Topgunuk69 said: I liked the CGI and the Star Wars-esque action but the story was barely there, the script awful (the Elite shipmaster was talking nonsense) and the voice acting mediocre (lack of Steve Downes saddens me also).
Again liberties were taken with the canon and once more there was a feeling that the stuff happening didn't really fit into the Halo universe (The UNSC ships cloak, booster frames, the fact that a small group of small single occupant fighters (if you can call them that) somehow manage to fight off an entire covenant fleet, the overweight spartan, spartans dropping like flies, etc).
The next part should have more good action though so I'm looking forward to the visuals and preparing to cringe at pretty much every other aspect.
I am an avid Halo freak and DEEPLY into the canon and lore, and was super excited when I learned they were doing Halo anime. I thought to myself, oh man this is going to be so cool! I have thus far been disappointed. The first episode was interesting, to say the least. I'll not nit-pick at it, as I don't really have a problem with it. The second episode, while I do understand was supposed to be an "artistic vision" I was angered by the visual style. It was mind-numbing and hurt my eyes. The story was rather in-depth, but where the hell did it come from? Who was the giant elite in the wacky armor? And since when did the Prophets allow such blasphemous statements to go on like that?
Now on to the third episode, "The Package." I just watched the whole thing last night after the VGA's expecting to be so pumped from overload of Halo that I would nearly explode in my seat. I was brought down from my high of the world premiere of Reach by witnessing the grotesque depiction of Halo lore that is titled, "The Package." From the get-go, the dialogue was horrible. There have never been such corny lines in a Halo story and this will hopefully be the first and ONLY time that this will ever happen. "Let's sprint this." and "That Elite was strong, I have to be stronger" are not things I want to hear superbadass Master Chief Petty Officer John - 117 saying. HORRIBLE dialogue. Next. STEVE DOWNES??? Seriously. If you can't get Downes, don't do the chief. Next, since when was there a FAT SPARTAN? No such thing. Trained from the age of six, and then BIOLOGICALLY enhanced to be super strong? Don't think fat SPARTANs fall into that category... Not to mention the fact that that SPARTAN knows duty before anything else and would NOT have run in there all gung-ho like he had. Then, a cloak on a ship? And what the hell kind of ship ought that to be? A prowler? If it's a prowler, last time I checked, that was NOT the general layout of that ship. Oh well. Fine. So far I can let it go. So next they drop the Booster Frames. Despite the fact that I have NEVER heard of these things before, I'm willing to ignore that and hang on to my life as I watch this drivel pour into my eyes. They take off. The cloak shield drops (wtf, again). Now I'm thinking to myself, "wow, how are one man aircraft supposed to take on an entire Covenant fleet, especially when they have point defense lasers that are DESIGNED to take out craft of that size?" So i sit and watch. Whatever. Next, Kelly gets hit by plasma fire from one of the Seraphs and the frame has SHIELDS? Ok fine. UNSC has managed to adapt SPARTAN shield technology to one manned aircraft. I'll let that one slide. Finally they're on the ship. Not much for a while except for where the Chief says, "Let's sprint this." Lame dialogue. Dismissed. Only one thing in the whole "sprint" to the asset bothers me. When Fred somehow manages to stop a sword with a Galilean Non-Linear Beam Rifle and the HIS BARE HANDS. wow. I wish THAT had been in the games... Now, finally the Chief arrives at the asset and it is none other than Doctor Halsey!!! Surprise! Now, last time I checked, Halsey was a woman in her mid to late FIFTIES and wore glasses. This is where I lost every bit of interest in this episode, but, being the avid fan that I am, I continued to watch, hoping, PRAYING, there would be a redeeming part later in the short. Nope. I was only slammed with more terrible dialogue and watching Dr Halsey look like a 20 year old still in college. Not to mention the fact that they manage to make it seem as though the Chief and Halsey are in love or something. Albeit, it was hinted at Halsey being interested in John as more than an applicant, but not as someone she was physically attracted to. Nor was He to Her. Bottom line is, to me, that Halo legends is making a mockery of the franchise. After all the hard work Bungie put into this to be so fine tuned, it seems as though Frank O'Connor and 343 Studios are not putting the care and effort into this that they should be. I am profoundly disappointed in O'Connor's poor approval of these shorts thus far and I can only hope they begin to shape up for the better. Please. It's hard to ruin something that was already amazing. Frank, please don't have let me down on all of it. Let there be some redeeming quality in all of this... |