DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| God bro this world is just so behind and stupid. Like, I refuse to believe to that a "child" found out about this magic before ANYBODY else has... like jeez. And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because.... |
 |
| Glad to see that Shion's mom is going to be OK. |
IzanaSolos said: God bro this world is just so behind and stupid. Like, I refuse to believe to that a "child" found out about this magic before ANYBODY else has... like jeez. And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because.... Yh so far this show isn't making sense logically. |
| What were they even barricading, the wall around the door? The door was completely free and let the goblin punch through instantly. Never seen before thing happened but the father instantly knew it was magic. Clearly it had to be that childish babbling made-up word his son once used. He has no clue what magic is, but obviously it's too dangerous for kids. Lets buy another sword instead. You are always reading books, but nvm that.. howcome do you have knowledge a kid wouldn't know! |
Reply to IzanaSolos
God bro this world is just so behind and stupid. Like, I refuse to believe to that a "child" found out about this magic before ANYBODY else has... like jeez.
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
| @IzanaSolos The story is literally purposefully made to be about the first people making magic in that world, of course the one looking for it is going to be the one to discover it. With the way you perceive the dad not wanting him to continue his research, you sound like you're 12. |
| The goblin scary/spooky vibes were portrayed quite well. MVP dad. |
| . |
Reply to Zero0Two0
How no one had medical knowledge on the house?
I would guess the women and elderly on a independent village would know the basics of treating wounds. Like, if they dont know, then no one ever got injuried or the ones that got ust died before a medic reached the village. This just don't make sense to me.
I would guess the women and elderly on a independent village would know the basics of treating wounds. Like, if they dont know, then no one ever got injuried or the ones that got ust died before a medic reached the village. This just don't make sense to me.
| @Zero0Two0 Well, yeah. Stitching wounds is first described in Egyptian literature 5000 years ago, and this looks like medieval Europe... |
Reply to IzanaSolos
God bro this world is just so behind and stupid. Like, I refuse to believe to that a "child" found out about this magic before ANYBODY else has... like jeez.
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
| @IzanaSolos this story is about a 30 years old fantasy lover getting reincarnated into a world where magic doesn't even exist yet,how tf is that even confusing ? Also,what his father did was pretty much the most logical thing a parents would do . |
| their area is that stupid and impoverished that nobody knew any medicine at all or about sewing wounds or using booze to clean injuries? well... i guess the expected level of thought and technology in this region just plummeted in my expectations. i figured since his dad had THAT many books of different types that his dad spent SOME kind of funds bringing in experts in various fields. some to teach and have apprentices like herb witches or hedge doctors or heck even midwives in the European Middle Ages had more knowledge than that gaggle of villagers. none of those ladies sewed ANYTHING in their lives? just the one? when all clothing was made at home BY the people wearing it? if it ripped or got damaged, they patched it up themselves. not every village around had tailors and seamstresses or cobblers! i don't know who is writing this... but they definitely dumbed EVERYTHING down to 'live in cave, hunter gather, ugh rock! stick! bang bang! unga bunga!' levels. even the weapons the guys used to attack the goblin nest were just farm tools! they didn't even wear leather body armor or padded gambesons made of layer upon layer of cloth sheets quilted together. uggghhh... this stuff just doesn't make sense! you don't build a two-story house like that mansion without SOMETHING like engineering and structural knowledge and you don't keep a large enough or viable enough population going in one location to build that mansion without SOME medical ability to patch up injuries in some way. their house's fence had freaking wrought iron or steel bars and spearpoints on it! that's a crap-ton of metal to just make the sections shown ON-SCREEN and just that length so far. that's alot of cash! also? glass pane windows that thin... look at the goblin's foot on the broken glass. and clear! and that big!!! do you know how long it took the expert glass houses of Murano, Venice, Italy to figure out how to make panes of very clear molded glass more than a foot on a side? two generations! TWO! it took them over 100 years of stealing glass techniques from all over Europe, North Africa, and Persia/Asia along the Silk Road to figure out how to get to the point of making SMALL molded colored glass and blown glass pieces... ugghhh being a history nerd is sometimes just so frustrating... |
just an ol school American otaku enjoyin the life. don't sass me kiddies, i've been otaku probably since before you were born. leave me in peace and i won't bother you either.  |
Reply to IzanaSolos
God bro this world is just so behind and stupid. Like, I refuse to believe to that a "child" found out about this magic before ANYBODY else has... like jeez.
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
| @IzanaSolos If no one ever thought about it, why would they discover something that does not exit even in a concept in their minds? The kid only asked about it and looked for it, because he was from another life / world, and the father explained that it is not a thing in the world. I am sure someone could have discovered something had they looked for it, but remember only a select few can actually it as well, which limits the number of people that could discover it. |
Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.  |
| goblin looked pretty tough today theres no medical knowledge in that village just weird magic discovery by a kid was unexpected lol poor mom got hurt but glad shes okay now no wonder some episodes make you facepalm pranksteure |
 |
| That goblin was so creepy, I liked his design and how malicious he was, I'm glad the mom is ok, she is pretty hot. |
Reply to AllySofya
@IzanaSolos The story is literally purposefully made to be about the first people making magic in that world, of course the one looking for it is going to be the one to discover it.
With the way you perceive the dad not wanting him to continue his research, you sound like you're 12.
With the way you perceive the dad not wanting him to continue his research, you sound like you're 12.
| @AllySofya "of course the one looking for it is going to be the one to discover it."... that's the dumbest thing I’ve heard lmao. It seems like the author just can’t write for anything, because there’s no way someone wouldn’t have noticed this magic aura or whatever he drained from the goblin in that episode on any other beast. And honestly, if anyone’s the 12-year-old here, it’s the dad. The son literally saved not just the people there but his wife too, thanks to this magic. But no, he’d rather stop him from continuing his research on something that could benefit both the world and their family. Make it make sense. |
|
| Shows like these make me think even I'd be able to write something better. Even if what I wrote was not good, it would still be true because anything would be better than this. And regardless of how bad the source material is there's gotta be something you can do in the adaptation process right? Like you'd have to pay me in beatings and insults for me to make such an uninspiring work. |
| This would be better if it wasn't an isekai. Create a story about a child who stumbles upon a power and starts researching it. I think the whole isekai part of it is just throwing thw whole thing into a jumble. |
 |
| The goblin: "Oh my goodness, this kid is crazier than I am!" Did someone order grilled goblin? I think it's a bit overcooked. |
| The mother is quite the MILF. I thought Shion would try healing magic, but good thing knowledge of modern medicine is enough. It's quite a slow burn. Things may only get exciting aroung Episode 7. And sorry, wincest-bait is over. |
Reply to IzanaSolos
@AllySofya "of course the one looking for it is going to be the one to discover it."... that's the dumbest thing I’ve heard lmao. It seems like the author just can’t write for anything, because there’s no way someone wouldn’t have noticed this magic aura or whatever he drained from the goblin in that episode on any other beast.
And honestly, if anyone’s the 12-year-old here, it’s the dad. The son literally saved not just the people there but his wife too, thanks to this magic. But no, he’d rather stop him from continuing his research on something that could benefit both the world and their family. Make it make sense.
And honestly, if anyone’s the 12-year-old here, it’s the dad. The son literally saved not just the people there but his wife too, thanks to this magic. But no, he’d rather stop him from continuing his research on something that could benefit both the world and their family. Make it make sense.
| @IzanaSolos You're not mature enough to understand the dad's point of view; hah. |
| Better than I thought it would be Some goblins have been spotted in the town and people are panicked, so then the father gets with a squad of dudes in black cloaks and tell the women and children to stay put- barricade the house, and they all ride off. Okay I have a pretty big problem with this scene. First of all- goblins? Really? Is anime so bored with itself and dried up of ideas that green goblins with creepy eyes are the only kind of threat they could think of for this fantasy world? Second thing is- the strong men all fuck off, leaving the women and children behind in the house undefended. They make it evident that goblins are a huge threat, so this dude basically fucked off and left his family behind to go be a hero. Shion wonders what was up with the vibe around these guys before they left; so it gave the feeling like they deliberately abandoned them. So of course Shion is the only one capable of doing anything, since it's a bunch of squeamish girls and he knows magic power; so he k'o the goblin, but not before it slashed his mother. The rest of the episode is daddy lecturing Marie and Shion to stop studying magic. And Shion gives his reason for why he wants to continue- he says "If I don't I'll be miserable!" ....... ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Really? That's like the worst reason you can give. It's selfish. Couldn't it have been, "I wanna protect my family" or something like that? No, because they are pretending this is an isekai fantasy, and that the boy had a prior life (that we didn't see) 4/5- better action, higher stakes |
| Good episode, bounced back after the trash of e2. Actually threatening goblins instead of just low level fodder is always great to see and it's nice to see a more basic spell instead of jumping straight to fireball. Also I want to fuck the mother. |
| Yo this show is absolutely underrated |
| Trying to watch all available anime series so you won't have to anymore, the list of anime I can recommend is still in progress, tho |
| this shit is good I can't understand the bad reviews |
Reply to IzanaSolos
God bro this world is just so behind and stupid. Like, I refuse to believe to that a "child" found out about this magic before ANYBODY else has... like jeez.
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
And that dad has some serious problems. Like yeah, he let bro continue he research in the end, but he legit SAVED YOUR WIFE AND EVERYBODY THERE IN THE ROOM BECAUSE OF MAGIC... but you weren't gonna let hm continue researching it because....
| @IzanaSolos Exactly lol the writing is a just a bit... off. Like I guess I can sort of get why maybe no one has discovered magic yet since only a select few people can see it, mainly children it seems, so maybe that could be why, plus the MC already had a basic concept of magic in mind, so glowing energy coming from monsters and the lake = magic... but come on surely SOMEONE in this vast world would have seen it too. Like, no one else saw the glowing energy and thought "yeah that's weird...", and just didn't bother to look into it? Another thing, how does no one know anything about medicine in the house? The child seems way more useful than anyone else. And 100% agree on the dad having some serious problems. It's stupid, and unnecessary, but it has to be thrown in there to have some "drama" and "plot", because reasons. Also, why is this an isekai? Why is the MC some 30 year old virgin loser from another world who really thought he would unlock magic at age 30 just because he's a virgin? Was there any need for it? You can remove the isekai aspect and I don't think you'd be losing anything of importance... |
 |
More topics from this board
» villahe name of Rose character of magic makerTachi27 - Feb 6 |
1 |
by komic
»»
Feb 9, 8:12 AM |
|
Poll: » Magic Maker: Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata Episode 5 DiscussionIzanaSolos - Feb 5 |
42 |
by pmarchand
»»
Feb 9, 7:01 AM |
|
Poll: » Magic Maker: Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 )KANLen09 - Jan 8 |
78 |
by Izayoi116
»»
Feb 6, 7:05 AM |
|
Poll: » Magic Maker: Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata Episode 4 DiscussionIzanaSolos - Jan 29 |
21 |
by gophercg
»»
Feb 4, 2:06 AM |
|
Poll: » Magic Maker: Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata Episode 2 DiscussionPranksteure - Jan 15 |
32 |
by zufaroro
»»
Feb 1, 5:52 AM |