- Last OnlineYesterday, 1:48 PM
- GenderFemale
- BirthdayApr 15, 2003
- JoinedApr 10, 2022
Fantasy Anime League MAL×entine Secret Santa Exchange MAL Bunkasai Attendee 20th Anniversary MALoween Mansion (Candy Hoarder) Fantasy Anime League A Bookworm's Haven
Also Available at
RSS Feeds
|
Apr 5, 2025
I feel the need to write a review after quite enjoying this short--I think the rating it has is much too harsh!
I certainly see the critique on the story being underexplained, but I think that's a given when something has a runtime of only 26 mins (3 of which are the ending theme). For the runtime, I think it actually did fairly well to create a cohesive (if vague) storyline with decently established characters--though, Noruda sadly felt more like a plot device than a character. She didn't have much agency in the story, and I found that to be a great shame.
The setting is fun--the
...
school overnight, just before the cultural festival, led to some funny background conversations and setpieces (such as a giant cardboard monkey).
I think my enjoyment was also helped by my slightly romance/BL-addled brain, as weird as that sounds--hear me out. I know it was completely unintended, but the relationship between the two boys felt romantic in certain points to me, which I think added an extra layer to Saijou's actions regarding Azuma 'leaving him' and being so desperate to help Noruda. My brain turned it into an interesting love triangle, though that says more about me than the short I think (lol). Regardless, it added another layer to the actions of the characters that I enjoyed.
The subtle romance between Azuma and Noruda was also quite cute, though she was sadly very underdeveloped as a character, they had some sweet moments.
The art is the highlight--the animation is smooth and the style is decently unique and very pretty in certain background shots regarding the typhoon. It made the whole short enjoyable to watch purely on an aesthetic level. The characters designs also had that great balance of simple but effective that I personally always really love. Mildly, I am reminded of Mamoru Hosada's work, and Evangelion.
Overall, this is an enjoyable little short, despite having an underdeveloped plot.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 12, 2025
One word immediately came to mind once I'd finished this manga: Beautiful.
This is the simple story of an unlikely friendship between a lonely girl and an old painter, as they think about the world and how it moves around them.
I love the art direction of the story, wherein the old man's memories are intercut with the present day story, and hold a more traditionally painted style--with graphite texture, sketch lines, and so forth. Not only does this work to distinguish them when they overlap, but also beautifully depicts the feeling of distant memories, how they become less tightly formed and hazier the older they get.
The
...
manga is only 14 chapters long, so please give it a read when you're next in the mood for something bittersweet and gentle--I promise it will be worth your time!
Reviewer’s Rating: 10
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 10, 2025
A beautiful set of stories, full of reflection and a soft feeling--despite some sad moments.
The first five are interconnected stories about Ruka, and his feelings at different points of his life. I really enjoyed how accurately every stage was portrayed, from an infant to a young adult. The characters thoughts, feelings, and actions felt so remarkably accurate that they brought up my own similar memories!
The last two stand on their own, one a bittersweet romance, the other about two siblings. Simlar to Ruka's stories, they have a charmingly soft introspective feeling.
To top it all off, the artstyle is very strong--someone realistic feeling, with a softness
...
to match the stories. In particular, I thought the final oneshot had some beautiful pages.
Highly reccomend giving these little stories a read, especially if you are in the mood for something emotional, yet calming.
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 16, 2025
This was a bit of a shame! I feel if this same concept was applied to a longer series, even just a full length movie, it had the potential to be a solid 7/8 star Sci-Fi Romance.
The ideas, story, and characters were promising, but either never developed beyond initial introduction, or were rushed due to the short run-time. For example--the main girls friend who appears at the start... there are a few scenes with her, and they all felt very pointless! I understand what they were trying to accomplish with the character, but it didn't feel neccessary when there was so little time to tell
...
the story. I wish they had been removed and the time had been spent on our central romance instead.
The romance had a nice plot, but again it was crunched down to feeling almost abrupt with how quickly the characters relationship developed, giving the climax a lacking feeling as the emotional set-up for it to feel impactful was not there.
The biggest plus, however, was the art--I really like the style and found it quite unique. The characters had a realistic look and feeling that I personally enjoy, and the backgrounds are well-painted.
I think it was a nice enough watch, if a little confusing in parts, but would have been alot better as a full-length movie/series.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 6, 2025
This manga felt like reading an abridged version of a longer story, in that every element of the plot is touched on very lightly, and/or resolved near-instantly. Character arcs are also similarly sped through, and their depth is only really alluded to. Some characters who seemed set up to be important new friends for our MC ended up only appearing in one-or-two chapters, with no relationship development despite it being set up... I wouldn't be surprised if the manga was cancelled at some point despite not being marked as such.
The art was very pretty, along with the character designs which were all fairly unique and
...
fun--I particularly like Tsukie, who has little Roses for her buns.
Overall the manga is an easy, quick, and enjoyable enough read, but will likely leave you wishing you got a longer version of the story that took the time to fully explore its characters, world, and plot elements.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 2, 2025
A lovely collection of stories, capturing many emotions surrounding love!
The main story, Mashikaku Rock, had a compelling set of protagonists. I love the main girls journey as she learns to live for herself. I appreciated that not only is her romance highlighted, but also her friendship with the third bandmate.
The second story made me cry, and was my personal favourite. A really poignant reflection on missed opportunities and dealing with it being too late, as a boy thinks about his seatmate--who he never spoke to or learned the name of--who died.
The third story was an exploration of a childhood friend love triangle, and explored unrequited
...
love and how it can affect friendships. I thought this one was sweet, and again had a compelling trio at the forefront.
And finally, the last story was just plain adorable.
Overall, I really reccommend this manga as a nice collection of romantic tales all headed by compelling protagonists and love interests!
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 2, 2025
This film is wonderful!
A slow paced slice-of-life, with a love story running through it, this film was just a joy to watch.
Firstly--the visuals are stunning, with use of vibrant colours that are well crafted to be complimentary and make things, well, pop! The animation is nice, fluid in places although many shots are also quite still. I think the backgrounds are 3D greasepencil, they mesh well with the 2D elements and again bring a unique look and feeling to the film!
The character designs are similarly unique and fun, especially our female lead Smile.
Speaking of her, I was initially worried that the 'streamer' aspect of her
...
character would be handled pourly, or be somewhat annoying to watch, but I think it was incorporated really well and didn't overstay it's welcome in scenes. She was a fun protagonist to follow, with a relatable struggle about appearance and embracing yourself that I found very lovely to watch.
Cherry, our male lead, also has a compelling arc about finding your voice and expressing yourself. The two arcs are weaved nicely together to create a compelling and sweet romance.
The story is slow-paced in a good way, just enough to keep you engaged while unfurling in a relaxed manner before ramping up for the climax at the end. I personally love slow-paced SOL stories, and think this is among the best of them! If you prefer faster-paced anime, it may not be for you, however.
Overall, this is a wonderfully compelling slice-of-life romance with a unique visual flair that makes it fun to watch, with a compelling cast and story--and I highly recommend it to those looking for a slow, cute, and visually compelling experience!
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jan 2, 2025
This anime was very stupid. I mean that positively!
A series of 3-minute funny shorts about three girls, this anime accomplishes what it sets out to be (silly, fun, and easy-to-watch) very well.
The animation was nice, fairly smooth, and the artstyle has a cute and fun feeling that matches the series nicely. The girls designs were nothing unique, but I didn't mind--they were easy to distinguish and suited their personalities.
The voice acting was notably good too, feeling very natural and pleasant to listen to, which was a nice bonus!
If you just watched a depressing anime, or are feeling low, I reccomending watching Aiura! Its a fun
...
little mood-boosting anime, with a surprisingly sweet final episode to round things off with a nice warm feeling as well.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Dec 27, 2024
A five-minute short drama made to motivate exam students, so it's a little hard to review! It feels like a trailer/clip compilation for a hard-hitting movie that would make you cry; but that's unavoidable. Within its constraints, it has done very well to deliver a compelling little short snippet that feels satisfying in its own right.
The style and animation are nice, and somewhat unique! I love the use of lighting and colour in particular.
Overall, worth a watch as it is a short and sweet little drama. Personally, it worked well as an advert for the studio as it makes me want to watch something full-length
...
from them!
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Dec 27, 2024
‘Stardust Telepath’ is a fairly rudimentary CGDCT Club Anime, centering around the rather unique concept of rocket building.
The long and short of this review is that I think it is a decent watch, but doesn’t do anything mind-blowing—rather, it seems a little bit hesitant to. Overall, I think that this show would’ve benefited if it was more a drama than a comedy, as character arcs that were starting to run deeper were often cut off by jokes or resolved very quickly.
The positive standouts:
- The Club being about rockets was very unique and fun, and I learned a fair bit about something I knew nothing about!
- The artstyle,
...
character designs, and animation are very very good—I love the hair design and movement in particular. This was definitely a highlight, and I love the aesthetic of night skies and stars, which appears a lot too!
- The OP and ED are catchy and pretty songs, with good visuals to match them.
- Haruno threatened to become deeply interesting—though unfortunately the show seemed hesitant to delve into it too much—as the typical ‘Mum Friend’ turns out to be deeply insecure in a way I found quite unique. She was certainly my favourite and I really enjoyed her, especially in the last few episodes!
- The main girls would be a cute couple, I wish it was actually a GL instead of just implying/teasing it! But I liked their relationship. Silly cutie pies!
The negatives:
- Raimon. Okay, okay, I’ll admit I tend to dislike the tsundere/harsh-but-secretly-soft characters in general; but I tend to love them when they develop and grow. She didn’t really in my opinion, and the narrative justified her actions far more than it should have. She is quite melodramatic about several situations and lashes out, but the show doesn’t do enough to explain WHY (it does explain a bit, but I found it quite surface level and not enough to warm me to her). I honestly found myself just wanting the other characters to leave her and move on at some points, as she had never been kind enough to any of them for me to believe in their friendship and want them all back together again. I think she is the main thing that would’ve benefited from a drama-focus again because she had many interesting ideas within her that just weren’t given the right timing or weighting within the narrative.
- The main character is a mix of positive and negative… I think she would’ve been great had her panic attacks been portrayed more realistically. I think she was hit by the common curse on anime girls on having to be ‘cute’ first, characters second (barf). She had to be anxious in a way that was still ‘moe’ to fit the show, and I think that weighed her down and made her annoying at some points. Almost every line being stuttery and having her blushing… was a bit much lol. However, as an anxious girlie myself, I still found some moments relatable and well done. Overall, she’s a decent protagonist.
- In general, I think the show would’ve been better as a drama than a more comedic one, because the characters often threatened more depth than they were ultimately given to explore. I think the concepts would’ve felt more complete and fulfilled given more time to focus on them, dissect them, and more intricately interweave them beyond the girls just having a mutual goal. Many character moments were punctuated by a joke, or resolved lightheartedly, when I feel they could’ve been very impactful and interesting had they instead gone deeper, taken longer, etc. (and I say this as a massive 4-koma comedy fan!) I understand it is based on a 4-Koma manga, though, so I do understand why it felt this way writing-wise from the original formatting.
So yeah. It’s a decent anime that I feel could’ve gone further, but still serves as a cute little watch with some fun moments and very pretty animation. If you like CGDCT, I think you’ll like it, but I don’t think it is a stand-out of the genre. But, well, not every anime has to be!
7/10!
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|