.