A good end of the story but was it really?

BunnySenpaiii1 said:
I started watching the anime back when season 2 was coming out. I watched till the end of season 3 and only just realised there was a movie when i decided to rewatch. Idk why but i had this memory than season 3 ended with a confession and by rewatching it i realised ive remembered wrong. So my thoughts about the series is that season 1 is the best season with every season afterwards dropping in quality. Now when i have seen what i consider to be a fitting end for the story finally i can say that season 3 sucked. I was reading a lot when season 3 was coming out that THIS IS THE SEASON from a lot of overhyped fans/manga readers and i expected that finally this story will come to conclusion but S3 ended poorly with , i thought , another 3-4 seasons coming up until FINALLY they get together. I was pleasantly surprised tho that they got together shortly after , i know there is a lot more material in the manga but for me this is the end of the story and i dont really want to know the rest. Now for what i dislike about the later stages of the series is that they nerfed Shirogane a LOT, in S1 he was a brave , strategic and consoled young man with intelligence that could rival even LIght Yagami's , but in S3 and especially the movie he was this hopeless romantic who broke down over the slightest change of Kaguya's attitude. In the movie they both already knew they like each other , kaguya was pushing him actively to take their relationship to the next level and yet he still acted like a little bi*** about it and chose to suffer instead of becoming a man and taking what he wants from god knows how much time. He was my favourite character and i just get mad when i see how much he fell in the movie , at the end kaguya told him she loves him first and proposed to him to be her boyfriend completely making him irrelevant as a man. Overral im happy that i got to see them together at last , and i liked the change of atmosphere in the movie - from a silly rom-com to a more serious rom-drama, its definitely a good story and i would recommend it to ppl in the future but its very far from a masterpiece and i feel it could have been better. What are your thoughts about the end?

BunnySenpaiii1 said:
I started watching the anime back when season 2 was coming out. I watched till the end of season 3 and only just realised there was a movie when i decided to rewatch. Idk why but i had this memory than season 3 ended with a confession and by rewatching it i realised ive remembered wrong. So my thoughts about the series is that season 1 is the best season with every season afterwards dropping in quality. Now when i have seen what i consider to be a fitting end for the story finally i can say that season 3 sucked. I was reading a lot when season 3 was coming out that THIS IS THE SEASON from a lot of overhyped fans/manga readers and i expected that finally this story will come to conclusion but S3 ended poorly with , i thought , another 3-4 seasons coming up until FINALLY they get together. I was pleasantly surprised tho that they got together shortly after , i know there is a lot more material in the manga but for me this is the end of the story and i dont really want to know the rest. Now for what i dislike about the later stages of the series is that they nerfed Shirogane a LOT, in S1 he was a brave , strategic and consoled young man with intelligence that could rival even LIght Yagami's , but in S3 and especially the movie he was this hopeless romantic who broke down over the slightest change of Kaguya's attitude. In the movie they both already knew they like each other , kaguya was pushing him actively to take their relationship to the next level and yet he still acted like a little bi*** about it and chose to suffer instead of becoming a man and taking what he wants from god knows how much time. He was my favourite character and i just get mad when i see how much he fell in the movie , at the end kaguya told him she loves him first and proposed to him to be her boyfriend completely making him irrelevant as a man. Overral im happy that i got to see them together at last , and i liked the change of atmosphere in the movie - from a silly rom-com to a more serious rom-drama, its definitely a good story and i would recommend it to ppl in the future but its very far from a masterpiece and i feel it could have been better. What are your thoughts about the end?

BunnySenpaiii1 said:
I started watching the anime back when season 2 was coming out. I watched till the end of season 3 and only just realised there was a movie when i decided to rewatch. Idk why but i had this memory than season 3 ended with a confession and by rewatching it i realised ive remembered wrong. So my thoughts about the series is that season 1 is the best season with every season afterwards dropping in quality. Now when i have seen what i consider to be a fitting end for the story finally i can say that season 3 sucked. I was reading a lot when season 3 was coming out that THIS IS THE SEASON from a lot of overhyped fans/manga readers and i expected that finally this story will come to conclusion but S3 ended poorly with , i thought , another 3-4 seasons coming up until FINALLY they get together. I was pleasantly surprised tho that they got together shortly after , i know there is a lot more material in the manga but for me this is the end of the story and i dont really want to know the rest. Now for what i dislike about the later stages of the series is that they nerfed Shirogane a LOT, in S1 he was a brave , strategic and consoled young man with intelligence that could rival even LIght Yagami's , but in S3 and especially the movie he was this hopeless romantic who broke down over the slightest change of Kaguya's attitude. In the movie they both already knew they like each other , kaguya was pushing him actively to take their relationship to the next level and yet he still acted like a little bi*** about it and chose to suffer instead of becoming a man and taking what he wants from god knows how much time. He was my favourite character and i just get mad when i see how much he fell in the movie , at the end kaguya told him she loves him first and proposed to him to be her boyfriend completely making him irrelevant as a man. Overral im happy that i got to see them together at last , and i liked the change of atmosphere in the movie - from a silly rom-com to a more serious rom-drama, its definitely a good story and i would recommend it to ppl in the future but its very far from a masterpiece and i feel it could have been better. What are your thoughts about the end?

BunnySenpaiii1 said:
I started watching the anime back when season 2 was coming out. I watched till the end of season 3 and only just realised there was a movie when i decided to rewatch. Idk why but i had this memory than season 3 ended with a confession and by rewatching it i realised ive remembered wrong. So my thoughts about the series is that season 1 is the best season with every season afterwards dropping in quality. Now when i have seen what i consider to be a fitting end for the story finally i can say that season 3 sucked. I was reading a lot when season 3 was coming out that THIS IS THE SEASON from a lot of overhyped fans/manga readers and i expected that finally this story will come to conclusion but S3 ended poorly with , i thought , another 3-4 seasons coming up until FINALLY they get together. I was pleasantly surprised tho that they got together shortly after , i know there is a lot more material in the manga but for me this is the end of the story and i dont really want to know the rest. Now for what i dislike about the later stages of the series is that they nerfed Shirogane a LOT, in S1 he was a brave , strategic and consoled young man with intelligence that could rival even LIght Yagami's , but in S3 and especially the movie he was this hopeless romantic who broke down over the slightest change of Kaguya's attitude. In the movie they both already knew they like each other , kaguya was pushing him actively to take their relationship to the next level and yet he still acted like a little bi*** about it and chose to suffer instead of becoming a man and taking what he wants from god knows how much time. He was my favourite character and i just get mad when i see how much he fell in the movie , at the end kaguya told him she loves him first and proposed to him to be her boyfriend completely making him irrelevant as a man. Overral im happy that i got to see them together at last , and i liked the change of atmosphere in the movie - from a silly rom-com to a more serious rom-drama, its definitely a good story and i would recommend it to ppl in the future but its very far from a masterpiece and i feel it could have been better. What are your thoughts about the end?

elderonn said:
What is more crazy to me is all these clowns in the comments with mha pictures not reading the actual thread and telling you that the show isn’t over. The attention span of y’all is very low.

Anyways I do agree that the series went downhill after season 1 but the movie was great.

elderonn said:
What is more crazy to me is all these clowns in the comments with mha pictures not reading the actual thread and telling you that the show isn’t over. The attention span of y’all is very low.

Anyways I do agree that the series went downhill after season 1 but the movie was great.

AgentDusk said:
Well, most people aren't going to consider this the end, because... I mean, it isn't. Just because you're gonna stop watching doesn't mean we have to judge the movie on its merits as an ending.

But to humor you, I think you greatly misunderstood what the series was about. You criticize the series for making Shirogane more insecure and emotional and less like Light Yagami, but here's the fundamental difference between those two: Shirogane is a good person, and Light isn't. And if Shirogane is supposed to be less of a man for not having confessed first, especially after what he pulled at the end of Season 3, I think you drastically misread his character from the very beginning.

I also don't quite get why this misunderstanding is all Shirogane's fault when a good two-thirds of the movie is shown from Kaguya's perspective with her being unwilling to admit her feelings for fear of exposing her weakness. She by no means was open to him about what she wanted during the movie, so she bears equal responsibility for their turmoil. Also, they're both 16, and the premise of the show involves them both being socially inept, so I don't know why you're only complaining now.

Both Miyuki and Kaguya are flawed people who complement each other and make each other better, and the whole angle of the show, being them at odds with each other, is absurd by design. If the series reached this point without having that dynamic be broken and both parties realizing the pointlessness of their competitive framework (which is what the confession scene in the movie does), it would have lost the plot much more than you're implying it did. All I can get from your complaint is that the show ended up being different than what you wanted (Death Note but rom-com?) and you decided that was a mistake.

AgentDusk said:
Well, most people aren't going to consider this the end, because... I mean, it isn't. Just because you're gonna stop watching doesn't mean we have to judge the movie on its merits as an ending.

But to humor you, I think you greatly misunderstood what the series was about. You criticize the series for making Shirogane more insecure and emotional and less like Light Yagami, but here's the fundamental difference between those two: Shirogane is a good person, and Light isn't. And if Shirogane is supposed to be less of a man for not having confessed first, especially after what he pulled at the end of Season 3, I think you drastically misread his character from the very beginning.

I also don't quite get why this misunderstanding is all Shirogane's fault when a good two-thirds of the movie is shown from Kaguya's perspective with her being unwilling to admit her feelings for fear of exposing her weakness. She by no means was open to him about what she wanted during the movie, so she bears equal responsibility for their turmoil. Also, they're both 16, and the premise of the show involves them both being socially inept, so I don't know why you're only complaining now.

Both Miyuki and Kaguya are flawed people who complement each other and make each other better, and the whole angle of the show, being them at odds with each other, is absurd by design. If the series reached this point without having that dynamic be broken and both parties realizing the pointlessness of their competitive framework (which is what the confession scene in the movie does), it would have lost the plot much more than you're implying it did. All I can get from your complaint is that the show ended up being different than what you wanted (Death Note but rom-com?) and you decided that was a mistake.

I started watching the anime back when season 2 was coming out. I watched till the end of season 3 and only just realised there was a movie when i decided to rewatch. Idk why but i had this memory than season 3 ended with a confession and by rewatching it i realised ive remembered wrong. So my thoughts about the series is that season 1 is the best season with every season afterwards dropping in quality. Now when i have seen what i consider to be a fitting end for the story finally i can say that season 3 sucked. I was reading a lot when season 3 was coming out that THIS IS THE SEASON from a lot of overhyped fans/manga readers and i expected that finally this story will come to conclusion but S3 ended poorly with , i thought , another 3-4 seasons coming up until FINALLY they get together. I was pleasantly surprised tho that they got together shortly after , i know there is a lot more material in the manga but for me this is the end of the story and i dont really want to know the rest. Now for what i dislike about the later stages of the series is that they nerfed Shirogane a LOT, in S1 he was a brave , strategic and consoled young man with intelligence that could rival even LIght Yagami's , but in S3 and especially the movie he was this hopeless romantic who broke down over the slightest change of Kaguya's attitude. In the movie they both already knew they like each other , kaguya was pushing him actively to take their relationship to the next level and yet he still acted like a little bi*** about it and chose to suffer instead of becoming a man and taking what he wants from god knows how much time. He was my favourite character and i just get mad when i see how much he fell in the movie , at the end kaguya told him she loves him first and proposed to him to be her boyfriend completely making him irrelevant as a man. Overral im happy that i got to see them together at last , and i liked the change of atmosphere in the movie - from a silly rom-com to a more serious rom-drama, its definitely a good story and i would recommend it to ppl in the future but its very far from a masterpiece and i feel it could have been better. What are your thoughts about the end?