Yosuga no Sora is greatly underestimated and I will prove it(The article contains a complete analysis of anime).
New
Dec 29, 2021 3:17 AM
#1
Foreword Hello dear visitors of the forum. In this thread I am going to explain why it happened that Yosuga no Sora is not appreciated (about 6/10) and also present objective evidence that this series deserves at least 8/10, although I tend to 9/10 and will also explain almost everything incomprehensible and unnoticed moments associated with Yosuga no Sora (with the actions and development of characters, social problems, symbolism, the plot itself, and so on).I watched anime,read manga and VN. I deliberately divided the narration into a part without spoilers for those who have not watched the anime and into a part for those who have already watched it,except chapters 1,2,4 which are for everyone.However, if you have watched anime or are just familiar with the story, read the first part, because in the part with spoilers, I do not particularly repeat what I wrote before. I know there is a lot of text,but I sincerely ask you to read to the end. English is not my native language, so in some places I apologize for my English.When I carefully analyzed this story and watched the anime, I was incredibly surprised at how well it was done.I guess this is the most serious story in the world of anime and manga that raises the topic of forbidden love between brother and sister. It seems that this story has no analogues in the world of anime, manga, light novel.I know I can't convince everyone and no one can do it, but I want to provide a complete analysis of this story that will be useful to some people, although unfortunately I think it will even be seen by a tiny percentage of the entire anime community.Enough people think that everyone can rate anime as they want, but why then do many consider it wrong to rate something that they have not watched or rate something for example at 1/10, although almost everyone rated it at 10/10, for example. It is clear that the one who rated it at 1 / 10 is wrong because he does not have sufficient information or the correct understanding of this information, as well as the one who has not watched the anime at all. Your assessment will be correct only when you not only watched the anime, but also completely analyzed it and understood almost all or all of the moments that are happening in story. Otherwise, the omitted or overlooked moments can underestimate the estimate, as often happens by 2-3 points. Naturally, there is a small mistake when, due to very controversial points, the assessment is quiet different (0-1 point). But most often regulate the facts.Many people evaluate anime based on how well they enjoyed it. This is not entirely correct judgment because, for example, in horror movies there are enough moments where you cannot enjoy what is happening or you even become disgusted. Therefore, if somewhere there are moments for which you feel disgust, this is not a drawback. It would be possible to develop a system of correct rating for each genre, but this is too long and therefore I will just rely on the comparison. Good love stories usually have 8/10 or more. Also, one lack of anime can cost 1 -2 points (rough judgment) I'll just show that story has a good construction.We can say what exactly was some moment in story.The more it makes sense, the better.We can take apart each moment from the story and establish its meaning, as well as the connection with other moments And this can be done with every moment, even if The reader feels disgust and simply hates all the moments entirely, and if these moments form something that make sense,and then this sense indicate what emotions should be when getting to know the story. In this case, you may not enjoy what is happening, but understand that the story is well written and therefore give it high mark.[b]You need to understand that the things that I am discussing cannot be completely objective. But they are the least subjective. Let's say the character design is quite subjective.The plot and personality of the characters cannot be subjectively interpreted. Because they shouldn't depend on the person's preferences.There are such moments connected with the personalities of the characters or the plot that can be explained in different ways,at the same time these explanations must correspond to the meaning of not only one moment, but also the entire chain of related moments. Therefore, the plot and the personalities of the characters are the most objective.Almost all of my text is about the Sora and Haru timeline.In the process of analyzing anime, I will rely on information only from anime. You can try to explain anime using information from a VN, but some points differ and I don't need to do this because this story has everything that is needed to explain without involving a VN. I was motivated by people's hatred of this story, especially Sora's timeline, and I still haven't seen a good enough analysis of this story so I decided to do it myself.I was not particularly pleased to see that the English-speaking community is incredibly small and almost dead, as well as that a good story is surrounded by hatred from many sides,popular tops and reviews that contain misinformation, creators of such content that absorb other people's delusions.And even though during the creation of this article at some point I ceased to care about such a situation around this story, I used to bring things to the end.It took me about a month and a half to create this article. Naturally, I did it in my free time from work and study, so it took so long.By far the 7th chapter in this article is the most valuable and a lot will be based on it. This article will be useful to you if you are having trouble understanding or analyzing this story or just looking for a good love story.Or if you are looking for an overview of this story and anime in particular.My main goal was to show that regardless of whether you are neutral or negative about incest, if you are interested in love anime,(not counting the case of a categorically negative attitude towards incest at the level of blind faith),then you should watch this anime or read VN. For those who have not seen this story 1.Where did the hatred for this story come from and how did it spread? So we have a visual novel, but it is hard to find this VN. So not everyone was able to play this novel, but reviews about it generally decent.The manga contains slightly more scenes from the visual novel, but no erotic scenes.Almost all the things that people don't like in the manga are also in the anime, but in the anime there are some things that people don't like, but they are not in the manga.Therefore, it is enough to consider only anime as an object of hatred. Let's start with what many already know.When the anime appeared, many people began to watch it but did not even suspect about different timelines, in the end, they just did not really understand anything, evaluating this anime much worse than it really deserves.And there were enough such people to influence the rating a little. We can’t calculate even an approximate number. But I don’t think that there could be more than 10%(this is more a number taken from the head than a reasonable estimate of the amount) of them who watched so much without understanding anything. Because most likely found this obvious thing as a division into different temporary links via the internet or other people.Obviously, there were also people who watched this anime of a very traditional nature as the most devoted believers. So they were disgusted with the concept on which the plot was built, which is why they could not see the love, the social problem that anime raises and possibly much more. Also, if you look at a lot of Reddit and YouTube posts, you might come to the conclusion that anime is quickly overgrown with a lot of memes.We can only say that memes partly made anime more popular but also lowered the rating in the same way. Because there was a sufficient percentage of people who watched anime just for the sake of memes. It is more likely that the number of people who came to see anime for the sake of memes and reduce the rating should be more than the number of people who came to watch for the meme and suddenly saw a really great story in it. This is not an entirely accurate statement. But usually people who see something in a meme do not even try to find something serious in it.Before that, we looked at people who gave incorrect ratings and wrote angry reviews about this anime. They said why they rated it incorrectly and lowered the rating of the anime itself, it could be said using knowledge of psychology, it is clear that the psychological assessment is not entirely accurate, but such people have in common and this common i use it to prove. There are people who simply either have not seen erotica, or are too accustomed to the fact that in love stories, as a rule, there is no erotica. Most of these people argued that this anime is just hentai or almost hentai without understanding the difference between erotica and hentai at all. These people especially influenced the rating of the anime. Their statements not only discouraged other people from watching this anime, but those who watched it began to assume that everything was going to hentai or simply saw erotic scenes and, due to the opinions of others, did not see the point in further viewing. I suppose that most of these people simply did not see this anime completely, but only excerpts from it. It is quite difficult to believe that the one who watched the anime saw only erotic scenes in it, although this is possible since they can suddenly surprise their appearance at some moments and remaining in the memory for a long time(Especially if a person does not take anime seriously.) because of which after viewing only one memory of erotic scenes will remain and a person will think that the focus is on them and there are a lot of them, although this is not so.After all, erotic scenes and hentai are different by definition, and in all this anime erotic scenes occupy less then 6% from the whole show(Each episode with no OP and ED lasts approximately 20 minutes.Sora's entire timeline is approximately 95 minutes or 5700 seconds. the duration of each erotic scene, then for the entire timeline Sora will be released approximately 300 seconds or 5 minutes.300 seconds from 5700 is less than 6%.) and not every episode contains erotic scenes.To be more precise then less than 4% in Episode 10, less than 15% in Episode 11, and less than 5% in Episode 12. So we have four main reasons for this anime's under-rating. 1.People who are incredibly strong against incest for reasons of morality and they do not at all doubt the correctness of their position. They seem to blindly believe. 2.people who watch this anime for memes 3.people who can't tell the difference between hentai and erotic scenes 4.people who just didn't see the timelines Naturally, this has all spread to such an extent that now this anime appears in the top worst anime. Naturally, the authors of such tops simply consume the delusions of other people.There are good reviews of this anime, but there are very few views on them. The most views are cut erotic scenes from this anime that became the stuff for silly memes.I'm not saying that these people are to blame for what happened.but this affected not only the rating of the anime itself, but also the entire YNS community.If it hadn't happened, the community of this anime would probably have been much larger.Now the English community seems to be almost dead. 2.why did most of these people misjudge anime ? There will be some repetitions from chapter 1, but I'll go into more detail. with people who do not see different timelines everything is clean. Let's start with 1. People who are extremely against incest usually experience disgust and other unpleasant feelings when watching Sora and Haru's relationship, which not only prevents them from focusing on the story, but sometimes even forces them to skip some points.It is worth noting that such people most often do not try to think about the correctness of the position from which they look at the whole story.And usually when the anime gives them a question that the viewer should answer, they either do not notice it.So Sora and Haru look like two completely immoral twins to such people. In which they are completely mistaken,because love arises independently of the rational desires of the characters. In other words, a person can love another person despite the fact that the person did not want to love another person. So there is no Sora or Haru's fault in this.Such people miss the social issue that this anime raises, and also cannot look from a different position at all.To forbid the relationship between Sora and Haru means to disrupt the happy between them, which will lead to the suffering of both, and this is also immoral. Thus, such people usually contradict themselves by defending position.In this particular case, it would be correct to accept the position of Haru and Sora, or neutral. Now let's talk about 2. Nowadays, many people who watch memes do not find anything serious in them. That is why people who came to watch anime see a meme in it and do not expect anything serious. Accordingly, they are not going to analyze it. Now let's talk about 3. Firstly, not every episode has erotic scenes at all. For those who do not know, ordinary kissing does not apply to erotic scenes.if you take Sora's entire timeline, there will be two episodes without erotic scenes and only three with erotic scenes(Where one of them has only one erotic scene). And one erotic scene in episodes are usually make up 30-60 seconds and only in rare cases 1-2 minutes. All erotic scenes make up about 15% of the entire episode, which is incredibly small. Also, I say it is erotica instead of ecchi, since in most anime ecchi is already more like hentai than erotic scenes because they have one goal. Hentai and ecchi are both aimed at absolute excitement,although ecchi copes with this much weaker.Often erotic scenes are only very little aimed at arousal and are much more aimed at showing feelings through sex scenes and how strong the chemistry between a love couple is. Since touch affects a person no less than words and the interaction of bodies without words reflects some sensory aspects between love couple.Hentai is also quite different and can also show different feelings and the strength of love between characters. Especially hentai in some love couple, but it is still hentai because it focuses on arousing a person and it is very difficult to watch hentai without feeling aroused. In this anime, you can safely watch erotic scenes without any excitement,especially when music symbolizes sad and loneliness. It should now be clear why it is wrong to say that a love story where erotic scenes make up less than 6% of the entire show and also hardly arouse people is hentai. I know it is wrong to divide people into categories, but this is all just a convention for the proof. 3.The social problem that this story raises This story wouldn't be so good if it wasn't for the problem it raises.Usually, in various love anime or short stories, the whole plot is built around the personal need of the protagonist or an accidental occurrence.Let's say he needs to find a girl, because he envies other boys who already have a girlfriend, maybe he doesn't envy other boys, but just looks at other boys who already have a girlfriend and understands that this is a social norm and he will also need to find a girl, or he does not want to look for a girl at all, but accidentally falls in love because of some event that happened in his life. In other words, the motivation is quite simple and understandable.It can be even easier when motivation is based on sex drive.For example both characters, or one, saw naked body parts or somehow interacted with it. It's more like ordinary sex drive.Love is very different from sex drive in that they have a much stronger chemistry between a love couple.The plot in YNS is really very different from others in that it is not built around personal needs or a random event, it is built around a serious social problem, so those who get acquainted with this story are interested in how society will affect Sora and Haru's relationship and how they will cope with the pressure that society produces. There is also a meaning that autor wants to convey to us through the disclosure of this problem and a sufficient amount of symbolism. This means that the observance of moral rules is not always correct.Why is it so, I would like to explain to those who are familiar with story, because spoilers are inevitable if we talk about it. However, for now I will state that the serious topic of the relationship between brother and sister, which involves society, not only distinguishes from other topics, but also keeps YNS story at a high level.There is enough to explain here, but I will leave that for those who are familiar with the story. 4.Anime's only objective flaw So it should be clear that the anime is based on the VN.I know the VN and the anime and therefore know the differences.The disadvantage of anime is that it is quite dynamic and also contains little romance.In 5 episodes of Sora and Haru's timeline, it is not easy to reveal Sora and Haru as characters and also fill the story with drama and also reveal the social problem associated with the relationship of the brother and sister.Nevertheless, the author succeeded in all this, which made the anime very dynamic. Haru and Sora have many moments in the visual novel, and if you add all of those moments in the anime, you get 7 or more episodes.So in the anime they put in a part that is considered the main one. Moreover, the presentation is not consistent. Some moments of the stories we learn immediately from the conversations of Sora and Haru, and some of Haru's conversations with someone only later. And some of the lost puzzles of the anime get up into place if you look at the behavior and actions of the characters. Nevertheless, all these moments are enough to make a complete picture. The development of the characters, the reasons for their behavior, the development of the storyline itself, and so on are quite noticeable.Because of this, many people may feel that relationships and characters develop much faster than they should in real life. However, it is clear that there is a time skip that is often used in anime.It is also worth saying that it is difficult when watching anime for the first time to catch all the moments that are hidden. Especially difficult for those who are not watching it seriously.When you first watch it, you do not know how the plot will go and how the characters will develop, so something may surprise you, or you may forget something altogether during viewing, which will then need to be remembered. Therefore, you need to watch it seriously, paying attention to every phrase that is used in the narration and try to analyze it.I think, like many others, I could not get the whole picture from the first time when watching this anime and find enough things that have semantic value.It was only when I watched YNS for the second time that I was able to establish the whole picture and almost completely analyze the story.I do not judge by myself, but I really think that it is worth watching it at least 2 times.Because the first time you only observe the development of events, noting the main points. And the second time you watch, knowing how events develop, you notice not very noticeable details and the rest that you did not notice for the first time. It probably applies to any dynamic anime.I think that the problem associated with the dynamic development of events is far from new for anime. Especially for those whose primary source is a VN.This is already understandable because organizing all the timelines without cutting anything is impossible.Therefore, I think that this drawback should be worth it not more than 2 points.The authors had to choose all the timelines or the central one, but in greater detail. Both have their positive sides But I suppose that if only the timeline of Sora and Haru was organized, then the anime would not be so underestimated because that it would be much easier to analyze it and those who were not going to watch it seriously could significantly change their position during the viewing process to a much greater probability.That's all I wanted to say for those who have not watched anime and have not read the VN,manga. 5.Music and background The music is just perfect for this anime. It's mainly piano and violin. A lot of music from this anime makes you feel sad and lonely. Which is great for making anime even more dramatic. But also when listening to it, there is a feeling of beauty. In other words, such a state of being in which you expect or imagine something beautiful. To find out if the music is correctly selected for the moment, you need to find out how the author wants people to feel when watching this moment. And if, when listening to one music, the feelings that the author wanted to evoke arise, then the music is selected correctly. And the more the music evokes feelings, the better it is matched. In this case, we can simply rely on statistics to confirm this. Even those who hate this anime generally rate music highly.In creating a love story, it is incredibly important to choose the right music because it reproduces just an incredible amount of human feelings.As for the background images, they are great for this anime. They bring their own symbolism. So let's say if you divide the loneliness into two, then these two should be in a place where there is no one. This place really looks like a place where there is almost no one. Of course people live here. but most of the time it is so quiet and calm that no one seems to live here. Also, various landscapes add romance.Even the usual open sky that often appears in the anime refers us to the name of the anime itself, because Sora is translated from Japanese as sky.It can be argued that the authors perfectly chose the scene of events and the music.In fact, the music and background are appreciated as far as I can see. My goal is to sort out popular moments that are not appreciated. But that was something else that was important to tell and can be done without spoilers. 6.Other timelines and where to start your acquaintance with this story. Other timelines are worth your attention, but they are slightly shorter than Sora's timeline. If Sora's timeline consists of 5 episodes of about 20 minutes each without OP and ED, in other words, it will last about 1 hour and 40 minutes. The rest of the timelines are one episode shorter than Sora's timeline. As I said, these timelines are noteworthy, the only thing to know is that they are not real for this story (For many obvious reasons, it is clear that the real timeline is Sora's timeline) and I'm not going to discuss other timelines because my goal is to discuss Sora's timeline, because this timeline has the most hate.It's better to start acquaintance with this story with anime.In anime, they skillfully cut off moments from the VN so that, despite the length of the timelines, they turned out to be worthy. In addition, the musical accompaniment and color pictures create a much stronger atmosphere than the manga. After watching the anime, it is better to read the VN.The VN is incredibly good in that it shows those moments that are not in the anime, but which can be reached by analyzing the anime(Such as Sora and Haru's past before moving to their old place, Sora's decision, Sora's thoughts when she was in the hospital, and etc.).But there are also very few things in VN that cannot be gleaned from anime through analysis.For example the fact that Akira played a role in Sora's timeline, more specifically, she helped a little Sora and Haru develop their relationship. In this VN, the plot is really detailed and it is much easier to notice the development of the characters than in the anime.Also in the VN, Haru and Sora have a lot more romantic moments that are cut from the anime.This all is also confirmed by how people evaluate this VN.If you do not like hentai scenes, then you can just skip them like some people do. The manga is quite short and contains some scenes from the visual novel. However, these scenes are few and the manga turns out to be almost as dynamic as anime, so I recommend reading the manga as a last resort. |
Dec 29, 2021 3:22 AM
#2
For those who watched anime 7.How Sora's love for Haru and Haru's love for Sora formed Do not think that it is impossible to explain the actions of people who love with someone. This can be done if we know how love affects people. And also what feelings it causes. When this usually happens and etc. This is all the knowledge I'm going to used to explain that Haru and Sora's actions and behaviors are reasonable and make sense for lovers.In this chapter, I will analyze how Sora's love for Haru and Haru for Sora came about. But this is not all. I will still analyze and explain the actions of the characters that may not be clear to someone. I will also analyze how the love between the characters grows. I will analyze the reason for the growth of love between the characters. And in general, gradually analyzing and explaining the chain of moments by which the characters come to confession and etc.I will not analyze the story in the order in which the events of the anime unfold, because the elements needed to create the whole picture are scattered in no particular order.My order of analysis will be dictated by the importance of the points in anime being considered. First you need to find out why the twins decided to move to the old place (this is what happened before the events of the anime) and why Haru decided to move with relatives in episode 12.Let's start with the fact that Sora and Haru lost their parents. And this is not a very good situation for them. They decided to move to a new place. Or rather, Haru decided so.Sora couldn't decide on her own because she relies on Haru all the time.In addition, even in the description for the anime, it was mentioned that Haru decided to take responsibility for Sora. The person who takes responsibility usually makes decisions for those people who are under the responsibility of this person. These two facts indicate that it was Haru who made the choice.Now you need to understand why he decided that. This can be understood from the message that Haru received In episode 12, we are shown how Haru contacted a relative who is ready to help them. In the message that Haru receives from a relative, it is written that the sender who is one of Haru's relatives informs Haru about a conversation with other relatives. Or rather, one of Haru's relatives says that he has agreed with another relative to help them.Why, having relatives ready to help, Haru decided to sell the property left by the parents and move to a much worse place to live, albeit familiar from childhood? After all, if relatives are ready to help even now, when they already live alone, then on the day of the death of the twins' parents, they should be even more ready.Now we can conclude that Haru refused the help of relatives and moved to old place. First, let's understand that he refused the help of relatives because of Sora. This becomes clear from episode 12 when Haru informs Sora that relatives are ready to shelter them and encourages Sora to agree. But we are shown how Sora goes berserk Sora is a character who has no real friends and she is in love with Haru. And as she herself says that she does not attach importance to others,she just wants to be with Haru.Analyzing Sora's personality, we come to the conclusion that her only desire will be destroyed by going to relatives that Haru proposed.In addition, Haru openly says that the relatives are ready to accept each of the twins, and then offers to leave.This means that they will shelter twins,but with one condition.They are going to separate them.That is why in the message that Haru received, one relative agreed with another relative to help them. Apparently, it is very unprofitable for each relative if one person takes two twins at once. That is why it will be economically profitable for both relatives to take one twin for themselves. Now we understand that Haru agreed to the proposal to separate the twins in episode 12.Now we can say with confidence that Haru, until the moment in episode 12, simply refused the help of relatives. Haru in episode 12 agrees to the relatives' proposal. Certainly there is a problem with money, but the main problem is related to Sora. More precisely, Haru sees the relationship with Sora as wrong and that their relationship causes many problems for both.Lack of money cannot be the main reason, because if that was the main reason, then Haru asked for the help of relatives earlier.In addition he agrees a day after trying to convince Sora to end the relationship and not knowing what to do with the large number of problems he has because of his love for Sora.It should now be clear that Sora is the main reason for agreement. Haru refuses the help of relatives all the time until episode 12. And at 12 episode he agrees only to stop those love relationships that he considers wrong. In other words, he agrees because of Sora. Maybe after his parents died, he decided to move to the old place, too, because of Sora?Here I really want to answer yes. But we have not yet proven this. For this we need to see why Haru decided to go to the old place, taking into account what we already know.Now let's move on to the question of what is the reason for the decision to move to the old place, knowing that relatives offer help to twins with the condition of their separation.First, let's remember the conversation between Haru and Nao in Episode 12, where Haru says that he feels a responsibility to protect Sora, in other words, he feels a responsibility to take care of her.Next, let's move on to the question itself. After the death of his parents, Haru was faced with a choice to ask relatives for help or move to an old place where, by a lucky coincidence, they have the house of their deceased grandfather.Here Haru did what most of the brothers would not do. Anyone would understand that refusing to help relatives entails serious problems. The main problem here is related to money. Very few people could earn money and study well. Another problem looks like small, but she has a place to be. Sora has poor health and therefore it is desirable for her to always have a person who is next to her. After all, something serious can happen to her at any time. Haru cannot always be with Sora, it is desirable to have a third person who will live with them. And the relatives probably have their own families in which there will be enough people to report something urgent. The problem is not so serious because Haru can call Sora at any time and Sora herself knows how to use medications. Not to mention the fact that her health to have become stronger than in childhood what can be found from Haru's conversation with a neighbor in episode However, Sora is not desirable to have a job because she is in poor health and Haru is not desirable to have a busy job because at any moment he may need to interrupt his work process (which is not to the liking of many employers) to return home and take care of his sister.It is likely that after school they probably will not have much time to work in the simplest job.Haru understood perfectly what problems would arise if he refused to help his relatives. If Haru just wanted to take care of Sora, then the best option would be was to hand her over to her relatives where she would be safe and her relatives would take care of her. They would also be able to meet later.We are perfectly shown how Sora is afraid of being left without Haru. So when such a moment came and Haru had to make a decision, Sora most likely begged Haru as best she could. She probably cried and asked Haru not to leave her alone.There are subtle differences between the forbidden love of a brother and sister and ordinary love of a brother and sister. This does not apply to sexual attraction. Brother and sister, like relatives, care for each other in difficult times. At a time when something serious arises, they usually act rationally even if something makes them separate from each other. Often they are aimed at making life better for everyone. Also, brother and sister move away from each other over time. Each of them has his own life. And they usually move away without experiencing pain. After all, this happens in every family. In forbidden love, brother and sister want to be together all the time. They usually want to take care of each other for every trifle. They tend to act more irrationally if something prevents them from being together.Haru needs to choose a better life with relatives who are able to provide and care for each twin or a life with Sora filled with serious problems. We already know that Haru will act irrationally and choose the worst.The reason for this act is forbidden love for Sora. Just because there is no other serious reason.All he wants for Sora would be accomplished by accepting the help of his relatives. If Sora was able to force him to make such a decision. Haru agreed because he could not leave Sora alone. If Sora did not influence here, then Haru had his own reasons. Such a reason can only be that he wants to be with Sora. Take care of her all the time. It doesn't matter that Sora influenced his choice or he had his own reasons. Analyzing both options, we come to the conclusion that these are signs of forbidden love. Both twins cannot let go of each other, knowing that if they accepted the help of relatives, then after each of them could become self-sufficient, they could still see each other in the future.A brother who does not feel forbidden love would very likely agree to help his relatives and consoled his sister by telling her that it was for her own good and then they will meet each other someday.In fact, we didn't have to consider this moment, because in episode 12, in a conversation with Nao, Haru reveals that he was sexually attracted to Sora even before moving to a new place. Sexual attraction is the main sign of forbidden love. Then we can conclude that Haru loved Sora even before moving to his old place He just couldn't leave her alone and wanted to be with her.Also that Haru refused the help of relatives because he loves Sora.And he decided to accept the help of relatives in episode 12 because of Sora. Haru actually loved Sora all the time, but did not understand that this love was forbidden. He thought he was doing what his brothers usually do.He takes care of his sister and does not notice the difference in his actions.He does not see the difference in his actions because ordinary love between brother and sister and forbidden love have a lot in common.Sora love Haru before moving to the old place.Her forbidden love for Haru after moving to the old place becomes clear from the moment in episode 1 where Sora sits on a chair looking at the sketchbook, gently traces her finger across the picture of Haru in the photo, and recalls the moment in her childhood when Haru kissed her for the first time, with an embarrassed expression on her face.No more proof is needed, this point clearly speaks of her sexual attraction to Haru. Sexual attraction to her brother is the main factor in forbidden love. The rest of the factors that belong to ordinary love besides sexual attraction, we will establish now, having considered her relationship with Haru before moving to her old place. More precisely, we will explain why Sora loved Haru before moving to the old place.Before that, let's take a look at Sora and Haru's first kiss.Why Haru kissed her in childhood can be understood from the conversation between Haru and Nao in Episode 12. When he says that Sora was in the hospital for a long time and when he came he saw a stranger in her. In other words, Haru liked Sora. And because they had not seen for a long time, he could not see her sister.At this time, Haru, as a child, probably did not understand why he was kissing Sora.He did it simply because he liked her. Nothing stopped him. Children usually do whatever they want without hesitation.Sora remembered the kiss.This kiss is probably not the main reason for the formation of Sora's forbidden love for his brother. Because at that time Haru and Sora were children. Children in most cases cannot fully understand what is happening.Also, we cannot say that children begin to actively experience sexual attraction.All this suggests that as a child, Sora could not awaken her sexual attraction to Haru after kissing. This kiss is more like an old memory that became really valuable to Sora after she became sexually attracted to Haru, rather than why Sora became sexually attracted to Haru.Because this memory is the only one where Haru performs any kind of sexual activity with Sora.Then it makes sense to assert that this is just her pleasant memory.Here we cannot say this with absolute certainty, but just is stronger reasons that explain the formation of love.Back to the topic.One of these reasons is Haru's concern for Sora. And the other reason is that Sora is in poor health. She was in the hospital for a long time and this was repeated periodically.The constant hospitalization also explains why Sora is afraid of loneliness.And after the death of her parents, Haru became for her the only person with whom she does not feel as lonely as with others, because in childhood she spent time with Haru or her parents. Parents died and she had no one left but Haru.And since she was often alone in the hospital, she did not have time to spend childhood with someone. Probably her parents and Haru are the only people who visited her. This conclusion follows from the fact that after losing her parents, judging by her behavior, she has very few friends. In other words, for Sora, her parents and brother Haru became one close people, after losing his parents Haru became the only close person to Sora.In Episode 12, Haru talks about Sora's secretiveness while talking to Nao. In addition, throughout the anime, we observe Sora talking to almost no one except Haru. When Ryouhei first approached Sora, she hid behind Haru's back and warily asked Haru about him.It is also likely that spending time in the hospital affected Sora's socialization.We are shown that Sora spends most of her time in her room with a laptop. Also, when arriving at the old place, one of the first things Sora asked was the internet.Also, upon arriving at the old place (1 episode), she said that she could not live without the Internet[b]All this suggests that Sora has some degree of socialization. As a result, Sora was in the hospital all the time and Haru was the only boy with whom she communicated due to her secretiveness.Haru actively took care of Sora.Due to her social problems, Haru is the only one who can help Sora not feel lonely.They also experienced many trials according to Haru's conversation with Nao in Episode 12, clearly one such trial was the death of their parents.It all strengthened the relationship between Sora and Haru(Why Sora didn't take care of Haru in the first episodes and before moving to the old place like Haru does will be explained later.).Because of these factors, love was formed between them. But we did not prove that it would be forbidden love because one factor is missing. It can be a strong love between relatives.So we need to explain where sex drive comes from.Sora's attraction to Haru; this factor raises love to the forbidden stage.It is clear that Sora feels sexual attraction towards Haru already in the first episode, but she probably began to feel it even earlier.Sora at some time began to feel sexual attraction like an ordinary girl. Because most girls under 16 know what sex is and understand many aspects associated with this concept.Plus, after Sora and Haru had sex for the first time, Sora told Haru that she had wanted this for a very long time. Well, the last factor associated with the fact that Sora is a bit antisocial character. It looks like Haru the only boy with whom she communicates.It turns out that as soon as Sora developed sexual attraction to the opposite sex, Haru became the best option. And Sora's sexual attraction, judging by the age when it usually appears, appeared before moving to the old place. Therefore, it is very likely that Sora had a sexual attraction to Haru even before moving to the old place, in other words, forbidden love for Haru.The kiss after Sora and Haru also plays a role, but after Sora has sexual desires. She realizes that these are sexual acts that Haru once performed with her. This also increases Sora's sexual attraction to Haru.So in the case of Sora and Haru.Now it is worth explaining why Sora began to feel a strong sexual attraction towards Haru like a normal boy, since siblings usually do not have strong sexual attraction towards each other. Much that has been written about Sora will also explain why Haru feels sexually attracted to Sora.Siblings grow up together. They can see each other's bodies in childhood. When you live with a person for several years, then you get used to him and find out everything interesting about this person. All this reduces the sexual attraction between brother and sister. Sora is the same long periods of time does not see Haru. After the appearance of sexual attraction in Sora, love acquires a change. For Sora, Haru becomes an attractive option. All the closeness that they had only increases Haru's attractiveness. Because she sees Haru from time to time, she cannot get used to him.For example, I will say this. One time Haru comes and Sora sees a big change in Haru's appearance. Then the second time Haru comes and again Sora sees how Haru's body changes.They did not have the experience that siblings usually have.Therefore, Sora and Haru are sexually attracted to each other.However, in Sora's case, the situation is a little more complicated. The reason for the emergence of sexual attraction to Haru could not only be the fact that they did not see each other for long periods of time, but perhaps her problem related to socialization and this fact together. At least her problem with socialization definitely increased his sexual attraction to Haru. As can be seen from the erotic scenes, Sora's sexual attraction to Haru is very high.As a result for the fact that there is already a high intimacy between Sora and Haru, because they have not seen each other for a long time, and also because Haru is the only boy with whom she communicates, Sora begins to experience a strong sexual attraction to Haru.Haru is also sexually attracted due to the fact that he often does not see Sora for a long time.Now that Sora has a strong sexual attraction to Haru, we can say that forbidden love appears. Now we have established that Sora loves Haru, but not as a sister, and that this love appeared even before they moved to their old place.The only difference between Sora's love for Haru and Haru for Sora is that Sora understood that she loves Haru, while Haru did not understand that he did not love her like a sister until episode 10.Now let's talk about the important moment when Haru realizes that she loves Sora not like her sister.All this time he thought that taking care of her like his sister.Only in episode 10 does he dream about how he meets Sora, who is discharged from the hospital. She turns from a child into a sixteen-year-old girl on Haru's eyes and kisses Haru who is in the child's body.Then he recalls the moment where Sora asks him if he wanted to touch her chest when he took measurements for her school uniform. Haru of course answers negatively, but the main thing is that he is embarrassed and not at all disgusted.This means that he feels sexually attracted to Sora, but it never goes far because he tries not to notice it.He then tries to calm down by forbidding himself to think of Sora as a girl because she is his sister and because he is dating Nao.That means he is not completely in control of himself.This dream is the initial moment that allows Haru to realize that he loves Sora not like a sister. Haru naturally cannot understand why he feels this way about his sister.Also in the morning, Haru starts to hang his clothes on the street. Sora comes up to him very close, so close that he violates his personal space and this is all to remove the thread from his face. Haru is frightened and falls back. This all suggests that he is afraid of letting Sora get too close. It probably seemed to him that she was going to kiss him. He was more not embarrassed, but frightened. It becomes clear that he is afraid of such a relationship.We can also see how Haru in Episode 10 responds to Ryouhei in a rude manner to stay away from Sora. It does not seem like suspicious caring for Sora, since everyone knows that Ryouhei is a pervert and the situation looks like Haru, as a loving brother, protects Sora from an unwanted friend. and so he is being complimented as a good brother, which once again makes him think about Sora.You can say that after dream, he begins understands how he feels about his sister, but tries to continue to lie to himself.Especially when he begins to think only of Sora during his dates with Nao.Also during lunch at school, he does not notice Nao preparing food for Haru because he thinks about Sora. And during a date with Nao, he buys Sora's things with such a happy face. In episode 10, after he sees that Sora began to communicate with some girl, he becomes a little happy for her, but then when he lies in bed at night and thinks that over time she will become so socialized that they move away from each other says a lot. At first at night, people somtimes think about what haunts them. Besides, Haru's face looks not happy at all when he thinks about separating from Sora. Then again, almost any brother would be glad that his sister starts making friends and that soon she will be able to handle everything alone. This moment is similar to the moment Haru decides to move to her old place.He sees Sora suffering. The more Haru spends time with Nao, the more and more Sora gets lonely.Now it's worth understanding why it is in episode 10 that Haru begins to understand what feelings he has for Sora. Starting with episode 10, Haru has to devote more and more time to Sora because Sora knows about Haru and Nao's relationship and therefore she tries to pay attention to herself as much as possible in order to slow down or stop their relationship.She lies to Haru that he promised to spend time with her and buy her a hair clip on the same day that Haru has a date with Nao.She tries to separate Nao and Haru when the three of them go somewhere. Haru adjusts to Sora's pace and Nao walks in front of the two of them.She also begins to take care of Haru to get attention. And sometimes appears half naked in front of Haru in the hope that he will cross the line, like in episode 10 where she meets Haru after a shower. Even random events such as Sora's loneliness nightmare in Episode 10 help to distance Nao from Haru and bring Haru and Sora closer.More will be said about the hair clip later.All these actions of Sora and random events help Haru to understand that he loves her not like a sister.He sees her suffering more and more from loneliness.So he begins to care for her more and more.He also fulfills Sora's various desires that are completely irrelevant. In Episode 10, while on a date with Nao, he buys Sora a hair clip and Sora's favorite food. It is clear that the brothers usually don't care so much about these little things. In addition he thinks about it directly during a date with Nao when he must devote his entire time to Nao.The last confirmation is the moment when Sora comes out after a shower and Haru is very embarrassed - in other words, that his sister's body turns him on.So, most likely, somewhere in the middle of episode 10,probably after he remembers kissing Sora for the first time he completly realizes that he loves Sora not like a sister.He wants to feel her as close as possible.He cares more for Sora than brothers should care.He wants her happy more than brother should want it.And he wants her body.These are three factors that allow Haru to understand that he loves Sora not as a sister.And this understanding comes in episode 10. He just does not say it. At the end of Episode 10, Haru finds that Sora loves him not like a brother.Why she started masturbating at this particular time is hard to say. But you can tell why she was inclined to do this in the near future.Sora feels lonely all the time. But as Haru started spending time with Nao, Sora began to feel even more lonely. During this time, she probably began to think about Haru even more. It is also probably not the first time she masturbates thinking of her brother. It's just the event when she thinks of him more than ever.And how in the future it will be clear Sora has strong libido. That is why she was inclined to such actions.Why Sora's behavior was influenced so much by her relationship with Nao will be explained later when we look at Sora's feelings and her confession to Haru after Haru and Sora moved to their old place.Let's think about why Haru started crying when he saw Sora masturbating and why Sora cried while masturbating.We know that Sora only cares about her relationship with Haru. Consequently, she cries because of that in her eyes everything goes for the worse. She feels more lonely every day and watches as the person she hates builds a relationship with Haru. We do not see how she enjoys during masturbation, but at the same time she is aroused.Propably that her masturbation was aimed at numbing the pain and loneliness that she is experiencing. Why is Haru crying? After what he saw, Haru wasn’t going to confess his feelings and didn’t know what to do, so he was crying not because he felt happy, considering it as Sora’s confession, but because he saw confirmation of a serious problem with which he didn’t know what to do.More precisely, he understands that their feelings are mutual, but he thinks that the wrongness of this love is a serious problem that cannot allow them to be together.In episode 11, an important event will take place. Sora confesses his feelings to Haru. It is also important for us to consider how love affects Haru in episode 11, which woke up back in episode 10. Besides moments from episode 10, we see Haru in episode 11 who continues to think about Sora but more. He thinks about Sora when he is waiting for Nao on a date, he makes a false smile when talking to Nao and lies to her. This is especially visible how his smile fades when he gets on the train. Then on a date with Nao, almost every thing reminds him of Sora. He realizes that he doesn't know what to do and decides to take Nao to the hotel in the hope that having sex with Nao will stop him from feeling such a feeling for his sister and let him fall in love with Nao. It turns out to be a futile attempt. He only smiles when he comes home and is with Sora. from episode 11, when Haru starts reading books about marriages in order to find information about forbidden love, it is Haru's next attempt to figure out what to do in such a situation.It should be clear that here Haru wants to accept forbidden love, but knows that this will entail a lot of problems. Therefore, it is not easy to make a decision, but time passes. Since Sora is not worried about problems not related to love for Haru, she will be the one who will show decisiveness and confesses his feelings to Haru.You also need to understand why Haru didn't want to tell Sora that they were in a relationship with Nao. He rejected it at the beginning of Episode 10 when Haru and Sora were walking home, also when Nao, Sora and Haru met the three on their way to school after Sora's loneliness nightmare. He also lied to Sora about a date with Nao that he had planned for the weekend saying that he had plans with Ryouhei. In addition, during lunch, Nao suggested that the three of us should go for the weekend, but Haru replied that it was better to go without Sora. These are all moments from episode 10 but there was a moment from episode 7 where Haru hid the phone from Sora, which was full of calls from Nao.In episode 7, when Haru hid his phone, Nao and Haru were not in a relationship. They will only start a relationship at the end of episode 7. So it’s clear that there was nothing to tell Sora. And he hid his phone because before that Sora reacted very rudely to Haru and Nao who were together in Haru's house. In other words, Haru didn't want Sora to get angry. In Episode 10, Haru says he is embarrassed to talk about her relationship to Sora. It’s clear that there’s an awkwardness about her relationship because Haru and Nao just started dating. So there’s nothing special. Haru just wanted to tell Sora about their relationship when they did. Because Sora can react negatively and cause a deterioration in the relationship between Haru and Nao. After a dream in which Sora kisses Haru as mentioned above, a lot changes. As a result, he tries not to talk about his relationship with Nao so as not to hurt Sora. such moments where she either had a nightmare, then Haru forgot to spend the weekend with her (a lie that Sora invented). He also understands how he feels about Sora that he did not notice. It turns out that some bad event happens with Sora and so Haru can't find the right moment.After Haru saw Sora masturbating, he realized that their feelings were mutual. He realized that it was not necessary to tell Sora anything about the relationship with Nao at all because it could end unpredictably in his eyes. Now consider the last moment when Haru accepts Sora's feelings. Then I understand that it makes no sense to tell Sora that he has a relationship with Nao, just because, accepting Sora's feelings, he realized that he automatically abandons Nao. However, due to the fact that Haru and Sora were absorbed in love, Haru did not inform Nao that wants to part with her, but this moment is worth talking about later. Now let's look more from Sora's perspective on Haru and Sora's relationship, the moments why she didn't confess to him earlier, why she confessed to him in Episode 11, why she started caring about Haru, etc.After we looked at the relationship from Haru's side, there is not much that needs to be explained.It is important that Sora restrains her feelings for Haru and also how Haru's relationship with Nao reflected on Sora.Let's start looking at Sora's actions from the moment of confession.In episode 11, Sora decides to step over the border. Both twins understand that crossing the border in this case is a sexual act. The question arises why now. Sora's motivation is simple. She does not want to be left alone and in her eyes the relationship between Nao and Haru is growing. Sora is in love with Haru and so she thinks that he will leave her sooner or later. In other words, Sora thinks that Nao will consume all or almost all of Haru's free time. Sora wants to be with Haru as much time as possible so it makes sense.But this is not the only reason. All the time she had to play the role of a doll in the hands of Haru. In other words, she loves him, but can not help it. After all,she understands that she is his sister and therefore restrains her feelings.Otherwise, she would not have acted as if she did not feel anything towards him, but simply confess him right away.This makes it clear more than one moment.Let's start in order.When Haru and Sora ride their bike in the first episode, Sora smiles and snuggles up to Haru after Haru invites her to go to the summer festival together. But this happy smile is not visible to Haru at all because Sora is behind him. But when Haru can see her facial expression she interacts with him almost like a stranger.In Episode 10,Sora informs Haru that they have a shopping trip planned for the weekend, which is actually the lie Sora came up with to spend time with Haru, because as soon as Sora informs Haru about her weekend plans, Haru says that doesn't remember at all.Then, after this scene, Sora is shown writing on her laptop that she lied to Haru because he became close with Nao. Haru also has a date with Nao this weekend, which Sora knows very well as she tries to keep eayes on Haru.Before this moment good shown how Sora overheard enough of Haru and Nao's conversations.This is great proof that Sora doesn't want Haru to get close with Nao.Let's also note the fact that Sora hates Nao because of the sexual intercourse that Nao had with Haru long ago. For now, let's just take it for granted, but we'll come back to that later.In episode 10 where Sora with a happy face chooses a dress in the hope of going to weekend shopping. Further from the back of Sora comes the voice of Haru who calls her name. Sora immediately turns with a happy face, changing her expression to an even happier one. Her expression at that moment said that this moment has finally come. But right then and there after a second, she makes her face as usual and responds in a calm voice, which means that she really wants to spend time with her brother, but she just holds back trying to give vent to her feelings as little as possible.At the same time, Haru informs her that she cannot cancel any plans for the weekend. Sora had hoped to go shopping with Haru this weekend, but Haru decided to move on from shopping for later.(It is useful here to mention the dynamics of the development of events. It is noticeable from what has been said, it cannot be argued that everything happened in 5-7 days).Sora responds angrily, but then adds with understanding that since it was not possible to cancel plans for the weekend, there is nothing to be done. She also asks him to let her know if he changes his mind.But Sora knows very well that he is going on a date with Nao this weekend. By doing so, she lets him go on a date without any tantrums or anger. Earlier it was proven that Sora does not want a relationship between Nao and Haru. But she understands that his sister and nothing can do about it. This is another moment where you can see that Sora is holding back his feelings for Haru.The question arises why she hides her feelings under the guise of an indifferent sister, and not a more friendly sister who constantly takes care of her brother. Two factors play a role here. Firstly, Sora is in pain, holding back her feelings, and therefore sometimes it becomes visible how she expels the accumulated feelings right in front of Haru in the form of rough treatment of him.When a person loves someone but cannot be loved by those whom he loves, then he experiences the so-called inner pain.And also Sora has poor health and problems with socialization, we are shown how Sora relies on Haru all the time because she does not know how to do something herself, or cannot because of poor health.In other words, due to the fact that poor health does not allow her to live a full life, it also causes negative emotions in her, which she sometimes spews out on her brother.Therefore, all these feelings accumulate when she is next to Haru but cannot do anything. It is more difficult for her to contain her feelings.Also, the time spent in the hospital and Haru's care for her formed Sora's not-so-good character traitt.She has become a little lazy, so she doesn't care about little things for her brother.And in order to seriously take care of your brother, you need to provide significant help, but Sora has poor health for such actions.All these factors are the reasons why Sora looks like an indifferent sister.Then Haru's relationship with Nao becomes a trigger. Here is also a fact that Sora hates Nao because of what Nao did to Haru in childhood.So she is tired of holding back her feelings. Afraid of being alone and besides giving Haru to the person she hates. That is why she should try to confess her love to Haru soon.In short, there are three main reasons: loneliness, Sora's hatred of Nao and the amount of accumulated feelings that Sora has accumulated holding them back because she is his sister.Sora also decided to go to school at the end of episode 1, but at the beginning of episode 1 she said that she would definitely not go to school. This is because Haru forgot his phone and started to be late home when he met Nao.Sora began to think that Haru left her because he did not reply to any of her messages. She also went outside and saw Nao with Haru. In the end, she decides to go to school to be closer to Haru because she does not want often to be alone at home and because she does not want Haru to get close to Nao. Someone will have a question why Sora just won't tell Haru about her feelings.Firstly, it is not always easy to tell the person you love about her feelings.Also important that She thinks that Haru will not accept her feelings because she is his sister.She sees that Haru takes care of her and nothing more. She is enough to be close to Haru so as not to feel lonely.And if Haru rejects Sora's confession, Sora realizes that then they will most likely not be able to live a normal life and Haru will begin to avoid Sora.There one simple way to try to avoid a forbidden relationship with Sora, which Sora certainly knew.Haru could easily agree to the help of relatives in order to stop Sora's attempts to accept her feelings, because he thinks it is wrong.As a result, Sora will become lonely.Sora is afraid that Haru will leave her alone and therefore is not able to confess her feelings to him. Over time, she gets used to it and it seems to her that it is enough that Haru does not leave her alone.Therefore, in order for Sora to confess her feelings, she needs an additional trigger, which is Nao.When she wakes up and sees Haru sleeping next to her, she realizes that this is one of the right moments. Also, she was pushed to this by the fact that he was so worried that he was next to her all the time and soon fell asleep. In addition, she got quite aroused when Haru rubbed her body. So she decides to confess to him. Haru could push Sora away but he did not. On the contrary, he merged in a kiss with her. It means that he accepted her feelings. Why did he do it? The answer is very simple.it's very hard to resist love. And when the person you love confesses to you, you cannot refuse it.Let's take a look at an important point separately. More specifically, the moment when Sora begins to actively take care of Haru. In Episode 11, as soon as Haru returns from his date with Nao, he finds Sora sleeping.Haru notices Sora doing a lot of housework and is surprised. Sora tells Haru that she decided to take more care of him because they are alone. Throughout the anime, we understand that Sora is quite lazy, but there is a reason for this bad trait that justifies her.She was often in the hospital, and there she was probably looked after by other people and due to her poor health she was not recommended to overexert herself in any physical actions. As a result, Sora developed a habit of being lazy. Sora rarely helped Haru with any business throughout the anime, and here she in episode 11 decides to help Haru because they are left alone? But as soon as Haru and Sora moved to their old place, they were also only two and Sora was not going to actively help and take care of Haru. Above, we found out that Sora actually restrains her feelings and plays the role of a sister who is indifferent to her brother. Haru actively begins to communicate with Nao, then Sora tries to separate Haru and Nao as often as possible and also begins to feel more lonely. Show of care is one of the elements necessary for building love. It becomes clear that the decision to help and care for Haru is more based on the fact to keep her brother. There is a factor that Sora and Haru were left alone, Sora is well aware of this, but this factor affects her decision to a much lesser extent. In other words, Sora's decision is one of the same actions where she shows herself half naked in front of Haru hoping to cross the line. Sora realizes that if she takes care of Haru, he will pay more attention to her.It is clear that Sora is trying with all her might to Haru crossed the line because she was getting worse from spending time with In Episode 11, after Sora confesses her feelings to Haru and he accepts her, they go to school and on the way to school, a happy smile appears on Haru and Sora's faces.Until then, dating Nao didn’t make him look so happy.This is another confirmation that Haru came to realize his love for Sora in episode 10.Also after Sora’s confession, Sora begins to take care about Haru even more. She gets up early and cooks for Haru. Now she does not restrain her feelings and therefore the developed role of behavior where she behaves indifferently to Haru disappeared.She experiences a lot of positive emotions, and perhaps relief and happiness are the main ones.So she just starts to take more care of Haru because it's a way of enjoying the feeling of love. We can actually see how she behaves so nice with Haru.This is another confirmation that she was restraining her feelings.Also it looks like Haru's decision to accept Sora's feelings had a positive effect on her health.After Sora and Haru confirmed their love in Episode 12, Haru continue to question whether Sora's feelings are correct.It is clear that only Haru matters to Sora. Sora behaves with Haru in front of other people as if she were his girlfriend. The person restrains his feelings, and then after recognition he is accepted and he begins to enjoy love. Love is like drugs on a person.Begins to want to enjoy love more and more. Add to this the fact that Sora is indifferent to everyone except Haru and it will become clear why Sora is openly behaving like Haru's girlfriend. Haru, despite the fact that he enjoys love, continues to actively ask himself if this is right and he also begins to fear that their relationship will be discovered due to Sora's actions.In episode 11 Kozuye tells Haru that he and Sora have become suspiciously close. Haru is able to give a plausible explanation for what is happening, but realizes that he cannot always lie.Haru tells Sora that they were found suspicious, but Sora replies that it doesn't matter. Sora says that they are special because they were able to love each other due to the fact that they often did not see each other.Why he suddenly decided to abruptly discard a large amount of moral torment that he had had since episode 10 becomes clear.Firstly, everything has already been done and they confessed to each other. Secondly, Haru is finally beginning to enjoy love and this feeling will clearly be much stronger than some kind of moral torment. As a result, Haru in episode 11 during the lesson reflects on Sora's words and decides to accept her position. At the end of the lessons, he immediately runs out of the class and together with Sora goes home, despite the fact that he understands that they will begin to be suspected more and more. They begin to sink more and more into love, and then at the next moment both were so excited that immediately upon entering the house they begin to have sex. At that moment they forget to close the door and Haru forgot his phone in class. It can be seen that they got very carried away after Haru took Sora's position. Even if the door was closed, Nao and Kozue could hear Sora's moans and understand what was happening.After the relationship between Haru and Sora is revealed and after talking with Kozue and Nao, Haru returns to his old thoughts.He begins to doubt Sora's position. After talking with Kozue, who showed how she condemned him and after he realized that he hurt his friend Nao,he starts to feel bad.It is clear that after opening such a situation, Haru's acquaintances would have exerted quite strong pressure on him. Now, after talking with Kozue and Nao, he realizes that their relationship has already brought enough problems and in the future will probably bring even more. Haru pounces on Sora kissing her in episode 12 for a reason. He tries to use sex as something to help him escape from problems(This attempt to avoid problems is similar to the one Haru used at the hotel with Nao.),but he does not succeed and he starts crying probably because he realizes that he will have to break up sooner or later. He asks Sora to end this relationship. Sora is surprised that Haru is still tormented by moral principles when they have already crossed the line. Haru takes a different position to get rid of a huge number of problems and therefore ending such a relationship with Sora.It seems that after accepting Sora's position in episode 11, he does not consider such a relationship completely wrong, but he is still cared for by the opinions of others. He does not want to live separately from society and the problem with money is beginning to manifest itself more actively. At the same time, Sora herself says that she understands how many problems they have, but says that all these problems are much less significant than love. As a result, the next day, Haru acts rationally and agrees to the help of relatives.Sora realizes that she will be left alone, even before that she really did not want to be separated. And now that she has come so far, she has experienced many pleasant feelings, separation will be an incredibly strong blow for her. She does not want this, but she cannot do anything about it. At the same time, when Haru and Sora are sleeping together, she is not angry with Haru and before leaving the house she says with a smile on her face that she loves him. Sora, in despair, decides to believe in the legend about the lake that Akira told about. If the legend is true, then Sora will not lose anything, but simply be reborn and get a second chance. And if it is not true, then she will die just like that. For Sora, dying is like parting with Haru. So it is better to try the option with the legend because Sora does not lose anything.So if you think about the suicide attempt that Sora made is not just a completely desperate and irrational act. After when Haru wakes up and does not find Sora anywhere, he starts looking for her and then he was lucky that he remembered about the lake. After Sora saved Haru, he again changes his views.This time, he decides, like Sora, to ignore what others are saying. It is clear that the fear of losing a loved one for Haru was more than fear of all his problems together. This fear caused Haru to change her mind.People who are in love are afraid of losing the person they love. And so afraid that they are ready to leave everything else.He realized it was a mistake to reject her after revealing their relationship. That is why Haru leaves all the problems and doubts associated with the correctness of his love.This is more like what Haru himself said. He was afraid of the relationship that was going on between them, because he decided to abandon the relationship with Sora and accept the help of relatives due to the fact that he was afraid of relations with Sora. After Sora disappeared, he realized that he was most afraid of losing Sora.[b] Fear of death Sora made his love for Sora fully accepted.Haru, like Sora, decided to put love above all problems.[b]Of course, Sora did not mind.They leave the old place. More precisely, they go to a friend of their parents. Here we have little information to understand what will happen next. After Haru fully accepted his love for Sora, he did not care about the attitude of other people to his relationship with Sora. So the only one They still have a problem with money. They go to a friend of their parents for a reason. The reason should only be a problem with money, because there are no other reasons. Probably, a friend of their parents is ready to share money or shelter both of them. How Sora and Haru will live in the future can be assumed in different ways. We are shown how they overcame the main problems. Haru and Sora will now do everything possible to be together and probably the problem with money will not be so serious. True, during life there are many random events and therefore Nao says that Haru There are many trials ahead, and in the end, it all ends with Haru and Sora starting a new life in which they try to be as happy as possible. Now let's look at the moments more related to Nao. Sora hates Nao. This is what a large number of moments tell us. In Episode 1, Sora has an angry expression when she sees the house where Nao lives and when Sora goes outside noticing Nao and Haru. In Episode 7, she abruptly closes the door in front of Haru and Sora. It is also best understood at the end of Episode 7, when Sora writes on her laptop that she hates Nao.Now let's find out why Sora hates Nao. In Episode 12, Nao reveals to Haru that Sora saw Nao having sex with Haru. From what we saw about Nao's past, it becomes clear that her parents were constantly fighting and she decided to relieve stress by using sex. Nao did not rape Haru, it was a common coercion on the part of Nao. When Sora grew up she realized that Nao had taught Haru about sexual things. This is a bad act for any person. Also, after Sora fell in love with Haru, she realized that his loved one had sex with Nao before.Therefore, she began to judge Nao even more.Sora probably thought that Haru should do this for the first time with the person she loves, and not just with the one who wanted to get rid of the stress as she saw. In short, Nao's bad deed and love for Haru play a role here.Now let's figure out why Haru and Nao began to build a relationship. As you can see from the expressions on Haru's face in Episode 7, he was not going to build a relationship with Nao, but his friends arranged a meeting. Haru is a very kind and responsible person. Therefore, it would be strange if he did not came to the meeting, and also he probably would like to learn how to swim. As a result, during the meeting, Nao said that she felt guilty for what she had done in the past. Haru replies that she does not hold any evil and all this is left in the past. Talking about Nao and Haru's childhood creates an atmosphere between them that pushes Haru to continue the relationship with Nao. Nao is an old friend of Haru and they spent a lot of time together, so it is not difficult for them to try to start building a relationship. To summarize, Sora has a forbidden love for Haru at the very beginning of the anime,but restrains his feelings and cannot confess to Haru. Haru also has a forbidden love for Sora, but thinks he loves her like a sister. Therefore, their current relationship is in hibernation. To awaken their true relationship, they need something else. Nao acts as such an element here. Because of Nao, Sora begins to show signs of love for Haru more actively. Sora's actions further help Haru understand that he has a forbidden love for Sora and as a result Sora confesses Haru in love. It seems that Sora and Haru have now awakened their real relationship and everything should end. But Haru cares about what other people say, and Haru has a lot of problems. So Haru is the weak element in this loving couple,their love can be destroyed because of the wrong decisions that Haru makes.Haru makes a mistake, in other words, decides to part with Sora. But the fear of losing Sora made him throw it off all doubts about their love.This is not the easiest love construction, but it is not the most difficult either.It’s not just a guy or a girl who is afraid to confess to each other or don’t want to accept the fact that they love someone. It’s more difficult and there are a number of reasons for each act. We see how the relationship develops and approaches the designated point. There are reasons for the development of relationships and these reasons make sense.If you look at how the love line was formed and how it developed, you can say that it was done great. |
Dec 29, 2021 3:24 AM
#3
8.Drama To begin with, Sora and Haru have lost their parents and are going to live alone, which is already a very bad situation for a love story, when most families have at least one parent.In Episode 1, although Haru happily tells Sora how he met his classmates, after she is about to end the conversation, he adds that they are now alone and must rely on themselves. In other words, Haru is trying to start a new life.It is assumed that when Haru starts dating Nao, and looking at Sora's condition, the viewer begins to feel bad for Sora.After Haru realizes that he has a forbidden love for Sora, the viewer begins feel bad for his situation.After Sora confesses to Haru, the viewer does not stop worrying about them.Because the past problems have not gone away and new ones have been added. Kozue, who begins to suspect that Sora and Haru have become very close and Haru himself begins to doubt the correctness of his relationship with Sora, all this only hints to the viewer that sooner or later everything will be revealed and will lead Sora and Haru to a bad ending.This is especially evident when Sora disappears in order to commit suicide.But Sora and Haru had to separate from society and be left alone, which refers to the title of the show.It is good that they can be together, but it is bad that they cannot see friends and actively communicate with other people, despite the fact that most friends have accepted their relationship.As a result, we can say that the situation is gradually worsening. Haru and Sora have more problems, one of which is their relationship. It is impossible to solve problems without hurting anyone in their situation, and as the plot progresses, the situation for Haru and Sora gets worse and worse. Exactly it creates drama. To create drama you don’t have to create a terrible ending.Simple enough construction. Events start with a bad situation and get worse all the time.In this show, the drama is good, but since most of the past events that happened to the characters and some romantic moments are cut, it is more difficult for them to feel bad for characters because first you need to understand what happened in some moments of this show that hidden. 9.Social problem First you need to understand why incest is condemned or prohibited. Society condemns incest from the point of view of morality, in fact, here the moral point of view is equivalent to the religious one. In other words, if you approach the issue rationally and try to explain why incest is condemned from a moral point of view, it is tantamount to trying to explain why there is God. Therefore, morality in this case is a very weak argument. Itcest is banned by some states due to genetic problems, more precisely because it will be difficult to control such a relationship.Genetic problems there are very different and someone can have a child, and someone - then no, and then still calculate all these generations that will change the situation even more.As a result, in addition to the fact that there are many different situations where the restrictions on incest are very different, there will be a much bigger problem with a huge number of tests to determine kinship if you try to properly control incest.It's easier to just prohibit such a relationship. As previously stated, Sora and Haru were separated from each other for a long time and therefore they do not have the kind of life experience that siblings usually get. In other words, Sora was right that they were special since they had not seen each other for a long time. This justifies their relationship more from a moral point of view,in other words, they did not initially have plans to enter into a sexual relationship, they just spent time with each other and eventually fell in love with each other as ordinary people because of the reason why they did not see each other(Not only for this reason, but it is one of the main reasons).By all this, the author is trying to say that Sora and Haru have the same pure love as other unrelated people, but they have the same blood.In Episode 12, Kozue and Nao discover Sora and Haru's real relationship. Nao reacted to their relationship with understanding, and Kozue began to despise Haru and condemn their relationship. Nao and Kozue in this case symbolize two parts of society, each of which perceives such a relationship differently .One of which treats with understanding incest, and the other strongly condemns.In the end, Nao says that when you love someone there is nothing you can do about it. She seems to understand the relationship between Haru and Sora very well. As you can see from Chapter 6, Sora and Haru did not love each other because of perverse desires. Judging by all the information what was found through analysis, it becomes clear that Sora and Haru should not be judged by society. But people in society do not know how love was formed between Sora and Haru and, as a result, do not know why their love is justified. The author wanted to say that you cannot blindly condemn everyone who commits incest.In other words, there may be cases when a love couple is not at all to blame for what happened between them, two people fell in love with each other.Of course, there are those people who intentionally commit incest for unjustified reasons, but one of the author's goals was to show that you cannot blindly condemn people based only on morality. 10.Romantic moments As I said in Chapter 4, one of the downsides of the show is its high dynamics, the consequence of this dynamic is that there are very few romantic moments in the show. Often the characters form a connection with each other when they go on dates or help each other with some routine.Оf these activities, romantic moments arise that encourage the characters to build relationships. True, in this anime, these romantic moments are not necessary because Sora and Haru already have a very strong bond and love each other, but still, as a genre of romance, this has its own drawback which I mentioned in Chapter 4. Afterword This is all that I wanted to explain to those people who do not understand the show, but want to understand. If you have read to the end, I express my gratitude. I propose to tell about your personal experience associated with this show. Tell about what you noticed and what did not, maybe what caused the most questions or feelings. I and probably other viewers of the forum will be interested in learning about the experiences of other people who have seriously watched this show. |
Dec 29, 2021 3:37 AM
#4
| Sorry. I'm too lazy to read. Have a nice day |
Dec 29, 2021 3:38 AM
#5
| I won't read all that but yeah, YnS is the best romance anime for me |
I love Monogatari Series |
Dec 29, 2021 3:41 AM
#6
| OMG.. to all those Who read this you're legends😂😂😂 |
Dec 29, 2021 4:10 AM
#7
| I didn’t read the whole but from reading most of the part of your composition,, I totally agree with you..It is a great anime where it shows that teenagers can go to wrong path and do some unchangeable mistake if their gurdians aren’t around. I don't know what people mean when they say I they say that they hate this anime because it's incest. They are just denying the fact that incest didn’t ever happened in earth and it is wrong for the writer to portray a story like Yosuga no sora's.This anime just shows a dark truth of life...not like I'm supporting incest but it's as what the anime indicates at last episode. Some people understands the the reason why they did and some don't even try to understand the guilty and just blame them. |
Dec 29, 2021 7:57 AM
#8
| Took awhile, but I read the whole article. I mostly agree with you. People should really give this anime a chance. It deserves a higher score than what it is now. |
Dec 29, 2021 8:15 AM
#9
| That's a great article, I really enjoyed it! I appreciate you taking so much time to analyze this anime and also sharing it with us. It made appreciate this great story even more and I'm probably going to rewatch it soon. Even though I understood it more or less the first time I watched it, I didn't see the great depht this story has up until now. Unfortunately most people are not bookworms like me, so your article probably won't get the appreciation it deserves. |
Dec 29, 2021 9:03 AM
#10
| I admire you for such a long article. I don't want to quote you for obvious reasons but yeah, Yosuga no Sora is not that bad as most of "reviewers" says. For me maybe it isn't phenomenal anime but still enjoyable. |
Dec 29, 2021 10:19 AM
#11
| Fucking hell I'm not gonna read all the but sora's arc was a masterpiece Everything else was just ok |
 |
Dec 29, 2021 11:41 AM
#12
| man woke up and said f**k this, imma write a whole novel of why an incest anime with trash relationships is good. but, yes I would agree there resolve was ok, though I don't like it at all |
Dec 30, 2021 4:09 AM
#13
_User_ said: For those who watched anime 7.How Sora's love for Haru and Haru's love for Sora formed Do not think that it is impossible to explain the actions of people who love with someone. This can be done if we know how love affects people. And also what feelings it causes. When this usually happens and etc. This is all the knowledge I'm going to used to explain that Haru and Sora's actions and behaviors are reasonable and make sense for lovers.In this chapter, I will analyze how Sora's love for Haru and Haru for Sora came about. But this is not all. I will still analyze and explain the actions of the characters that may not be clear to someone. I will also analyze how the love between the characters grows. I will analyze the reason for the growth of love between the characters. And in general, gradually analyzing and explaining the chain of moments by which the characters come to confession and etc.I will not analyze the story in the order in which the events of the anime unfold, because the elements needed to create the whole picture are scattered in no particular order.My order of analysis will be dictated by the importance of the points in anime being considered. First you need to find out why the twins decided to move to the old place (this is what happened before the events of the anime) and why Haru decided to move with relatives in episode 12.Let's start with the fact that Sora and Haru lost their parents. And this is not a very good situation for them. They decided to move to a new place. Or rather, Haru decided so.Sora couldn't decide on her own because she relies on Haru all the time.In addition, even in the description for the anime, it was mentioned that Haru decided to take responsibility for Sora. The person who takes responsibility usually makes decisions for those people who are under the responsibility of this person. These two facts indicate that it was Haru who made the choice.Now you need to understand why he decided that. This can be understood from the message that Haru received In episode 12, we are shown how Haru contacted a relative who is ready to help them. In the message that Haru receives from a relative, it is written that the sender who is one of Haru's relatives informs Haru about a conversation with other relatives. Or rather, one of Haru's relatives says that he has agreed with another relative to help them.Why, having relatives ready to help, Haru decided to sell the property left by the parents and move to a much worse place to live, albeit familiar from childhood? After all, if relatives are ready to help even now, when they already live alone, then on the day of the death of the twins' parents, they should be even more ready.Now we can conclude that Haru refused the help of relatives and moved to old place. First, let's understand that he refused the help of relatives because of Sora. This becomes clear from episode 12 when Haru informs Sora that relatives are ready to shelter them and encourages Sora to agree. But we are shown how Sora goes berserk Sora is a character who has no real friends and she is in love with Haru. And as she herself says that she does not attach importance to others,she just wants to be with Haru.Analyzing Sora's personality, we come to the conclusion that her only desire will be destroyed by going to relatives that Haru proposed.In addition, Haru openly says that the relatives are ready to accept each of the twins, and then offers to leave.This means that they will shelter twins,but with one condition.They are going to separate them.That is why in the message that Haru received, one relative agreed with another relative to help them. Apparently, it is very unprofitable for each relative if one person takes two twins at once. That is why it will be economically profitable for both relatives to take one twin for themselves. Now we understand that Haru agreed to the proposal to separate the twins in episode 12.Now we can say with confidence that Haru, until the moment in episode 12, simply refused the help of relatives. Haru in episode 12 agrees to the relatives' proposal. Certainly there is a problem with money, but the main problem is related to Sora. More precisely, Haru sees the relationship with Sora as wrong and that their relationship causes many problems for both.Lack of money cannot be the main reason, because if that was the main reason, then Haru asked for the help of relatives earlier.In addition he agrees a day after trying to convince Sora to end the relationship and not knowing what to do with the large number of problems he has because of his love for Sora.It should now be clear that Sora is the main reason for agreement. Haru refuses the help of relatives all the time until episode 12. And at 12 episode he agrees only to stop those love relationships that he considers wrong. In other words, he agrees because of Sora. Maybe after his parents died, he decided to move to the old place, too, because of Sora?Here I really want to answer yes. But we have not yet proven this. For this we need to see why Haru decided to go to the old place, taking into account what we already know.Now let's move on to the question of what is the reason for the decision to move to the old place, knowing that relatives offer help to twins with the condition of their separation.First, let's remember the conversation between Haru and Nao in Episode 12, where Haru says that he feels a responsibility to protect Sora, in other words, he feels a responsibility to take care of her.Next, let's move on to the question itself. After the death of his parents, Haru was faced with a choice to ask relatives for help or move to an old place where, by a lucky coincidence, they have the house of their deceased grandfather.Here Haru did what most of the brothers would not do. Anyone would understand that refusing to help relatives entails serious problems. The main problem here is related to money. Very few people could earn money and study well. Another problem looks like small, but she has a place to be. Sora has poor health and therefore it is desirable for her to always have a person who is next to her. After all, something serious can happen to her at any time. Haru cannot always be with Sora, it is desirable to have a third person who will live with them. And the relatives probably have their own families in which there will be enough people to report something urgent. The problem is not so serious because Haru can call Sora at any time and Sora herself knows how to use medications. Not to mention the fact that her health to have become stronger than in childhood what can be found from Haru's conversation with a neighbor in episode However, Sora is not desirable to have a job because she is in poor health and Haru is not desirable to have a busy job because at any moment he may need to interrupt his work process (which is not to the liking of many employers) to return home and take care of his sister.It is likely that after school they probably will not have much time to work in the simplest job.Haru understood perfectly what problems would arise if he refused to help his relatives. If Haru just wanted to take care of Sora, then the best option would be was to hand her over to her relatives where she would be safe and her relatives would take care of her. They would also be able to meet later.We are perfectly shown how Sora is afraid of being left without Haru. So when such a moment came and Haru had to make a decision, Sora most likely begged Haru as best she could. She probably cried and asked Haru not to leave her alone.There are subtle differences between the forbidden love of a brother and sister and ordinary love of a brother and sister. This does not apply to sexual attraction. Brother and sister, like relatives, care for each other in difficult times. At a time when something serious arises, they usually act rationally even if something makes them separate from each other. Often they are aimed at making life better for everyone. Also, brother and sister move away from each other over time. Each of them has his own life. And they usually move away without experiencing pain. After all, this happens in every family. In forbidden love, brother and sister want to be together all the time. They usually want to take care of each other for every trifle. They tend to act more irrationally if something prevents them from being together.Haru needs to choose a better life with relatives who are able to provide and care for each twin or a life with Sora filled with serious problems. We already know that Haru will act irrationally and choose the worst.The reason for this act is forbidden love for Sora. Just because there is no other serious reason.All he wants for Sora would be accomplished by accepting the help of his relatives. If Sora was able to force him to make such a decision. Haru agreed because he could not leave Sora alone. If Sora did not influence here, then Haru had his own reasons. Such a reason can only be that he wants to be with Sora. Take care of her all the time. It doesn't matter that Sora influenced his choice or he had his own reasons. Analyzing both options, we come to the conclusion that these are signs of forbidden love. Both twins cannot let go of each other, knowing that if they accepted the help of relatives, then after each of them could become self-sufficient, they could still see each other in the future.A brother who does not feel forbidden love would very likely agree to help his relatives and consoled his sister by telling her that it was for her own good and then they will meet each other someday.In fact, we didn't have to consider this moment, because in episode 12, in a conversation with Nao, Haru reveals that he was sexually attracted to Sora even before moving to a new place. Sexual attraction is the main sign of forbidden love. Then we can conclude that Haru loved Sora even before moving to his old place He just couldn't leave her alone and wanted to be with her.Also that Haru refused the help of relatives because he loves Sora.And he decided to accept the help of relatives in episode 12 because of Sora. Haru actually loved Sora all the time, but did not understand that this love was forbidden. He thought he was doing what his brothers usually do.He takes care of his sister and does not notice the difference in his actions.He does not see the difference in his actions because ordinary love between brother and sister and forbidden love have a lot in common.Sora love Haru before moving to the old place.Her forbidden love for Haru after moving to the old place becomes clear from the moment in episode 1 where Sora sits on a chair looking at the sketchbook, gently traces her finger across the picture of Haru in the photo, and recalls the moment in her childhood when Haru kissed her for the first time, with an embarrassed expression on her face.No more proof is needed, this point clearly speaks of her sexual attraction to Haru. Sexual attraction to her brother is the main factor in forbidden love. The rest of the factors that belong to ordinary love besides sexual attraction, we will establish now, having considered her relationship with Haru before moving to her old place. More precisely, we will explain why Sora loved Haru before moving to the old place.Before that, let's take a look at Sora and Haru's first kiss.Why Haru kissed her in childhood can be understood from the conversation between Haru and Nao in Episode 12. When he says that Sora was in the hospital for a long time and when he came he saw a stranger in her. In other words, Haru liked Sora. And because they had not seen for a long time, he could not see her sister.At this time, Haru, as a child, probably did not understand why he was kissing Sora.He did it simply because he liked her. Nothing stopped him. Children usually do whatever they want without hesitation.Sora remembered the kiss.This kiss is probably not the main reason for the formation of Sora's forbidden love for his brother. Because at that time Haru and Sora were children. Children in most cases cannot fully understand what is happening.Also, we cannot say that children begin to actively experience sexual attraction.All this suggests that as a child, Sora could not awaken her sexual attraction to Haru after kissing. This kiss is more like an old memory that became really valuable to Sora after she became sexually attracted to Haru, rather than why Sora became sexually attracted to Haru.Because this memory is the only one where Haru performs any kind of sexual activity with Sora.Then it makes sense to assert that this is just her pleasant memory.Here we cannot say this with absolute certainty, but just is stronger reasons that explain the formation of love.Back to the topic.One of these reasons is Haru's concern for Sora. And the other reason is that Sora is in poor health. She was in the hospital for a long time and this was repeated periodically.The constant hospitalization also explains why Sora is afraid of loneliness.And after the death of her parents, Haru became for her the only person with whom she does not feel as lonely as with others, because in childhood she spent time with Haru or her parents. Parents died and she had no one left but Haru.And since she was often alone in the hospital, she did not have time to spend childhood with someone. Probably her parents and Haru are the only people who visited her. This conclusion follows from the fact that after losing her parents, judging by her behavior, she has very few friends. In other words, for Sora, her parents and brother Haru became one close people, after losing his parents Haru became the only close person to Sora.In Episode 12, Haru talks about Sora's secretiveness while talking to Nao. In addition, throughout the anime, we observe Sora talking to almost no one except Haru. When Ryouhei first approached Sora, she hid behind Haru's back and warily asked Haru about him.It is also likely that spending time in the hospital affected Sora's socialization.We are shown that Sora spends most of her time in her room with a laptop. Also, when arriving at the old place, one of the first things Sora asked was the internet.Also, upon arriving at the old place (1 episode), she said that she could not live without the Internet[b]All this suggests that Sora has some degree of socialization. As a result, Sora was in the hospital all the time and Haru was the only boy with whom she communicated due to her secretiveness.Haru actively took care of Sora.Due to her social problems, Haru is the only one who can help Sora not feel lonely.They also experienced many trials according to Haru's conversation with Nao in Episode 12, clearly one such trial was the death of their parents.It all strengthened the relationship between Sora and Haru(Why Sora didn't take care of Haru in the first episodes and before moving to the old place like Haru does will be explained later.).Because of these factors, love was formed between them. But we did not prove that it would be forbidden love because one factor is missing. It can be a strong love between relatives.So we need to explain where sex drive comes from.Sora's attraction to Haru; this factor raises love to the forbidden stage.It is clear that Sora feels sexual attraction towards Haru already in the first episode, but she probably began to feel it even earlier.Sora at some time began to feel sexual attraction like an ordinary girl. Because most girls under 16 know what sex is and understand many aspects associated with this concept.Plus, after Sora and Haru had sex for the first time, Sora told Haru that she had wanted this for a very long time. Well, the last factor associated with the fact that Sora is a bit antisocial character. It looks like Haru the only boy with whom she communicates.It turns out that as soon as Sora developed sexual attraction to the opposite sex, Haru became the best option. And Sora's sexual attraction, judging by the age when it usually appears, appeared before moving to the old place. Therefore, it is very likely that Sora had a sexual attraction to Haru even before moving to the old place, in other words, forbidden love for Haru.The kiss after Sora and Haru also plays a role, but after Sora has sexual desires. She realizes that these are sexual acts that Haru once performed with her. This also increases Sora's sexual attraction to Haru.So in the case of Sora and Haru.Now it is worth explaining why Sora began to feel a strong sexual attraction towards Haru like a normal boy, since siblings usually do not have strong sexual attraction towards each other. Much that has been written about Sora will also explain why Haru feels sexually attracted to Sora.Siblings grow up together. They can see each other's bodies in childhood. When you live with a person for several years, then you get used to him and find out everything interesting about this person. All this reduces the sexual attraction between brother and sister. Sora is the same long periods of time does not see Haru. After the appearance of sexual attraction in Sora, love acquires a change. For Sora, Haru becomes an attractive option. All the closeness that they had only increases Haru's attractiveness. Because she sees Haru from time to time, she cannot get used to him.For example, I will say this. One time Haru comes and Sora sees a big change in Haru's appearance. Then the second time Haru comes and again Sora sees how Haru's body changes.They did not have the experience that siblings usually have.Therefore, Sora and Haru are sexually attracted to each other.However, in Sora's case, the situation is a little more complicated. The reason for the emergence of sexual attraction to Haru could not only be the fact that they did not see each other for long periods of time, but perhaps her problem related to socialization and this fact together. At least her problem with socialization definitely increased his sexual attraction to Haru. As can be seen from the erotic scenes, Sora's sexual attraction to Haru is very high.As a result for the fact that there is already a high intimacy between Sora and Haru, because they have not seen each other for a long time, and also because Haru is the only boy with whom she communicates, Sora begins to experience a strong sexual attraction to Haru.Haru is also sexually attracted due to the fact that he often does not see Sora for a long time.Now that Sora has a strong sexual attraction to Haru, we can say that forbidden love appears. Now we have established that Sora loves Haru, but not as a sister, and that this love appeared even before they moved to their old place.The only difference between Sora's love for Haru and Haru for Sora is that Sora understood that she loves Haru, while Haru did not understand that he did not love her like a sister until episode 10.Now let's talk about the important moment when Haru realizes that she loves Sora not like her sister.All this time he thought that taking care of her like his sister.Only in episode 10 does he dream about how he meets Sora, who is discharged from the hospital. She turns from a child into a sixteen-year-old girl on Haru's eyes and kisses Haru who is in the child's body.Then he recalls the moment where Sora asks him if he wanted to touch her chest when he took measurements for her school uniform. Haru of course answers negatively, but the main thing is that he is embarrassed and not at all disgusted.This means that he feels sexually attracted to Sora, but it never goes far because he tries not to notice it.He then tries to calm down by forbidding himself to think of Sora as a girl because she is his sister and because he is dating Nao.That means he is not completely in control of himself.This dream is the initial moment that allows Haru to realize that he loves Sora not like a sister. Haru naturally cannot understand why he feels this way about his sister.Also in the morning, Haru starts to hang his clothes on the street. Sora comes up to him very close, so close that he violates his personal space and this is all to remove the thread from his face. Haru is frightened and falls back. This all suggests that he is afraid of letting Sora get too close. It probably seemed to him that she was going to kiss him. He was more not embarrassed, but frightened. It becomes clear that he is afraid of such a relationship.We can also see how Haru in Episode 10 responds to Ryouhei in a rude manner to stay away from Sora. It does not seem like suspicious caring for Sora, since everyone knows that Ryouhei is a pervert and the situation looks like Haru, as a loving brother, protects Sora from an unwanted friend. and so he is being complimented as a good brother, which once again makes him think about Sora.You can say that after dream, he begins understands how he feels about his sister, but tries to continue to lie to himself.Especially when he begins to think only of Sora during his dates with Nao.Also during lunch at school, he does not notice Nao preparing food for Haru because he thinks about Sora. And during a date with Nao, he buys Sora's things with such a happy face. In episode 10, after he sees that Sora began to communicate with some girl, he becomes a little happy for her, but then when he lies in bed at night and thinks that over time she will become so socialized that they move away from each other says a lot. At first at night, people somtimes think about what haunts them. Besides, Haru's face looks not happy at all when he thinks about separating from Sora. Then again, almost any brother would be glad that his sister starts making friends and that soon she will be able to handle everything alone. This moment is similar to the moment Haru decides to move to her old place.He sees Sora suffering. The more Haru spends time with Nao, the more and more Sora gets lonely.Now it's worth understanding why it is in episode 10 that Haru begins to understand what feelings he has for Sora. Starting with episode 10, Haru has to devote more and more time to Sora because Sora knows about Haru and Nao's relationship and therefore she tries to pay attention to herself as much as possible in order to slow down or stop their relationship.She lies to Haru that he promised to spend time with her and buy her a hair clip on the same day that Haru has a date with Nao.She tries to separate Nao and Haru when the three of them go somewhere. Haru adjusts to Sora's pace and Nao walks in front of the two of them.She also begins to take care of Haru to get attention. And sometimes appears half naked in front of Haru in the hope that he will cross the line, like in episode 10 where she meets Haru after a shower. Even random events such as Sora's loneliness nightmare in Episode 10 help to distance Nao from Haru and bring Haru and Sora closer.More will be said about the hair clip later.All these actions of Sora and random events help Haru to understand that he loves her not like a sister.He sees her suffering more and more from loneliness.So he begins to care for her more and more.He also fulfills Sora's various desires that are completely irrelevant. In Episode 10, while on a date with Nao, he buys Sora a hair clip and Sora's favorite food. It is clear that the brothers usually don't care so much about these little things. In addition he thinks about it directly during a date with Nao when he must devote his entire time to Nao.The last confirmation is the moment when Sora comes out after a shower and Haru is very embarrassed - in other words, that his sister's body turns him on.So, most likely, somewhere in the middle of episode 10,probably after he remembers kissing Sora for the first time he completly realizes that he loves Sora not like a sister.He wants to feel her as close as possible.He cares more for Sora than brothers should care.He wants her happy more than brother should want it.And he wants her body.These are three factors that allow Haru to understand that he loves Sora not as a sister.And this understanding comes in episode 10. He just does not say it. At the end of Episode 10, Haru finds that Sora loves him not like a brother.Why she started masturbating at this particular time is hard to say. But you can tell why she was inclined to do this in the near future.Sora feels lonely all the time. But as Haru started spending time with Nao, Sora began to feel even more lonely. During this time, she probably began to think about Haru even more. It is also probably not the first time she masturbates thinking of her brother. It's just the event when she thinks of him more than ever.And how in the future it will be clear Sora has strong libido. That is why she was inclined to such actions.Why Sora's behavior was influenced so much by her relationship with Nao will be explained later when we look at Sora's feelings and her confession to Haru after Haru and Sora moved to their old place.Let's think about why Haru started crying when he saw Sora masturbating and why Sora cried while masturbating.We know that Sora only cares about her relationship with Haru. Consequently, she cries because of that in her eyes everything goes for the worse. She feels more lonely every day and watches as the person she hates builds a relationship with Haru. We do not see how she enjoys during masturbation, but at the same time she is aroused.Propably that her masturbation was aimed at numbing the pain and loneliness that she is experiencing. Why is Haru crying? After what he saw, Haru wasn’t going to confess his feelings and didn’t know what to do, so he was crying not because he felt happy, considering it as Sora’s confession, but because he saw confirmation of a serious problem with which he didn’t know what to do.More precisely, he understands that their feelings are mutual, but he thinks that the wrongness of this love is a serious problem that cannot allow them to be together.In episode 11, an important event will take place. Sora confesses his feelings to Haru. It is also important for us to consider how love affects Haru in episode 11, which woke up back in episode 10. Besides moments from episode 10, we see Haru in episode 11 who continues to think about Sora but more. He thinks about Sora when he is waiting for Nao on a date, he makes a false smile when talking to Nao and lies to her. This is especially visible how his smile fades when he gets on the train. Then on a date with Nao, almost every thing reminds him of Sora. He realizes that he doesn't know what to do and decides to take Nao to the hotel in the hope that having sex with Nao will stop him from feeling such a feeling for his sister and let him fall in love with Nao. It turns out to be a futile attempt. He only smiles when he comes home and is with Sora. from episode 11, when Haru starts reading books about marriages in order to find information about forbidden love, it is Haru's next attempt to figure out what to do in such a situation.It should be clear that here Haru wants to accept forbidden love, but knows that this will entail a lot of problems. Therefore, it is not easy to make a decision, but time passes. Since Sora is not worried about problems not related to love for Haru, she will be the one who will show decisiveness and confesses his feelings to Haru.You also need to understand why Haru didn't want to tell Sora that they were in a relationship with Nao. He rejected it at the beginning of Episode 10 when Haru and Sora were walking home, also when Nao, Sora and Haru met the three on their way to school after Sora's loneliness nightmare. He also lied to Sora about a date with Nao that he had planned for the weekend saying that he had plans with Ryouhei. In addition, during lunch, Nao suggested that the three of us should go for the weekend, but Haru replied that it was better to go without Sora. These are all moments from episode 10 but there was a moment from episode 7 where Haru hid the phone from Sora, which was full of calls from Nao.In episode 7, when Haru hid his phone, Nao and Haru were not in a relationship. They will only start a relationship at the end of episode 7. So it’s clear that there was nothing to tell Sora. And he hid his phone because before that Sora reacted very rudely to Haru and Nao who were together in Haru's house. In other words, Haru didn't want Sora to get angry. In Episode 10, Haru says he is embarrassed to talk about her relationship to Sora. It’s clear that there’s an awkwardness about her relationship because Haru and Nao just started dating. So there’s nothing special. Haru just wanted to tell Sora about their relationship when they did. Because Sora can react negatively and cause a deterioration in the relationship between Haru and Nao. After a dream in which Sora kisses Haru as mentioned above, a lot changes. As a result, he tries not to talk about his relationship with Nao so as not to hurt Sora. such moments where she either had a nightmare, then Haru forgot to spend the weekend with her (a lie that Sora invented). He also understands how he feels about Sora that he did not notice. It turns out that some bad event happens with Sora and so Haru can't find the right moment.After Haru saw Sora masturbating, he realized that their feelings were mutual. He realized that it was not necessary to tell Sora anything about the relationship with Nao at all because it could end unpredictably in his eyes. Now consider the last moment when Haru accepts Sora's feelings. Then I understand that it makes no sense to tell Sora that he has a relationship with Nao, just because, accepting Sora's feelings, he realized that he automatically abandons Nao. However, due to the fact that Haru and Sora were absorbed in love, Haru did not inform Nao that wants to part with her, but this moment is worth talking about later. Now let's look more from Sora's perspective on Haru and Sora's relationship, the moments why she didn't confess to him earlier, why she confessed to him in Episode 11, why she started caring about Haru, etc.After we looked at the relationship from Haru's side, there is not much that needs to be explained.It is important that Sora restrains her feelings for Haru and also how Haru's relationship with Nao reflected on Sora.Let's start looking at Sora's actions from the moment of confession.In episode 11, Sora decides to step over the border. Both twins understand that crossing the border in this case is a sexual act. The question arises why now. Sora's motivation is simple. She does not want to be left alone and in her eyes the relationship between Nao and Haru is growing. Sora is in love with Haru and so she thinks that he will leave her sooner or later. In other words, Sora thinks that Nao will consume all or almost all of Haru's free time. Sora wants to be with Haru as much time as possible so it makes sense.But this is not the only reason. All the time she had to play the role of a doll in the hands of Haru. In other words, she loves him, but can not help it. After all,she understands that she is his sister and therefore restrains her feelings.Otherwise, she would not have acted as if she did not feel anything towards him, but simply confess him right away.This makes it clear more than one moment.Let's start in order.When Haru and Sora ride their bike in the first episode, Sora smiles and snuggles up to Haru after Haru invites her to go to the summer festival together. But this happy smile is not visible to Haru at all because Sora is behind him. But when Haru can see her facial expression she interacts with him almost like a stranger.In Episode 10,Sora informs Haru that they have a shopping trip planned for the weekend, which is actually the lie Sora came up with to spend time with Haru, because as soon as Sora informs Haru about her weekend plans, Haru says that doesn't remember at all.Then, after this scene, Sora is shown writing on her laptop that she lied to Haru because he became close with Nao. Haru also has a date with Nao this weekend, which Sora knows very well as she tries to keep eayes on Haru.Before this moment good shown how Sora overheard enough of Haru and Nao's conversations.This is great proof that Sora doesn't want Haru to get close with Nao.Let's also note the fact that Sora hates Nao because of the sexual intercourse that Nao had with Haru long ago. For now, let's just take it for granted, but we'll come back to that later.In episode 10 where Sora with a happy face chooses a dress in the hope of going to weekend shopping. Further from the back of Sora comes the voice of Haru who calls her name. Sora immediately turns with a happy face, changing her expression to an even happier one. Her expression at that moment said that this moment has finally come. But right then and there after a second, she makes her face as usual and responds in a calm voice, which means that she really wants to spend time with her brother, but she just holds back trying to give vent to her feelings as little as possible.At the same time, Haru informs her that she cannot cancel any plans for the weekend. Sora had hoped to go shopping with Haru this weekend, but Haru decided to move on from shopping for later.(It is useful here to mention the dynamics of the development of events. It is noticeable from what has been said, it cannot be argued that everything happened in 5-7 days).Sora responds angrily, but then adds with understanding that since it was not possible to cancel plans for the weekend, there is nothing to be done. She also asks him to let her know if he changes his mind.But Sora knows very well that he is going on a date with Nao this weekend. By doing so, she lets him go on a date without any tantrums or anger. Earlier it was proven that Sora does not want a relationship between Nao and Haru. But she understands that his sister and nothing can do about it. This is another moment where you can see that Sora is holding back his feelings for Haru.The question arises why she hides her feelings under the guise of an indifferent sister, and not a more friendly sister who constantly takes care of her brother. Two factors play a role here. Firstly, Sora is in pain, holding back her feelings, and therefore sometimes it becomes visible how she expels the accumulated feelings right in front of Haru in the form of rough treatment of him.When a person loves someone but cannot be loved by those whom he loves, then he experiences the so-called inner pain.And also Sora has poor health and problems with socialization, we are shown how Sora relies on Haru all the time because she does not know how to do something herself, or cannot because of poor health.In other words, due to the fact that poor health does not allow her to live a full life, it also causes negative emotions in her, which she sometimes spews out on her brother.Therefore, all these feelings accumulate when she is next to Haru but cannot do anything. It is more difficult for her to contain her feelings.Also, the time spent in the hospital and Haru's care for her formed Sora's not-so-good character traitt.She has become a little lazy, so she doesn't care about little things for her brother.And in order to seriously take care of your brother, you need to provide significant help, but Sora has poor health for such actions.All these factors are the reasons why Sora looks like an indifferent sister.Then Haru's relationship with Nao becomes a trigger. Here is also a fact that Sora hates Nao because of what Nao did to Haru in childhood.So she is tired of holding back her feelings. Afraid of being alone and besides giving Haru to the person she hates. That is why she should try to confess her love to Haru soon.In short, there are three main reasons: loneliness, Sora's hatred of Nao and the amount of accumulated feelings that Sora has accumulated holding them back because she is his sister.Sora also decided to go to school at the end of episode 1, but at the beginning of episode 1 she said that she would definitely not go to school. This is because Haru forgot his phone and started to be late home when he met Nao.Sora began to think that Haru left her because he did not reply to any of her messages. She also went outside and saw Nao with Haru. In the end, she decides to go to school to be closer to Haru because she does not want often to be alone at home and because she does not want Haru to get close to Nao. Someone will have a question why Sora just won't tell Haru about her feelings.Firstly, it is not always easy to tell the person you love about her feelings.Also important that She thinks that Haru will not accept her feelings because she is his sister.She sees that Haru takes care of her and nothing more. She is enough to be close to Haru so as not to feel lonely.And if Haru rejects Sora's confession, Sora realizes that then they will most likely not be able to live a normal life and Haru will begin to avoid Sora.There one simple way to try to avoid a forbidden relationship with Sora, which Sora certainly knew.Haru could easily agree to the help of relatives in order to stop Sora's attempts to accept her feelings, because he thinks it is wrong.As a result, Sora will become lonely.Sora is afraid that Haru will leave her alone and therefore is not able to confess her feelings to him. Over time, she gets used to it and it seems to her that it is enough that Haru does not leave her alone.Therefore, in order for Sora to confess her feelings, she needs an additional trigger, which is Nao.When she wakes up and sees Haru sleeping next to her, she realizes that this is one of the right moments. Also, she was pushed to this by the fact that he was so worried that he was next to her all the time and soon fell asleep. In addition, she got quite aroused when Haru rubbed her body. So she decides to confess to him. Haru could push Sora away but he did not. On the contrary, he merged in a kiss with her. It means that he accepted her feelings. Why did he do it? The answer is very simple.it's very hard to resist love. And when the person you love confesses to you, you cannot refuse it.Let's take a look at an important point separately. More specifically, the moment when Sora begins to actively take care of Haru. In Episode 11, as soon as Haru returns from his date with Nao, he finds Sora sleeping.Haru notices Sora doing a lot of housework and is surprised. Sora tells Haru that she decided to take more care of him because they are alone. Throughout the anime, we understand that Sora is quite lazy, but there is a reason for this bad trait that justifies her.She was often in the hospital, and there she was probably looked after by other people and due to her poor health she was not recommended to overexert herself in any physical actions. As a result, Sora developed a habit of being lazy. Sora rarely helped Haru with any business throughout the anime, and here she in episode 11 decides to help Haru because they are left alone? But as soon as Haru and Sora moved to their old place, they were also only two and Sora was not going to actively help and take care of Haru. Above, we found out that Sora actually restrains her feelings and plays the role of a sister who is indifferent to her brother. Haru actively begins to communicate with Nao, then Sora tries to separate Haru and Nao as often as possible and also begins to feel more lonely. Show of care is one of the elements necessary for building love. It becomes clear that the decision to help and care for Haru is more based on the fact to keep her brother. There is a factor that Sora and Haru were left alone, Sora is well aware of this, but this factor affects her decision to a much lesser extent. In other words, Sora's decision is one of the same actions where she shows herself half naked in front of Haru hoping to cross the line. Sora realizes that if she takes care of Haru, he will pay more attention to her.It is clear that Sora is trying with all her might to Haru crossed the line because she was getting worse from spending time with In Episode 11, after Sora confesses her feelings to Haru and he accepts her, they go to school and on the way to school, a happy smile appears on Haru and Sora's faces.Until then, dating Nao didn’t make him look so happy.This is another confirmation that Haru came to realize his love for Sora in episode 10.Also after Sora’s confession, Sora begins to take care about Haru even more. She gets up early and cooks for Haru. Now she does not restrain her feelings and therefore the developed role of behavior where she behaves indifferently to Haru disappeared.She experiences a lot of positive emotions, and perhaps relief and happiness are the main ones.So she just starts to take more care of Haru because it's a way of enjoying the feeling of love. We can actually see how she behaves so nice with Haru.This is another confirmation that she was restraining her feelings.Also it looks like Haru's decision to accept Sora's feelings had a positive effect on her health.After Sora and Haru confirmed their love in Episode 12, Haru continue to question whether Sora's feelings are correct.It is clear that only Haru matters to Sora. Sora behaves with Haru in front of other people as if she were his girlfriend. The person restrains his feelings, and then after recognition he is accepted and he begins to enjoy love. Love is like drugs on a person.Begins to want to enjoy love more and more. Add to this the fact that Sora is indifferent to everyone except Haru and it will become clear why Sora is openly behaving like Haru's girlfriend. Haru, despite the fact that he enjoys love, continues to actively ask himself if this is right and he also begins to fear that their relationship will be discovered due to Sora's actions.In episode 11 Kozuye tells Haru that he and Sora have become suspiciously close. Haru is able to give a plausible explanation for what is happening, but realizes that he cannot always lie.Haru tells Sora that they were found suspicious, but Sora replies that it doesn't matter. Sora says that they are special because they were able to love each other due to the fact that they often did not see each other.Why he suddenly decided to abruptly discard a large amount of moral torment that he had had since episode 10 becomes clear.Firstly, everything has already been done and they confessed to each other. Secondly, Haru is finally beginning to enjoy love and this feeling will clearly be much stronger than some kind of moral torment. As a result, Haru in episode 11 during the lesson reflects on Sora's words and decides to accept her position. At the end of the lessons, he immediately runs out of the class and together with Sora goes home, despite the fact that he understands that they will begin to be suspected more and more. They begin to sink more and more into love, and then at the next moment both were so excited that immediately upon entering the house they begin to have sex. At that moment they forget to close the door and Haru forgot his phone in class. It can be seen that they got very carried away after Haru took Sora's position. Even if the door was closed, Nao and Kozue could hear Sora's moans and understand what was happening.After the relationship between Haru and Sora is revealed and after talking with Kozue and Nao, Haru returns to his old thoughts.He begins to doubt Sora's position. After talking with Kozue, who showed how she condemned him and after he realized that he hurt his friend Nao,he starts to feel bad.It is clear that after opening such a situation, Haru's acquaintances would have exerted quite strong pressure on him. Now, after talking with Kozue and Nao, he realizes that their relationship has already brought enough problems and in the future will probably bring even more. Haru pounces on Sora kissing her in episode 12 for a reason. He tries to use sex as something to help him escape from problems(This attempt to avoid problems is similar to the one Haru used at the hotel with Nao.),but he does not succeed and he starts crying probably because he realizes that he will have to break up sooner or later. He asks Sora to end this relationship. Sora is surprised that Haru is still tormented by moral principles when they have already crossed the line. Haru takes a different position to get rid of a huge number of problems and therefore ending such a relationship with Sora.It seems that after accepting Sora's position in episode 11, he does not consider such a relationship completely wrong, but he is still cared for by the opinions of others. He does not want to live separately from society and the problem with money is beginning to manifest itself more actively. At the same time, Sora herself says that she understands how many problems they have, but says that all these problems are much less significant than love. As a result, the next day, Haru acts rationally and agrees to the help of relatives.Sora realizes that she will be left alone, even before that she really did not want to be separated. And now that she has come so far, she has experienced many pleasant feelings, separation will be an incredibly strong blow for her. She does not want this, but she cannot do anything about it. At the same time, when Haru and Sora are sleeping together, she is not angry with Haru and before leaving the house she says with a smile on her face that she loves him. Sora, in despair, decides to believe in the legend about the lake that Akira told about. If the legend is true, then Sora will not lose anything, but simply be reborn and get a second chance. And if it is not true, then she will die just like that. For Sora, dying is like parting with Haru. So it is better to try the option with the legend because Sora does not lose anything.So if you think about the suicide attempt that Sora made is not just a completely desperate and irrational act. After when Haru wakes up and does not find Sora anywhere, he starts looking for her and then he was lucky that he remembered about the lake. After Sora saved Haru, he again changes his views.This time, he decides, like Sora, to ignore what others are saying. It is clear that the fear of losing a loved one for Haru was more than fear of all his problems together. This fear caused Haru to change her mind.People who are in love are afraid of losing the person they love. And so afraid that they are ready to leave everything else.He realized it was a mistake to reject her after revealing their relationship. That is why Haru leaves all the problems and doubts associated with the correctness of his love.This is more like what Haru himself said. He was afraid of the relationship that was going on between them, because he decided to abandon the relationship with Sora and accept the help of relatives due to the fact that he was afraid of relations with Sora. After Sora disappeared, he realized that he was most afraid of losing Sora.[b] Fear of death Sora made his love for Sora fully accepted.Haru, like Sora, decided to put love above all problems.[b]Of course, Sora did not mind.They leave the old place. More precisely, they go to a friend of their parents. Here we have little information to understand what will happen next. After Haru fully accepted his love for Sora, he did not care about the attitude of other people to his relationship with Sora. So the only one They still have a problem with money. They go to a friend of their parents for a reason. The reason should only be a problem with money, because there are no other reasons. Probably, a friend of their parents is ready to share money or shelter both of them. How Sora and Haru will live in the future can be assumed in different ways. We are shown how they overcame the main problems. Haru and Sora will now do everything possible to be together and probably the problem with money will not be so serious. True, during life there are many random events and therefore Nao says that Haru There are many trials ahead, and in the end, it all ends with Haru and Sora starting a new life in which they try to be as happy as possible. Now let's look at the moments more related to Nao. Sora hates Nao. This is what a large number of moments tell us. In Episode 1, Sora has an angry expression when she sees the house where Nao lives and when Sora goes outside noticing Nao and Haru. In Episode 7, she abruptly closes the door in front of Haru and Sora. It is also best understood at the end of Episode 7, when Sora writes on her laptop that she hates Nao.Now let's find out why Sora hates Nao. In Episode 12, Nao reveals to Haru that Sora saw Nao having sex with Haru. From what we saw about Nao's past, it becomes clear that her parents were constantly fighting and she decided to relieve stress by using sex. Nao did not rape Haru, it was a common coercion on the part of Nao. When Sora grew up she realized that Nao had taught Haru about sexual things. This is a bad act for any person. Also, after Sora fell in love with Haru, she realized that his loved one had sex with Nao before.Therefore, she began to judge Nao even more.Sora probably thought that Haru should do this for the first time with the person she loves, and not just with the one who wanted to get rid of the stress as she saw. In short, Nao's bad deed and love for Haru play a role here.Now let's figure out why Haru and Nao began to build a relationship. As you can see from the expressions on Haru's face in Episode 7, he was not going to build a relationship with Nao, but his friends arranged a meeting. Haru is a very kind and responsible person. Therefore, it would be strange if he did not came to the meeting, and also he probably would like to learn how to swim. As a result, during the meeting, Nao said that she felt guilty for what she had done in the past. Haru replies that she does not hold any evil and all this is left in the past. Talking about Nao and Haru's childhood creates an atmosphere between them that pushes Haru to continue the relationship with Nao. Nao is an old friend of Haru and they spent a lot of time together, so it is not difficult for them to try to start building a relationship. To summarize, Sora has a forbidden love for Haru at the very beginning of the anime,but restrains his feelings and cannot confess to Haru. Haru also has a forbidden love for Sora, but thinks he loves her like a sister. Therefore, their current relationship is in hibernation. To awaken their true relationship, they need something else. Nao acts as such an element here. Because of Nao, Sora begins to show signs of love for Haru more actively. Sora's actions further help Haru understand that he has a forbidden love for Sora and as a result Sora confesses Haru in love. It seems that Sora and Haru have now awakened their real relationship and everything should end. But Haru cares about what other people say, and Haru has a lot of problems. So Haru is the weak element in this loving couple,their love can be destroyed because of the wrong decisions that Haru makes.Haru makes a mistake, in other words, decides to part with Sora. But the fear of losing Sora made him throw it off all doubts about their love.This is not the easiest love construction, but it is not the most difficult either.It’s not just a guy or a girl who is afraid to confess to each other or don’t want to accept the fact that they love someone. It’s more difficult and there are a number of reasons for each act. We see how the relationship develops and approaches the designated point. There are reasons for the development of relationships and these reasons make sense.If you look at how the love line was formed and how it developed, you can say that it was done great. I actually read some of this and all I can say is *wow dude* |
Dec 30, 2021 6:29 AM
#14
| Its a really nice anime idc if its about incest. Plus the tracks are banger as fuccc |
Dec 30, 2021 8:16 PM
#15
| My dude just put this in a review. Might even hit review limit LMFAO |
Dec 31, 2021 9:33 AM
#16
| I cudn't read all but I think I forgot about this anime. so for me it was ok as I remember not an iota of main story of this, though I can remember some other parts from some other shows which I felt were good. So it is an Ok n avg show but not that hateful otherwise I wud hv dropped it |
Dec 31, 2021 9:35 AM
#17
| 1. I'm not reading the whole wall of text 2. Don't care, didn't like it 3. Although the protagonist is unfathomably based (like me) , the themes of this show pale in comparison to Boku No Pico (better than Evangelion). |
Jan 6, 2022 12:15 AM
#18
| Oh shit you’re serious(watch this be a bait thread) I’m not reading something longer than my english 4 honors final and to that one guy saying this is their favorite romance anime pleaseeee go touch some grass |
ChivamaruJan 6, 2022 12:23 AM
Jan 6, 2022 12:17 AM
#19
WaylonSmithers said: THE WHOLE THING???? bro please put this much effort into something elseTook awhile, but I read the whole article. I mostly agree with you. People should really give this anime a chance. It deserves a higher score than what it is now. |
Jan 6, 2022 12:19 AM
#20
MechanicalDead said: damn right it wont? Also man aside from the incest the story is not that good is it a 6/10 no but at the same time its not a 8/10 if i were to rate it ignoring that one final arc it be a 7.3/10 at bestThat's a great article, I really enjoyed it! I appreciate you taking so much time to analyze this anime and also sharing it with us. It made appreciate this great story even more and I'm probably going to rewatch it soon. Even though I understood it more or less the first time I watched it, I didn't see the great depht this story has up until now. Unfortunately most people are not bookworms like me, so your article probably won't get the appreciation it deserves. |
Jan 10, 2022 5:12 PM
#22
| My man write a 14,000 word essay to defend incest anime. |
Jan 11, 2022 10:20 AM
#23
| it probably took him more time to wrote this than watching the whole series |
Jan 25, 2022 6:14 AM
#24
| Same here it's my favourite romance anime at least the Sora arc it's far better than shit like YLIA , Angel beats and your name |
| The most dangerous irony is, people are angry with others because of their own incompetence |
Jan 25, 2022 6:15 AM
#25
| Hahaha, what the actual fuck? |
Jan 31, 2022 6:57 AM
#26
| Nice write-up. Been seeing more positive words being spoken about the series recently, which is nice to see. Cheers! |
Feb 3, 2022 7:05 PM
#27
| Man u gain my respect love u🙌 U literally prove that I'm not the one alone who love this anime far than anyone else i thought I'm alone😔 but nah the are more people like me outside and i love that😭 |
Feb 19, 2022 6:04 PM
#29
| Personally, I need 3 things to be able to enjoy an anime. Good animation and direction, good characters, and a good story. This has none of them. The animation looks cheap and generic. Take any anime from the 2000s and it'll look the same as this. Character designs are all way too similar, and Sora looks like she's 10 even though she's somehow the same age as everyone else. Also has way too much fanservice, the animators couldn't resist putting ass, boob jiggle, and underwear shots in every scene. Not to mention the sex scenes. Characters were all flat and fell into just generic character archetypes. He's the goofy one! She's the genki cheerful one! She's the childhood friend! She's the possessive little sister! She's the rich princess one! Absolutely paper-thin characterization. Also, the main character is one of the most blatant self-inserts I've ever seen. He has absolutely no personality other than wanting to protect his sister. Writing is also pretty bad. When the show starts every girl is immediately attracted to the protagonist for no reason other than he's somewhat attractive. Perfect! We don't need development if every girl already swoons for him! The pacing was janky and each route felt rushed. The writers decided to adapt 4 routes instead of just one. Great decision! That lake scene at the end was laughable. How did they get out? Who saved them? Judging by how deep they were, I guess it was an act of God! This anime has absolutely nothing to offer. The sex scenes are censored and short so you couldn't even get your rocks off to this. If you want an anime debating the morality of incest go watch Koi Kaze. If you want to watch brother sister fucking just go watch hentai. I'm not going to read the 14,000 words you wrote about an incest harem ecchi anime. I'll just let you know that anime that are actually good don't include copious amounts of godawful fanservice and certainly don't require 14,000 word explanations on why they're definitely good and respectable and definitely not ecchi incest trash. |
Feb 21, 2022 6:51 AM
#30
| I love this human and I love the YnS fandom in general because of shit like this. one of the most passionate fanbases of all time. 14,000 words on why this series is great. take it or leave it |
 |
Apr 9, 2022 4:07 AM
#33
| Can someone tell me where i can find were they were saying the rabbit was a mistake on the train because i can't find any article or interview on the net is there link to an article people are saying the rabbit is a mistake but i'm any article so can read it |
Apr 30, 2022 11:20 PM
#34
_User_ said: For those who watched anime 7.How Sora's love for Haru and Haru's love for Sora formed Do not think that it is impossible to explain the actions of people who love with someone. This can be done if we know how love affects people. And also what feelings it causes. When this usually happens and etc. This is all the knowledge I'm going to used to explain that Haru and Sora's actions and behaviors are reasonable and make sense for lovers.In this chapter, I will analyze how Sora's love for Haru and Haru for Sora came about. But this is not all. I will still analyze and explain the actions of the characters that may not be clear to someone. I will also analyze how the love between the characters grows. I will analyze the reason for the growth of love between the characters. And in general, gradually analyzing and explaining the chain of moments by which the characters come to confession and etc.I will not analyze the story in the order in which the events of the anime unfold, because the elements needed to create the whole picture are scattered in no particular order.My order of analysis will be dictated by the importance of the points in anime being considered. First you need to find out why the twins decided to move to the old place (this is what happened before the events of the anime) and why Haru decided to move with relatives in episode 12.Let's start with the fact that Sora and Haru lost their parents. And this is not a very good situation for them. They decided to move to a new place. Or rather, Haru decided so.Sora couldn't decide on her own because she relies on Haru all the time.In addition, even in the description for the anime, it was mentioned that Haru decided to take responsibility for Sora. The person who takes responsibility usually makes decisions for those people who are under the responsibility of this person. These two facts indicate that it was Haru who made the choice.Now you need to understand why he decided that. This can be understood from the message that Haru received In episode 12, we are shown how Haru contacted a relative who is ready to help them. In the message that Haru receives from a relative, it is written that the sender who is one of Haru's relatives informs Haru about a conversation with other relatives. Or rather, one of Haru's relatives says that he has agreed with another relative to help them.Why, having relatives ready to help, Haru decided to sell the property left by the parents and move to a much worse place to live, albeit familiar from childhood? After all, if relatives are ready to help even now, when they already live alone, then on the day of the death of the twins' parents, they should be even more ready.Now we can conclude that Haru refused the help of relatives and moved to old place. First, let's understand that he refused the help of relatives because of Sora. This becomes clear from episode 12 when Haru informs Sora that relatives are ready to shelter them and encourages Sora to agree. But we are shown how Sora goes berserk Sora is a character who has no real friends and she is in love with Haru. And as she herself says that she does not attach importance to others,she just wants to be with Haru.Analyzing Sora's personality, we come to the conclusion that her only desire will be destroyed by going to relatives that Haru proposed.In addition, Haru openly says that the relatives are ready to accept each of the twins, and then offers to leave.This means that they will shelter twins,but with one condition.They are going to separate them.That is why in the message that Haru received, one relative agreed with another relative to help them. Apparently, it is very unprofitable for each relative if one person takes two twins at once. That is why it will be economically profitable for both relatives to take one twin for themselves. Now we understand that Haru agreed to the proposal to separate the twins in episode 12.Now we can say with confidence that Haru, until the moment in episode 12, simply refused the help of relatives. Haru in episode 12 agrees to the relatives' proposal. Certainly there is a problem with money, but the main problem is related to Sora. More precisely, Haru sees the relationship with Sora as wrong and that their relationship causes many problems for both.Lack of money cannot be the main reason, because if that was the main reason, then Haru asked for the help of relatives earlier.In addition he agrees a day after trying to convince Sora to end the relationship and not knowing what to do with the large number of problems he has because of his love for Sora.It should now be clear that Sora is the main reason for agreement. Haru refuses the help of relatives all the time until episode 12. And at 12 episode he agrees only to stop those love relationships that he considers wrong. In other words, he agrees because of Sora. Maybe after his parents died, he decided to move to the old place, too, because of Sora?Here I really want to answer yes. But we have not yet proven this. For this we need to see why Haru decided to go to the old place, taking into account what we already know.Now let's move on to the question of what is the reason for the decision to move to the old place, knowing that relatives offer help to twins with the condition of their separation.First, let's remember the conversation between Haru and Nao in Episode 12, where Haru says that he feels a responsibility to protect Sora, in other words, he feels a responsibility to take care of her.Next, let's move on to the question itself. After the death of his parents, Haru was faced with a choice to ask relatives for help or move to an old place where, by a lucky coincidence, they have the house of their deceased grandfather.Here Haru did what most of the brothers would not do. Anyone would understand that refusing to help relatives entails serious problems. The main problem here is related to money. Very few people could earn money and study well. Another problem looks like small, but she has a place to be. Sora has poor health and therefore it is desirable for her to always have a person who is next to her. After all, something serious can happen to her at any time. Haru cannot always be with Sora, it is desirable to have a third person who will live with them. And the relatives probably have their own families in which there will be enough people to report something urgent. The problem is not so serious because Haru can call Sora at any time and Sora herself knows how to use medications. Not to mention the fact that her health to have become stronger than in childhood what can be found from Haru's conversation with a neighbor in episode However, Sora is not desirable to have a job because she is in poor health and Haru is not desirable to have a busy job because at any moment he may need to interrupt his work process (which is not to the liking of many employers) to return home and take care of his sister.It is likely that after school they probably will not have much time to work in the simplest job.Haru understood perfectly what problems would arise if he refused to help his relatives. If Haru just wanted to take care of Sora, then the best option would be was to hand her over to her relatives where she would be safe and her relatives would take care of her. They would also be able to meet later.We are perfectly shown how Sora is afraid of being left without Haru. So when such a moment came and Haru had to make a decision, Sora most likely begged Haru as best she could. She probably cried and asked Haru not to leave her alone.There are subtle differences between the forbidden love of a brother and sister and ordinary love of a brother and sister. This does not apply to sexual attraction. Brother and sister, like relatives, care for each other in difficult times. At a time when something serious arises, they usually act rationally even if something makes them separate from each other. Often they are aimed at making life better for everyone. Also, brother and sister move away from each other over time. Each of them has his own life. And they usually move away without experiencing pain. After all, this happens in every family. In forbidden love, brother and sister want to be together all the time. They usually want to take care of each other for every trifle. They tend to act more irrationally if something prevents them from being together.Haru needs to choose a better life with relatives who are able to provide and care for each twin or a life with Sora filled with serious problems. We already know that Haru will act irrationally and choose the worst.The reason for this act is forbidden love for Sora. Just because there is no other serious reason.All he wants for Sora would be accomplished by accepting the help of his relatives. If Sora was able to force him to make such a decision. Haru agreed because he could not leave Sora alone. If Sora did not influence here, then Haru had his own reasons. Such a reason can only be that he wants to be with Sora. Take care of her all the time. It doesn't matter that Sora influenced his choice or he had his own reasons. Analyzing both options, we come to the conclusion that these are signs of forbidden love. Both twins cannot let go of each other, knowing that if they accepted the help of relatives, then after each of them could become self-sufficient, they could still see each other in the future.A brother who does not feel forbidden love would very likely agree to help his relatives and consoled his sister by telling her that it was for her own good and then they will meet each other someday.In fact, we didn't have to consider this moment, because in episode 12, in a conversation with Nao, Haru reveals that he was sexually attracted to Sora even before moving to a new place. Sexual attraction is the main sign of forbidden love. Then we can conclude that Haru loved Sora even before moving to his old place He just couldn't leave her alone and wanted to be with her.Also that Haru refused the help of relatives because he loves Sora.And he decided to accept the help of relatives in episode 12 because of Sora. Haru actually loved Sora all the time, but did not understand that this love was forbidden. He thought he was doing what his brothers usually do.He takes care of his sister and does not notice the difference in his actions.He does not see the difference in his actions because ordinary love between brother and sister and forbidden love have a lot in common.Sora love Haru before moving to the old place.Her forbidden love for Haru after moving to the old place becomes clear from the moment in episode 1 where Sora sits on a chair looking at the sketchbook, gently traces her finger across the picture of Haru in the photo, and recalls the moment in her childhood when Haru kissed her for the first time, with an embarrassed expression on her face.No more proof is needed, this point clearly speaks of her sexual attraction to Haru. Sexual attraction to her brother is the main factor in forbidden love. The rest of the factors that belong to ordinary love besides sexual attraction, we will establish now, having considered her relationship with Haru before moving to her old place. More precisely, we will explain why Sora loved Haru before moving to the old place.Before that, let's take a look at Sora and Haru's first kiss.Why Haru kissed her in childhood can be understood from the conversation between Haru and Nao in Episode 12. When he says that Sora was in the hospital for a long time and when he came he saw a stranger in her. In other words, Haru liked Sora. And because they had not seen for a long time, he could not see her sister.At this time, Haru, as a child, probably did not understand why he was kissing Sora.He did it simply because he liked her. Nothing stopped him. Children usually do whatever they want without hesitation.Sora remembered the kiss.This kiss is probably not the main reason for the formation of Sora's forbidden love for his brother. Because at that time Haru and Sora were children. Children in most cases cannot fully understand what is happening.Also, we cannot say that children begin to actively experience sexual attraction.All this suggests that as a child, Sora could not awaken her sexual attraction to Haru after kissing. This kiss is more like an old memory that became really valuable to Sora after she became sexually attracted to Haru, rather than why Sora became sexually attracted to Haru.Because this memory is the only one where Haru performs any kind of sexual activity with Sora.Then it makes sense to assert that this is just her pleasant memory.Here we cannot say this with absolute certainty, but just is stronger reasons that explain the formation of love.Back to the topic.One of these reasons is Haru's concern for Sora. And the other reason is that Sora is in poor health. She was in the hospital for a long time and this was repeated periodically.The constant hospitalization also explains why Sora is afraid of loneliness.And after the death of her parents, Haru became for her the only person with whom she does not feel as lonely as with others, because in childhood she spent time with Haru or her parents. Parents died and she had no one left but Haru.And since she was often alone in the hospital, she did not have time to spend childhood with someone. Probably her parents and Haru are the only people who visited her. This conclusion follows from the fact that after losing her parents, judging by her behavior, she has very few friends. In other words, for Sora, her parents and brother Haru became one close people, after losing his parents Haru became the only close person to Sora.In Episode 12, Haru talks about Sora's secretiveness while talking to Nao. In addition, throughout the anime, we observe Sora talking to almost no one except Haru. When Ryouhei first approached Sora, she hid behind Haru's back and warily asked Haru about him.It is also likely that spending time in the hospital affected Sora's socialization.We are shown that Sora spends most of her time in her room with a laptop. Also, when arriving at the old place, one of the first things Sora asked was the internet.Also, upon arriving at the old place (1 episode), she said that she could not live without the Internet[b]All this suggests that Sora has some degree of socialization. As a result, Sora was in the hospital all the time and Haru was the only boy with whom she communicated due to her secretiveness.Haru actively took care of Sora.Due to her social problems, Haru is the only one who can help Sora not feel lonely.They also experienced many trials according to Haru's conversation with Nao in Episode 12, clearly one such trial was the death of their parents.It all strengthened the relationship between Sora and Haru(Why Sora didn't take care of Haru in the first episodes and before moving to the old place like Haru does will be explained later.).Because of these factors, love was formed between them. But we did not prove that it would be forbidden love because one factor is missing. It can be a strong love between relatives.So we need to explain where sex drive comes from.Sora's attraction to Haru; this factor raises love to the forbidden stage.It is clear that Sora feels sexual attraction towards Haru already in the first episode, but she probably began to feel it even earlier.Sora at some time began to feel sexual attraction like an ordinary girl. Because most girls under 16 know what sex is and understand many aspects associated with this concept.Plus, after Sora and Haru had sex for the first time, Sora told Haru that she had wanted this for a very long time. Well, the last factor associated with the fact that Sora is a bit antisocial character. It looks like Haru the only boy with whom she communicates.It turns out that as soon as Sora developed sexual attraction to the opposite sex, Haru became the best option. And Sora's sexual attraction, judging by the age when it usually appears, appeared before moving to the old place. Therefore, it is very likely that Sora had a sexual attraction to Haru even before moving to the old place, in other words, forbidden love for Haru.The kiss after Sora and Haru also plays a role, but after Sora has sexual desires. She realizes that these are sexual acts that Haru once performed with her. This also increases Sora's sexual attraction to Haru.So in the case of Sora and Haru.Now it is worth explaining why Sora began to feel a strong sexual attraction towards Haru like a normal boy, since siblings usually do not have strong sexual attraction towards each other. Much that has been written about Sora will also explain why Haru feels sexually attracted to Sora.Siblings grow up together. They can see each other's bodies in childhood. When you live with a person for several years, then you get used to him and find out everything interesting about this person. All this reduces the sexual attraction between brother and sister. Sora is the same long periods of time does not see Haru. After the appearance of sexual attraction in Sora, love acquires a change. For Sora, Haru becomes an attractive option. All the closeness that they had only increases Haru's attractiveness. Because she sees Haru from time to time, she cannot get used to him.For example, I will say this. One time Haru comes and Sora sees a big change in Haru's appearance. Then the second time Haru comes and again Sora sees how Haru's body changes.They did not have the experience that siblings usually have.Therefore, Sora and Haru are sexually attracted to each other.However, in Sora's case, the situation is a little more complicated. The reason for the emergence of sexual attraction to Haru could not only be the fact that they did not see each other for long periods of time, but perhaps her problem related to socialization and this fact together. At least her problem with socialization definitely increased his sexual attraction to Haru. As can be seen from the erotic scenes, Sora's sexual attraction to Haru is very high.As a result for the fact that there is already a high intimacy between Sora and Haru, because they have not seen each other for a long time, and also because Haru is the only boy with whom she communicates, Sora begins to experience a strong sexual attraction to Haru.Haru is also sexually attracted due to the fact that he often does not see Sora for a long time.Now that Sora has a strong sexual attraction to Haru, we can say that forbidden love appears. Now we have established that Sora loves Haru, but not as a sister, and that this love appeared even before they moved to their old place.The only difference between Sora's love for Haru and Haru for Sora is that Sora understood that she loves Haru, while Haru did not understand that he did not love her like a sister until episode 10.Now let's talk about the important moment when Haru realizes that she loves Sora not like her sister.All this time he thought that taking care of her like his sister.Only in episode 10 does he dream about how he meets Sora, who is discharged from the hospital. She turns from a child into a sixteen-year-old girl on Haru's eyes and kisses Haru who is in the child's body.Then he recalls the moment where Sora asks him if he wanted to touch her chest when he took measurements for her school uniform. Haru of course answers negatively, but the main thing is that he is embarrassed and not at all disgusted.This means that he feels sexually attracted to Sora, but it never goes far because he tries not to notice it.He then tries to calm down by forbidding himself to think of Sora as a girl because she is his sister and because he is dating Nao.That means he is not completely in control of himself.This dream is the initial moment that allows Haru to realize that he loves Sora not like a sister. Haru naturally cannot understand why he feels this way about his sister.Also in the morning, Haru starts to hang his clothes on the street. Sora comes up to him very close, so close that he violates his personal space and this is all to remove the thread from his face. Haru is frightened and falls back. This all suggests that he is afraid of letting Sora get too close. It probably seemed to him that she was going to kiss him. He was more not embarrassed, but frightened. It becomes clear that he is afraid of such a relationship.We can also see how Haru in Episode 10 responds to Ryouhei in a rude manner to stay away from Sora. It does not seem like suspicious caring for Sora, since everyone knows that Ryouhei is a pervert and the situation looks like Haru, as a loving brother, protects Sora from an unwanted friend. and so he is being complimented as a good brother, which once again makes him think about Sora.You can say that after dream, he begins understands how he feels about his sister, but tries to continue to lie to himself.Especially when he begins to think only of Sora during his dates with Nao.Also during lunch at school, he does not notice Nao preparing food for Haru because he thinks about Sora. And during a date with Nao, he buys Sora's things with such a happy face. In episode 10, after he sees that Sora began to communicate with some girl, he becomes a little happy for her, but then when he lies in bed at night and thinks that over time she will become so socialized that they move away from each other says a lot. At first at night, people somtimes think about what haunts them. Besides, Haru's face looks not happy at all when he thinks about separating from Sora. Then again, almost any brother would be glad that his sister starts making friends and that soon she will be able to handle everything alone. This moment is similar to the moment Haru decides to move to her old place.He sees Sora suffering. The more Haru spends time with Nao, the more and more Sora gets lonely.Now it's worth understanding why it is in episode 10 that Haru begins to understand what feelings he has for Sora. Starting with episode 10, Haru has to devote more and more time to Sora because Sora knows about Haru and Nao's relationship and therefore she tries to pay attention to herself as much as possible in order to slow down or stop their relationship.She lies to Haru that he promised to spend time with her and buy her a hair clip on the same day that Haru has a date with Nao.She tries to separate Nao and Haru when the three of them go somewhere. Haru adjusts to Sora's pace and Nao walks in front of the two of them.She also begins to take care of Haru to get attention. And sometimes appears half naked in front of Haru in the hope that he will cross the line, like in episode 10 where she meets Haru after a shower. Even random events such as Sora's loneliness nightmare in Episode 10 help to distance Nao from Haru and bring Haru and Sora closer.More will be said about the hair clip later.All these actions of Sora and random events help Haru to understand that he loves her not like a sister.He sees her suffering more and more from loneliness.So he begins to care for her more and more.He also fulfills Sora's various desires that are completely irrelevant. In Episode 10, while on a date with Nao, he buys Sora a hair clip and Sora's favorite food. It is clear that the brothers usually don't care so much about these little things. In addition he thinks about it directly during a date with Nao when he must devote his entire time to Nao.The last confirmation is the moment when Sora comes out after a shower and Haru is very embarrassed - in other words, that his sister's body turns him on.So, most likely, somewhere in the middle of episode 10,probably after he remembers kissing Sora for the first time he completly realizes that he loves Sora not like a sister.He wants to feel her as close as possible.He cares more for Sora than brothers should care.He wants her happy more than brother should want it.And he wants her body.These are three factors that allow Haru to understand that he loves Sora not as a sister.And this understanding comes in episode 10. He just does not say it. At the end of Episode 10, Haru finds that Sora loves him not like a brother.Why she started masturbating at this particular time is hard to say. But you can tell why she was inclined to do this in the near future.Sora feels lonely all the time. But as Haru started spending time with Nao, Sora began to feel even more lonely. During this time, she probably began to think about Haru even more. It is also probably not the first time she masturbates thinking of her brother. It's just the event when she thinks of him more than ever.And how in the future it will be clear Sora has strong libido. That is why she was inclined to such actions.Why Sora's behavior was influenced so much by her relationship with Nao will be explained later when we look at Sora's feelings and her confession to Haru after Haru and Sora moved to their old place.Let's think about why Haru started crying when he saw Sora masturbating and why Sora cried while masturbating.We know that Sora only cares about her relationship with Haru. Consequently, she cries because of that in her eyes everything goes for the worse. She feels more lonely every day and watches as the person she hates builds a relationship with Haru. We do not see how she enjoys during masturbation, but at the same time she is aroused.Propably that her masturbation was aimed at numbing the pain and loneliness that she is experiencing. Why is Haru crying? After what he saw, Haru wasn’t going to confess his feelings and didn’t know what to do, so he was crying not because he felt happy, considering it as Sora’s confession, but because he saw confirmation of a serious problem with which he didn’t know what to do.More precisely, he understands that their feelings are mutual, but he thinks that the wrongness of this love is a serious problem that cannot allow them to be together.In episode 11, an important event will take place. Sora confesses his feelings to Haru. It is also important for us to consider how love affects Haru in episode 11, which woke up back in episode 10. Besides moments from episode 10, we see Haru in episode 11 who continues to think about Sora but more. He thinks about Sora when he is waiting for Nao on a date, he makes a false smile when talking to Nao and lies to her. This is especially visible how his smile fades when he gets on the train. Then on a date with Nao, almost every thing reminds him of Sora. He realizes that he doesn't know what to do and decides to take Nao to the hotel in the hope that having sex with Nao will stop him from feeling such a feeling for his sister and let him fall in love with Nao. It turns out to be a futile attempt. He only smiles when he comes home and is with Sora. from episode 11, when Haru starts reading books about marriages in order to find information about forbidden love, it is Haru's next attempt to figure out what to do in such a situation.It should be clear that here Haru wants to accept forbidden love, but knows that this will entail a lot of problems. Therefore, it is not easy to make a decision, but time passes. Since Sora is not worried about problems not related to love for Haru, she will be the one who will show decisiveness and confesses his feelings to Haru.You also need to understand why Haru didn't want to tell Sora that they were in a relationship with Nao. He rejected it at the beginning of Episode 10 when Haru and Sora were walking home, also when Nao, Sora and Haru met the three on their way to school after Sora's loneliness nightmare. He also lied to Sora about a date with Nao that he had planned for the weekend saying that he had plans with Ryouhei. In addition, during lunch, Nao suggested that the three of us should go for the weekend, but Haru replied that it was better to go without Sora. These are all moments from episode 10 but there was a moment from episode 7 where Haru hid the phone from Sora, which was full of calls from Nao.In episode 7, when Haru hid his phone, Nao and Haru were not in a relationship. They will only start a relationship at the end of episode 7. So it’s clear that there was nothing to tell Sora. And he hid his phone because before that Sora reacted very rudely to Haru and Nao who were together in Haru's house. In other words, Haru didn't want Sora to get angry. In Episode 10, Haru says he is embarrassed to talk about her relationship to Sora. It’s clear that there’s an awkwardness about her relationship because Haru and Nao just started dating. So there’s nothing special. Haru just wanted to tell Sora about their relationship when they did. Because Sora can react negatively and cause a deterioration in the relationship between Haru and Nao. After a dream in which Sora kisses Haru as mentioned above, a lot changes. As a result, he tries not to talk about his relationship with Nao so as not to hurt Sora. such moments where she either had a nightmare, then Haru forgot to spend the weekend with her (a lie that Sora invented). He also understands how he feels about Sora that he did not notice. It turns out that some bad event happens with Sora and so Haru can't find the right moment.After Haru saw Sora masturbating, he realized that their feelings were mutual. He realized that it was not necessary to tell Sora anything about the relationship with Nao at all because it could end unpredictably in his eyes. Now consider the last moment when Haru accepts Sora's feelings. Then I understand that it makes no sense to tell Sora that he has a relationship with Nao, just because, accepting Sora's feelings, he realized that he automatically abandons Nao. However, due to the fact that Haru and Sora were absorbed in love, Haru did not inform Nao that wants to part with her, but this moment is worth talking about later. Now let's look more from Sora's perspective on Haru and Sora's relationship, the moments why she didn't confess to him earlier, why she confessed to him in Episode 11, why she started caring about Haru, etc.After we looked at the relationship from Haru's side, there is not much that needs to be explained.It is important that Sora restrains her feelings for Haru and also how Haru's relationship with Nao reflected on Sora.Let's start looking at Sora's actions from the moment of confession.In episode 11, Sora decides to step over the border. Both twins understand that crossing the border in this case is a sexual act. The question arises why now. Sora's motivation is simple. She does not want to be left alone and in her eyes the relationship between Nao and Haru is growing. Sora is in love with Haru and so she thinks that he will leave her sooner or later. In other words, Sora thinks that Nao will consume all or almost all of Haru's free time. Sora wants to be with Haru as much time as possible so it makes sense.But this is not the only reason. All the time she had to play the role of a doll in the hands of Haru. In other words, she loves him, but can not help it. After all,she understands that she is his sister and therefore restrains her feelings.Otherwise, she would not have acted as if she did not feel anything towards him, but simply confess him right away.This makes it clear more than one moment.Let's start in order.When Haru and Sora ride their bike in the first episode, Sora smiles and snuggles up to Haru after Haru invites her to go to the summer festival together. But this happy smile is not visible to Haru at all because Sora is behind him. But when Haru can see her facial expression she interacts with him almost like a stranger.In Episode 10,Sora informs Haru that they have a shopping trip planned for the weekend, which is actually the lie Sora came up with to spend time with Haru, because as soon as Sora informs Haru about her weekend plans, Haru says that doesn't remember at all.Then, after this scene, Sora is shown writing on her laptop that she lied to Haru because he became close with Nao. Haru also has a date with Nao this weekend, which Sora knows very well as she tries to keep eayes on Haru.Before this moment good shown how Sora overheard enough of Haru and Nao's conversations.This is great proof that Sora doesn't want Haru to get close with Nao.Let's also note the fact that Sora hates Nao because of the sexual intercourse that Nao had with Haru long ago. For now, let's just take it for granted, but we'll come back to that later.In episode 10 where Sora with a happy face chooses a dress in the hope of going to weekend shopping. Further from the back of Sora comes the voice of Haru who calls her name. Sora immediately turns with a happy face, changing her expression to an even happier one. Her expression at that moment said that this moment has finally come. But right then and there after a second, she makes her face as usual and responds in a calm voice, which means that she really wants to spend time with her brother, but she just holds back trying to give vent to her feelings as little as possible.At the same time, Haru informs her that she cannot cancel any plans for the weekend. Sora had hoped to go shopping with Haru this weekend, but Haru decided to move on from shopping for later.(It is useful here to mention the dynamics of the development of events. It is noticeable from what has been said, it cannot be argued that everything happened in 5-7 days).Sora responds angrily, but then adds with understanding that since it was not possible to cancel plans for the weekend, there is nothing to be done. She also asks him to let her know if he changes his mind.But Sora knows very well that he is going on a date with Nao this weekend. By doing so, she lets him go on a date without any tantrums or anger. Earlier it was proven that Sora does not want a relationship between Nao and Haru. But she understands that his sister and nothing can do about it. This is another moment where you can see that Sora is holding back his feelings for Haru.The question arises why she hides her feelings under the guise of an indifferent sister, and not a more friendly sister who constantly takes care of her brother. Two factors play a role here. Firstly, Sora is in pain, holding back her feelings, and therefore sometimes it becomes visible how she expels the accumulated feelings right in front of Haru in the form of rough treatment of him.When a person loves someone but cannot be loved by those whom he loves, then he experiences the so-called inner pain.And also Sora has poor health and problems with socialization, we are shown how Sora relies on Haru all the time because she does not know how to do something herself, or cannot because of poor health.In other words, due to the fact that poor health does not allow her to live a full life, it also causes negative emotions in her, which she sometimes spews out on her brother.Therefore, all these feelings accumulate when she is next to Haru but cannot do anything. It is more difficult for her to contain her feelings.Also, the time spent in the hospital and Haru's care for her formed Sora's not-so-good character traitt.She has become a little lazy, so she doesn't care about little things for her brother.And in order to seriously take care of your brother, you need to provide significant help, but Sora has poor health for such actions.All these factors are the reasons why Sora looks like an indifferent sister.Then Haru's relationship with Nao becomes a trigger. Here is also a fact that Sora hates Nao because of what Nao did to Haru in childhood.So she is tired of holding back her feelings. Afraid of being alone and besides giving Haru to the person she hates. That is why she should try to confess her love to Haru soon.In short, there are three main reasons: loneliness, Sora's hatred of Nao and the amount of accumulated feelings that Sora has accumulated holding them back because she is his sister.Sora also decided to go to school at the end of episode 1, but at the beginning of episode 1 she said that she would definitely not go to school. This is because Haru forgot his phone and started to be late home when he met Nao.Sora began to think that Haru left her because he did not reply to any of her messages. She also went outside and saw Nao with Haru. In the end, she decides to go to school to be closer to Haru because she does not want often to be alone at home and because she does not want Haru to get close to Nao. Someone will have a question why Sora just won't tell Haru about her feelings.Firstly, it is not always easy to tell the person you love about her feelings.Also important that She thinks that Haru will not accept her feelings because she is his sister.She sees that Haru takes care of her and nothing more. She is enough to be close to Haru so as not to feel lonely.And if Haru rejects Sora's confession, Sora realizes that then they will most likely not be able to live a normal life and Haru will begin to avoid Sora.There one simple way to try to avoid a forbidden relationship with Sora, which Sora certainly knew.Haru could easily agree to the help of relatives in order to stop Sora's attempts to accept her feelings, because he thinks it is wrong.As a result, Sora will become lonely.Sora is afraid that Haru will leave her alone and therefore is not able to confess her feelings to him. Over time, she gets used to it and it seems to her that it is enough that Haru does not leave her alone.Therefore, in order for Sora to confess her feelings, she needs an additional trigger, which is Nao.When she wakes up and sees Haru sleeping next to her, she realizes that this is one of the right moments. Also, she was pushed to this by the fact that he was so worried that he was next to her all the time and soon fell asleep. In addition, she got quite aroused when Haru rubbed her body. So she decides to confess to him. Haru could push Sora away but he did not. On the contrary, he merged in a kiss with her. It means that he accepted her feelings. Why did he do it? The answer is very simple.it's very hard to resist love. And when the person you love confesses to you, you cannot refuse it.Let's take a look at an important point separately. More specifically, the moment when Sora begins to actively take care of Haru. In Episode 11, as soon as Haru returns from his date with Nao, he finds Sora sleeping.Haru notices Sora doing a lot of housework and is surprised. Sora tells Haru that she decided to take more care of him because they are alone. Throughout the anime, we understand that Sora is quite lazy, but there is a reason for this bad trait that justifies her.She was often in the hospital, and there she was probably looked after by other people and due to her poor health she was not recommended to overexert herself in any physical actions. As a result, Sora developed a habit of being lazy. Sora rarely helped Haru with any business throughout the anime, and here she in episode 11 decides to help Haru because they are left alone? But as soon as Haru and Sora moved to their old place, they were also only two and Sora was not going to actively help and take care of Haru. Above, we found out that Sora actually restrains her feelings and plays the role of a sister who is indifferent to her brother. Haru actively begins to communicate with Nao, then Sora tries to separate Haru and Nao as often as possible and also begins to feel more lonely. Show of care is one of the elements necessary for building love. It becomes clear that the decision to help and care for Haru is more based on the fact to keep her brother. There is a factor that Sora and Haru were left alone, Sora is well aware of this, but this factor affects her decision to a much lesser extent. In other words, Sora's decision is one of the same actions where she shows herself half naked in front of Haru hoping to cross the line. Sora realizes that if she takes care of Haru, he will pay more attention to her.It is clear that Sora is trying with all her might to Haru crossed the line because she was getting worse from spending time with In Episode 11, after Sora confesses her feelings to Haru and he accepts her, they go to school and on the way to school, a happy smile appears on Haru and Sora's faces.Until then, dating Nao didn’t make him look so happy.This is another confirmation that Haru came to realize his love for Sora in episode 10.Also after Sora’s confession, Sora begins to take care about Haru even more. She gets up early and cooks for Haru. Now she does not restrain her feelings and therefore the developed role of behavior where she behaves indifferently to Haru disappeared.She experiences a lot of positive emotions, and perhaps relief and happiness are the main ones.So she just starts to take more care of Haru because it's a way of enjoying the feeling of love. We can actually see how she behaves so nice with Haru.This is another confirmation that she was restraining her feelings.Also it looks like Haru's decision to accept Sora's feelings had a positive effect on her health.After Sora and Haru confirmed their love in Episode 12, Haru continue to question whether Sora's feelings are correct.It is clear that only Haru matters to Sora. Sora behaves with Haru in front of other people as if she were his girlfriend. The person restrains his feelings, and then after recognition he is accepted and he begins to enjoy love. Love is like drugs on a person.Begins to want to enjoy love more and more. Add to this the fact that Sora is indifferent to everyone except Haru and it will become clear why Sora is openly behaving like Haru's girlfriend. Haru, despite the fact that he enjoys love, continues to actively ask himself if this is right and he also begins to fear that their relationship will be discovered due to Sora's actions.In episode 11 Kozuye tells Haru that he and Sora have become suspiciously close. Haru is able to give a plausible explanation for what is happening, but realizes that he cannot always lie.Haru tells Sora that they were found suspicious, but Sora replies that it doesn't matter. Sora says that they are special because they were able to love each other due to the fact that they often did not see each other.Why he suddenly decided to abruptly discard a large amount of moral torment that he had had since episode 10 becomes clear.Firstly, everything has already been done and they confessed to each other. Secondly, Haru is finally beginning to enjoy love and this feeling will clearly be much stronger than some kind of moral torment. As a result, Haru in episode 11 during the lesson reflects on Sora's words and decides to accept her position. At the end of the lessons, he immediately runs out of the class and together with Sora goes home, despite the fact that he understands that they will begin to be suspected more and more. They begin to sink more and more into love, and then at the next moment both were so excited that immediately upon entering the house they begin to have sex. At that moment they forget to close the door and Haru forgot his phone in class. It can be seen that they got very carried away after Haru took Sora's position. Even if the door was closed, Nao and Kozue could hear Sora's moans and understand what was happening.After the relationship between Haru and Sora is revealed and after talking with Kozue and Nao, Haru returns to his old thoughts.He begins to doubt Sora's position. After talking with Kozue, who showed how she condemned him and after he realized that he hurt his friend Nao,he starts to feel bad.It is clear that after opening such a situation, Haru's acquaintances would have exerted quite strong pressure on him. Now, after talking with Kozue and Nao, he realizes that their relationship has already brought enough problems and in the future will probably bring even more. Haru pounces on Sora kissing her in episode 12 for a reason. He tries to use sex as something to help him escape from problems(This attempt to avoid problems is similar to the one Haru used at the hotel with Nao.),but he does not succeed and he starts crying probably because he realizes that he will have to break up sooner or later. He asks Sora to end this relationship. Sora is surprised that Haru is still tormented by moral principles when they have already crossed the line. Haru takes a different position to get rid of a huge number of problems and therefore ending such a relationship with Sora.It seems that after accepting Sora's position in episode 11, he does not consider such a relationship completely wrong, but he is still cared for by the opinions of others. He does not want to live separately from society and the problem with money is beginning to manifest itself more actively. At the same time, Sora herself says that she understands how many problems they have, but says that all these problems are much less significant than love. As a result, the next day, Haru acts rationally and agrees to the help of relatives.Sora realizes that she will be left alone, even before that she really did not want to be separated. And now that she has come so far, she has experienced many pleasant feelings, separation will be an incredibly strong blow for her. She does not want this, but she cannot do anything about it. At the same time, when Haru and Sora are sleeping together, she is not angry with Haru and before leaving the house she says with a smile on her face that she loves him. Sora, in despair, decides to believe in the legend about the lake that Akira told about. If the legend is true, then Sora will not lose anything, but simply be reborn and get a second chance. And if it is not true, then she will die just like that. For Sora, dying is like parting with Haru. So it is better to try the option with the legend because Sora does not lose anything.So if you think about the suicide attempt that Sora made is not just a completely desperate and irrational act. After when Haru wakes up and does not find Sora anywhere, he starts looking for her and then he was lucky that he remembered about the lake. After Sora saved Haru, he again changes his views.This time, he decides, like Sora, to ignore what others are saying. It is clear that the fear of losing a loved one for Haru was more than fear of all his problems together. This fear caused Haru to change her mind.People who are in love are afraid of losing the person they love. And so afraid that they are ready to leave everything else.He realized it was a mistake to reject her after revealing their relationship. That is why Haru leaves all the problems and doubts associated with the correctness of his love.This is more like what Haru himself said. He was afraid of the relationship that was going on between them, because he decided to abandon the relationship with Sora and accept the help of relatives due to the fact that he was afraid of relations with Sora. After Sora disappeared, he realized that he was most afraid of losing Sora.[b] Fear of death Sora made his love for Sora fully accepted.Haru, like Sora, decided to put love above all problems.[b]Of course, Sora did not mind.They leave the old place. More precisely, they go to a friend of their parents. Here we have little information to understand what will happen next. After Haru fully accepted his love for Sora, he did not care about the attitude of other people to his relationship with Sora. So the only one They still have a problem with money. They go to a friend of their parents for a reason. The reason should only be a problem with money, because there are no other reasons. Probably, a friend of their parents is ready to share money or shelter both of them. How Sora and Haru will live in the future can be assumed in different ways. We are shown how they overcame the main problems. Haru and Sora will now do everything possible to be together and probably the problem with money will not be so serious. True, during life there are many random events and therefore Nao says that Haru There are many trials ahead, and in the end, it all ends with Haru and Sora starting a new life in which they try to be as happy as possible. Now let's look at the moments more related to Nao. Sora hates Nao. This is what a large number of moments tell us. In Episode 1, Sora has an angry expression when she sees the house where Nao lives and when Sora goes outside noticing Nao and Haru. In Episode 7, she abruptly closes the door in front of Haru and Sora. It is also best understood at the end of Episode 7, when Sora writes on her laptop that she hates Nao.Now let's find out why Sora hates Nao. In Episode 12, Nao reveals to Haru that Sora saw Nao having sex with Haru. From what we saw about Nao's past, it becomes clear that her parents were constantly fighting and she decided to relieve stress by using sex. Nao did not rape Haru, it was a common coercion on the part of Nao. When Sora grew up she realized that Nao had taught Haru about sexual things. This is a bad act for any person. Also, after Sora fell in love with Haru, she realized that his loved one had sex with Nao before.Therefore, she began to judge Nao even more.Sora probably thought that Haru should do this for the first time with the person she loves, and not just with the one who wanted to get rid of the stress as she saw. In short, Nao's bad deed and love for Haru play a role here.Now let's figure out why Haru and Nao began to build a relationship. As you can see from the expressions on Haru's face in Episode 7, he was not going to build a relationship with Nao, but his friends arranged a meeting. Haru is a very kind and responsible person. Therefore, it would be strange if he did not came to the meeting, and also he probably would like to learn how to swim. As a result, during the meeting, Nao said that she felt guilty for what she had done in the past. Haru replies that she does not hold any evil and all this is left in the past. Talking about Nao and Haru's childhood creates an atmosphere between them that pushes Haru to continue the relationship with Nao. Nao is an old friend of Haru and they spent a lot of time together, so it is not difficult for them to try to start building a relationship. To summarize, Sora has a forbidden love for Haru at the very beginning of the anime,but restrains his feelings and cannot confess to Haru. Haru also has a forbidden love for Sora, but thinks he loves her like a sister. Therefore, their current relationship is in hibernation. To awaken their true relationship, they need something else. Nao acts as such an element here. Because of Nao, Sora begins to show signs of love for Haru more actively. Sora's actions further help Haru understand that he has a forbidden love for Sora and as a result Sora confesses Haru in love. It seems that Sora and Haru have now awakened their real relationship and everything should end. But Haru cares about what other people say, and Haru has a lot of problems. So Haru is the weak element in this loving couple,their love can be destroyed because of the wrong decisions that Haru makes.Haru makes a mistake, in other words, decides to part with Sora. But the fear of losing Sora made him throw it off all doubts about their love.This is not the easiest love construction, but it is not the most difficult either.It’s not just a guy or a girl who is afraid to confess to each other or don’t want to accept the fact that they love someone. It’s more difficult and there are a number of reasons for each act. We see how the relationship develops and approaches the designated point. There are reasons for the development of relationships and these reasons make sense.If you look at how the love line was formed and how it developed, you can say that it was done great. I'm not alone, maybe it's not wrong if I give a score 10 for this anime |
May 6, 2024 10:45 AM
#35
| Nice essay, but you could have summarized it in just 1 sentence: Yosuga no Sora is greatly underestimated because it's a serious ecchi harem with incest sex. That's why prude puritans downrated the show and I honestly couldn't care less, because it's great regardless. |
DesuMaiden said: Nobody resembles me physically because I don't even physically exist. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Yosuga no Sora Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Dunkmaru - Dec 20, 2010 |
520 |
by _anixia
»»
Jan 11, 2:56 PM |
|
» Rank each arcChainsaw_Heart - Nov 25, 2024 |
30 |
by AdisAray
»»
Dec 6, 2024 6:47 AM |
|
Poll: » Yosuga no Sora Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Yumekichi11 - Nov 29, 2010 |
200 |
by cologne_chan
»»
Dec 5, 2024 7:01 AM |
|
Poll: » Yosuga no Sora Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Baka_Inu - Nov 15, 2010 |
179 |
by cologne_chan
»»
Dec 2, 2024 2:28 PM |
|
Poll: » Yosuga no Sora Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )-Quasar - Oct 11, 2010 |
175 |
by cologne_chan
»»
Nov 25, 2024 3:41 PM |