Back to vrataski_'s Profile vrataski_'s Profile

My overall feelings with this are as follow: this is a good shounen. Sounds simple, and that's because it is! I'd put this at the same level as something like Naruto, and that's because they both make the same mistakes, as well as have the same strong points. If you like shounens, read this. If you are looking for something to surprise you, this might just do the trick. I'm not a fan of shounens, and I enjoyed my time with this regardless, don't underestimate it!
If you care at all about any more of an in-depth take, here goes (beware for very minor spoilers).

Strong premise ... to start it off, well paced action, my only real complaint about the first half of the series is the bad quality comedy. Especially at around volume 15, the manga drops in quality a LOT. The Gentle Criminal arc and everything prior to that is quite bad.
But luckily, as the mangaka figures out how he wants to close things out, the quality SKYROCKETS for the final couple arcs.

The villain focused arc is where he manages to reignite that spark that drives the series, although I'm not a fan of the tsundere girl, Twice has got to be the best character in the entire manga. Not only does he bring a style of comedy that fits the theme (a la Deadpool), he has a SUPER dark backstory that also fits perfectly with the entire mood switch! This encompasses the entire villain arc and closure to it, as well as the Shigaraki family arc, focused on Endeavor and Hawkeye.

All I have left to mention is the art. This guy is a fucking GENIUS. I don't think it's quite as complex as something like Berserk or Vagabond, but the fact that he's managing to pull off some of these spreads in a WEEKLY SHONEN is completely nuts. It's hard to convey how surprised I was when turning pages and noticing how good and gritty the artwork is. Bravo! In fact, the mangaka uses this change of artstyle in a very deliberate way, and it elevates moments of tension as well as action focused shots.


Some more specific nitpicks:

- There's a couple "heat of the moment" plot points, but this is a shounen, so you have to take that for granted.

- The main cast is quite unlikeable. That is, apart from Todoroki, who is the only enigmatic guy that gets a very good development arc. Our protagonist, together with everyone else, feels very one-dimensional and static. It's kind of ironic how much better the manga becomes when it's NOT about the main cast of characters lol.

- Eri's power is like a wildcard that the mangaka can end up using however he wants to make the manga unpredictable in a cheap way. I'm kind of opposed to it, but he didnt overuse it so it's fine.

- As cool as Star and Stripes is, she comes outta nowhere and feels to me like a big ripple issue stemming from how underutilised the global worldview is. Setting your fantasy shounen manga in the real world presents some real diffculties that are rarely dealt with correctly. In fact, this exact same thing happens in JJK!

- Something interesting to mention is how the anime completely butchers the source material. I had a pretty bad opinion of MHA which I now realise originates from the anime.
It's all in the details. The anime loses all that makes the manga feel cool, such as gritty art or fucked up scenes, and even things like pacing feel slow and tedious. As an example, the small reminders the manga does with character names + quirks are small and painless, but in the anime they are intrusive and eye catching. The animation is also quite subpar, which I noticed is a very weird pattern in anime adaptations, that I'd like to touch upon some other time.

- There's some chapters around the end that feel very rushed and underworked, but it's a very small number in comparison with how long the manga is.
Compared to other mangas that commit this crime ALL throughout, this is not that bad IMO. I guess you really do get quality stuff when your team consists of 6 assistants huh...


Overall, this feels like manga made by a manga reader. This is the case with a lot of mangakas, but in this case it really feels like he knows what shounen readers like to see. Which yea, if you like shounens, this is just right for you.

With all that said, I'm REALLY looking forward to his next work, but I hope he decides on a change of genre. I think he's very proficient at making dark and gritty works, as those are the best parts to come out of this story, and he could definitely cook up something amazing if he decides to embrace that!

7.5

This manga is the biggest pile of hot, steaming garbage I have ever read.
The author manages to fill in 200 chapters with constant pedophilia, rape, violence and countless other fucked up shit.
The comedy is bad, and I cant believe the sort of ideas it fed japanese kids back when it was publishing. How this averages an 8.88 on MAL is beyond me. If you argue it tries to criticise all these fucked up things by making the characters normalise them, you have an enormous copium addiction.
The last couple volumes try so hard to be super philosophical and deep when all it really manages ... to be is stupid and out of place, since it goes completely out of the shitty standard it had set during the 20 volumes prior. The art has nothing special. The plot is uninteresting. The characters are stupid, very one-dimensional and forgotten after their "development" arc. Too uncomfortable to read, aged like shit.
An easy 0/10.

One of the most recently published manga I have read. Calling it unique is an understatement, as I'm not even sure who this appeals to. It has strong shoujo manga tropes, as well as an all-girl lesbian fantasy feel to it, but somehow mixes a religious and psychological backdrop to it all. In fact, the character cast feels like a japanese version of Steven Universe, the setting is very unique and the art is also very refreshing. These are obviously all very good things, but these pros quickly became cons the longer the manga went on for.

- The character cast is too unstable (as ... in characters disappearing, appearing, and changing way too frequently, especially the MC).
- The art quality for this manga is very fucking exhausting, as you get the 1 every 10 chapters fight scene, with admittedly great character design, that is unfortunately very unintelligible (due to the soft shading style that the mangaka went for, together with pure white / pure black backgrounds that make it even more of a mess to decypher). I feel like the art and feel the author was going for would've been way better as an anime original, as the combination of colourful gem characters and paradise-like scenery would make for some insanely lively scenes that just can't be appreciated in black and white.
- Most of the chapters have a very happy go lucky feel to it, with cheery characters and constant :P moments, that take away all the seriousness that the plot was going for.
- About the plot, this felt like an inferior version of Eden: It's an Endless World, and as magical as that manga was to me, this one felt like a lackluster cousin.
- The actual story and big answer to the plot is given halfway throughout the manga as a simple, serious, lore dump conversation, which completely kills all of the mistery and made the idea behind the plot feel unimportant.
- Related to the last point, the Manga is too long for its own good. Most of the stuff that happens is drawn out for way too long. For example, what felt like the "final arc" of the manga, ends up being literally 50% of the length.


Overall, the lack of a real MC, the constant transformation of the entire cast (as well as some characters that only impact the story negatively from the reader point of view), the inconsistent art quality, as well as the ending hiding such a strong niche buddhism lore dump, ended up mortally wounding what could've been one of the most unique mangas of the decade.

DISCLAIMER: (Romance and slice of life is not my cup of tea, but I gave this a fair chance regardless.)
This is a comedy, school drama, fictional, romance story. The cast is composed by 2 male characters and around 6 female, of which the male that isnt the MC gets screentime in around a third of the episodes (and no development whatsoever). The episodes are structured in pairs, functioning as miniature character arcs that develop each girl in the cast, starting with the MC's girlfriend. The anime mixes in clear fantasy into the story, causing the characters to get affected by supernatural phenomena that can't be ... explained (even though they throw random science jergo at each problem, trying to "justify" it). These phenomena range from a girl becoming invisible to anyone but the MC, or a girl splitting into two clones of herself, each with a different ego. There's also a very prominent comedy aspect that the series takes that I dislike. The girlfriend's behaviour is a perfect example of this, or the mc's little sister saying some pretty questionable stuff. Luckily there isn't much fan service in the form of oversexualization of the cast, apart from the initial skits with the bunny suit.
Now that I have properly explained the basics, I can list out the main pros and cons:

+ It's short.
+ Well animated.
+ Good OST.
+ Despite what one may think, it's actually fairly serious.

- It's too short for its own good. Despite me liking short anime, I think this one doesnt benefit from it, since the girls get picked up and abandonded after their one (and only) 2 episode long development.
- The comedy is overdone, repetitive and unfunny (It made me chuckle around 4 times in the span of 4 hours and a half of screentime).
- The "romance" aspect of the anime gets resolved in the first 2 episodes, from where it basically becomes a slice of life.
- The cast is unlikeable. The girls range from socially inept to attention hoarders to "I'm not like other girls" motif.
So, this leaves us with an anime that I believe to be indecisive with what it wants to do, which is an unluckily common fault in the industry.
- It lacks a real romance story factor that is achieved in a much better and simpler fashion in classic anime romance movies.
- It lacks good character writing, since most of them can be simplified down to one core problem they have faced or are facing.
- The supernatural part of the story ends up feeling very out of place and just non-sensical, a story like this would've benefit much more from a down-to-earth approach.
- It's a shame, but it follows many of the tropes I dislike in anime, such as scenes that add nothing to the story and characters, cringe interactions, or just plain out of touch shit.

All in all, even though it's trying to convey some very clear and important life messages, such as the usual be kind to your neighbour, it does so in a way that doesnt feel impactful, through characters that don't get enough time to feel whole, since a lot of the screentime is spent on unfunny comedy and boring slice of life portions.
(5 = average, NOT bad)