Mada, Ikiteru

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

This easily became one of my favorite manga (and surely my favorite short manga, although I didn't believe that to be possible) for the sole reason of it's concept (and execution). This manga showcases just how far removed we currently are from anything close to what a natural human is supposed to live like in terms of food, health, lifestyle, relationships and technology (lack thereof), which not only people don't seem to realize (because of brainwashing), but it’s also crucial to the current state of the world and one of the reasons of so many psychological, but especially physical issues that people have these ... days. The main focus of the manga is an old man betrayed by the world who decides to give up on it and him finding satisfaction and a purpose not in the technological advances of the world, nor in money or anything else specific to these times, but in a simple, humble, life in the woods, far removed from jobs, money, people that tell him what to think and what he is "allowed" to do (just like slaves are ordered by their owners).

Even the title is pretty suggestive: "I'm Still Alive" - which characterizes the protags journey in this manga fairly well, seeing as he manages to live and grow old despite trying to use a rope to help himself, having no money and, at first, being homeless in the woods. And through all that, the manga shows how there is no need for money or even a fancy house or apartment in order to live a fulfilling life, just a cabin in the woods built by your own hands while nature provides all the food that is needed in order to survive and thrive: animal meat, organs and blood. Just like that, a story set in the modern world suddenly becomes a story set in prehistoric times, where the mc, while mainly living in the woods, is still bound from time to time to the current world, making for quite the funny and sometimes insightful scenarios and conversations that show just how far removed the protagonist is from the current state of the world, but also his character development.

The protagonist goes from being a wimpy dog of his coworkers and family to becoming a confident, mature, free man that takes his life in his own hands and becomes a man worthy of respect, a hunter that can provide and fight for himself and his freedom (and later on, for someone else), despite living a "new" lifestyle that is sure to get people's looks and critiques (especially irl). Especially in the first quarter, there are a few scenes that highlight the modern insanity that we live in: people OWNING land (although the land is owned by the planet itself), people being conditioned and brainwashed to think a certain way (the protagonist becoming a free thinker, not manipulated by media or "science") and people needing to "prepare" or "cook" food (humans being the only animals that think we need to do that, because we eat seeds, oils, flowers, leaves, grass and animals raised in bad conditions that damage it's quality and our capacity to eat it raw).

Since the second half of the story is kind of hard to tap into without spoiling anything, what I can say is that it perfectly highlights the natural way people used to live in more primitive times and what makes them happy, which sure as hell ain't school achievements or a slave job, but relationships and living free in nature.

The main reason I give this manga only a 7 is just because of it's simplicity and length, while I don't think it subjectively hurts the experience, I do believe a more complex and nuanced take on the subject matter presented in this manga could only benefit it's message.

That's about it for this manga, while it ain't no masterpiece and I don't expect that anyone will have the same respect and appreciation for this work, nor the same enjoyment I felt while reading through it, what I can say is, if anyone read through this, you probably already know if this story does or does not interest you. It's a quick read, so I don't think it's a waste of time even if you happen to be mixed or not enjoy this. I also recommend the sequel, it's very similar to this work, both of which you can find if you look for them.

Review for Mada Ikiteiru, I Am Still Alive.

Story : 6/10
Nothing original. A city dwelling man who lost everything decides to live in the wilderness. But the little challenges he faces over time change him. And that's where it gets interesting.

Character : 8/10
Chara development is the forte in this manga. From a wimpy, weak salaryman to a hardened mountain man, seeing the growth in our protagonist is what brought me the most enjoyment. There's a female character who also goes through a transformative progression, but I don't want to reveal too much of the plot.

We learn more about our hero's family in the 2nd ... volume and it does add a good layer of bittersweet feeling to the story. Again, I don't want to reveal too much or spoil the second volume, which is to me even more emotional.

Art : 7/10
Correct, good. But not exceptional. Could do a bit better, but it does fit the manga and is solid without dipping down at any point.

I would recommend it for a more mature audience. I know I would not have enjoyed this one at 15, but it hits different at 30+.
Also the criticism of man's role in society, the work culture, is a background (though not sufficiently explored) to the story.

7/10 enjoyment overall

I like the premise of this manga, it's not very original but it's a concept that isn't really touched on very frequently in the manga medium.

The idea of an old man down on his luck failing to kill himself and just going feral and finding a new love for life and it's beauty is enjoyable and it reminds me of a very toned down Suicide Island.

However, part way through the story we are introduced a pregnant female character and the twos relationship constantly shifts from paternal to romantic enough times that it ruins the already weak and distasteful character of the mc and ... makes him into a bit of a lecherous codger.

The relationship, to me, just seems groomy in nature and off-putting and while they never do act on it they do get very close and feels like some self insert smut for the authors part which makes it harder for me to like the story.

I feel like anyone who takes issue with gross relationship dynamics will feel the same, regardless it's a decent read and I enjoyed the time I spent reading. Though if it had been any longer I know my opinion on that would shift pretty strongly.