If you liked
Hidan no Aria
|
...then you might like
Sakura-sou no Pet na Kanojo
|
Both male protagonists have more than one girl going for them in the series (although I wouldn't consider either of them to be "serious" harem by any means), and at least one of those girls in both series shows their love for the protagonist in creepy, overbearing ways and demonstrates extraordinary skill in a certain area - although Sakurasou probably pulls this off without being as cliché or unrealistic.
If you liked
Ookami to Koushinryou
|
...then you might like
Sakura-sou no Pet na Kanojo
|
Although the atmosphere and setting are hardly similar, both series start out with a male protagonist having a strange encounter with an eccentric girl, and having to live with, take care of, and overcome hardships with (or relating to) said girl throughout the anime. The girls in both series are both often called out for their differences by everyone else, and are highly revered for their unique qualities.
If you liked
Sword Art Online
|
...then you might like
Choujigen Game Neptune The Animation
|
SAO attempts to pass itself off as having a serious plotline with an added romance aspect, while Neptune is much more lighthearted. However, both series share a similar atmosphere in a game-inspired, futuristic universe, and characters in both series are often seen fighting off monsters and other enemies with swords, spells, etc.