Maker Hikoushiki Hatsune Mix
Unofficial Hatsune Miku Mix

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

This is how I got in to Vocaloid. It is a bunch of small stories of the Vocaloids from Crypton Future Media, it features the Original artist of the official art of Miku, Rin, Len, and Luka. The story has, Miku, rin, len, Luka, Kaito and Meiko. (Although Kaito is called Onii-san and Meiko is called Onee-san for some reason.) The personalities of the Vocaloids come from what a lot of people think of the Vocaloids to be especially the personality stereotypes of the early days of Vocaloid. (Except Len, because if that was the case this manga would rated 17+ at least lol.) Examples ... are Meiko is a Drunk and Kaito is an idiot who likes Ice cream. There are a lot to reference to songs as well, as an example I believe Magnet is referenced at one point. There are some other charicters who make an appearance as well, Gackpo makes an appearance as well as the fanaloids, hachune Miku, Neru, and Haku. You can tell the people working on this manga were having fun. It's not supposed to be taken seriously at all. It's just something for Vocaloid fans to enjoy

One thing you should know about me before writing this review- I am a big vocal synth fan, as may be expected, as a lot of manga/anime fans are, I've found. My favourite of all time is Hatsune Miku, the main mascot of Crypton, one of the main contributors to the vocal synth community, and she's a cultural icon at this point. I'm even going to Miku Expo London in October of this year and I believe she's the most prominent character out of all of my merch collections. I've been a fan for about 3 years, for reference. So, after a bit of background ... on me, it's time for the review.

Maker Hikoushiki Hatsune Mix, or Unofficial Hatsune Mix, as it's called in Western countries, is a collection of, well, collections, of short stories that were originally released very early on in Miku's reign, throughought 2007 and 2008. They were drawn and written by KEI, who is definetly the most influential artist in the vocal synth community, being the creator of the at this point, iconic official PNGs for the Cryptonloids. The stories follow the Cryptonloids going through their daily lives and just general silly antics. My general opinion on the collection is quite mixed for several reasons, so let's start with the pros and why you should give it a try.

• Some of the pages in the book are made up of these gorgeous official arts that come up after each collection of stories. They're in full colour, and, in my opinion, really show the best of KEI's iconic late-2000s artstyle, with at least one of them depicting each of the Cryptonloids. If you wanted to, you could cut them out of the book and make some amazing posters out of them, because, believe me, most, if not all of KEI's serious pieces are absolutely gorgeous.
• The stories absolutely get across the different universes that can be created with the help of vocal synths. Not being limited to a singular universe where the characters have a certain age or personality type is a really interesting feature of this collection that I absolutely love. It's an absolute haven for anyone who happens to be a Cryptonloid multishipper, and is an absolute beast at proving those 'Miku is 16, you know!' and 'That can't be ___, they act/look different!' TikTok people wrong to a point.
• My favourite stories were Working Mix, Chibi Mix, Celebrity Mix, Matsuri Mix, Sports Day Mix, Miko Mix, and the really interestingly illustrated extra story, Miku Goes To Sega, which uses real pictures of buildings and gameplay as essentially a cutely illustrated ad for the at-the-time upcoming Project Diva Arcade, which, by the way, and partly due to this side story, I'd love to play someday.
• I loved the cameos of other characters like Gakupo, Neru, and Haku! Gakupo and Haku were probably my favourite characters in the entire collection when they appeared. I also found it quite funny that they couldn't be named, Gakupo DEFINETLY due to copyright and all that (his voice being provided by GACKT and all), and the others probably for a similar reason.

Well, those are the main points I enjoyed with Unofficial Hatsune Mix. Now let's move onto the cons...or rather, the singular con.
• For a lighthearted comedy series, there are some very questionable themes that might leave some readers feeling kind of, a little bit, creeped out. Obviously the stories are supposed to be bizarre and out of context, but there were two running 'gags' that I found to be a bit...wrong??? One of these was the weirdly persistent theme of KAITO being absolutely DECIMATED by pretty much all of the others characters. Like, full on abused. Yes, in the silly Vocaloid manga. He's stupid, and so he gets beaten up in every story he's featured in, I think. Obviously there's nothing wrong with dark humour, but I don't like the way that it's presented as just something to be laughed at. Haha, man gets violently beat by woman. The collection itself is pretty funny, don't get me wrong. I just found KAITO's whole gag a bit odd, and leaning towards a bad kind of odd.
The other theme I wanted to touch on was Miku's constant desperation throughout the separate realities to be/look more mature. Obviously, she's presented as a 16-year-old almost all of the time, and wanting to look more 'appealing' or adult-like is, like, the most normal thing ever for that age. But I feel like it's pushed to a bit of a creepy level, especially as this whole aspect of her character is devoted entirely to her wanting a more adult-like physique. This personality trait as a whole is never presented well in manga/anime, and Unofficial Hatsune Mix is no different.
So, that's my read-at-your-own-risk list. Now, for my general opinion.

I think, if you're a vocal synth (especially Cryptonloid) fan, you should take the time to read Unofficial Hatsune Mix. Most of it is cute, it's got a generally nice artstyle, and there's plenty of silly moments that are worth the read. It is on the pricier side, but there's plenty of stories to get through, and if you read manga more casually, like I generally do, then you'll be on it for a couple of days (I'm pretty sure it took me 2 days to finish???). If you want to get into Vocaloid and this is your first opportunity, I would tell you to read it, as well. But, if you know nothing about Vocaloid and have no interest in it, definetly skip it. It's not the best manga in the world- I'd rank it at around mid on a tierlist- but it's fun to pick up every once in a while and flick through. I hope my little review helped you decide or gave you some insight, and look out for my other stuff in the future. Thanks for reading! [○_○]
~ Pheonix

Story -3-
The manga attempts to do a new story each chapter. There are mangas that can do this well, but this is not one of them, each story was half baked and never really followed a real story line. A repeat story within the manga was always that the main Vocaloids, Miku, Rin and Len, were always broke. One of the recycled plots was the three of them attempting to make money in different ways, only to gather just enough money for the concert that they wanted to have, but surprise, the money is used for Meiko and Kaito’s concert. The characters were always just ... all thrown in so they could all be there, there were one or two good stories, but they were far and few in between. Even the good stories tended to have recycled plots, as the good chapters often focused on the characters developing slightly as a person. The stories also had the feeling that they were just thrown in so that you could laugh at the characters or feel bad for them. For mangas that do a new story for each chapter, the chapter needs to be more than a few pages long so that the story can have a clear beginning, middle and end, without this the stories are often muddled and leave the reader confused and dissatisfied.

Art -8-
The art in the manga was rather good. Where the story falls flat, the art was able to make the manga at least bearable. The art was also constant; there were no times where the art would feel out of place. The characters were all different from one another, so there was no confusion between them.

Character -4-
I feel as though the characters were a bit underdeveloped, much like the stories. Miku was always the ditz, air headed idol, Rin the aggressive little sister, ect. These characters can appeal to many people and they could have worked better within the manga, but how they were presented made them very unappealing and made the characters feel as though they were simple stock characters, and in other words severely underdeveloped. The vocaloid characters are known, and they are known as somewhat like stock characters, but there is a way to make them feel as though they are more of original ideas. There is potential in the characters, they just need to be more thought out, they are currently more of a frame-work rather than a full character.

Enjoyment -2-
I did not enjoy the manga, because of the frame-work characters and the frantic stories. I found myself rushing to finish the manga just to be done with it, wanting to move onto a different manga. The art work was good and the one or two good stories that I would find every so often saved this from being a 1, but beyond that, I could not find myself enjoying the manga. I feel that if KEI had spent more time making the stories and more time making the characters a bit more realistic, than this manga would have had a lot more enjoyment in it.

Overall -4.25-
This manga feels as though it was someone’s attempt to try and make some money due to Miku’s popularity. If you see the manga for sale, I would not recommend one to buy it, rather try to find it online if you’re that interested in reading it. If you want to see the art work and try to study from it, again find it online, it is not worth the money that is asked for it. There are other mangas that do the one story per chapter better and have the same characters throughout the entire story line, such as Orenchi no Furo Jijou.