TV Anime &#039;Nejimaki Seirei Senki: Tenkyou no Alderamin&#039; Announces Staff for Summer 2016

Offline

Apr 2013

7945

Madhouse for Alderamin? Ok, we're probably going to get good animation but butchered content. Looks like the sound and seiyuu will be fairly good too. I suppose that can sell...
I usually mostly refer to the director's name but he's completely unknown to me. His only show is a reverse harem currently airing which received a very low rating on MAL too (not like rating on MAL is relevant, but when it's this low...) Why are they giving something that isn't simple to adapt to a non experienced director... With a studio known to screw up novels adaptation....

I suppose my hope of seeing the very good Alderamin adapted at least half as faithfully as RnY was is now over. Madhouse have done very nice anime, but I would be very surprised if they were to handle properly something like Alderamin.

Kuma said:

this series screaming edgy right in your face. not really my faforite type os stories, but i will wait.

Alderamin isn't especially edgy. It's military. And try to have war without deaths. Also, except if Madhouse decides to reaaallly butcher the whole thing, you will not see such thing happening.

Mar 10, 2016 1:43 AM

#23

kanarazukarasu

Offline

Sep 2013

895

lol..after Overlord's success, Madhouse will stick with LN adaptations for a while

**Summer 2017**
Anime of the Season Poll!!

Mar 10, 2016 2:01 AM

#24

Kuma

Offline

Mar 2015

47066

Zefyris said:

Kuma said:

this series screaming edgy right in your face. not really my faforite type os stories, but i will wait.

Alderamin isn't especially edgy. It's military. And try to have war without deaths. Also, except if Madhouse decides to reaaallly butcher the whole thing, you will not see such thing happening.

i don't find any problem with military stuff it slef, but just first arc and mc doesn't care about another person life. even worse i mean in characterization when introgation scane. okay, war is cruel and i know it, but is it even necessary to doing it in that way? after that, okay, i already stabilished that mc has bad personality but later, author try to justfy it by showing his bad past. of course i also feel nothing since i already stabilished that war is cruel and i don't give a fuck of him just because bad past. bad past can't be excuse he is being dick for current time.

"If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on."

Mar 10, 2016 2:02 AM

#25

Offline

Apr 2014

6858

>That staff

Literally a bunch of nobodies. This will definitely not end well.

Mar 10, 2016 2:08 AM

#26

Offline

Apr 2013

7945

Kuma said:

Zefyris said:

Alderamin isn't especially edgy. It's military. And try to have war without deaths. Also, except if Madhouse decides to reaaallly butcher the whole thing, you will not see such thing happening.

i don't find any problem with military stuff it slef, but just first arc and mc doesn't care about another person life. even worse i mean in characterization when introgation scane. okay, war is cruel and i know it, but is it even necessary to doing it in that way? after that, okay, i already stabilished that mc has bad personality but later, author try to justfy it by showing his bad past. of course i also feel nothing since i already stabilished that war is cruel and i don't give a fuck of him just because bad past. bad past can't be excuse he is being dick for current time.

it's not that he doesn't care, but that someone had to do it. And he choose to do it, believing he was the most appropriate for that kind of harsh job. And yes, it was necessary. If you think that war is pretty, you've watched too much animu about war lately. HE didn't want the others to handle that kind of "job" and be dirtied by it, and choose to have the blood on his hands himself.
Besides, that guy would have died anyway. So yes, it was cruel, but necessary.

Mar 10, 2016 2:11 AM

#27

NotThisShitAgain

Offline

Dec 2015

367

Guess who right?? hehe

With these adaptation maybe Madhouse will make three LN adaptation this year, I believe Clockwork Planet/Youjo Senki done by Madhouse too.

Well, this LN was so good, could become AOTY, if Madhouse do right.
I hope TWO COURS with 26 episodes and covered volume 4/5 .

Best Girl of the year has come, YATORI!!

Murphy's Law

"Anything that can go wrong will go wrong"

Mar 10, 2016 2:14 AM

#28

Offline

Apr 2013

7945

NotThisShitAgain said:
Guess who right?? hehe

With these adaptation maybe Madhouse will make three LN adaptation this year, I believe Clockwork Planet/Youjo Senki done by Madhouse too.

Well, this LN was so good, could become AOTY, if Madhouse do right.

Best Girl of the year has come, YATORI!!

Don't talk about bad thing like that. If both Youjo Senki and alderamin were to be given to Madhouse, talk about a horrible year for novel adaptations...

Mar 10, 2016 2:16 AM

#29

Kuma

Offline

Mar 2015

47066

Zefyris said:

Kuma said:

i don't find any problem with military stuff it slef, but just first arc and mc doesn't care about another person life. even worse i mean in characterization when introgation scane. okay, war is cruel and i know it, but is it even necessary to doing it in that way? after that, okay, i already stabilished that mc has bad personality but later, author try to justfy it by showing his bad past. of course i also feel nothing since i already stabilished that war is cruel and i don't give a fuck of him just because bad past. bad past can't be excuse he is being dick for current time.

it's not that he doesn't care, but that someone had to do it. And he choose to do it, believing he was the most appropriate for that kind of harsh job. And yes, it was necessary. If you think that war is pretty, you've watched too much animu about war lately. HE didn't want the others to handle that kind of "job" and be dirtied by it, and choose to have the blood on his hands himself.
Besides, that guy would have died anyway. So yes, it was cruel, but necessary.

that's why i mentioned investigation scane. that's part is the one that totaly unnecessary. they havesuster. those everything happened after that is not even wasted more than half a day. they can not kill them but make them remaint silent, but they chose not, so i established that way to series. yet after that, autor try to ptoray protag is justifiable being bad guy. that's part is the one that i can't take seriously.

i don't said this series is bad or something, but i am myself just can't take those how author potray war seriously when character it self contradict with that.

"If taking responsibility for a mistake that cannot be undone means death, it's not that hard to die. At least, not as hard as to live on."

Mar 10, 2016 2:23 AM

#30

Offline

Dec 2011

475

Z4k said:
>That staff

Literally a bunch of nobodies. This will definitely not end well.

The series composition isn't noob though.

Zefyris said:
Madhouse for Alderamin? Ok, we're probably going to get good animation but butchered content. Looks like the sound and seiyuu will be fairly good too. I suppose that can sell...
I usually mostly refer to the director's name but he's completely unknown to me. His only show is a reverse harem currently airing which received a very low rating on MAL too (not like rating on MAL is relevant, but when it's this low...) Why are they giving something that isn't simple to adapt to a non experienced director... With a studio known to screw up novels adaptation....

I suppose my hope of seeing the very good Alderamin adapted at least half as faithfully as RnY was is now over. Madhouse have done very nice anime, but I would be very surprised if they were to handle properly something like Alderamin.

Kuma said:

this series screaming edgy right in your face. not really my faforite type os stories, but i will wait.

Alderamin isn't especially edgy. It's military. And try to have war without deaths. Also, except if Madhouse decides to reaaallly butcher the whole thing, you will not see such thing happening.

Norn9 is pretty decent, but then he is not director, just assistant director, so can't really give much credit to him.
Though he is experienced for storyboard/episode director, so i guess this is biggest challenge for him.
http://www19.atwiki.jp/enshutsu/pages/350.html

Mar 10, 2016 2:38 AM

#31

Offline

Apr 2014

6858

D-Joe said:

Z4k said:
>That staff

Literally a bunch of nobodies. This will definitely not end well.

The series composition isn't noob though.

Yes and so was the staff for Mahou Sensou.

Mar 10, 2016 2:47 AM

#32

CapedBaldy21

Offline

May 2014

326

Excited for this, Madhouse production values hopefully are their normal high standard. Hope we get 2-cour or split-cour and not another 1-cour LN adaptation by them with the series only feeling halfway complete (cough cough No Game No Life). The guy on series composition and the sound director are great, just hope the director does a god job as well.

Mar 10, 2016 3:05 AM

#33

Offline

Dec 2011

475

Z4k said:

D-Joe said:

The series composition isn't noob though.

Yes and so was the staff for Mahou Sensou.

Mahou Sensou's LN is crap you know, so the anime adaption is in-line.
And seriously the staff is alright, we don't know how will it end up until it on air, like someone talked about Rokka in few post ago, but form what i remember, when people found out Passione is going adapt Rokka, the negative is freaking crazy(right, Z4K)?

Mar 10, 2016 3:09 AM

#34

thepath

Offline

May 2012

6867

Looks go to me. I will watch it

Mar 10, 2016 3:09 AM

#35

Mayuka

Offline

Jul 2012

48256

Looks like Owari no Seraph www

underneath the stars

Mar 10, 2016 3:15 AM

#36

Offline

Apr 2014

6858

D-Joe said:

Z4k said:

Yes and so was the staff for Mahou Sensou.

Mahou Sensou's LN is crap you know, so the anime adaption is in-line.
And seriously the staff is alright, we don't know how will it end up until it on air, like someone talked about Rokka in few post ago, but form what i remember, when people found out Passione is going adapt Rokka, the negative is freaking crazy(right, Z4K)?

Rokka no Yuusha staff members were all veterans.

Mar 10, 2016 3:15 AM

#37

Nidhoeggr

Offline

Apr 2009

5752

Zefyris said:

NotThisShitAgain said:
Guess who right?? hehe

With these adaptation maybe Madhouse will make three LN adaptation this year, I believe Clockwork Planet/Youjo Senki done by Madhouse too.

Well, this LN was so good, could become AOTY, if Madhouse do right.

Best Girl of the year has come, YATORI!!

Don't talk about bad thing like that. If both Youjo Senki and alderamin were to be given to Madhouse, talk about a horrible year for novel adaptations...

Yes, Madhouse is too good a studio to be wasted on LN adaptions and we certainly don't need more of them.

Z4k said:

Rokka no Yuusha staff members were all veterans.

When the story is bad, even the best staff can't save it when they are forced to stay close to the source.

Steel Ball Run anime when?

Mar 10, 2016 3:18 AM

#38

Offline

Dec 2011

475

Z4k said:

D-Joe said:

Mahou Sensou's LN is crap you know, so the anime adaption is in-line.
And seriously the staff is alright, we don't know how will it end up until it on air, like someone talked about Rokka in few post ago, but form what i remember, when people found out Passione is going adapt Rokka, the negative is freaking crazy(right, Z4K)?

Rokka no Yuusha staff members were all veterans.

"Yes and so was the staff for Mahou Sensou." See i can reply the same thing to you.

Also even the director wasn't noob actually, his first show as episode director was Gankutsuou, which already 12 years ago.

Mar 10, 2016 3:21 AM

#39

Offline

Apr 2013

7945

Nidhoeggr said:

Zefyris said:

Don't talk about bad thing like that. If both Youjo Senki and alderamin were to be given to Madhouse, talk about a horrible year for novel adaptations...

Yes, Madhouse is too good a studio to be wasted on LN adaptions and we certainly don't need more of them.

Z4k said:

Rokka no Yuusha staff members were all veterans.

When the story is bad, even the best staff can't save it when they are forced to stay close to the source.

Madhouse fanboy here?
I'm sorry , but both RnY and Alderamin are far better than several of your favourite. And so is Youjo Senki for which we're still awaiting to know which studio will adapt, as well. They're too good to be wasted on a studio that thinks it's fine to adapt 7-8 volumes in 12-13 episodes, though.

@D-Joe RnY's adaptation being that faithful in this day and age was pretty much a miracle brought to you by Spice & wolf's director and the guy responsible for kyoukaisenjou no horizon's series composition. I wouldn't base myself on an extremely rare occurrence like this to judge anything.

@Kuma : can you edit your post please? I can't understand half of your sentences so I don't know what you're trying to say.

ZefyrisMar 10, 2016 3:29 AM

Mar 10, 2016 3:27 AM

#40

Offline

Apr 2014

6858

D-Joe said:

Z4k said:

Rokka no Yuusha staff members were all veterans.

"Yes and so was the staff for Mahou Sensou." See i can reply the same thing to you.

Also even the director wasn't noob actually, his first show as episode director was Gankutsuou, which already 12 years ago.

What makes you so sure he'll do a great job handling his first TV series with a mediocre staff?

Mar 10, 2016 3:29 AM

#41

MKusanagi

Offline

Nov 2013

136

Nidhoeggr said:

Yes, Madhouse is too good a studio to be wasted on LN adaptions and we certainly don't need more of them.

Current Madhouse is Deadhouse for years already, their best staff gone to MAPPA long time ago.

MKusanagiMar 10, 2016 3:33 AM

Mar 10, 2016 3:35 AM

#42