Lucky star, nichijou, azumanga daioh

hanekawastiddi said:
I agree with this. Lucky star easily beats them all. I still love them all tho. It is surpassed a little bit by minami-ke for my favorite sol/comedy.

Mr_Sai said:
interms of humor animation and characters
nichijou solos both azumanga daioh and lucky star
i really liked azumanga daioh and it made me laugh many times but lucky star was boring and kinda generic

wizdom224 said:
Azumanga for me. Its sense of humor is on point.
Nichijou was my first ultra moe anime and coupled with KyoAni's animation, it was an absolute blast. But unfortunately the jokes just didn't do it for me so it didn't stick with me in the long term.
Lucky Star kinda killed my interest via the live-action segments at the end of each episode. Probably my fault for forcing myself to watch them.

But honestly they're all great. I don't think there are any wrong answers here.

llamafemalebd said:
I do love all of them very much! I think the appeal varies due to the times they were made - Azumanga Daioh came first, Lucky Star was later and a parody of this style of show and anime in general, and Nichijo was the latest. Azumanga Daioh is my fav purely because it’s humour resonants with me most. What I will say tho as watching these shows as a teenage girl Azumanga Daioh’s and Nichijo’s character felt much more relatable and realistic as characters whilst the Lucky Star ones feel more moe-fan servicey characters who are there to be liked as oppose to related to.

Faxtual_Ghoul said:
This Slice of Life Big 3 is better than the Big Shit 3

Anyways, I love Lucky Star the most

Chosarttrain said:
Lucky Star for me. I watched a few episodes of Nichijou but the humor didn't really do it for me, same with Azumanga Daioh.

xXGoreGrinderXx said:
Out of lucky star, nichijou, and azumanga daioh which is your favorite? I just recently received all of these on dvd and have watched them for the first time over the past few months and I was wondering which everyone liked best. Personally lucky star is an easy win of the 3 for me. I love the art style of nichijou but it took about half the series before it started to grow on me and I'm still not a huge fan. Just not my type of humor. And azumanga never really grew on me. I thought this was weird since they're all essentially the same type of show with the Same comedy and I love lucky star but was a bit bored with the other two. Let me know your thoughts.

staruke said:
azumanga daioh is probably objectively better comedy-wise but I just have a special place in my heart for lucky star. I could never get into nichijou

Lakitu64 said:
Nichijou is my favorite. I still listen to the character songs years later (look them up when your done watching the show, they are so funny). The other two are still classics but I like the energy of Nichijou more.

SKILIFT26 said:
i’ve been meaning to watch Azumanga for years but still haven’t gotten to it :(

that said, it’s Nichijou and by a lot. that was the show that really got me interested in anime and even now i have so much appreciation for the amount of detail in all of Arawi’s art. and the anime feels like it was doing something new for the genre while still being a love letter to the slice of life shows of old

VampireLord1024 said:
All three are my favorite.

_lxna_ said:
For me it's Azumanga Daioh > Lucky Star > Nichijou.

Lucky Star used to be my least favorite out of these 3 but I've been rewatching it lately and it's actually much better than I remembered.

OrbitalForce said:

Nichijou. Azumanga Daioh was weird but didn't have as much execution Nichijou does (with that weirdness). Lucky Star is good if you understand humour from way in the past so it didn't age well.

xXGoreGrinderXx said:
they're all really fun watches

hanekawastiddi said:
I agree with this. Lucky star easily beats them all. I still love them all tho. It is surpassed a little bit by minami-ke for my favorite sol/comedy.

Mitz_17 said:

trueee minami-ke is underated... well the anime might be too boring for someone else... but still a good comedy-sol.. i keep wishing for new animes to be like this tho...

LordSozin said:
1. Azumanga
2. Nichijou
3. Lucky Star

Frankly, I didn't really like Lucky Star.

dicloflom said:
Nichijou in general. Has far more better production values then both. But as far as comedy goes Lucky Star is a little bit on the stronger side. I didn't find azumanga as appealing as the other two. But nichijou has the best cast ever. And shinonome household always makes me smile.

hakase_246 said:
Comedy-wise, it's Azumanga for me. Nichijou is better in terms of animation, though the jokes are sometimes hard to catch for a non-Japanese audience. I didn't like Lucky Star that much, it's just not for me. Though I liked the MCs in all of them. Finally it just boils down to personal preference.

TRC_Randy said:
Currently watching the other two and they're almost as good but Nichijou's defo #3.

xXGoreGrinderXx said:
it's humor was the most off for me but I found it more fun and comforting than azumanga

TRC_Randy said:
i thought both shows are comforting and fun in their own ways.

ryzxgum said:
lucky star >>> azumanga > nichijou. i had a laugh during every episode of lucky star, especially during the lucky channel segment and the live action endings. azumanga had a few funny moments across the whole show but it was mainly just cute. nichijou, i don't think i laughed at all. maybe i did once or twice but i can't remember lol, and it was kinda cute but i didn't enjoy it at all even though it has the best animation by far of the 3.