If you were given a second chance, if you could live your life over, how would you live it? What would you do differently? Could you (and should you) change the flow of events that had transpired?
Fiction has always been fond of time travel. There have been numerous, some more, some less successful, attempts at exploring this concept. It is a potent theme that has tickled the imagination of many and to which many writers turn to. One of those writers is the author of Harukana Machi-E.
One may rightfully ask whether Harukana Machi-E can make something noteworthy with a tried and tired concept like this.
...
The answer is, fortunately, a resounding yes.
Actually, I lied there a bit. Harukana is not really about time travel. Don’t let the synopsis fool you, that is not a theme this manga sets to examine. Rather, time travel is a plot device, a means of setting the story in motion and putting the protagonist at a desired time frame.
Coming from the pen of an award-winning mangaka, Taniguchi Jiro, Harukana Machi-E (translated as “A Distant Neighborhood“ in English) brings us a personal story of a middle-aged man, Hiroshi, who, during a visit to his mother’s grave, suddenly gets transported into the past, back to his middle-school days. With his adult consciousness, memories and abilities retained, Hiroshi finds himself in the body of his 14-year old self, 35 years into the past, at a period of a single crucial event that would have a profound influence on his later life. There he begins a journey of reliving and rediscovering his past, people and events. It is also there that, after realizing not everything is unfolding exactly as he remembers, Higuchi faces his big dilemma – should he try and change the past? And if the answer is yes, how could that influence the future?
Despite such a fantastical premise, Harukana Machi-E is very much down-to-earth. There are no crazy time traveling hijinks, no world-changing events, no super powers, no shounen heroes nor villains. Instead, what Harukana provides its audience with is a bittersweet, rather intimate and relatable story of a single person and his family that reads more like a literary work than a standard manga.
The plot is unlikely to keep anyone on the edge of their chair, nervously biting their nails in anticipation since it never tries to be neither bombastic nor groundbreaking. Rather, the story unfolds in a leisurely manner, never using the sense of urgency to force the reader to flip the next page. It gives the reader time to slowly savour the artwork, characters and their interactions, muse on the questions raised by the protagonist’s narration, and, bit by bit, gets sucked into the world of the protagonist’s small Japanese town and its residents.
In a manga like this plot would mean little without well-developed characters. And it is obvious that the author paid special attention to them. From the protagonist to his schoolmates, family and townspeople, Harukana Machi-E’s cast consists of realistic and relatable characters. There is no trace of artificiality; they truly come off as real people you meet every day. As a result, their feelings, interactions and reactions appear natural and believable.
Naturally, the focus is on Hiroshi’s character, but others, especially a couple of his classmates and family members receive a fair share of fleshing out as well. That is an impressive feat to accomplish in only 16 chapters and speaks volumes of the mangaka’s skill.
Looking at the premise, Hiroshi could’ve easily been an annoying, self-pitying protagonist that exasperates the audience. Thankfully, that doesn’t happen. Although often depressed, troubled and selfish, his character never crosses the fine line between being realistic and being obnoxious. Truth be told, the manga does approach the maudlin territory at a couple of occasions, especially when it tries to convey the protagonist's feelings about his mother. However, the author manages to successfully steer away from delving into unpleasant melodrama that would irritate the reader.
Whether intentional or not, Hiroshi’s father, Yoshio, is the one character that the reader may find too distant and hard to understand. His actions, especially towards the end, come off as somewhat unsympathetic and odd. However, he is most likely deliberately portrayed as distant and incomprehensible in order to reflect how the protagonist sees him since the story is, after all, narrated from Hiroshi’s point of view. This becomes even clearer as the story unfolds and we realize that Yoshio plays the role of a foil to Hiroshi, enabling the author to easily contrast the two characters and their life choices.
During the process of weaving Hiroshi's tale, the mangaka doesn't fall into the common pitfall of making the supporting cast too dependent on the protagonist. Instead, while playing their respective roles, most characters in the manga feel as if they have lives of their own, lives that flow with, not because of the main character. The protagonist is at the centre of the story, but is in no way at the centre of its world.
Apart from characters, Harukana Machi-E excels in the art department. Even at first glance, it is apparent that Harukana does not look like the majority of the manga fare. Taniguchi’s art is highly accomplished, crisp and clean. Again, just like it is the case with characters, realism is what makes Harukana’s art work. Taniguchi’s attention to detail in depicting background, whether scenery or urban structures, is impressive and, coupled with careful, movie-like framing, gives the manga near-photographic artwork. Thus, the author succeeds at bringing to life Hiroshi’s small home town of Kurayoshi and, in a way, invites the reader to embark on the journey into the past.
Similarly, the character designs follow the principle of realism as well, while also retaining a very small, but necessary dose of “cartoonism”. Worth mentioning is a certain Ghibli-esque quality to the author’s ability to effortlessly express a wide range of emotions on characters’ faces and this is quite a delight to look at.
Harukana Machi-E examines and explores a variety of themes and issues. The most apparent ones, which even become a sort of a leitmotif, are the themes of regret and loss. They permeate the manga, creating a sweetly melancholic atmosphere. In addition to those, this short manga finds time and space to tackle other, mostly related themes such as grief, frustration, remembrance, acceptance and appreciation. Never trying to be preachy or coming off as pretentious, Harukana naturally, through its characters and their actions, speaks to the reader about the importance of coming to terms with oneself, learning to appreciate and value what one has and accepting the inexorable fleetingness of life.
As perfect as everything said up to now may seem, Harukana, of course, is not impeccable. Although expected and understandable, the rather abrupt ending and resolution may feel anticlimactic and will probably leave some readers with a slight feeling of dissatisfaction. The lack of any explanation regarding the time travel aspect may have a similar effect. However, Harukana never was a story about time traveling, so one can’t really hold this against it.
Its length can be regarded as both a flaw and a strength. Being only two volumes long, it may be argued that Harukana's shortness doesn't allow the manga to fully spread its wings. However, at the same time, it means that the story never loses steam and no scene feels superfluous. “Short but meaningful“ may very well be the rule Taniguchi chose to follow with Harukana.
Personal and down-to-earth in its presentation, distinctively Japanese in execution, yet universal and timeless in themes it explores, Harukana Machi-E is a highly recommended read, especially if you are in search for a mature slice of life drama with believable, relatable characters that is very likely to make you think and reflect on life. Or if you're simply tired and want a breath of fresh air. In that case, I cannot recommend this short manga enough.
Oh, yeah, one more thing… Once you’ve read the manga, I suggest you keep it (unless you’ve borrowed it from a library, in which case you better not). You will probably want to revisit it several years (or decades) down the line when your own childhood and past starts feeling like a part of a distant neighborhood.
Alternative TitlesSynonyms: Harukana Machi-E Japanese: 遥かな町へ More titlesInformationType: Manga
Volumes: 2
Chapters: 16
Status: Finished
Published: Apr 10, 1998 to Nov 25, 1998
Theme:
Time Travel
Demographic:
Seinen
Serialization:
Big Comic Authors:
Taniguchi, Jiro (Story & Art) Statistics Ranked: #8532 2 based on the top manga page. Please note that 'R18+' titles are excluded. Popularity: #874
Members: 22,124
Favorites: 428 Resources | Reviews
Filtered Results: 11 / 11
Sort
Your Feelings Categories May 6, 2013
If you were given a second chance, if you could live your life over, how would you live it? What would you do differently? Could you (and should you) change the flow of events that had transpired?
Fiction has always been fond of time travel. There have been numerous, some more, some less successful, attempts at exploring this concept. It is a potent theme that has tickled the imagination of many and to which many writers turn to. One of those writers is the author of Harukana Machi-E. One may rightfully ask whether Harukana Machi-E can make something noteworthy with a tried and tired concept like this. ... May 17, 2009
This was a very interesting read. It was a story full of heart and heartbreak and realizing who you are.
The story is, in a nutshell, about time travel. I wasn't very attracted to the idea at first, but I'm glad that I chose to read this. The story is carried out in a very literaturical (I don't even think this is a word, but whatever) fashion with Hiroshi narrating through the whole thing. After reading the first few chapters you start seeing the beauty of the story. The art was very different than what I am used to seeing, but very good. The character's emotions really ... Sep 5, 2010
For most of the people on this site, there are probably things in life we all regret. Things we wish we could have done differently if given a second chance. Even as a much younger reader than what the manga was probably targeted at, I can sympathize with the idea of doing things I’ve done in the past differently. Harukana Machi-E (hereby referred to in its English title A Distant Neighborhood) is a story that addresses this deplorable feeling felt by many people around the world, taking an 48 year old man back into a pivotal moment of his youth.
The main character of the story ... Apr 5, 2019
Taniguchi often reads like some of the old impressionistic writers. Form, time, direction all seem to have their own shape; they breathe on their own accord. The world then is distilled down to sensory syllogisms, where truth and fiction really are just extensions of one another. Consequently, all that seems to matter is the continuity of perception and the exaltation of sense, transforming into ephemeral experiences embedded in some forgotten psychology. These are never presented as factual, but as fleeting moments offering glimpses into all that was lost. These stories are appendages of the self: ones that serve to internalize the world and externalize the
...
Nov 16, 2009
I had to wait a few days after finishing Harukana Machi-E before I wrote this review. I just couldn't believe how much I liked this manga. If I had reviewed this manga immediately after I finished it I would have done nothing but rain 10s down upon it. Now that it's sunk in, nothing has changed.
STORY: 10/10 What would you do if you were a 48-year-old man who was visiting your mothers grave. You closed your eyes to pray, and when you opened them you were 14 year old again? But you arn't the only one to suddenly lose 34 years. The world does too. You've ... Apr 28, 2012
The cycle of trials and tribulations is never ending. A few bitter experiences of the past may leave a permanent scar on our life and we often wish to go back into the past, hoping to do things differently that would perhaps prevent the ‘dreadful’ from happening. While it’s usually us who were responsible for our sorrows at one point of time, there were also things that we just couldn’t do anything about and we can’t do anything at this very moment either, and we question ourselves as to why it had to happen. But what if we are somehow given a chance to relive
...
Jul 29, 2011
i think the obvious criticism of this manga would be its brevity. there was scope for a whole lot more. it really gave off the impression that taniguchi had been told by publishers that he needed to wrap it up.
i thought that taniguchi did well in playing a fine balancing act between agreeable formula and some more mature reflections on family life. it was respectable that he didn't go all ecchi with the school life, but i also think that all of the overwrought 'uwaa~ this can't be real...' stuff was a waste of panels. all in all, a bittersweet little package on the realities of ... Apr 29, 2019
Haruka na Machi e is an interesting take on the time travel story. The protagonist, Hiroshi, is a middle-aged man with a wife and children. He misses his stop while coming back from a business trip, and ends up in his childhood neighborhood where he visits the grave of his mother. He ends up falling asleep there, and wakes up in the same place as a child, to the time before his father suddenly left his family without explanation. Upon going home and seeing his whole family together again, Hiroshi makes it his goal to find out why his father abandoned his seemingly perfect and
...
Aug 18, 2018
Haruka na Machi e, to say the least, is an intriguing story about family, regret, and learning about who you truly are. It's a more mature take on the concept of "going back in time", in which the main character isn't a teenager with many hopes and dreams, but a 48 years old man whose life is already far weathered with many ups and downs. Nakahara Hiroshi, now in his 14 years old body but his memory still retained, struggles to decide whether he can change the course of his life, and relive his youth once more.
What's most interesting about the series is certainly the ... Oct 19, 2019
Now, here's my take on time travel stories. Most of them are okay, very few of them are brilliant while others are just trying to jump on the nostalgia bandwagon, sci-fi cart, try to cram many concepts and basically ruin it.
Haruka na Machi e is about a guy who gets transported to the past (his childhood - in particular). That's where all the similarities with other stories I've read end. Here, we don't focus on the time travel bit (I mean in the beginning we have the lead being surprised a lot) nor about how you might encounter your past self (He lives ... Dec 2, 2024
A Distant Neighbourhood – Spoiler Free – Recommended
TLDR Story – 7/10 – 7 x 0.275 = 1,925 Art – 7/10 – 7 x 0.2 = 1,4 Characters – 6/10 – 6 x 0.225 = 1,35 Enjoyment – 8/10 – 8 x 0.3 = 2,4 Total: 7,075 -> 7 Story – 7/10 A Distant Neighbourhood is an interesting manga by Jiro Taniguchi. Its premise is quite simple: a 48-year-old worker, named Hiroshi Nakahara, catches the wrong train and goes back to his hometown. Upon visiting his mother's grave, he falls asleep and wakes up in his former 14-year-old body, although retaining all his memories. He thus returns to school and faces a dilemma: ... |