| He did a solid job and I have no idea where this hate comes from other than attention seeking. |
 |
| too bad the japanese fans that constantly complained wants anime and not western cinema |
| I guess I'm a manga elitist because I think that the manga is better in every way than the anime, but the anime was still great, just wish they did better with the color palette and that it wasn't only 12 ep |
 |
Zar20 said: CheekyNimrod said: I really loved it!! However, after reading the manga I understood people’s frustration with it. The manga was way more frightening and eerie which made it extremely thrilling. I personally would’ve preferred the mangas tone over what we did get but I still loved the cinematic version!! 8/10 I thought that's why they hated it because it was too eire and had more of a dark tone to it. i mainly heard people wanting a more colorful palet with goofyness. The adaptation was incredible. idk why people are complaining. tbh I think a super vibrant color palette and all the fucked up gore just fits Fujimoto's style better. That's my opinion tho, it doesn't need to be goofy I just feel like the color palette needs to be more vibrant |
|
Zar20 said: AntiSadboi said: tbh I think a super vibrant color palette and all the fucked up gore just fits Fujimoto's style better. That's my opinion tho, it doesn't need to be goofy I just feel like the color palette needs to be more vibrant I can understand it for sure. The manga covers give off that vibe, obviously. I just think in terms of the story(makima's twist- light spoiler), the dark aspect fits overall better. Especially in the later half of part one, things get really dark. I would be completely open to a different adaptation later in the future that has more of those vibrant colors mybe even by a different studio. This adaptation is what I wanted, though, and it is going to be a joy to watch in the next decade. Yeah I get what if saying, honestly I tell ppl to experience it both ways and choose what they like best |
|
| You all should respect what Nakayama doing. The reason he leaving Mappa because of worst work condition, thigh schedule and harassments from japan fans. I remember read his twitter saying he, TNK and Yoshihara not sleeping finishing csm final episode that will airing few days later. Mappa is the worst studio. They should treat their animator as human not a slave. I hate Mappa but i still will support with watching at Cinema Reze movie. Lets goo. |
CrazyFrogzJan 9, 2024 5:52 AM
 |
| amazing experience, haven't enjoyed another new gen adaptation as much as that and i just wish it had more than 12 episodes. i rewatch it every 6 months since it's so short and just completed it a few days ago so it's very fresh in my mind. shame how the fans treated ryu, don't deserve him but i'm glad we got what we got although it'll probably never be done again sadly. |
 |
GoatPieceLuffy said: I loved the cinematic feel of it, and it truly felt like he was inspired by many amazing movie directors. All in all, it was an incredible experience. CSM S1 was a 9/10 for me. Dude only the 1st episode has a cinematic feeling, that’s about it. The rest felt like a normal anime. The anime is low key a cheap version of the manga to me it was a 6-7/10 I think I gave it a 7 bc I was being nice but it’s now closer to a 6 looking at it at an objective standpoint |
They have their reasons and they are valid ngl. |
haaaku1 said: The only issue i had with CSM S1 is the overuse of CGI, but still It was fun to watch:) They added so much unnecessary cgi to the point where it felt like they were cutting corners. |
| After seeing anime and reading manga, I prefer anime anyway. Aside from some really good pages, Fujimoto's style is very Simple, and honestly, I have seen better (by reading for the last 10y of my life). Especially last arc I read only for some characters as the story seems to be kinda stuck in one place. |
| “You are not alone, Ash. I am with you. My soul is with you.” - Eiji Okumura. |
| the cgi was so fucking cool. people just love acting like spoiled childs. i cannot say anything about Japaneese viewers hating it tho. have no clue what they think about. |
| I do! His approach has elevated the source material, in my opinion. Stuff adapted in the first seasons felt mediocre to me in the manga format (well... the whole manga felt underwhelming, to be fair), while in the anime format it was really pleasant to watch. Cinematic feel really did the work, haha. Combined with high production quality, it resulted in a totally awesome show. |
โจSaint Seiya Club๐ |
GoatPieceLuffy said: @Dixoncider8142 1. Art is subjective & I loved it, that I gave it a 9/10. You're also trippin if you think there wasn't any cinematic feel besides EP1. & 2. Elitist Manga fans are toxic as hell and think most anime adaptations are "inferior". They got the character designs perfectly I’ll give them that but the animation wasn’t at its best just like other MAPPA projects that they’ve done for the past year, also csm barely had any sakuga, I could only think of 2-3 scenes that had sakuga. Also it didn’t have a cinematic feel to it, I assure u I’m not tripping it’s just the truth. Also manga readers are right 55-60% of the time |
| Really liked it, waiting for season 2 |
 |
| I loved the direction of s1 The only downside is the cgi, but the cgi isn't bad and still can be considered as one of the best looking cgi in animes For color tone controversy, I dunno which one works well for the anime adaptation. The realistic or chaotic color tone I hope the reze arc will keep the cinematic direction, even tho with a different director All I can say, Chainsawman anime is overHATED and deserved more love because of it's creative way on directing |
We all have shit taste, especially in animes No one's right, no one's wrong  |
GoatPieceLuffy said: @Dixoncider8142 1. I don't know. To me, CSM animation was fire and Mappa has been doing an amazing job with most of their projects. 2. It did have a cinematic feel to it so yeah, you're trippin. & 3. If you think manga readers are right most of the time, then you're just blind. There's a reason why most anime-only people don't listen to manga elitists because quite frankly, they complain about EVERYTHING. I’m not even gonna give u any evidence at this point ur just a MAPPA fanboy who’s in denial and can’t accept that their projects for the past year have been in low quality. |
| I don't get where the hate even came from. CSM S1 is a masterpiece, and argubly better produced than JJKS2. Yes, the plot wasn't too interesting in S1, but that isn't the anime's problem. S1's animation is insanely well, regardless of the use of cgi (which is needed anyway). I also loved the cinematic artstyle, its a shame that JJKS2 abandoned it later in the season. |
Reply to dixoncider8142
GoatPieceLuffy said:
@Dixoncider8142
1. Art is subjective & I loved it, that I gave it a 9/10. You're also trippin if you think there wasn't any cinematic feel besides EP1.
& 2. Elitist Manga fans are toxic as hell and think most anime adaptations are "inferior".
@Dixoncider8142
1. Art is subjective & I loved it, that I gave it a 9/10. You're also trippin if you think there wasn't any cinematic feel besides EP1.
& 2. Elitist Manga fans are toxic as hell and think most anime adaptations are "inferior".
They got the character designs perfectly I’ll give them that but the animation wasn’t at its best just like other MAPPA projects that they’ve done for the past year, also csm barely had any sakuga, I could only think of 2-3 scenes that had sakuga. Also it didn’t have a cinematic feel to it, I assure u I’m not tripping it’s just the truth.
Also manga readers are right 55-60% of the time
| @filthyfrank8142 They got the character designs perfectly I’ll give them that but the animation wasn’t at its best just like other MAPPA projects that they’ve done for the past year Nah bro really is tripping. CSM, JJKS1 and AOT Final season are some of the best animated MAPPA works, and in the entirety of anime. Sakuga is such a vague word anyway. Chatgpt defines it as "moments of exceptionally high-quality animation within a series or film. These moments often stand out due to their fluidity, attention to detail, and dynamic movement" CSM has all over that, and I really don't know where you got your idea from that CSM didn't have sakuga. Im not even just talking about the background, but all the little attention to how characters move, how their hairs moves, fingers, even eyes. CSM did this perfectly. |
Reply to Zimmu
@filthyfrank8142
Nah bro really is tripping. CSM, JJKS1 and AOT Final season are some of the best animated MAPPA works, and in the entirety of anime. Sakuga is such a vague word anyway.
Chatgpt defines it as "moments of exceptionally high-quality animation within a series or film. These moments often stand out due to their fluidity, attention to detail, and dynamic movement"
CSM has all over that, and I really don't know where you got your idea from that CSM didn't have sakuga. Im not even just talking about the background, but all the little attention to how characters move, how their hairs moves, fingers, even eyes. CSM did this perfectly.
They got the character designs perfectly I’ll give them that but the animation wasn’t at its best just like other MAPPA projects that they’ve done for the past year
Nah bro really is tripping. CSM, JJKS1 and AOT Final season are some of the best animated MAPPA works, and in the entirety of anime. Sakuga is such a vague word anyway.
Chatgpt defines it as "moments of exceptionally high-quality animation within a series or film. These moments often stand out due to their fluidity, attention to detail, and dynamic movement"
CSM has all over that, and I really don't know where you got your idea from that CSM didn't have sakuga. Im not even just talking about the background, but all the little attention to how characters move, how their hairs moves, fingers, even eyes. CSM did this perfectly.
| @Zimmu I agree that jjk season 1 had good animation, the final season of aot part 1 was good in terms of direction but had subpar animation compared to jjk s1. Not every action scene has sakuga, just to let you know. I want to know what parts you think have sakuga that's longer than 5 seconds bc ppl love pointing out anime having sakuga like within 30-50ms which is almost nothing not even the bare minimum. Most of the time csm looked normal, if anything the manga panels looked better than anything that the anime has adapted. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 27, 2022 |
981 |
by Soldierz17
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )YoshePlays - Oct 7, 2022 |
2659 |
by peluusaa
»»
Mar 16, 7:05 PM |
|
» Tatsuya Yoshihara will not be directing Reze movieCreepHazard - Feb 6, 2024 |
29 |
by Oongbuh
»»
Mar 2, 2:18 PM |
|
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 20, 2022 |
392 |
by YolkyGoblin
»»
Feb 20, 6:59 PM |
|
Poll: » Chainsaw Man Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 6, 2022 |
583 |
by Sul_Anoji
»»
Feb 15, 12:10 AM |