Back to StrawbryMilk's Profile StrawbryMilk's Profile

Seeing these reviews, I had to give my own. So I went into Black Clover almost completely blind, besides knowing the synopsis. I'm not too involved in the anime community despite being an avid reader of manga, so I hadn't heard anything about Black Clover prior to reading it.
Anyway, I did enjoy this manga. Yet after having its flaws/cliches pointed out to me, I could no longer ignore them, which is why it does not have an overly high score from me.

Story: 5/10
The story is kind of original. It's original in the sense that I haven't read a manga written about magic yet. In saying ... that, it gives me 'extremely toned down' Berserk vibes.
However, this gets the 'fair' rating because it's extremely cliche. Main character wants to be the best at something, check. Many love interests, check. Overpowered, unique ability that shocks all the bad guys, check. Hardly any character development besides 'I hit things with my big sword', check. Main character is more morally righteous than any other character, check. It's just mediocre. I did find myself on the edge of my seat or cheering on the characters, waiting for what's next at times, so it's not all bad. That being said, the fights can be extremely predictable. At times, the story can feel rushed too.

Art: 7/10
The art is nice and consistent. Not too much to say on this front, but it does work nicely for this manga.

Characters: 5/10
Like I said above, pretty run of the mill. I do see what people are saying about it being a rip-off of Naruto, too. But yeah, pretty bland. Personally, I hate the typical tsundere love interest, which is definitely present in Black Clover. I would have liked to see a bit more originality rather than 'idiot protagonist' and 'smart, naturally talented rival'. In saying that, I did quite enjoy Yami - the Captain of the Black Bull - in particular, despite he himself having some cliches.

Enjoyment: 7/10
Still enjoyable, if you can look past the cliches like I did. I only really took a lot of notice of them once someone pointed it out. It's a great time waster.

Overall: 6/10
I, in no way, think this is worthy of a 3/10, like so many people appear to be giving it. It's just... average. But I feel like the Art kind of gives it a bit of redemption from just a 5/10, and if you ignore the cliches, it's pretty enjoyable. Overall, its not the worst, yet far from the best.