Manga or Movie?

Nov 3, 9:19 PM

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

210

Is the movie more impactful? Should I read or watch?

Nov 3, 9:37 PM

Chainsaw_Derp

Offline

May 2021

146

They’re both great but I slightly prefer the movie.

You should still experience both tho.

Nov 3, 9:46 PM

Daniel_funes99

Online

Apr 2021

534

well the movie has really good music and good voice acting which imo made it more impactful...

Nov 3, 10:10 PM

ReMightyRon

Offline

Jan 2020

166

I recommend you do both, read and watch.

Nov 3, 11:48 PM

Swin21

Offline

Feb 2021

Movie is a lot better

Nov 4, 12:18 AM

BoyUnderSky

Offline

May 2024

both ...
manga is one shot and movie is short too

manga is really good too so you can do both .
don't need comparison .

like we can compare if manga is big example I want to eat your pancreas which has like ig 10 chapters while movie is for 1 or 2 hours only.

BoyUnderSkyNov 4, 12:28 AM

Nov 4, 3:11 AM

Lonely_Island

Offline

Jul 2020

both. both is good

Nov 4, 3:25 AM

RichRinJin

Offline

Mar 2021

I’ll reaffirm what most people are going to say, do both. It’s not like it’s a few hundred chapters!

Nov 4, 3:58 AM

BipulGamer07

Offline

Mar 2023

210

BoyUnderSky said:
both ...
manga is one shot and movie is short too

manga is really good too so you can do both .
don't need comparison .

like we can compare if manga is big example I want to eat your pancreas which has like ig 10 chapters while movie is for 1 or 2 hours only.

The characters in manga version of IWTEYP look childish which makes the story a lot less impactful imo

Nov 4, 4:57 AM

#10

BoyUnderSky

Offline

May 2024

Reply to BipulGamer07

The characters in manga version of IWTEYP look childish which makes the story a lot less impactful imo

@BipulGamer07 youre right.. I feel same for that

That's why I like movie more than iwteyp manga .. also that's why I said we can compare iwteyp because manga is little big and movie is like one go movie so for that we can compare which would be better to watch or read . But for look back even manga is short so we can read and watch both because both are good.

I've read look back and I really liked that manga that's why I'm yapping lol

Nov 4, 5:01 AM

#11

SorewaKirito

Offline

Nov 2023

254

well what media impacts you most ...That should be it...Both are great...
i prefer Manga cause it had more impact on me...but as a new watcher movie should be a get go

Nov 4, 8:06 AM

#12

Yoshibocchi

Offline

Jun 2024

Movie is more longer and cooler but i sitll like the manga.

Nov 4, 3:27 PM

#13

BLUEBERYyummy

Offline

May 2024

106

MOVIE Athen MANGA

Nov 4, 5:46 PM

#14

jacobizm

Offline

Feb 2022

manga is better imo

Nov 4, 7:00 PM

#15

Uto_

Offline

Sep 2022

Manga, definitely

Nov 4, 11:19 PM

#16

kihel

Lucky★supporter

Offline

Mar 2021

1828

I've seen both the movie and the manga and both were good. However, I feel that the movie is some of its goodness is diminished if you watch it at home on a video streaming service, etc. instead of seeing it in a movie theater.

Nov 5, 2:46 AM

#17

MoNotromatic

Offline

Jan 2023

Both. Absolutely both. The manga is only 144 pages, and the movie doesn't even break the 60 minute mark. You can finish both in under 2 hours.

Nov 5, 5:23 AM

#18

Ponkos

Offline

Jun 2020

i prefer the manga, but the movie is also goated, it even rank at 74th best rated movie of all time on letterboxd as of this comment

Nov 5, 7:46 PM

#19

D1zzyBoy

Offline

Aug 2021

the movie is a 1 to 1 of the manga if you have to choose just watch the movie

Nov 5, 9:00 PM

#20

IWatchAnimeBruh

Offline

Apr 2020

movie is better than manga

Nov 5, 10:28 PM

#21

thetkakaka

Offline

Oct 2022

382

I haven't watch the movie yet but you should read it regardless. Tatsuki Fujimoto is brilliant manga artist and it's a shame to not read his works if you enjoy the movie. It's like 180 pages so it's not a lot. Start with your prefer medium then read/watch the other one again.

I'm still looking forward to watch the movie. If it's as good as people tell it is (which I have no doubt about it) then I'll be very glab.

Nov 7, 6:27 PM

#22

ryzxgum

Offline

Apr 2022

6338

you should consume both but the movie is better, only made me appreciate the oneshot even more.

See All Discussions

Poll: » Look Back Chapter 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) isimyok - Jul 18, 2021	150	by Adnash »» Nov 19, 4:06 PM
» Anime movie PV and KV, scheduled to premiere on June 28th, 2024. ARK-13 - Feb 13	19	by K3Vz0 »» Apr 17, 11:10 AM
» short explanation pls inumxkii - Jul 22, 2021	5	by waalex11 »» Feb 14, 2:20 AM
» Anime adaptation MegamiRem - Feb 1	31	by Dbagas8 »» Feb 13, 7:27 AM
» a question Rafaelwokeuplike - Jul 1, 2023	6	by KawaiiWaz »» Jul 13, 2023 6:34 PM

Manga or Movie?

More topics from this board

Poll: » Look Back Chapter 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

» Anime movie PV and KV, scheduled to premiere on June 28th, 2024.

» short explanation pls

» Anime adaptation

» a question

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters