May 27, 2013
I once read that all anime (and manga by extension) is derivative. This shouldn't be shocking for most anime fans, as often times they will see the same plot points and character types get recycled and re-interpreted again and again. So, it should come as no surprise that K: Stray Dog Story is a derivative work. Yet, I'll go even further to say that K:SDS is a derivative of a derivative of a derivative- there is a lot you have to understand about the world of K and the world of anime and manga before you can fully enjoy this manga.
...
Likewise, this manga doesn't function as a stand-alone story very well. Even though it acts as a prequel to the anime series K, it doesn't provide much information on the world of K, so readers new to the series will probably be very lost. However, it makes up for this with a very straightforward plot. The story centers around a wandering, modern samurai named Kuroh who embarks on a journey to carry out his late master's final wish. Throughout the story, he rescues people in distress, occasionally using a weird hand power that's never really explained. There's really no feeling of distress in any of the situations he's in because Kuroh seems to possess a set of elite skills far beyond that of any of his adversaries. While the plot is easy to follow, the simplicity of it drags this manga down into mediocrity. Even high speed chases and cooking battles can't hide the fact that the story is bland at best.
However, if you interpret K as a derivative work, you're in for a few surprises. In a way, this is a parody of the samurai genre as well as the fujoshi genre. There are a handful of action genre clichés it makes look over the top (and thus pokes fun at) and there's even a thinly veiled allusion to a certain voice actor's previous work. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that the K series functions brilliantly as a derivative work because it's so obviously a conglomeration of popular archetypes and tropes that have come before it, and this manga is no exception. This is why people new to anime and manga will not quite enjoy this story, or get all the references it makes, the same way as people familiar to the anime/manga scene of the late 00's will.
Yet, those wanting more from the world of K will likely be disappointed with this story as well. First of all, the drawings do not have the same crisp and stylish quality that one has come to expect from the series. The art is subpar at best, though not terrible. As well, the world of the manga seems less technologically advanced than the one in the show, almost as if the two take place in different universes (which probably was not the intention). Still, perhaps the only way this manga does expand K's world is by giving Kuroh his time in the limelight. While he is not the most complex of characters, he is charming and this story serves to flesh him out a bit more.
Reading K: Stray Dog Story straight or at face value will probably leave a vast majority disappointed. The real joy about this manga comes from knowing the genres surrounding it. If you enjoy K because of the fact that it seems aware of the demographic its catering to, then you'll probably enjoy this. If not, then this is a manga probably not worth picking up.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
