What did you think of this episode?
5Loved it!
62.0%
137
4Liked it!
28.1%
62
3It was OK
9.0%
20
2Disliked it
0.9%
2
1Hated it
0.0%
0
Average 4.5
221 votes
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Oh great, aired on TV Aichi : > (And it's up on Himado and Say-Move, for those interested in the raw.) Oh hurr durr, Brian Roscoe, what a nice surprise. So that was him, after all. And apparently, Victorique had already begun researching the disappearances in the papers. Well how surprising expected wasn't that? The Blue rose "copy" was actually the real deal. And it's annoying, but Grevil is much smarter than Kujo. Also, dun dun dunnn everything turns into a brawl, wooo ヽ(´ー｀)ﾉ What a chaotic arc. In more than one way. Nice pipe holder. What? Well, that turned out well, and I think this is probably the best arc so far. Unless the first arc was better. And this new woman, Grevil's acquaintance, she seems pretty nice and all. I wonder for how long. So far, this show has been pretty mean to new characters who "seem nice". Now, to see what Roscoe actually has to do with everything. Edit: Oh and next week there's a special episode, apparently. |
OosranMar 14, 2011 1:04 PM
| Protip: I don't really check the forums anymore, so if you want something, take it on my profile. Is it time for my long-awaited return to the forums? щ(ﾟДﾟщ) Nope™, probably not. |
| Grevil and Kujo make an ok team, and the brawl was epic as well as the sting operation. Victorica is on the ball even when she's sick. Classy Pipe Holder |
 |
| Oh wow, you've seen it? I really didn't expect it to air. Well I gotta wait for subs anyway. :3 |
 |
| horse carriage mystery ~~~ ....how they get out of that horse carriage ??~~~ |
 Gravil plays a nice role in this episode. He's pretty cool-looking in that screenshot too. (Btw, I'm kinda curious about the relationship between the debt he owed to Victorica and his drill hair. :3 )  Victorica's one of the most moe character in this winter season. So adorable! XD I thought the deduction part was pretty weak in this episode, and my guess is that the show skipped certain parts in the light novel to speed up the plot. I still like Gosick as a historical thriller though, as it has interesting backgrounds, characters, and settings. :) |
stevewiess01Mar 14, 2011 9:32 PM
 |
| Well, this arc was sooohooooo much better than the previous 2. Let's hope Gosick will get as good as it was in the first 3 episodes. 5/5 for this episode. Oh, and that shot at the and where Victorique held the green shoe thingy with her pipe was beautiful. I'd like her more if she weren't tsundere though. |
 |
| OK episode, I'm just glad I can watch something.... it seems almost every anime has been postponed. |
| "Let me tell you my brother's secret. In his drill, there is...candy, Kujo." I didn't catch the Anastasia-Russia connection until they mentioned that she escaped and was apart of royalty and that was a nicely planned out operation to solve the case, could have been a little more action with Kujo though, instead of him just running by everything |
| Yay subs finally came out tried watching the RAW was able to understand bits, but yeah prefer subs.. anyways, this episode was good somehow on the paperweight thing, I remembered what my friend said once about that, "if it breaks its glass, if it doesn't then its crystal" so yeah, the things that pop into anime too lol ROFL, anyone notice that Victorique's mom had a cold too funny how they both have a cold at the same time, oh well as for the preview of the next ep, I can't wait, always wondering why Grevil had that hairstyle... and stuff lol |
 |
| I sense Ace Attorney reference (on Kujo.) |
RandomPerson4 said: YES! FUCK YOU LIGHT YAGAMI! FUCK YOU!!!!!!! |
| I was happy to find out that the subs are out and for me the wait was worth it. The mystery was not as big as I had hoped for but in the end it was still pretty good. |
| Sick Victorique was as adorable as ever. The ending to the mystery was pretty meh though. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Nice episode, kind of funny how Grevil completely depends on Victorique to solve all the cases for him. |
| What a nice way to end this arc. The girls ended up being save except for the ones that have already been sold. Victorica gets well in the next episode. YAY!!!! It just doesn't say Gosick if she's not always on screen. |
 |
| I wasn't expecting the brawl but it definitely added to the show. Victorique's new pipe holder is awesome. This was a good episode for sure. |
  |
| Kujo should have kicked some ass!! I know he has brass knuckles on him somewhere. |
| It seems from a throwaway line, that Grevil may have renounced his position of heir, "That is all in the past". I wonder if there is a connection with his female friend or with Victorique? |
Please don't feed the trolls! In my next life I want to collide at the corner with the cute transfer student carrying a piece of toast in her mouth...rodac |
| I'm more than ready for Victorique to rejoin Kujo in his adventures. I'm glad they solved that case fairly quickly, selling young girls is just wrong. |
stevewiess01 said: Victorica's one of the most moe character in this winter season. So adorable! XD Shame she is such a moody little madam! Anyway, enjoy this: http://sadpanda.us/images/399901-4L857RQ.jpg ;) |
| Not as meh as the other arcs but still meh. |
 |
| That was a pretty good episode. Its funny that Victorica puts her pipe in the glass shoe. And I notice Grevil's hair looks normal in the preview. |
Although I did not have time comment on episode 8 and 9, TBH episode 8 is still the best and #9 is the cutest. In fact sickly cute Victorica. Seriously this episode rocked! Action, drama and cruelty along with some comedy. The best was really Victorica at the end with that pipe/cinder-ally show combo in the following, although it looks a little strange, I do wonder how she will look now with taking that pipe in her mouth. Well certain it represents 2 things, that of beauty with intelligence. Another that mind fucked is WTF at Victorica with what looks like the shadow of Grevil in the spoiler About Kujo, at first the hand grabbing his face scared me out as a kidnapping. I liked how Kujo knew of Ruji’s face and meets up with him of all places in a dark alley. The fact he believes him while others did not and becomes quite friendly with him was a nice moment to be seen developed between them while I liked the fact he did remind himself of Victorica be looking over the handkerchief that had written all over idiot from Victorica. I was not surprised as much as Kujo was with the whole Blue rose thing of the real one not breaking since it was a too obvious thing. I loved finger pointing in the spoiler About Grevil, I have enough seen of him in this episode to get a good glimpse into his personality further on. The first thing that grabbed my attention is when Grevil grabbed Kujo rather violently and in response Kujo asked him why not phone Victorica himself. The key thing here is exactly the way he responded with his facial expression on the level of his mouth. It was of a aggressive/frustrating regretful nature TBH. His plan of suddenly grabbing Kujo in front of Garnier and his assistant only as a means of faking with that wink of his as a end to having the officers mark down the windows that do not have Blue John stone in them. Grevil’s shinning moment is where he grabbed Miss martial arts trained girl in the spoiler About Anastasia, I was really surprised at first that she was the one who grabbed Kujo. While being inside the carriage she looked a little defiant towards Kujo. As she tells him her story I find her most cute in the spoiler About the brawl, just want to mention that the girl in the spoiler Rest in the spoiler |
Yumekichi11Mar 20, 2011 10:39 PM
| So, Brian Roscoe really was a magician. It seems that he remembers Kujo. I wonder if Cordelia was still with him (that sneeze and joke about lady having caught cold... I wonder if that means that Cordelia was hiding in that doll?..) For a moment I thought that I'm going to see Mildred again. Too bad that Grevil's friend turned out to be woman named Jacquilene (sorry if spelled wrong). Next episode seems to be more about Grevil. Looking forward to seeing it. |
| So from the way I gathered it Grevil has his hair like that as a returning favor to Victorique every time he asks her help? Brilliant and hilarious. |
| Ara ara. |
| In that drill... he has hidden... candy... |
| Don't forget. Always, somewhere, someone is fighting for you. As long as you remember her, you are not alone. |
| I found the mystery to be pretty interesting. Only thing was that we knew the blue rose was the real deal from the start, but i guess they needed to prove it again by dropping a national treasure. I like the little guy. At this point Kujo is one of the few idiots, everyone else is smarter in some way except the teacher. |
| Pretty good arc this was. Kujo was actually a bit useful solving this one even though Victorique did most of it as always. ^^ So that is where Graviel got his drill-hair from. I was something he had to do in return for Victorique helping him solve a mystery. Still wonder why she was called "The Grey Wolf" though (or maybe I just missed that? =P). And to top it all off we got this epically cute scene:  |
|
| and looks like BONES just covered three light novels and one short story in just 10 episodes ^^ well, what amazes me is how they managed to cover that amount of material into pleasant, well-played and enjoyable episodes. aside from that, this episode is amazing. I just love what they did to Jiantan, that "Blue John" plan was amazing to see and i love seeing our Inspector and the police in action. and i can't believe Glaviel has "long hair" ? well base on the preview and i can't wait to watch it but i guess i have TWO WEEKS to patiently wait for it. (next week is a Gosick special) and finally, Hope Japan recovers from its crisis. |
| Simplistic beauty can't be appreciated by someone who looks for something grand in everything he watch. |
STM said: Agreed.I'd like her more if she weren't tsundere though. HawthorneKitty said: Agreed.The ending to the mystery was pretty meh though. When will Resuscitated Hope's full version come out? Dying to get my hands on it. |
 |
| The mystery was indeed easily solved but it wasn't a bad episode as a mater of fact i really liked it. I hope that warehouse owner gets the most severe punishment out there, selling girls as slaves he really is scum. Anastasia looked so much better near the end of the episode it was really nice to see that her situation improved. After the treatment she went trough. Then there is also that boy it's nice to see that he will have a brighter future and with his memory and intellect it would not be surprising to see him ending up as a scientist or something similar. It was also nice the see that Victorique got better from her cold at the end of the episode tho seeing her sick was cute. It appears her mother was also sick since i suspect she was the one in the box of the magician and the one that magician was talking about. Victorique was pretty demanding of the teacher almost demanding her to get those newspapers i wonder tho how she knew that Kujo was on that case. I wonder where Kujo was keeping the souvenirs when he was on board the train since he didn't seem to be holding on to them and he also didn't went shopping for that mater. I also like the fact that he got interrupted during his speech about being the son of a imperial soldier, it makes him look so chauvinistic. |
| Cute Victorique is cute. |
 |
| A few questions... How did Kujo and Anastasia escape from the carriage? Who is Jacqueline? Who is Brian Roscoe? My memory is not that great. |
GarLogan78 said: How did Kujo and Anastasia escape from the carriage? They didn't need escaping since they weren't trapped. We were never told who drove that carriage (a bit weird, yes) but I am guessing that Jacqueline girl or something like that. An ally, not an enemy. The only reason for Anastasia to be inside that thing was probably so none of the staff of that creepy place would spot her. The most intresting scene was Roscoe's little speech. Was he actually implying that there was a girl inside of that doll-thingy? Sure sounded like it. All in all a very well executed episode. The tempo is still a tad high, but not by a whole lot. I expect great things from the remainder of the series, especially when we get to those inevitable arcs that Bones think deserve a lot of time (otherwise they really wouldn't speed through the material like this). |
| The mysteries still suck. Good thing Victorique is cute. |
| Nice ep overall. It's nice to see the guys being useful for a change. One thing didn't make sense though. Kujo may be an idiot, but his memory is one of his strong points. Him not remembering where he heard the name Brian Roscoe before was highly unlikely. |
 |
Yumekichi11 said: Another that mind fucked is WTF at Cordelia with what looks like the shadow of Duke De Blois in the spoiler Yeah, all that stuff is really sick. It seems that Grevil isn't a good guy, but we'll just have to wait and see if that shadow was actually him. It could be a trick by the creators just trying to screw with us. The children stuff is really sad too. Kind of make it seems that Hobbes was right when he said that man is evil by nature. Looking at how stuff like this goes on irl (as you brought up with your example) you wonder if he is right, but I don't like to be too pessimistic. |
alexcampos said: I hear you. It's understandable, but this is the first time I've watched any of the on-goings since last Thursday. I was really starting to miss them. ^_^;;OK episode, I'm just glad I can watch something.... it seems almost every anime has been postponed. Linalee-Stratos said: Pretty sure it's April 27th, but don't quote me on it. I've been waiting for its release, too.When will Resuscitated Hope's full version come out? Dying to get my hands on it. GarLogan78 said: Jacqueline was just introduced this episode, so you're not missing anything.Who is Jacqueline? Who is Brian Roscoe? Brian Roscoe was introduced at the beginning of the last mystery. He was the guy that made Kujo's textbooks disappear. He was shown again at the end of mystery, along with (unconfirmed) Victorique's mother (ep. 8). Brian Rosco was also the one that brought electricity to that secluded village. So while I'm on Roscoe-san... his eyes are just too cool! No, really, I love the way his eyes are drawn. I can't wait 'til they show more of his character. To me he's the biggest mystery in the whole show. I love how everyone just started fighting. You're gonna get caught, guys. I guess they thought they could slip out during the chaos. And I'm starting to like Grevil a lot more, too. Pretty cool how he shutdown that martial arts woman. I'm sure everyone else thought that glass boot Victorique got was pretty random, but my mom collects those things so I was all, "Hey, I know what that is!" :P *Points at signature* I've got a Blue Rose! |
    |
| Lol victorique actually uses the pipe for something...i wonder if its just for fashion |
 Behold of my awesomeness~ controversial and/or sensitive topics likely devolve into the same repetitive, derogatory, abusive, and harassing comments can no longer be posted. But my feels. |
ManInBlack said: ^freakin' saved!!! XDDShame she is such a moody little madam! Anyway, enjoy this: http://sadpanda.us/images/399901-4L857RQ.jpg ;) For a while when I saw those "demons" when Anastasia described it, I thought they were fans squealing or something and those girls were the idols XDD I hate to see them selling young girls, good thing they solved it fast xDD |
| lol whenever the police say don't move or freeze ....that's when everybody runs :P |
 |
| Great episode as always...and I honestly did not think the slipper was for the pipe..silly me... : ) Candy in the drill....now that I'd like to see.. |
I am a sucker for romance!!!! ] |
prismheart said: Even if it's not him then his father is still sick. That may explain why he feels ashamed to speak To Victorica because he could not stop his father from abusing her mother. BTW what would Victorica's mother be to Grevil? Stepmother? Anyways I think he had appreciation for her and resented his father over it. I need to get sleep but I will elaborate later on this.Yumekichi11 said: Another that mind fucked is WTF at Cordelia with what looks like the shadow of Duke De Blois in the spoiler Yeah, all that stuff is really sick. It seems that Grevil isn't a good guy, but we'll just have to wait and see if that shadow was actually him. It could be a trick by the creators just trying to screw with us. prismheart said: It's not the man who is evil but the force driving him, IMO that would be what people call Satan or whatever else it may be such as devils. The problem is how to eliminate that threat.The children stuff is really sad too. Kind of make it seems that Hobbes was right when he said that man is evil by nature. Looking at how stuff like this goes on irl (as you brought up with your example) you wonder if he is right, but I don't like to be too pessimistic. |
Hakochi said: ROFL, anyone notice that Victorique's mom had a cold too funny how they both have a cold at the same time, oh well l What? As I recall her mom was dead. Or am I wrong? ManInBlack said: Shame she is such a moody little madam! Anyway, enjoy this: http://sadpanda.us/images/399901-4L857RQ.jpg ;) "Save as" on HDD.... :D She's the MOE character of this season....... ;) |
 |
twonline said: Hakochi said: ROFL, anyone notice that Victorique's mom had a cold too funny how they both have a cold at the same time, oh well l What? As I recall her mom was dead. Or am I wrong? Cordelia is alive. She was seen together with Brian Roscoe in episode 8. In episode 10 he said: "Be careful with lady. She has caught cold." and then we hear someone sneeze. She definitely was in that doll.  |
Amaya-no-Hime said: Oh hell yes, I wasn't expecting an episode this week. Fabulous as always. I can't wait to hear more about Brian Roscoe and that scene with the Gray Wolf near the end. Initially thought it was Victorica and Grevil, so Grevil nearly lost all his cool points, but after reading through, it'd make a lot of sense if it was actually Cordelia and the Marquis. Mystery was rather straightforward as always, but I don't really mind anyway. Tbh, I'm watching this as more of a thriller/comedy/drama than as a mystery. Basically, everything I wanted to say. I wanna know more about Brian Roscoeee... |
  |
| the last part just made me lol xD victorica sure is creative hehehe |
 |
melody423 said: lol whenever the police say don't move or freeze ....that's when everybody runs :P That is so true. I totally lol'ed at that part. |
PerlaNemesis said: twonline said: Hakochi said: ROFL, anyone notice that Victorique's mom had a cold too funny how they both have a cold at the same time, oh well l What? As I recall her mom was dead. Or am I wrong? Cordelia is alive. She was seen together with Brian Roscoe in episode 8. In episode 10 he said: "Be careful with lady. She has caught cold." and then we hear someone sneeze. She definitely was in that doll. Oh! damn, I totally forgot that..... |
|
| So, Victorique is the one responsible for Grevil's hair? He probably asked her for help on a case and as payment she forced him to wear his hair in that lame ass style. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Gosick Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )timeagent - Jan 14, 2011 |
204 |
by wnix1
»»
Nov 14, 6:21 PM |
|
Poll: » Gosick Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Oosran - Feb 4, 2011 |
168 |
by owiiuiuiu
»»
Oct 31, 5:07 AM |
|
Poll: » Gosick Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Oosran - Jan 21, 2011 |
222 |
by Alkimia
»»
Sep 5, 6:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Gosick Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Kuro4735 - Jan 7, 2011 |
278 |
by Alkimia
»»
Sep 5, 7:26 AM |
|
Poll: » Gosick Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Oosran - Jul 1, 2011 |
523 |
by keynutil
»»
Sep 3, 11:34 AM |