If you liked
Ao Haru Ride
|
...then you might like
Orange
|
In my opinion Ao Haru Ride is a straight-up better version of Orange. There's none of the time-travel, which I guess is really the entire plot, but Murao is basically a shy Chino, Kominato is a better Suwa, and Kou is a better Kakeru. Some characters are practically identical. Yoshioka, though, is very different from Naho - she's not really shy at all. Warning, though, Ao Haru Ride isn't conclusive unless you read the manga (which I recommend, but the anime is great on its own)
If you liked
Toradora!
|
...then you might like
Golden Time
|
Koko and Taiga are very similar - overly bossy and controlling while violent and aggressive only toward the person they like. With Golden Time though, it's set in university, and Tada Banri makes a massive difference to the story
If you liked
Fruits Basket
|
...then you might like
Kamisama Hajimemashita
|
They're both reverse harems that revolve around the concept of the zodiac animals. I personally prefer Kamisama Kiss - I find Nanami much more likeable and cute than Tohru
If you liked
Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu
|
...then you might like
Seishun Buta Yarou wa Bunny Girl Senpai no Yume wo Minai
|
Psychological but light-hearted. Both have a kind of harem but with a clear emphasis on one particular girl. They do adolescence syndrome and kind of supernatural things happen whilst going unnoticed by others, I guess? It's hard to explain, but these two shows are amazingly similar and I personally love them both.