| Shoujo fans are hyping up this anime soo much but this turned out to be one of the most boring overdramatic poorly written anime just like A Condition called love and many other recent shoujo romance. I don't understand why shoujo fans hype up every single new shoujo doesn't matter if it's good or bad. Just to be clear I love good romance anime doesn't matter which demography it's belong to but the recent shoujo romance isn't hitting the right mark imo. |
Reply to Lamp1009
Dude gave Komi Can't Communicate an 8 and is complaining about the most typical shoujo being a shoujo. What did you expect? If you want good romance that doesn't fall into tropes, you have look towards the seinen series.
| @Lamp1009 I have given Maid Same and Boys over flowers 10/10 which are shoujo romance anime. I don't hate shoujo romance but I am suprised to see shoujo fans are hyping every single shoujo anime doesn't matter if the source material is good or bad. This kind of thing doesn't happened among Shounen and Seinen anime fanbase. |
| My guess is that Shoujo romance fans are so starved for anime adaptations that they're just ecstatic when there's one in the season at all. This is the only Shoujo romance of Winter 2025, as far as I know (not counting a reverse harem show). I also don't really understand the hype around this show. And I liked Kimi ni Todoke, A Sign of Affection and Akagami no Shirayuki-hime. I know it's only been 2 episodes, but this made a very poor impression. I wonder if things will drastically improve. |
Reply to casilo
Just 2 ep in and judge the whole anime. If u dont like it just drop it no need to say this stupid statement. The series is one of the best sell manga for shoujo, if they dont hype it then what series they hype ?
| @casilo If this is the best shoujo romance can offer then I am glad that we aren't getting tons of shoujo romance adaptation lately. |
| We just have 2 chapters, so I don't think it's fair to judge it like that. I also have my doubts about Honey Lemon Soda (I haven't read the manga), but I think it's normal for a shojo series to start slow, especially if the protagonist is an anxious shy girl who was bullied. If you think that's overdramatic... well, maybe it is, but I see it as necessary to show us her struggles. I don't think you're the target audience of this anime. |
Reply to ReXiRa
ZXEAN said:
@Lamp1009 I have given Maid Same and Boys over flowers 10/10 which are shoujo romance anime. I don't hate shoujo romance but I am suprised to see shoujo fans are hyping every single shoujo anime doesn't matter if the source material is good or bad. This kind of thing doesn't happened among Shounen and Seinen anime fanbase.
@Lamp1009 I have given Maid Same and Boys over flowers 10/10 which are shoujo romance anime. I don't hate shoujo romance but I am suprised to see shoujo fans are hyping every single shoujo anime doesn't matter if the source material is good or bad. This kind of thing doesn't happened among Shounen and Seinen anime fanbase.
This is like someone saying "I can't be racist, I have a black friend!"
It just amuses me to no end when people like you are suddenly very critical when the demographic label is shoujo.
Calling it overdramatic is also pretty funny, like yea, different people are gonna react differently in the same situations. Just because you think they're making mountains out of molehills, doesn't mean it's the worst thing to ever happen to someone else
| @ReXiRa ReXiRa said: Yaa you are right. Is their anything wrong in this statement? I mean I have watched more shoujo anime then you. I wouldn't have wasted soo much of my time if I hate this demography.This is like someone saying "I can't be racist, I have a black friend!" |
| yeah it's a trashy shoujo filled with mid and cringe dialogue, but i guess that's what sells it. i agree that it's boring and poorly written |
 |
| i wonder when ppl will respect others ppl taste, ok you dont like it, me personally so far i share your opinion on thos titles however saying shoujo fans hype everything nowadays is funny bc seinen and shoujo fans say this about shounen, mecha fans say this about isekai and so on... |
 |
| Agreed, but I think this sort of cheese and dramatics must be what young girls want to consume (I think it's all mostly horrible, but this is just coming from some 31 year old guy lol), much like the generic fantasy tropes for guys. I hear there are some truly epic shoujo manga that aren't primarily romance focused, would be cool to see them adapted instead. |
| 2 episodes is way too soon to judge. Lets see how the story will move on. So far its not bad to me i love slow story buildup. Opening sounds good aswell. Im confident for a decent shoujo anime atm. |
| This show isn't for me but I would just let shoujo romance fans have it. Whatever that may be, because for a long time the opposition was the loudest. |
| don't let them silence you |
Reply to Daniel_cr99
i wonder when ppl will respect others ppl taste, ok you dont like it, me personally so far i share your opinion on thos titles however saying shoujo fans hype everything nowadays is funny bc seinen and shoujo fans say this about shounen, mecha fans say this about isekai and so on...
| Really, you're right. He dissing shoujo fans who hype this adaptation but he doesn't realize how crazy shounen fans hype popular shounen adaptation almost every season even tho it turned out it's generic shounen story, i mean @ZKEAN give them a break cause popular school shoujo manga (not villainess) rarely get adaptation nowadays. Sheesh, hypocricy on internet people nowadays, smh |
|
Reply to ZXEAN
@casilo If this is the best shoujo romance can offer then I am glad that we aren't getting tons of shoujo romance adaptation lately.
ZXEAN said: If this is the best shoujo romance can offer then I am glad that we aren't getting tons of shoujo romance adaptation lately. Seconded What's with all of these self decrepitating awful MH leads with 0 personality. And all this "give it a chance it get's better" bullshit, just give it a rest, 99% of shoujo characters stay the same from episode 1 to xx with zero development, but most shows have something else to spice it up, like comedy or at least characters with two dimensional personality. I can maybe count on number of one hand shoujo shows where leads actually get some meaningful character development over time. There's nothing here, overdramatic bullshit with first world problems. This is THE type of show for fat or ugly girls so they can selfinsert. |
| I don't know about the manga and it might have played out a little better than it did in the anime. But the sake of sanity, this anime is braindead. In one scene she is a weakling but then she is genius. And then she got bullied (yeah, very interesting plot of the year.) but wait she is actually an upcoming NBA player. Neither the characters nor the plot are interesting. You can fail one or the other and the show would be still interesting but to failed both at the same time in the beginning I doubt there is any hope left still in the show. |
 "A Legend is but a tale of a beautiful lie." |
Reply to shuno-oni
@perseii you are quite right, shoujoseis barely get any adaptation, so hype was for this series and the slow resurrection of shoujo on anime scene but....of course we won't get an adaptation for series like oyomegatari MARS or second season of soredemo sekaii ga utsukushii.
| @shuno-oni A Bride's Story is actually a Seinen. Though I agree with the sentiment. I want more diverse ShouJosei adaptations. Though Honey Lemon Soda is a good start, and a good series for those fans. It sold over 13 million copies, so it definitely deserves the adaptation when you look at raw numbers. |
Reply to shuno-oni
@LuxuriousHeart wait what, is this the "I thought it was shoujosei" moment? I read on tumblr it was shoujosei. But apparently all kaoru mori's works are seinen. I still want an anime of oyomegatari and emma though:)
Totally, HLS being adapted was a bit unexpected for me since I wasn't aware of its popularity but I'm happy though I believe the adaptation could have been better.
Totally, HLS being adapted was a bit unexpected for me since I wasn't aware of its popularity but I'm happy though I believe the adaptation could have been better.
shuno-oni said: Emma already have an anime.I still want an anime of oyomegatari and emma though:) |
Reply to shuno-oni
@LuxuriousHeart wait what, is this the "I thought it was shoujosei" moment? I read on tumblr it was shoujosei. But apparently all kaoru mori's works are seinen. I still want an anime of oyomegatari and emma though:)
Totally, HLS being adapted was a bit unexpected for me since I wasn't aware of its popularity but I'm happy though I believe the adaptation could have been better.
Totally, HLS being adapted was a bit unexpected for me since I wasn't aware of its popularity but I'm happy though I believe the adaptation could have been better.
| @shuno-oni I don't get the popularity either, but it is popular. Sold over 13 million copies. Take in mind, Sakamoto Days sold 4 million and Dandadan sold 3.5 million before they got an adaptation. Shounen privilege. π Meanwhile, Don't Call it Mystery sold over 18 million, and has yet to get an anime. Queen's Quality sold 3.3 million, and it still doesn't have an adaptation. Yona of the Dawn sold over 15 million, and it can't get a second second. Kimi ni Todoke sold over 30 million, and it's just recently got a third season. I don't even think Honey Lemon Soda will get a second season, if we go by the pattern. |
Reply to larimatsui
perseii said:
My guess is that Shoujo romance fans are so starved for anime adaptations that they're just ecstatic when there's one in the season at all. This is the only Shoujo romance of Winter 2025, as far as I know (not counting a reverse harem show).
My guess is that Shoujo romance fans are so starved for anime adaptations that they're just ecstatic when there's one in the season at all. This is the only Shoujo romance of Winter 2025, as far as I know (not counting a reverse harem show).
I think that too. And maybe it will be the only shoujo adaptation this year... The pattern has been like this. Yeah, let them be happy...
----
ZXEAN said:
I love good romance anime doesn't matter which demography it's belong to but the recent shoujo romance isn't hitting the right mark imo.
I love good romance anime doesn't matter which demography it's belong to but the recent shoujo romance isn't hitting the right mark imo.
About that, everybody knows what a shoujo is about, yet people stills expects flying cars, dragons, superpowers and amazing fights... And no, shoujo is not only romance: it has other topics like bullying, insecurities, growing up while building emotional intelligence, sometimes abuse or death... If that kind of topic is not your thing, you can stay in "shounen" romance, that have simpler approaches and more "waifu". You don't have to force yourself to watch what you don't like... :)
larimatsui said: You should have read my comment before writing this. I was talking about romance anime here and I know there are shoujo which aren't romance. Natsume and the book of friends is one of my all time favorite it's a shoujo series which isn't romance. About that, everybody knows what a shoujo is about, yet people stills expects flying cars, dragons, superpowers and amazing fights... And no, shoujo is not only romance: it has other topics like bullying, insecurities, growing up while building emotional intelligence, sometimes abuse or death... If that kind of topic is not your thing, you can stay in "shounen" romance, that have simpler approaches and more "waifu". You don't have to force yourself to watch what you don't like... :) |
ZXEANFeb 2, 6:25 PM
Reply to larimatsui
perseii said:
My guess is that Shoujo romance fans are so starved for anime adaptations that they're just ecstatic when there's one in the season at all. This is the only Shoujo romance of Winter 2025, as far as I know (not counting a reverse harem show).
My guess is that Shoujo romance fans are so starved for anime adaptations that they're just ecstatic when there's one in the season at all. This is the only Shoujo romance of Winter 2025, as far as I know (not counting a reverse harem show).
I think that too. And maybe it will be the only shoujo adaptation this year... The pattern has been like this. Yeah, let them be happy...
----
ZXEAN said:
I love good romance anime doesn't matter which demography it's belong to but the recent shoujo romance isn't hitting the right mark imo.
I love good romance anime doesn't matter which demography it's belong to but the recent shoujo romance isn't hitting the right mark imo.
About that, everybody knows what a shoujo is about, yet people stills expects flying cars, dragons, superpowers and amazing fights... And no, shoujo is not only romance: it has other topics like bullying, insecurities, growing up while building emotional intelligence, sometimes abuse or death... If that kind of topic is not your thing, you can stay in "shounen" romance, that have simpler approaches and more "waifu". You don't have to force yourself to watch what you don't like... :)
larimatsui said: 2/3 of my favourite romance anime are shoujo. I don't hate watching shoujo romance to be honest.If that kind of topic is not your thing, you can stay in "shounen" romance, that have simpler approaches and more "waifu". You don't have to force yourself to watch what you don't like... :) |
| It's best to ignore hype tbh, for me blue box was the last straw. Considering the insane hype surrounding it even prior to release it's really not all that. Honey lemon soda is the other romance that doesn't live up to the hype, it's not even good, but it's starting to be slowly. If you ignore the hype you can't be let down if something falls short, even posting about it just seems to be pointless, i dared to talk bad about blue box and the bandwagoners just threw general bs at me, romance fans (all demographics) might just be the most unreasonable beings when it comes to anime |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Honey Lemon Soda Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Yesterday |
64 |
by Mione48
»»
33 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Honey Lemon Soda Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jan 15 |
89 |
by Ten
»»
Today, 6:33 AM |
|
Poll: » Honey Lemon Soda Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Feb 5 |
56 |
by Fenyy
»»
Yesterday, 3:05 AM |
|
Poll: » Honey Lemon Soda Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jan 22 |
59 |
by AboAhmed130
»»
Feb 10, 12:15 PM |
|
» I really like Honey Lemon soda, what's your thoughts + episode 4 discussion ( 1 2 )Ron014 - Jan 29 |
60 |
by bahimiron
»»
Feb 5, 12:27 AM |