DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Anime was getting better and better.And it has finished.The end was amazing,happy end which has satisfied me.I'm glad that after all troubles characters have been through,they finally found their happiness.Amazing anie wortch watching.I wasn't expecting that not popular anime could be so good.I recomed for all who like dramas to watch this anime because it is full of it! |
 |
Sarhmi said: This is technically in the top 200 by popularity which is pretty damn popular. lolAnime was getting better and better.And it has finished.The end was amazing,happy end which has satisfied me.I'm glad that after all troubles characters have been through,they finally found their happiness.Amazing anie wortch watching.I wasn't expecting that not popular anime could be so good.I recomed for all who like dramas to watch this anime because it is full of it! |
 |
| So whats the deal with the twins? Together-together or no? Anyways It was great. One of my faves now. I would like to see what happened to the twins when the left and up tot the point of us seeing them again. |
| [Catchy, cool, insightful quote] |
| I didn't think the ending was extremely rushed, but it felt weak. For an ending like that though, I'd say they did a good job at it. Story could have been a lot more than just Sana getting bullied and Nanaka escaping a house fire. It felt more like an arc in a bigger story if you asked me. The story jumped to 10 years after the incident...it did not feel like a sudden jump but the way they left the story hanging before was a let down. They could've at least been more romantic! I wonder what became of the Wakatsuki twins..they were holding hands..not that it really proves anything since they held hands before, but who knows. Don't think this series is gonna continue on but if it does, I'd like to see a better story with the same characters, maybe putting the twins this time as the main character (or Hinako + Asami's cousin) speaking of Hinako..when i first saw her i thought she was cute, but then the voice came and it didn't feel like it matched..but as I continued watching it grew on me and now I feel like it has to be that voice to be her. overall this anime will get a 7.5/10 in my list..but since MAL doesn't have .5 in their scales..im debating whther this would be a 7 or an 8. |
  |
| WOW That was an AWFUL ending. Lol. How is it that the Japanese are sooooo bad at ending things? I literally laughed at that horrific jump TEN YEARS LATER.. LOLOL And the watch was just to cover up a scar? I thought it would be like his dad's or something who was murdered. And how do you introduce a music teacher with cancer and end any role of his 3 minutes later? And Sana's teacher said congrats on becoming a man.... he's gotta be like freakin 26!!! Man what a stupid ending. So dumb. Good grief. haha |
| Romance comedy anime - Japan's gift to America |
| Well I liked how things ended like with Sana and Nanaka and the good part is that there were no deaths. And seeing the twins like that after 10 years looks just soo wrong. The romance was pretty poor in this anime though it is more likely just drama to be honest , Sana needed some more romance with Nanaka to , but in the end she was happier than ever. Sana's hair = :( |
| I was pretty angry with how they ended it! I love the slice-of-life episodes where it is just them living everyday life and relationships growing out of it. I really wish they would have made this 26 episodes long and slowly worked their way up to 10 years later. When it first said "10 years later" I thought it was a joke. I actually like how the twins turned out. There is no real answer if they are "together" or just really close. It makes sense to be that close to someone when you have both suffered the same pain. All in all i would say a very good anime...but falls just short of that 9-10 range. If it was 26 episodes long and covered all of the characters in detail...it would most likely have been a 9 maybe even a 10! Would recommend it to anyone! |
| wow 10 year time skip! I would have given it it a 8 or 9, but they rushed it so much. 7 for me. I really like the ending song... Twincest! How did I know.... =( |
| Be humble or be humbled. |
| This series is greatttt. Loved how everything was foreshadowed and was wrapped up in the last 3 episodes. |
| Below average show tbh. wasn't greatfrom beginning to the end - and I amusually easy to please :/. Felt weak, not much emotion to it, especially felt insulting when certain aspects (i.e. making it obvious like 200x that main chracters hiding a slit wrist), really killed this show. I guess you could say nothing was tooo surprising, or even then, it wasn't done to the fullest of effects. Always huge anti-climax when even an inkling of some kind of development was coming about. |
| Only 2 episode aren't boring: 11 y this ending. 6 or 7? that's the point... |
| Okay, I was seriously pissed off by the number of scenes with black blood. Aside from that this was a great drama/romance. 8/10 |
 |
| finished this series after ages well i'll give it a 7/10 it was an alright ending might of been better if it was longer like a 24 or 26 episode series but oh well. |
| Very good series, though I`ve expected another ending... This show is joining my favourites drama list among School Days, Clannad and Kimi ga Nozomu Eien... 9/10 |
| I enjoyed the series very much...it was darker than I expected, but that doesn't equate to "unwelcome." In fact, I most likely enjoyed it all the more because of it. My only beef with this series is that it really could have continued for another six to twelve episodes. |
 |
| liked it, i disliked a few things, i didnt like the 10 time jump, 3-4 years would have been aceptable, i would have prefered if sana had been playing the piano at the end and or nonokas reaction to his proposal, and another ep showing sana and nonoka together after her atepted suicide would have been nice. the black blood didnt bother me it looked good mixed with water imo. all in all 8/10 |
[url=http://myanimelist.net/animelist/lostfallstar&sclick=1] [/ |
| Late to the party lol I liked this show a lot. I will say the first half of it is really not what the show is all about. I mean there are bits and pieces of drama that happen that are significant when it is all said and done. But really, the latter half is where it is at. The black blood didn't bother me. I haven't seen School Days yet but I'm thinking that show left a sour taste in everyone's mouth and are feeling that again this time around? Regarding the twins. I'm one to take the position that they are not in a romantic relationship. I think the hand holding was to show that they never left each others side from the day they left everything behind. Grant it, the two scenes they are shown in are them holding hands so I guess there is argument to support a romance. However, I just think they are really close and the moment they are in right now, surrounded by their friends again, called for a hand holding moment? Idk. Maybe I'm just trying to make excuses to wave off incestuous love, even if they are good people. Wish they show itself was a bit longer because the real meat of the show did get rushed into the last 3 or so episodes. Still 8/10 for drama and a lesser score for romance as I was disappointed on that front. Although the 10 year future (I'll be it a little too far for this situation) showing of him proposing was nice. He kept his promise, to never leave her side. |
| I enjoyed the series overall. No regrets here. 7.5/10 |
 |
| This anime was pretty sad .. liked it stillz 9/10 |
 |
| The plethora of "hard" of topics presented in this show is rather impresive. Sadly besides Aoi and Hina, all the characters where pretty useless. They belittle themselves to a corner and make such a big deal out of the smallest problems. While this sort of anime have never been of my taste, I do agree this was rather well executed. The story has its charm, but sadly the main protagonist (Sana and Kana) are greatly outshine by the rest of the cast. Even Hina and the teacher (considered supporting char) where more appealing than the main couple. The lack of foreshadow for every single event (but the wrist watch) really make the plot twist look like something the writer came up last minute than have them build up properly through out the story. Maybe the format was the correct one, and a 24ep season could have done this more justice. Overall it did a good/decent job and is worth watching until ep 11 imo |
choyosFeb 16, 2012 11:50 AM
| huh? |
| I didn't get this show at all. I didn't see what was supposed to be the focus. I didn't know what I was supposed to be anticipating. It was perhaps more like a mystery than a romance. Except it didn't make me curious. It was all over the place. The little girl Hinako thing was fun. Then it was over, and it never played any role in the rest. The false letter about the twins came out of nowhere, and then they were gone. That's it? Huh? Oh, and also Hoshino confesses to writing that letter out of nowhere as well, revealing herself as an entirely different character than she seemed. No hints I recall of her acting strangely to make you curious. Nope, we're just suddenly told all this stuff, and then Sana says something nice and it's all over as fast as it started. Their stories are over, The End. It's almost the same with Sana and Nanaka. Though she does show some strange insecurities and jealousy at the beginning, there's no hint of explanation until it's quite suddenly revealed (the stuff about the mailbox, etc.). And then that seemed sort of over, until we get her breakdown after remembering her past. The whole thing where she won't see anyone and then eventually tries to commit suicide felt undramatic. And then all that was needed to make everything better is Sana coming in uninvited and saying "oh, btw, I DO know what you're going through, since I was bullied and tried to commit suicide too". Another story out of nowhere. Pretty pathetic. I didn't even like Sana and Nanaka. Sana's a plain old boring, timid, fairly clueless (except when he's a sudden genius saying all the right things at some climatic moment), "nice guy". Nanaka was just a difficult person who would keep wavering between happy and sad as she would always just happen to be in the right place to misunderstand everything. I did like the twins, Hinako, and Aoi. Aoi's voice may have been... interesting... But it sure was a funny voice when she excited or surprised. Anyway, I can only give this a 6, mainly for the earlier lighthearted comedy portions of it, and the characters I liked. But overall, this seems like it'd be pretty lackluster even as a visual novel. |
| This was more of a character's development anime rather than a typical romance/love triangle. Way too much foreshadowing makes it too predictable, which kills a lot of enjoyment. Some plot holes here and there. Some of the voice doesn't match the character either. I thought I was gonna go crazy hearing Aoi's voice, but it became the reason I kept watching this so-so anime instead. A lot of potential for intense romance for sure. I'd cheer for Hinako if that was the case. Average anime is average. 7/10 |
 |
| I honestly loved this anime but that ending killed it. 10 year skip is such a joke. To me this anime focused more on the development of character and not just romance wise. That's what i loved the most. The dark sides each character has....except Aoi.....made this entire series amazing. But the main point is to show us how these characters overcome the challenges and they did show us alot of great ways but it was half assed. What happened to the twins? Well we know they get together and what not and I don't mind it one bit. Love is love. What happened to Hoshino? She saves the park as a way to redeem herself in a way whether it's one sided or not. What happened to the father of twins after? The stepmother slut? What happened to the little girl? She's dating a 16 year old? What happened between Sana and Nanae? They get together but we need to see how. They need to show us what happened b/w them specially the violin. That's what makes things interesting. I expected more with the flashback regarding Sana's suicide attempt but it wasn't as powerful as I thought. I'll admit, I also wanted to see more romance b/w those two and the twins but cmon. Skipping 10 years within a 4min time slot is ridiculous. During the violin scene, they should've shown a flashback when the memories of their time together as friends. This anime would've been great at both mystery and romance. But sadly it fails at its expansion as it's too damn rushed. Literally. What's done is done. All I can conclude is that everyone is happy and Nane's mother is a slut...oh and Shuu's stepmother aswell. Originally a 8-9/10 but I give it 7/10. |
Cian13thApr 2, 2012 8:18 PM
| <img src="http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q545/Cian13th/1234.png" /> |
Timofmars said: I didn't get this show at all. I didn't see what was supposed to be the focus. I didn't know what I was supposed to be anticipating. It was perhaps more like a mystery than a romance. Except it didn't make me curious. It was all over the place. The little girl Hinako thing was fun. Then it was over, and it never played any role in the rest. The false letter about the twins came out of nowhere, and then they were gone. That's it? Huh? Oh, and also Hoshino confesses to writing that letter out of nowhere as well, revealing herself as an entirely different character than she seemed. No hints I recall of her acting strangely to make you curious. Nope, we're just suddenly told all this stuff, and then Sana says something nice and it's all over as fast as it started. Their stories are over, The End. It's almost the same with Sana and Nanaka. Though she does show some strange insecurities and jealousy at the beginning, there's no hint of explanation until it's quite suddenly revealed (the stuff about the mailbox, etc.). And then that seemed sort of over, until we get her breakdown after remembering her past. The whole thing where she won't see anyone and then eventually tries to commit suicide felt undramatic. And then all that was needed to make everything better is Sana coming in uninvited and saying "oh, btw, I DO know what you're going through, since I was bullied and tried to commit suicide too". Another story out of nowhere. Pretty pathetic. I didn't even like Sana and Nanaka. Sana's a plain old boring, timid, fairly clueless (except when he's a sudden genius saying all the right things at some climatic moment), "nice guy". Nanaka was just a difficult person who would keep wavering between happy and sad as she would always just happen to be in the right place to misunderstand everything. I did like the twins, Hinako, and Aoi. Aoi's voice may have been... interesting... But it sure was a funny voice when she excited or surprised. Anyway, I can only give this a 6, mainly for the earlier lighthearted comedy portions of it, and the characters I liked. But overall, this seems like it'd be pretty lackluster even as a visual novel. Couldn't agree more. This series needed more time/episodes to fill in plot holes and show development. It skips way to many things....and specifically the end. |
| <img src="http://i1163.photobucket.com/albums/q545/Cian13th/1234.png" /> |
| One of the best anime I've seen, considering re-watching 10/10 |
 |
| This was one of the first anime I ever watched, and it's what really drew me into romantic anime. Of course, that also means that I never really compared this series with anything else, but I can see why people are giving it a 7/8. Personally, however, it holds a very special spot in my heart, especially since the romance is very innocent and there aren't really any romantic plot twists (after years of watching romance anime, you get tired of harems and love triangles). So myself, I give it a 10. Watched it over and over again countless times. Oh, and regarding the twins...I never saw them as being romantically involved with each other. I personally feel like people are kinda overreacting... So yeah. If you're reading this, hoping to gauge how good the series is, all I can say is: it's refreshing in its simplicity. If you're tired of watching girls getting heartbroken, and just want some plain development between two lovers, watch this. |
| 'I met many people. We were separated. And then reunited. This tune contains all those feelings.' - Nanaka Yatsushiro, Myself;Yourself, Episode 13  |
| I don't really understand why people are saying that its bad because you couldn't figure out Hoshino was a lesbian or something. If this was a fair mystery which uses Knox's 10 rules for a fair mystery, I would understand why you were mad, but it ISN'T!!! This is a romance drama and you should not say its bad because you couldn't figure out what was happening before it happened! I had already figured out that it wasn't the uncle, but rather the father before hand, so if you say that wasn't fair, I will argue that you can have your suspicions beforehand. But don't treat this like it is a mystery when it isn't! Maybe they don't expect you to figure out what was actually happening until they told you! As for this anime, I loved it! It is true that they could have made it longer and it seemed a bit "rushed" at times, but it was still great. It was very suspenseful and had quite a few epic scenes. Though it won't beat something on my list like stiens gate or zero no tsukaima, it will definitely be one of my favorites!! =D |
 "I like to expose what people hide. I'm an intellectual rapist." - Furudo Erika |
| I didn't particularly enjoy this over the top drama scattered everywhere. Wish it could have remained the good old comedy it was at the start. All this shit thrown at my face didn't feel good at all. Going to be generous and give it a 6/10 even if my mind is begging me to lower it to 5. |
| The ending was too abrupt for my liking, and there are still too many questions not being answered (the main one being: what happened to the twins??). The drama in the series was sudden and came without explanation, though it still left an impact on me. I did love the twist with teen suicide though. 7/10. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| a 6 for me, I found it hard to keep interested until like 3eps from the end which brought it back up, was going to give it a 5! |
| a little bit rushed but all you need is to use ur imagination to make it more dramatic and romantic :) but i want to see the reaction that sana propose to nanaka.. unpredictable anyways that makes it interesting... |
 |
| I really enjoyed this show however the ending seemed rushed thus making it a little bad. I'm Very Happy that the gang got reunited with the twins :) |
| Awesome episode to an awesome show, I'm giving Myself ; Yourself a 9/10. It had me happy at times and then there were times in which I had tears running down my face, I'm just glad that at least we got a happy ending for all of the characters. I was worried that this was gonna turn out like School Days lol Anyway from I'm also happy for the twins, even though allot of people don't agree with what they are doing as long as they are happy that's all that counts :) Also Sana and Nanaka getting married = the best ending possible!!! |
 |
| Sweet ending, couldnt help but smile when i saw the engagement ring. Like everyone above has said it felt very rushed especially the ending, this anime could have really benefited by having a few more episodes and for that reason i cant give it a 10 but still, this was a beautiful well done anime. 9/10 would watch again. |
 |
| Well, a good ED to a good anime. But, iam a little dissapointed. It seems the twins get more lover (right?) scenes than a main character's. The anime shows a lot of sweet moment between the twins. But for the main char? They have skipped sana's propose scene to nanaka. But all of it just disappeared because the music that nanaka's played with her violin. That was beautiful ! I almost cried back then, the music is indeed a perfect summary for myself; yourself story. Awesome. Hope that the anime has 24 or 26 episodes instead of just 13. |
| Well, they managed to link Sana's story to Nanaka, which was very well done i felt. Ending off which Nanaka's tune was a really nice touch, finally we know the significance behind the title of the anime xD While the plot wasn't too impressive, it did have its touching moments, and i really liked the characters. Deciding between giving it 7 or 8 but will most probably end up as 7. |
 |
| didn't like how sana's past was so weak sauce....they kept it a mystery and in less than 2 minutes we found out the reason behind it..it wasn't powerful enough...that being said it was a nice ending....love the twincest lolol...but i'm disappointed it didn't end like school days....also some things were unanswered but whatever P.S: people bitching about the black blood get the BD version for it hahah same thing with School Days....the blood is nice and red |
Uiriamu_BusujimaSep 12, 2012 4:17 AM
  |
| yeah, good show, ill be giving it a 7 or 8, ive been wondering about his backstory ever since he freaked out a second time when he saw the droplets of blood on the knife by the apple now that that one is done, i guess its a toss up between air and zero no tsukaima next, probably ZnT lol |
 |
| This series was amazing. Adding it to my favorite O_O |
| Could have been better if last ep was not rushed. 6/10 |
| This anime surprised me, infact, it's very good! The only thing that I disliked was the ending: 10 years later epilogue? WTF? And what happened with the twins? Who knows? Oh, and let's not forget aoi's voice...awful. This said, I liked the story, the characters' backgrounds and the OST. 8/10 for me. |
| Good, but in the end I was debating on whether or not it would be a 7 or 8 out of 10. I settled on 7/10 |
 |
| This Anime makes me feel all the pain i have been true.. ;( 10/10 |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Myself ; Yourself Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 )radiantfire - Dec 19, 2007 |
65 |
by SailorFairyDxD24
»»
Nov 3, 2023 11:01 AM |
|
Poll: » Myself ; Yourself Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )radiantfire - Dec 12, 2007 |
166 |
by SailorFairyDxD24
»»
Nov 3, 2023 10:07 AM |
|
Poll: » Myself ; Yourself Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Faust721 - Dec 5, 2007 |
115 |
by SailorFairyDxD24
»»
Nov 2, 2023 4:56 PM |
|
Poll: » Myself ; Yourself Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Faust721 - Nov 28, 2007 |
61 |
by SailorFairyDxD24
»»
Nov 2, 2023 4:05 PM |
|
Poll: » Myself ; Yourself Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )deli53 - Nov 21, 2007 |
93 |
by SailorFairyDxD24
»»
Nov 2, 2023 3:14 PM |