Back to camay1997's Profile camay1997's Profile

On the positive I binge watched it in three days, so it's not so bad as to be deemed unwatchable. But I have a lot of issues that stem from the characters themselves. Nina & Subaru are the only characters that seem to have any depth to them while the other three come across as repeating cliche. For example, Tomo is tsundere and there's no aspect of her character beyond that. Rupa is nothing more than a cheerleader encouraging the others to do their best, while ignoring her tragic backstory. If Subaru has any character outside of her Grandma story feel free to let me ... know. But the one thing that bugged about this show more than anything is this show's concept of conflict. Every conflict can be summed up as "Nina throws a temper tantrum until everyone else in the group agrees with her." Yes I understand her youthful enthusiasm but her naivety makes her condescending. She doesn't want Momoka to keep sing because she thinks she's great, but rather what her quitting does to Nina's world view. "Keep singing because otherwise I'll kill myself. Let's form a band or I might kill myself." Then there's the whole conflict with her family which simply acquiesced to her whims with no consequences. This anime sums up why no one values the opinions of teenage girls. Here's where I mention the animation looks worse than RWBY vol 5. The characters are stiff and lack fluid motion. For a series with no action scenes I expect it to look better.

TL:DR - Watch Bocchi The Rock and/or Nana instead. both do a better job than this does

Everything is good: The score, animation, characters, story, world building and the design are all top notch. My low score is a reflection of the overwhelming problem, I've seen the original anime adaptation. Which makes Stampede a different road to locations I've already been. So, if you watched and enjoyed the original anime, I have no real reason to recommend this one. But if you hadn't seen it, this is a great show for sci fi fans. Another issue is the show has elements of sexism that the modern audience will find off putting. It's a remake of a good show different enough to justify ... watching yet also similar enough to not recommend.

Well, I liked the characters designs, it was easy to identify and distinguish between the characters. Also I loved the adult content, there isn't enough sex and ultra violence anime anime these days. I also like the setting, cyberpunk was my second favorite genre of Japanimation if you catch my meaning. The world they built is okay. Visually it's nothing to rave about, and the only time the backgrounds shine is when they're out side the urban areas. I almost love this anime. What doesn't work is it's pacing. The time jumps between episodes and non-linear storytelling towards the end make this feel like I'm ... watching the cutscenes from a video game I never played. Another then that bugged me was too many animation shortcuts, too many scenes of dialogue over a slowly panning background. Too many scenes of idle characters talking with their backs to the camera to masked Kiwi. Would I watch it again? Eventually. Would I buy it? No, that's why it's seven out of ten

Let me start by saying I liked the character designs. It was easy to distinguish each character. I had no problem with animation quality or voice acting. What I did not like about this show is its episode count. When the show ends with there were further adventures and the show isn't guaranteed to showcase those adventures, then the show barely told a complete story. Like it's literally 8 episodes leading up to one battle and two episodes of a flashback to a previous battle that inspires this battle. This show is why actually watching your main character train and train and train doesn't pay ... off.

The show is 14 years old when I completed it, so I won't dwell on animation, design or sound. Suffice to say they do not suck. Also, I'm assuming the show's reputation proceeds itself, so no need for trigger warnings and disclaimers. Instead I want to focus on what I didn't like about the show because I love over the top raunchy adult humor and the show is nothing but that and it delivers. My issue is the show just feels juvenile with the literal potty humor and random profanity, like it was made by 12 year olds for 12 year olds. It brings back ... memories of being a kid watching something and hoping your parents don't walk in. Memories, that's all they are though. As a grown adult the effect is lost. That's why I wasn't keen on the show when it first came out, I was a grown adult back then. Fans of South Park will love it, the more sophisticated not so much.

Okay, let's start by stating the obvious, it's very pretty in terms of art, style, backgrounds and characters. It is animated well and the action is engrossing. Like you're on the battlefield witnessing this. World building is so/so, meaning sci Fi fans will get it but those with questions won't get answers. How do these gladiator types differ from other neans? How do they differ from each other? Why do their weapons and abilities differ? No answers coming. I also want to say that the big red flag is the best bits of animation are used on the opening. The characters are all single mind ... and lack any kind of depth save Naomi and the detective. Any and all other depth and substance is destroyed by the last episode. This is where the show falls apart. The problem with the Puppet master reveal is there were only two possible suspects. The revelation of their lack of autonomy destroys every nuance of the question, "What is freewill?" we asked for the previous 12 episodes. The final battle ends in the most predictable fashion followed by a chance at a second season to build upon. Only to be faked out because this doesn't deserve a second season.

A good anime ruined by pointless melodrama
I liked the characters and design. They all seem unique and likable. Animation, sound, voice acting and music are on or above par. No the problem is the story outside the cafe and esports. No spoilers but isn't the drama of using esports to save the cafe enough? Couldn't that be built upon? Yuu's drama could've been solved with one adult conversation and/or a few social media posts. Who wrote this? The esports portion is fine, but the rest of it feels added on for the sake of building drama, that still takes a backseat to the esport.

I liked the world, and world building. Particularly the concept of forbidden skills and the persecution that comes with it. I can relate to that as a POC who follows non traditional religious beliefs, and persecuted for it. The big issue is Fate is the most over powered MC I have ever seen. Not just his gluttony skill, that's cool, I meant Greed's various forms and powers. It's so ridiculous that I had to check to see if this was based on a video game. None of the characters are likable or memorable save Fate. There isn't much of a story, the action becomes ... pointless when Greed is just a transformation from victory and the lore behind the deadly skills is ignored. The worst part is the end because nothing is presented that even suggests it could end any other way. Watch Redo of Healer instead.

What I liked is the superior art and animation to the original. When I watched the original I was disappointed the art and animation didn't measure up to Samurai X's. That alone was my primary reason for wanting to watching this. Kenshin and his morale code and backstory make him a character you can understand even if you don't identify with him. It's a question we all have to deal with, "Should you never kill people, even if they deserve it?" This is combined with the villains and their motives giving us the viewers the chance to empathize or not with them. Always asking the ... same question, do they deserve to die? Us the viewers and the characters have to ask this question every time. Also, I expected a more streamlined, less filler version this time.
Speaking of the characters, the rest of the main cast are one note chard board cut outs. Yahiko is always yelling and defiant, Sannosuke is always brawling and drinking, the rest are even less memorable. My biggest issue is this show requires a desire to learn about Japanese history to be truly enjoyed; or at least an intimate awareness of it. If history isn't your thing, this might not be the series for you. My last issue is, if you genuinely enjoyed the original version, I can give you no real reason to watch this.
In conclusion, I loved it for the visual upgrade from the original, but but it's a bit of a history lesson. And if you loved the original, there's no need to watch this

I liked the characters, they are all socially awkward and imperfect. That makes them relatable to me and human. There's a depth to these characters that makes the tragedy of Miyo's life all the more heartbreaking. The story is complex with twists and turns that keep the viewer guessing. I like that because predictable stories make something not worth watching. It is hard provide examples how such, as it'll create spoilers that would ruin the series. What I can say is that Miyo's constant Self-deprecation will resonate with some viewers who can relate to being made to feel worthless and unneeded. Kudo is a ... set in his ways authoritarian who should be relatable to private people who favor routines and schedules. Neither are presented as faults, but rather part of their characters. The message is that is is okay to be you, a unique individual.
The problem with this series is the last three episodes. It's cliched and predicable. It sets up an inevitable conclusion and then everything falls into place and it's sad.