Forum Settings
Forums
Aldnoah.Zero Season One
Available on Manga Store
New
Jan 1, 11:26 AM
#1

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Compilation under the tag Re? Do they want to make some changes to the original story to make more content in the vein of the Code Geass movies? If so, it seems like only the Oshi no Ko fans are screwed again while everything else gets reworked or extended endings, lmao.
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
Jan 1, 12:00 PM
#2
Offline
Jan 2014
40
Lol who asked for this after the dumpster fire that was season 2?
Jan 1, 12:04 PM
#3

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Namoonriver
Lol who asked for this after the dumpster fire that was season 2?
@Namoonriver I don't know how popular it was in Japan when it aired, but it looks like they're trying to revive it as a franchise now.
Jan 1, 12:30 PM
#4
Offline
Jul 2010
10
Reply to RobertBobert
@Namoonriver I don't know how popular it was in Japan when it aired, but it looks like they're trying to revive it as a franchise now.
@RobertBobert - It was very popular in Japan and continues to have a dedicated fanbase! I'm happy to see they're revisiting it and hope they'll give us some more content for the time period between the two seasons. It probably took this long because it wasn't very famous and came from a pretty small studio.

@Namoonriver (and anyone else on the same train):
I typically avoid comment sections for this anime because it's my favorite and I know most people hated it, but since it seems the series might get picked up again, I feel like I should rep Karice's series of articles (links below). I liked both seasons already but their articles really helped bridge the gap and explain a lot of the reasons that the show was so well-liked in Japan but so hated in the west (translation issues, bad/missing promotional materials that were integral to set the tone for the series, etc.), and also explained a lot of the underlying philosophy that informs the series' storyline. If you liked the show at all I urge you to give them a look and consider giving the show a second chance! It's not perfect by any means, but I think it deserves better than the western fandom has been treating it. :<

It finally clicks - specifically relating to s01e12, leading into season 2
The main problem with Aldnoah.Zero - about translation errors
Aldnoah.Zero through an international relations lens - key points for the storyline, and talking about the missing promotional materials in the west
Jan 1, 12:32 PM
#5

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to ComposerLOST
@RobertBobert - It was very popular in Japan and continues to have a dedicated fanbase! I'm happy to see they're revisiting it and hope they'll give us some more content for the time period between the two seasons. It probably took this long because it wasn't very famous and came from a pretty small studio.

@Namoonriver (and anyone else on the same train):
I typically avoid comment sections for this anime because it's my favorite and I know most people hated it, but since it seems the series might get picked up again, I feel like I should rep Karice's series of articles (links below). I liked both seasons already but their articles really helped bridge the gap and explain a lot of the reasons that the show was so well-liked in Japan but so hated in the west (translation issues, bad/missing promotional materials that were integral to set the tone for the series, etc.), and also explained a lot of the underlying philosophy that informs the series' storyline. If you liked the show at all I urge you to give them a look and consider giving the show a second chance! It's not perfect by any means, but I think it deserves better than the western fandom has been treating it. :<

It finally clicks - specifically relating to s01e12, leading into season 2
The main problem with Aldnoah.Zero - about translation errors
Aldnoah.Zero through an international relations lens - key points for the storyline, and talking about the missing promotional materials in the west
@ComposerLOST Apparently it's not popular enough if it became deader than disco after the second season finale. Well, let's see how they are going to change this.
Jan 1, 12:39 PM
#6

Offline
Oct 2018
2753
Lol this does look like a way to build a continuing franchise depending on the movie reception and the follow-up BD release the eventual month. Since Aldnoah 2 ended, Aoki has been making originals with various interesting writers, will be such a shame to see him stay involved in just one thing.

The new episode is titled "24.5", so it's not changing anything of the original just doubling down on the original direction the story progressed and the aftermath.
Jan 1, 12:43 PM
#7

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Etherius_ZS
Lol this does look like a way to build a continuing franchise depending on the movie reception and the follow-up BD release the eventual month. Since Aldnoah 2 ended, Aoki has been making originals with various interesting writers, will be such a shame to see him stay involved in just one thing.

The new episode is titled "24.5", so it's not changing anything of the original just doubling down on the original direction the story progressed and the aftermath.
@Etherius_ZS What was he doing all this time? I haven't heard of him since ReCreators and Bloom into you.
Jan 1, 12:45 PM
#8
Offline
Jul 2010
10
Reply to RobertBobert
@ComposerLOST Apparently it's not popular enough if it became deader than disco after the second season finale. Well, let's see how they are going to change this.
@RobertBobert Yeah it is pretty wild to bring it back a decade later but who knows how the anime industry works haha
Jan 1, 12:48 PM
#9

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to ComposerLOST
@RobertBobert Yeah it is pretty wild to bring it back a decade later but who knows how the anime industry works haha
@ComposerLOST Well, if it really improves the franchise, then I'm all for it. Especially if a positive example of this opens the way to other "fixes" for previously tainted franchises.
Jan 1, 12:48 PM

Offline
Oct 2018
2753
Reply to RobertBobert
@Etherius_ZS What was he doing all this time? I haven't heard of him since ReCreators and Bloom into you.
@RobertBobert
Id Invaded
Overtake

and he has been boarding episodes of few shows helmed by people he is quite close to like Ikariya, Katou and Shuu Watanabe.

Bloom Into You wasn't him btw
Jan 1, 12:49 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Etherius_ZS
@RobertBobert
Id Invaded
Overtake

and he has been boarding episodes of few shows helmed by people he is quite close to like Ikariya, Katou and Shuu Watanabe.

Bloom Into You wasn't him btw
@Etherius_ZS Really? It seemed to me that he was the director. I didn’t know about Overtake, but Invisible seemed like a pretty old show to me.
Jan 1, 12:53 PM

Offline
Oct 2018
2753
Reply to RobertBobert
@Etherius_ZS Really? It seemed to me that he was the director. I didn’t know about Overtake, but Invisible seemed like a pretty old show to me.
@RobertBobert He is listed as a supervisor on a new thing "Special Kid Factory" with the same writer as Id Invaded, and it seems like the concept of this thing was originally thought back in the mid 2000s by the writer, so I wonder if you heard something about Id Invaded in the same way.
https://x.com/AkutagawaKakuzo/status/1705775036769210578
https://x.com/AkutagawaKakuzo/status/1705775043962392936
Jan 1, 12:53 PM
Offline
Jul 2010
10
Reply to RobertBobert
@ComposerLOST Well, if it really improves the franchise, then I'm all for it. Especially if a positive example of this opens the way to other "fixes" for previously tainted franchises.
@RobertBobert Definitely the better use of the remake/reimagining trend that's been going on for awhile!
Jan 1, 12:57 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to ComposerLOST
@RobertBobert Definitely the better use of the remake/reimagining trend that's been going on for awhile!
@ComposerLOST Well, I definitely liked their take on Code Geass, not gonna lie.

@Etherius_ZS I'm not denying his work on the show. I thought it was older.
Jan 1, 1:09 PM

Offline
May 2009
9253
Reply to Namoonriver
Lol who asked for this after the dumpster fire that was season 2?
@Namoonriver It's not like S1 was that good, cue to DemoD's review
Jan 1, 1:10 PM
Offline
Apr 2014
22
This show is a decade old. I'd be surprised if they did.
Jan 1, 1:42 PM

Offline
Dec 2010
2201
Reply to Namoonriver
Lol who asked for this after the dumpster fire that was season 2?
@Namoonriver My immediate reaction. Lol. Nobody asked for this. Nobody wanted this.
Jan 1, 2:15 PM

Offline
Dec 2012
16161
Please be the Slaine Route where best boy wins.
Jan 1, 2:34 PM

Offline
Jan 2009
103259
if this sells well we might see an anime sequel and maybe correct the ntr ending
Jan 1, 2:53 PM

Offline
Oct 2011
20854
Ah, a thread!

I wonder if A/Z is trying to pull a Code Geass Re.. Hehe
Jan 1, 4:21 PM
Offline
Oct 2019
798
Pknoctis said:
@Namoonriver My immediate reaction. Lol. Nobody asked for this. Nobody wanted this.

Me I don't want this.
I don't care.
But if it's here, then there are massively more people asking for it than you think.
So saying "nobody" is false and condescending.
It's "I don't care".


And besides, I personally don't care but good for the fans, I hope you enjoy this fan of the anime !
Jan 1, 6:20 PM
Offline
Jun 2014
1
Reply to RobertBobert
@Namoonriver I don't know how popular it was in Japan when it aired, but it looks like they're trying to revive it as a franchise now.
@RobertBobert feel the gacha game hidding in the shadow.

Was a good anime i liked it but never seen it as a potential franchise as the story already covered everything we needed to know about the world and even got a final.

Making it as a franchise seem like a bad idea as they are risking to kill a nice anime.
Jan 1, 8:39 PM

Offline
Feb 2015
822
Reply to RobertBobert
@Etherius_ZS What was he doing all this time? I haven't heard of him since ReCreators and Bloom into you.
@RobertBobert he directed ID:Invaded and Overtake

Jan 1, 11:38 PM

Offline
Oct 2008
2044
Scrapping the bottom of the barrel to check what can be salvaged.
Jan 2, 1:30 AM
Offline
Apr 2017
96
who is gonna watch this shit in this recession, who even remembers this shit. 30+ yr old shutin manchildren who still watch anime all night? Season2 was like Western and Kdrama TV season twos, just fillers and garbage to create a "franchise"
Jan 2, 1:51 AM
Offline
Mar 2021
72
Reply to tokomata
who is gonna watch this shit in this recession, who even remembers this shit. 30+ yr old shutin manchildren who still watch anime all night? Season2 was like Western and Kdrama TV season twos, just fillers and garbage to create a "franchise"
@tokomata why are you throwing stones about age when you’re in a glass house yourself?
Jan 2, 2:15 AM
Offline
Apr 2017
96
Reply to Noegusis
@tokomata why are you throwing stones about age when you’re in a glass house yourself?
@Noegusis I lived my life. My kid graduated and I have nothing much to do at home. Even so I'm not watching anime or doing weeb things all day
Jan 2, 4:24 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Saeria
@RobertBobert feel the gacha game hidding in the shadow.

Was a good anime i liked it but never seen it as a potential franchise as the story already covered everything we needed to know about the world and even got a final.

Making it as a franchise seem like a bad idea as they are risking to kill a nice anime.
@Saeria Well, there had to be some meaning to this anyway. Because you are unlikely to give out money for such a waste out of pure interest.
Jan 2, 4:44 AM
Offline
Mar 2021
72
Reply to tokomata
@Noegusis I lived my life. My kid graduated and I have nothing much to do at home. Even so I'm not watching anime or doing weeb things all day
@tokomata Wow you're lucky. I wish I had enough time to not do much at home and watch anime all day.
Jan 2, 4:55 AM
Offline
Nov 2024
4
Reply to tokomata
who is gonna watch this shit in this recession, who even remembers this shit. 30+ yr old shutin manchildren who still watch anime all night? Season2 was like Western and Kdrama TV season twos, just fillers and garbage to create a "franchise"
@tokomata people like me, i remembered it 10 years after first watch. For some reason. There's other anime I've completely forgot about, but distinctly remember about A/Z. Maybe it's just godly soundtrack that grabbed me, the power of Sawano Drop, so to say.
Jan 2, 12:43 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
58
Reply to RobertBobert
@ComposerLOST Apparently it's not popular enough if it became deader than disco after the second season finale. Well, let's see how they are going to change this.
@RobertBobert You being here posting about it after our last discussion but alright I can ignore that and I can respect you disliking it. So to not harm your own sanity it's for better if you dont pin your hope nor get invested in A/Z. This anime is for mecha autist not ppl as you really, it wasnt dead it waited after Armored Core 6(AC6) release that's how mecha works so play AC6 if you intent to understand and stay in mecha. Or else better leave.

@ComposerLOST you are absolutely right! I was on japanese trailers and shorts, theres literally 0 negative comments about AZ the worst they felt was little bad about ending but saying it was irrelevant. This is why anime should only be for japanese market first as they know better. Japan definitely waited until AC6 released.

@tokomata me I watched it when I was 13-14, in first place most ppl that watched it were kids too so who tf is 30+ year dude ? Japanese adults liked AZ/okay with sequel so why would western adults start puberty A/Z hate bandwagon that we kids did in anime like A/Z?
Jan 2, 12:49 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
58
Reply to otvalsky
@tokomata people like me, i remembered it 10 years after first watch. For some reason. There's other anime I've completely forgot about, but distinctly remember about A/Z. Maybe it's just godly soundtrack that grabbed me, the power of Sawano Drop, so to say.
@otvalsky just like me exactly ! The mecha franchise was always dead outside japan like you can see Original 80s gundam is dead while in japan still popular. Unfortunately west here doesn't like mecha as ppl like me are in minority. Even in mecha they want slice of life or romance like in thread here, appreciation for mecha is low outside japan.
Jan 2, 12:49 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Destined321
@RobertBobert You being here posting about it after our last discussion but alright I can ignore that and I can respect you disliking it. So to not harm your own sanity it's for better if you dont pin your hope nor get invested in A/Z. This anime is for mecha autist not ppl as you really, it wasnt dead it waited after Armored Core 6(AC6) release that's how mecha works so play AC6 if you intent to understand and stay in mecha. Or else better leave.

@ComposerLOST you are absolutely right! I was on japanese trailers and shorts, theres literally 0 negative comments about AZ the worst they felt was little bad about ending but saying it was irrelevant. This is why anime should only be for japanese market first as they know better. Japan definitely waited until AC6 released.

@tokomata me I watched it when I was 13-14, in first place most ppl that watched it were kids too so who tf is 30+ year dude ? Japanese adults liked AZ/okay with sequel so why would western adults start puberty A/Z hate bandwagon that we kids did in anime like A/Z?
@Destined321 I don't think trying to assume that I don't know or like a genre just because I have a different opinion about a show in that genre than you obviously doesn't make this debate any better. You really need to stop basing your discussions with other people on jumping to conclusions, labels and generalizations.
Jan 2, 12:50 PM
Offline
Jul 2014
327
Bro, nobody asked for this, dogshit season 2 dogshit ending nobody cares
Jan 2, 12:52 PM

Offline
Dec 2012
417
Bringing this back is certainly a choice
Jan 2, 12:58 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
58
Reply to RobertBobert
@Destined321 I don't think trying to assume that I don't know or like a genre just because I have a different opinion about a show in that genre than you obviously doesn't make this debate any better. You really need to stop basing your discussions with other people on jumping to conclusions, labels and generalizations.
@RobertBobert you may not like the assumptions but I didn't assume or say you don't like genre or mecha. I said you shouldnt hurt your own sanity and hurt sanity of fans here liking AZ, as you will be negative towards this series. You personally don't like it better leave it, it will just increase hate for AZ and annoy ppl that personally like it. We can be peaceful in our own fence that all it meant.

@dragoncapsule505 bvro if you dont like it just ignore and leave it, mecha is not for everyone maybe slice of life is your home. Be happy instead of caring for anything annoying.
Jan 2, 1:01 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Destined321
@RobertBobert you may not like the assumptions but I didn't assume or say you don't like genre or mecha. I said you shouldnt hurt your own sanity and hurt sanity of fans here liking AZ, as you will be negative towards this series. You personally don't like it better leave it, it will just increase hate for AZ and annoy ppl that personally like it. We can be peaceful in our own fence that all it meant.

@dragoncapsule505 bvro if you dont like it just ignore and leave it, mecha is not for everyone maybe slice of life is your home. Be happy instead of caring for anything annoying.
@Destined321 Have I ever said anywhere that I don’t like this series in the first place?
Jan 2, 1:12 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
58
Reply to RobertBobert
@Destined321 Have I ever said anywhere that I don’t like this series in the first place?
@RobertBobert its alright if you dont remember if you know you are coming disappointed there's no reason to be like many here. Also my replies are cloned twice for some reason. You won't like it really japanese first rule of mecha is liking robots and machines as their YT comments on gundam/aldnoah show, characters 2nd. It's tiresome to see aldnoah disappointment restarted decade later.
Jan 2, 1:18 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Destined321
@RobertBobert its alright if you dont remember if you know you are coming disappointed there's no reason to be like many here. Also my replies are cloned twice for some reason. You won't like it really japanese first rule of mecha is liking robots and machines as their YT comments on gundam/aldnoah show, characters 2nd. It's tiresome to see aldnoah disappointment restarted decade later.
@Destined321 Just because I agree that the Season 2 finale was disappointing doesn't mean I don't love the show as a whole. I first learned about it years after the broadcast and already knew most of the spoilers in advance.
Jan 2, 8:02 PM
Offline
Oct 2012
8
Reply to ComposerLOST
@RobertBobert - It was very popular in Japan and continues to have a dedicated fanbase! I'm happy to see they're revisiting it and hope they'll give us some more content for the time period between the two seasons. It probably took this long because it wasn't very famous and came from a pretty small studio.

@Namoonriver (and anyone else on the same train):
I typically avoid comment sections for this anime because it's my favorite and I know most people hated it, but since it seems the series might get picked up again, I feel like I should rep Karice's series of articles (links below). I liked both seasons already but their articles really helped bridge the gap and explain a lot of the reasons that the show was so well-liked in Japan but so hated in the west (translation issues, bad/missing promotional materials that were integral to set the tone for the series, etc.), and also explained a lot of the underlying philosophy that informs the series' storyline. If you liked the show at all I urge you to give them a look and consider giving the show a second chance! It's not perfect by any means, but I think it deserves better than the western fandom has been treating it. :<

It finally clicks - specifically relating to s01e12, leading into season 2
The main problem with Aldnoah.Zero - about translation errors
Aldnoah.Zero through an international relations lens - key points for the storyline, and talking about the missing promotional materials in the west
@ComposerLOST Thank you for these links! I remember liking s1 and disliking s2, and now I have a better idea why that was. I assume I watched the CR version back in the day.
Jan 2, 11:39 PM

Offline
Apr 2010
440
Reply to Crownowa
@ComposerLOST Thank you for these links! I remember liking s1 and disliking s2, and now I have a better idea why that was. I assume I watched the CR version back in the day.
@Crownowa Just read the first link and the last paragraph blew me away:

I found out recently that there’s a slight mistranslation in the English version of what Clausewitz wrote in German. The sentence is actually “War is the continuation of politics with other means.” The word ‘with’ conveys much more clearly how war is just another tool in the political toolkit, rather than a red line that leaders would not want to cross. For what it’s worth, the line of dialogue that they gave Inaho in Japanese actually does convey that.


I can't believe such an important book in the canon of Western political literature has been mistranslated like this for almost 200 years.
Jan 3, 7:59 AM

Offline
Nov 2017
986
so it's purely compilation or there's more newer story in the movie ? idk after finished season 2 many years ago, i still kinda hoping there's another route where's the MC and the Princess ended up together lmao
Jan 3, 8:04 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to NiaAlexandria
so it's purely compilation or there's more newer story in the movie ? idk after finished season 2 many years ago, i still kinda hoping there's another route where's the MC and the Princess ended up together lmao
@NiaAlexandria I don't know, I haven't really followed this franchise anymore. You might think that this is a regular compilation, but with the RE tag and after all these years?
Jan 4, 6:44 AM
Absolute Zenith

Offline
Mar 2016
3942
Oh hell naw, no way, not again... This is one of those series that held such a golden potential when it started but flopped the further the story progressed...
Jan 5, 4:09 PM
Offline
Nov 2018
68
Typical retarded thread of overthinking some media existence, when it's a popular show with dedeicated fanbase and in the immediate sense is promoting the BD re-release
Flick_onJan 9, 11:56 PM
Jan 5, 4:11 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Flick_on
Typical retarded thread of overthinking some media existence, when it's a popular show with dedeicated fanbase and in the immediate sense is promoting the BD re-release
@Flick_on Do people speculate about media after it gets new content? Oh my God, what retards! And yes, the announcement after all these years speaks volumes about how strong of a fanbase it has, lmao.
Jan 7, 1:03 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
58
Reply to RobertBobert
@Destined321 Just because I agree that the Season 2 finale was disappointing doesn't mean I don't love the show as a whole. I first learned about it years after the broadcast and already knew most of the spoilers in advance.
@RobertBobert that's not the problem, the problem is this show was mecha p*rn for ppl that care less about character relations more about the designs, cool movement, normally leaning little L-R sideways epic poses etc it's long list. Most importantly it's math-physics science using show, so you or if not you majority of ppl didn't get how insanely hard the mc turned the tide of war. You can see toxic ppl here so for me it's better to dissude ppl from caring in hatred
Jan 9, 10:26 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
22328
Reply to Destined321
@RobertBobert that's not the problem, the problem is this show was mecha p*rn for ppl that care less about character relations more about the designs, cool movement, normally leaning little L-R sideways epic poses etc it's long list. Most importantly it's math-physics science using show, so you or if not you majority of ppl didn't get how insanely hard the mc turned the tide of war. You can see toxic ppl here so for me it's better to dissude ppl from caring in hatred
@Destined321 You sound like people who justify shitty kids' content by saying "it's for kids, so quality isn't that important."
Jan 9, 10:42 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
58
Reply to RobertBobert
@Destined321 You sound like people who justify shitty kids' content by saying "it's for kids, so quality isn't that important."
@RobertBobert no ,I would say "it's a show for kids so the quality will be specially handcrafted towards kids" and the quality (taking kids into acc) should be best it can be regards to kids content.
Jan 9, 10:42 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
58
Reply to RobertBobert
@Destined321 You sound like people who justify shitty kids' content by saying "it's for kids, so quality isn't that important."
@RobertBobert no ,I would say "it's a show for kids so the quality will be specially handcrafted towards kids" and the quality (taking kids into acc) should be best it can be regards to kids content.
Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

» People are wondering who and why asked this ? Answer: Japanese.

Destined321 - Jan 2

13 by shimofuriquon »»
Mar 6, 1:52 PM

» Why?

RiasatSenpai - Jan 22

0 by RiasatSenpai »»
Jan 22, 1:39 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login