Ani to Imouto no Shitai Shitai Shitai Koto

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

This manga is peak fiction as long as you can overlook the incest. But the name of the manga is Brother and Sister Doing what they want to do so what did you expect? The first reviewer for this manga was clearly confused because it seems he couldn't read a title to understand what he was getting himself into. It's like someone rating the manga Isekai NTR 1/10 because it has NTR. LIKE BRO THAT IS THE POINT. READ THE TITLE

Art: 10/10. The art style is really good and the characters have tangible emotions

Characters: The characters feel real because it passes the good writing litmus ... test. When a character does something wrong it doesn't make you mad at the writer instead it makes you mad at the character because you fully understand why they are the way they are. The characters are people

Storyline: The story is pretty good. It runs on the concept of what happens when a yandere has already corrupted her love target. When you are reading it there is this palpable feeling of dread because you know that all the characters have some screws loose but they are still trying to do their best despite that.

7.1/10


You know the meme of “confused screaming?” Yeah, that’s me during the entire reading session of this manga. Like your everyday incest manga, your moral compass for the day will be broken from each chapter, possibly stacking for the rest of the week. I like to separate incest mangas into two categories: the incest subjects are perverted and are totally trying to bone each other, or the siblings that make jokes and try to be lighthearted. For better or worse, this manga takes the former route, and it f*cking swerves into that route. No matter how off-putting this manga was or should be at times ... with the characters, I couldn’t stop myself from clicking the devil’s tainted “Next Chapter” button.

To start off with, the plot is somehow addicting. You can’t help but want to realize the finished product in the plot line, no matter how nonsensical it is. However, where I sort of “drew a threshold” were the characters’ realism. At first, I thought the characters were somewhat realistic, minus the incest, but as the chapters go, the author forces characters to like or dislike with weird reasoning or explanations. In other words, the characters are not grounded in the manga and often go against their ideology.

This manga definitely appeals to people with a screw loose or kink; as the author best says himself, “Manga is the best because it doesn’t have to be realistic, and you could write about illegal things,” or something like that. If you have the slightest intolerance of incest in stories, your best option might to be erasing your memory of this manga’s existence since you might throw up; however, if you have that one screw loose or don’t care either way, it’s somewhat addicting.


Reading Rankings (Portnoy inspired & A Huang Teizan Original)
10 – God’s penmanship
9 – Must-read. Drop everything else.
8 – Instant bookmark
7 – Entertaining
6 – Good to pass time
5 – Why are you reading this?
4 – Bad.
3 – Typical garbage.
2 – My head hurts.
1 – Retirement is a thought.
0 – “Did they even give you a story?!”

I was dared to give this review. LMAOOOO

3/5 Art
The art was good, nothing notable though. The art's of average quality for a manga.

1/5 Story,
Generic for incest erotica. No soul.

2/5 Characters,
MMC is irredeemable, FMC is deluded. Everyone else literally acts how every other incest erotica characters would act.
...
3/5 Fappability,
I've fapped to worse. A healthy dose of almost-nip-on-booba.

2/5 Personal Enjoyment
Gained nothing from reading it. It was nothing special. At least it didn't mentally hurt me though.

Total: 11/25 or 4.4/10.

TLDR: Would smash Bazett Fraga Mcremitz. ONG ONG GIRLS IN SUITS!!!!
(Seriously though, this is literally every other incest erotica. There are WAY better incest works out there, so if you're really itching for them you can go look at those instead. This doesn't seem like it would be worth anyone's time to read.)

I clicked on this one on a whim, but surprisingly it held my interest from beginning to the end.

This manga begins as an erotic manga with lots of nudity, but a few chapters in the nudity fades into the background and the author focuses on the plot. Our protagonists are siblings who are in love with each other, and honestly their interactions and the reactions of their family and friends to their relationship felt very realistic. The author balances happy and despairing moments perfectly throughout the manga, knowing when and how far to push our male protagonist into the pits of despair.

Acceptance is something that ... doesn't exist in this manga. If anything, the people related to the siblings find them disgusting and don't want want to involve themselves with them, which I appreciate. It's clear that the author isn't trying to defend these kinds of relationships, but is simply focused on writing about a fetish in a realistic way through the display of the internal and external struggles of the leads.

Therefore, if you wanna jerk the turkey you should probably read something else, as the last third of the manga is devoid of adult scenes. But if you want to read something interesting for a couple of hours, then this is definitely not a bad choice.