Ace-Lace said:Himawari9 said:
Please don't bring that modern day transgender thinking into this. This anime setting is Sengoku era and this is a work from 50 years ago. This is just a simple case of girl disguising as boy existed in hundreds of anime and manga. There are many reasons for them to do that like to protect themselves, avoid being look down at a girl, easier to travel or fight etc. Ever watch Kazemakase Tsukikage Ran, the MC dressed as a man to travel across Japan and fight other villains but she still calls herself a woman.
No offense but I found that LGBT fans like to apply their way of thinking to anime and manga while it is obviously not the case. The series that have trans characters portrayed seriously are drama and slice-of-life and the theme would be about their struggles. Outside of that, trans characters usually treated as joke or a fetish since Japan has a really conservative view in this matter.
You are wrong about one thing though, Dororo dressed as boy to hide from her father's enemy who is still alive and well. Her father only killed the some random samurai. His real enemy is his second-in-command from when he was still a bandit, Itachi-no-Saigo.
Media is to be seen as the viewer intended, I won't say your wrong in that you think Dororo is a girl, but I won't say I'm wrong either it's all up to the individual.
THAT BEING SAID I am aware of the era and queer individuals have ALWAYS existed we are only more known now because it is safer, I am aware of the mundane slice of life shows (that while I appreciate them LGBTQ+ deserve some exciting shows as well as the casual) I also stated that I think that this is to stand for the 2019 version of the show, not the versions done prior or the original content.
So I will bring in my "modern" thinking into this because the people making it are from Modern times you are free to disagree with me on if Dororo is a trans boy or a cis female you have that right to interpret as you please and I won't sit here and force you to think otherwise, but I'll be damned if someone sits here and tells me I'm not ALOUD to think of a character as being part of my community.
and as for your comment saying how the "good" queer rep is done in drama and slice-of-life and anything else is a joke, we can be written in other situations to, dramas and slice of life had to START showing us at one point or another so what makes you think action/adventure shows can't do that to? your logic behind why Dororo CANT be trans is flawed at best when it comes to the current run of the show.
as for me being wrong about Dororo's parents I wasn't I said his attackers, not his enemy(this was pointed out by people saying he was hiding from his Parents' murderers), I'm aware of his second in command still being around still alive but if Dororo had intended to hide from him then why keep the name? we know it's his birth name his parents and the second-hand man himself called him as such, and you can't tell me Dororo is just a kid not smart enough to think of it because this same child changed their perceived gender for the supposed same reason in your argument.
Say what you will but until the 2019 run of the show, Dororo tells me whether the character identifies as male or female I personally will consider them a trans boy.
Now you Sir, Madam, or Neutral. I hope you have a nice day and from now on respect those opinions who differ from your own without telling them that they shouldn't have them at all.