Promise Cinderella

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

It's been a while since I binged a manga in less than a day, and Promise Cinderella is now one of my favourites. The storyline grabbed me in from the first chapter, and I adore reading age gap manga, especially when the female lead is older.

Hayame Katsuragi, our female lead, is quite a bold type of character; she is a 27-year-old housewife living a happy life, but things turn kind of bad for her and she ends up being divorced and homeless. Living in a park, she is spotted by Issei, our male lead, who is 17 years old, whom she had once encountered on ... a train bullying his classmate. Issei is a spoiled rich boy, but somethings happens and he decides to take Hayame into his home; well, from the start, I loved the plot, and I love both Hayame and Issei, they both have harsh backstories.

I really enjoyed this series; the character development was excellent, and I adored all of the supporting characters. And Hayame suffered a lot, but in the end she found her happiness.

And, I absolutely loved the art, and Hayame is soooo cute.

Overall, the story was wonderful; I absolutely loved it. However, there are a few things I'd like to point out: there was a lot of unnecessary drama, and it occasionally felt unreal because so many evil characters appeared. Additionally, the ending was perhaps a bit rushed.

Thats why I’m giving it a 9/10.

Anyways, The way the relationship develops, with the two continuing to deny their feelings up until they can no longer hide them, was charming. The final chapter also had a satisfying ending.

Although there is some intense drama in this series, I still recommend it.

An age gap comedy romance drama with a lot going on! FL is fun and refreshing; she's 27 years old with a strong sense of justice and will swing on anyone acting up. ML is 17, and a HUGE asshole in the beginning. Honestly considered dropping the series because of how awful the situation between FL and Ml was. His character development is pretty fast imo (thankfully), so it does get better. The side characters are really fun too! One big downside (other than the age gap and initial lack of chemistry) is that basically all of the arcs ... dont really have...a resolution? Let me explain...

MILD SPOILERS AHEAD.
Each arc is very distinct, but once they reach the end, the characters are kind of tossed aside, and the resolutions are kind of bland imo, especially with the FLs husband. The FLs husband and his mistress are a whole other frustration story wise, but if you read you'll see what I mean lol (like...the mistress is a big character, and while we learn why she does what she does, it still feels...empty ://). The end of the manga especially is very much "woah ok, we're missing SO much"; I didn't find the ending very satisfying because the very last chapter is a five year time skip and then it ends. Like you can gather what happened, but there is SO much missing with the family drama and relationships that was just not covered. I was really looking forward to the situations with the parents to be covered and resolved :(

Overall fun and drama-filled, but if you want substance and solid answers/endings, this is an eh read. I do love the FL though, and the side characters are well fleshed out and fun! Not big on age gaps in general, so that was another downside for me personally; I was roped into the manga because of the cute cover art and didn't expect the age gap, but I stayed along for the ride. Ok story and writing, again lots of things weren't covered and it was a bit disappointing. The ending was cute though, i'll give it that. Hope this review helps anyone interested in reading!

Promise Cinderella presents an engaging yet problematic premise with its age gap romance at the forefront. The manga's strength lies in its ability to create well-rounded and relatable mature characters. Hayame Katsuragi, the 27-year-old protagonist, emerges as a resilient and courageous individual despite facing immense hardships. Her transformation from a housewife to a homeless divorcee adds depth to her character. Similarly, Issei, the 17-year-old male lead, starts as a spoiled rich boy but matures through his interactions with Hayame.

One of the central themes explored in Promise Cinderella revolves around individuals who have experienced failure in life and grapple with self-esteem issues, often leading to self-destructive ... tendencies. The manga delves into the psychological and emotional struggles faced by such individuals, emphasising their inclination to distance themselves from family and friends due to feelings of burden and guilt. They believe their mere existence would only bring harm to those close to them.

This theme finds resonance in the backgrounds of both Hayame and Issei, the two main characters of the manga; Hayame's father plays a crucial role in the manga by depicting his detachment from her, intensifying her emotional struggles and deepening her sense of inadequacy and self-doubt. Hayame's father is depicted as a key character in the story, who distanced himself from Hayame, his daughter. This poignant portrayal of the unfortunate parental disconnection emphasises the toll it takes on Hayame's self-esteem and emotional well-being, leading her to distance herself from others as well due to the absence of a nurturing and supportive father figure. Consequently, the manga delves into the profound impact that familial disconnection can have on an individual's life.

Amidst Hayame's initially content life as a 27-year-old housewife, circumstances take a drastic turn, resulting in her divorce and homelessness. The manga captures her descent into despair, vividly illustrating the self-destructive behavior she exhibits in response to her failures. Through Hayame's struggles, the series highlights the detrimental effects of failure on one's self-esteem. This exploration serves as a reminder of the challenges individuals face when confronted with personal setbacks and the toll it can take on their overall well-being.

Similarly, Issei, the 17-year-old male lead, comes from a privileged background as a spoiled rich boy. However, his experiences with Hayame and their shared hardships prompt him to confront his own issues of self-esteem and familial disconnection. Issei's mother, like Hayame's father, has distanced herself from him, adding to his emotional turmoil. Through the characters of Hayame and Issei, Promise Cinderella sheds light on the common struggles faced by individuals who have experienced parental figures distancing themselves, compounding their feelings of inadequacy and guilt.

Throughout the series, both Hayame and Issei undergo personal growth, gradually learning to confront their insecurities and re-establish connections with their loved ones. Their journeys serve as a poignant reminder that even in the face of failure and despair, it is possible to rebuild self-esteem and find solace through genuine human connections.

By exploring the theme of self-esteem and familial disconnection, Promise Cinderella offers a relatable portrayal of the struggles faced by individuals who feel burdened by their own existence. It encourages readers to reflect on the impact of their own actions and emotions, urging empathy and understanding for those who may be battling similar issues. This thematic exploration adds depth and emotional resonance to the narrative, making Promise Cinderella a thought-provoking manga that goes beyond a simple romantic dramedy.

However, the manga's narrative occasionally succumbs to unnecessary drama and an overabundance of antagonistic characters. This excess dilutes the story's realism and impact, stretching the boundaries of believability. While conflict is essential for driving the plot forward or generating tension, an excessive number of antagonists can hinder character development and overshadow the central themes. By introducing numerous villainous characters, the manga loses some of its authenticity and compromises its potential for a more nuanced exploration of interpersonal relationships.

The rushed ending of Promise Cinderella is a significant drawback. In the final volume, the author draws attention to unresolved problems, such as Hayame's strained relationship with her father, but fails to provide satisfactory resolutions. The conclusion feels like a cop-out, leaving readers hanging and relying on hope and wishful thinking for the characters' future. The final volume's brevity adds to the disappointment, suggesting that the manga may have been axed. As a result, the author resorts to time skips to tie up loose ends and deliver a rushed conclusion.

On a positive note, the visual aspect of Promise Cinderella is a notable highlight. The manga's artwork is vibrant, detailed, and the character designs were visually appealing. The illustrations effectively convey the characters' emotions, capturing their struggles and joys with finesse.

Promise Cinderella excels in crafting well-rounded characters, tackling social issues, and showcasing captivating artwork. The growth of Hayame and Issei throughout the series provides emotional depth, and their shared experiences resonate with readers on a profound level. However, the manga falters in its execution due to an excess of unnecessary drama and antagonistic characters. The rushed ending further diminishes the impact by leaving crucial plot points unresolved, relying on hope and wishful thinking rather than providing concrete resolutions. Additionally, the brevity of the final volume and the premature conclusion suggests a possible cancellation, resulting in a reliance on time skips. Despite these shortcomings, Promise Cinderella manages to be an above-average romantic dramedy, reminding readers of the importance of personal growth and human connections, while leaving room for improvement in its narrative execution.