Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (7) « First ... « 2 3 [4] 5 6 » ... Last »
Oct 1, 2017 1:05 AM

Offline
Mar 2007
24
What a convoluted mess of a story this was. There was no retribution for what Charioce did to hundreds if not thousands of lives (except the loss of sight? Are you kidding me?). Thank God the annoying Nina lost her voice, definitely a plus.

That eerie bit where Kaisar was patched up as a zombie was a bit creepy.

6/10, the mistake was to allow Nina to steal the protagonist's spot instead of Favaro.
Oct 1, 2017 1:15 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
1260
Out of all possible ships, the one that sailed across the horizon is Bachus x Sofiel,.. nice.

ManlyTear said:
Whoever judges a show mostly on it's ending is gonna be pretty disappointed with here, however even this ending, while going in a direction not many of us wanted, is well-executed. With the way they decided to go about it, I'd have personally preferred if Nina & Chaorice would have ran away together or something, as Jeanne,the gods,Azazel & the demons letting him go to be king just like that kind of stretches it.


This sums up my feelings about it quite nicely. Mugaro's and Kaisar's perma-deaths felt so uncomprimising, especially by anime standards. Yes, we got zombie Kaisar, but I think it's pretty clear that that is a reanimated pet (like Rocky), and not the real Kaisar. I personally think it'd been better if they left that out of the epilogue, but I can see it as a comical tribute.

I also really liked the relationship between Jeanne and Azazel, as well as Favaro's character development. His reaction to Amira's message from Nina, together with Rita's reaction to Kaisar's death were the highlights of this show.

Regarding Charioce remaining as king, I guess everyone had lost enough, and his intentions were noble in the end. The way he sits on the throne in the end doesn't really look like a reward either, so there is no real reason to remove him from that position.

8/10

telmo_trooper said:
What I don't get is: Why Charioce enslaved the demons, waged war against the gods and revive the goddamn Bahamut?

What point was there in enslaving the demons besides being a fucking prick?
Even if the gods weren't going to give away that ancient technology, did he have to fucking wage war against them? He even attempted to put the people against them. Couldn't he have been open about his plan all along?


If the Bahamut was gonna revive anyway, didn't he just speed up the process and seal him again?



  • The world was in ruins. Charioce enslaved the daemons because he needed cheap mass labour. Up untill then the daemons had terrorised humanity. Charioce thus hit three birds with one stone: he avenged centuries of daemon terror, he removed the active hindrance to human development and reconstruction, and he facilitated said development and reconstruction through providing a source of slave labour. Human nobles subsequently abbused their position and committed atrocities to daemons, while Charioce was too pre-occupied to reprimand them.
  • Charioce concluded that the real problem was precisely that Bahamut was sealed every time he was resurrected, which allowed him to be resurrected again and again too. Thus Charioce's plan was not to seal Bahamut again, but to annihilate Bahamut once and for all. For this he needed Bahamut to be revived at a point in time determined by Charioce himself, so he could fight the beast at his own terms.
  • Charioce never revealed his plan to the gods, the daemons, or even the humans, because he realised all too well that none would ever agree to resurrecting for whatever purpose, even if they would believe that they'd be able to kill him (which they probably wouldn't believe either).


Favaro's comment in the epilogue suggests Charioce failed though, and Bahamut can not be killed. Instead it seems, Bahamut is simply there by a law of nature, above humans, gods, and daemons, to ensure balance.
"I'm a middle schooler bartender!"
- Mishima Hitomi
Oct 1, 2017 1:32 AM

Offline
May 2015
771
Season 3 better be the adventures of zombie Rita, Kaisar and Rocky. Hopefully Azzy will join their shenanigans too!
Oct 1, 2017 1:33 AM

Offline
Nov 2012
436
Hime-sama said:
Well overall i liked the show but there were times i was disappointed in the anime. Il be honest i actually wanted a showdown with Bahamut and Nina. Still enjoying favaro smiling over Amira that was a cute moment. Well to me it was a good ending and hopefully no season 3. i dont mind ova but not another one since it wasnt as best as the first one with the action packed and battle scenes.


It took the combined power of gods and demons to barely deflect one blast from Bahamut, wth is Nina gunna do? Lmao
Oct 1, 2017 2:30 AM

Offline
Jun 2013
1771
Another day....
Another (half) bad sequel
At least is not bad like Aqurion Evol or Garo guren no tsuki
Oct 1, 2017 2:30 AM

Offline
Jun 2013
1771
Another day....
Another (half) bad sequel
At least is not bad like Aqurion Evol or Garo guren no tsuki
Oct 1, 2017 2:42 AM
Offline
Jul 2018
564084
So much cancer in one thread, someone call 911.

Jagh said:
That's because MAL is full of children that see the world in black and white. They think the concepts of good and evil actually exist. And think that their morals are the correct ones.


Daltonisam is a heavy disease.
Oct 1, 2017 2:46 AM
Offline
Apr 2017
277
I rated this show 8/10 because it caught me off guard several time, n they dare to sacrifice a few loveable character, which a lot of people couldn't stand it and rated low score for it.
A story is good because it's good, not because the character is living well, as for my opinion.
The ending is quite...bad though. Just feel like they have to wrap everything up ASAP...But then take half of this episode to explain the aftermath, which can be put in OVA. Not affecting my scoring though
Oct 1, 2017 2:58 AM

Offline
Sep 2009
1214
I feel like somewhere down the line the show swapped directors and he like "ever see Tokyo Drift?" and was just slamming the gas and spinning the wheel constantly. At times the shit was exciting and fun and at others you'd kinda fear for your life and wonder where this death ride was heading towards. Oh and the radio is blasting Taylor Swift-esque love songs and the mood kept on clashing with everything around you.

You'd get off thinking to yourself that should of been better but you're glad it's wasn't any worse.

8/10 being the supa dupa optimist that I am but really just enjoying seeing cool and likable characters return in an over ambitious play in the park.

EDIT: Oh man the ending. I mean in hindsight I get what they were trying to accomplish in comparison with the first season and it's ending but man...cracked too many eggs to make this omelet :P
LordLagannOct 1, 2017 3:02 AM
Oct 1, 2017 4:33 AM

Offline
Mar 2009
8123
I certainly didn't think the second season was shit, but in the end it left me feeling very mixed towards it, unlike the first season. I pretty much loved the first season, despite a few things here and there.

The main problem - and all we have to do is look at these forums and everywhere else around the internet - is that people really hated Charioce. And I don't think the show wanted us to hate him, but instead to understand him, and maybe even sympathize with him a little. See, they really wanted us to be invested in Charioce and Nina's relationship. And really, not much of the audience was invested in their relationship. It took up time from other things and characters, and, honestly, it even brough Nina's character down a little, whom I dearly loved at the very beginning of this season. She almost became wholly dependent on Charioce, and that was a shame. Charioce's characterization was the main problem, of course. The execution was not there. Yes, you can see the arguments and the logic behind his decisions, but they never really bothered to make him sympathetic to the audience's feelings. Or if they did, it just all fell flat. And yet, they constantly focused on Nina and Charioce's relationship over and over again in the second half, without doing enough for Charioce's own character. Hell, sometimes it seemed like he simply had different personalities. Like, there he was playing ball with the demon kids, and yet horrible things happened to the demon kids BECAUSE of him. And he's aware of that. It seemed like a laughable moment to me, but I think the show was nudging us like, "SEE! SEE! HE CAN BE A NICE GUY, AFTER ALL!" But we knew the shit he did, and the show also obviously wanted us to be sympathetic towards demon-kind and all the demon children. It was just all really confusing, and to sum up, the writing was not up to par to deal with the complexities here.

Favaro and Kaisar were side-characters in the second season, and they were always meant to be side-characters. I mean, they didn't introduce Favaro until much later. People here can say they hated this season just because the 2nd half went downhill, but so many people here were expecting Favaro and Kaisar to have main roles, and I don't think many of you were ever going to give the show a fair chance from the beginning. I swear, I've seen posts here saying "where's Amira, when is Amira going to show up, etc." Did people really believe Amira was going to show up, after everything that happened at the end of the first season? We were lucky enough to see her in some form at the end of this one. I didn't even think we would get that, to be honest. All that being said, Kaisar's character kind of got the short end of the stick here. He was so intent on protecting Charioce, and preventing bloodshed; sometimes, it was just too stupid. More stupid than the usual fun and kind of stupid that his character was in the first season. And from a writing standpoint, his death was just not very good. It sucked, really. And yet again, it goes back to the main problem: Charioce. He protected Charioce, a character that, again, we didn't really care for. Favaro was fine, I thought. Sure, he didn't get much of the spotlight, but I loved his mature and laid-back personality in the 2nd season. Dude grew up, and that was really cool. I liked him in the first season, as well, and he was more fun there, obviously, but after everything with Amira, it made sense that he changed a little.

A few things that were good about this season(and also the last episode):

-Azazel and El/Mugaro's relationship. El completely changed Azazel and he became very sympathetic towards the audience, when he was kind of a bad dude in the first season. Really, their relationship was quite endearing. And it was honestly a high point of the second season for me.

-Animation and art's still as good as ever.

-Jeanne's character. We got to know more about her and she changed for the better, and the episode focused on her and El was easily one of the best. Of course, it all came crashing down when El was suddenly killed. Which, I guess, makes sense.

-Nina telling Favaro what Amira said was a touching moment.
-And Kaisar being brought back to life as a zombie is totally a thing Rita would do. And Kaisar still being alive in some form is better than nothing. And Rita deserves to be happy. Maybe a selfish thing for Rita to do, but I just don't care. And it's consistent with her character.



Welp. Didn't expect to write this much, but here we are. Just going back to things: the writing failed when it came to Charioce's characterization and perhaps if it were done better, maybe the audience would have been more invested in their relationship, and maybe people would have actually liked this season then. I strongly feel Charioce was the main problem with this season as a whole.


One last thing: what the hell was the point of Bahamut still being alive? Sure, everyone's finally getting along now, but doesn't it feel like everything was pointless? Near genocide of the demons - all for nothing.
Seems like it was simply done as a sequel bait. If they ever decide to visit the series again. Oh, well. Guess we'll see.
MormegilOct 1, 2017 4:39 AM
Oct 1, 2017 5:20 AM

Offline
Jul 2009
4805
This season was depressing...I am not happy with this ending, Nina lost her voice, the king got blind and worse of all, Kaisar is dead...I was not ready for this, I know we saw him as a zombie, we know Rita might get him to speak and to be like her, but even so, it's sad...
7/10
Oct 1, 2017 5:33 AM

Offline
Jul 2008
1703
Laionidas said:
Regarding Charioce remaining as king, I guess everyone had lost enough, and his intentions were noble in the end. The way he sits on the throne in the end doesn't really look like a reward either, so there is no real reason to remove him from that position.


Also, even if you wanted to kill him (which I'm sure Jeanne and Azazel still do), him killing Bahamut made it a dangerous prospect for them. He is now hero in the eyes of the humans, and if they kill him now he will just become a martyr and thus humans will just become even more hateful towards the other two races. And even some angels and demons will no doubt view his actions as "well, it did kill Bahamut" so they are less likely to rally on any suicidal missions to kill the evil King.
Oct 1, 2017 5:41 AM
Offline
Dec 2015
14
Chaotic_beauty said:
Step one: make a show exclusively about a rivalry between two guys and their chemistry as they dance around a mediocre plot.
Step two: Put them both in the background or not there at all for the sequel.
Step three: Kill one of them, destroying the main appeal of the show forever.
Step four: Make it all about a promiscuous girl romancing demons and kings.

The real abomination here is Virgin Soul, not the Bahamut. Now I truly see why he should've destroyed the world.


Damn homie you're so right on this one. Team Bahamut all the way!1
Oct 1, 2017 5:50 AM

Offline
Apr 2016
767
Not so great and true it went downhill with the writing but at least it managed to NOT be as bad as the first season.
Oct 1, 2017 5:54 AM
Offline
Dec 2015
14
deadoptimist said:
5/10 All in all it felt like a waste.
It's sort of a strange ending for Charioce and Nina. I mean - what stops them from being properly together now? Why is Nina still living a low life? Tho the show did at least some bitter notes right - they can't communicate in any way aside from touch now. That's some price.


Wow, that's true, I haven't thought about it. If he's blind, he can't read, only listen. If she's mute she can't speak, only write. And that is another example of forced asspulls. I mean, WHY her voice? To try to pull some heartstrings of course. You'd expect that if they both did the same thing (put their hands on the dromos) they'd get the same side effects (loss of vision). But you know, they had to make the dancing scene meaningful I guess.

deadoptimist said:

And nothing was done to explain just why Nina insisted so much on her relationship with him. It was actually ok for her to choose love over other stuff - she was a 17 y.o. girl and she wanted to date, not war or politics, she had kept her decisions personal for the most part too, so her running to the king's help could be a beautiful scene, something like a revolt of a neutral character. But we had to see why she valued that love so much for that to work. And personally, I didn't. .


When Favaro told her to choose between the asshole king and the world and she answers, without an ounce of hesitation that she chose him... man that is really disappointing. I get that she's a teenager in love with her hormones maxed but SERIOUSLY this is the fate of the f*cking world we talking about. you mother, family, your friends, everybody is less important than that one asshole you KISSED ONCE FFS! That's why I was hoping them both to die on the dromos, it fitted the theme of her choosing him over the world.

Zapredon said:
What a shitty end for a supposedly once a great anime. Charoice motivation doesn't make any sense. It's a huge plot hole(or bad writing). Why doesn't he tell the Gods that Bahamut is about to revive. Instead he make enemy out of them just so he can become a gray area villains. Season 2 is an absolute joke. Also, too much screen time on Nina x Charoice that try to drag the whole series.


NOT only that, his plan would've implied the whole city would be wasted. It was the *demons* and *gods* that protected the city. Highly ironical considering the King of said city made a hobby of being an asshole to all the other races.

So his complete plan was utter shit.
- But... but... bahamut is going to wake up sooner or later!
Yeah well you can PREPARE for when he ACTUALLY wakes up. Refine your techonoly. Convince the other races to work together. Just because there's a land mine on your backyard you don't have to step on it! Even the dromos could've been built somewhere NOT RIGHT NEXT TO A MAJOR POPULATION CENTER

And finally, Jesus they just completely forgot about Mugaro. That scene where Azazel and JEanne are standing right next to charioce after Kaisar is dead is awkward as hell. They had no way to know that Charioce wasn't the one that gave the order for killing mugaro. Not even nina knew that. So i'd like expect for them to still be willing to off him. Even if they had to wait until he killed bahamut. I just really hate how mugaro died because of Kaisar stupidity, Alessand greed and Charioce... chariociness. I need closure on this one. What I hoped for was Alessand and Charioce dying at the hands of Azazel and Jeanne, and Kaisar has to LIVE with the guilt of creating that mess in first place.
irterisOct 1, 2017 6:24 AM
Oct 1, 2017 6:22 AM

Offline
May 2013
96
Laionidas said:
The world was in ruins. Charioce enslaved the daemons because he needed cheap mass labour. Up untill then the daemons had terrorised humanity. Charioce thus hit three birds with one stone[...]


I'm satisfied with this explanation.
Oct 1, 2017 6:34 AM
Offline
Jan 2014
88
Literally everything I hoped to not happen happened. It's been a really long time since I'm this much disturbed by just the writing of a show alone. If I hadn't know I would've thought this was written by a teenage girl.

The production was still good, as expected of Mappa. New characters were a big mistake.
5/10

Also, what the hell was that Kaiser's dying moment? "Death is so peaceful" and Charioce nodded. xD wtf was that really?
sosiickOct 1, 2017 6:43 AM
Oct 1, 2017 7:27 AM
Offline
Sep 2014
52
What a letdown ....
First 13 episode were really good then next were mediocre and the 4 last were a compilation of nonsense .....

I don't know who wright this fuckery but he don't know that the
likelihood of a story is REALLY important if you want to be invested in it.

6/10 for the awesome 13 first episode


Oct 1, 2017 7:36 AM

Offline
Jul 2014
5407
An insultingly pointless ending to what has been a disastrous, insulting second season of what was once a good series, at least until this second cour completely tarnished the reputation of anything "Rage of Bahamut" forever. The focus has been completely wrong for most of this show, and ultimately my initial concern about Nina contributing to the ruin of the show proved to be completely and utterly true.

6/10

It wouldn't have made sense, but I'm pissed that Favaro didn't get to see Amira again; it would have been as nonsensical as what we did get, but it also would have been much, much better.
AtavisticOct 1, 2017 7:39 AM
Oct 1, 2017 8:53 AM

Offline
Mar 2017
30
Laionidas said:
telmo_trooper said:
What I don't get is: Why Charioce enslaved the demons, waged war against the gods and revive the goddamn Bahamut?

What point was there in enslaving the demons besides being a fucking prick?
Even if the gods weren't going to give away that ancient technology, did he have to fucking wage war against them? He even attempted to put the people against them. Couldn't he have been open about his plan all along?


If the Bahamut was gonna revive anyway, didn't he just speed up the process and seal him again?



  • The world was in ruins. Charioce enslaved the daemons because he needed cheap mass labour. Up untill then the daemons had terrorised humanity. Charioce thus hit three birds with one stone: he avenged centuries of daemon terror, he removed the active hindrance to human development and reconstruction, and he facilitated said development and reconstruction through providing a source of slave labour. Human nobles subsequently abbused their position and committed atrocities to daemons, while Charioce was too pre-occupied to reprimand them.
  • Charioce concluded that the real problem was precisely that Bahamut was sealed every time he was resurrected, which allowed him to be resurrected again and again too. Thus Charioce's plan was not to seal Bahamut again, but to annihilate Bahamut once and for all. For this he needed Bahamut to be revived at a point in time determined by Charioce himself, so he could fight the beast at his own terms.
  • Charioce never revealed his plan to the gods, the daemons, or even the humans, because he realised all too well that none would ever agree to resurrecting for whatever purpose, even if they would believe that they'd be able to kill him (which they probably wouldn't believe either).



Yeah, there's this situation when someone is powerful, they will abuse it. That's what happened throughout the series. From what I understand from the show, they just cooperate when they are in dire circumstances. At the end, that's somewhat changing so at least, that's nice. Maybe because the demons experienced what it's like to be powerless or a human 'killed Bahamut'? But of course, humans are no better for abusing their power.
Oct 1, 2017 10:39 AM

Offline
Dec 2009
52
Yep lets sweep mass genocide, slavery, discrimination that Charioce was responsible for under the rug

Let's make him a hero who gets the girl(who he ordered to kill several times) at the end of the day while we're at it
Oct 1, 2017 10:45 AM

Offline
Sep 2014
4838
Im not sure if I liked this season more or not. With the last scenes it hints towards a 3rd season. But now that Kaisar is dead .. Im not too sure about this.

I overall liked this season because it did not feel like watching something I already saw (which always bothered me with the first)
But Nina is a trash MC compared to Favaro, Kaisar and Amira last season.

But hey they managed to made Jeanne an even more tragic character which I never thought was possible.

7/10 (just like the first season) while I initially liked it better, Nina stole too much screentime.

Like many people wrote already, the main mistake of this season was placing Nina as the MC instead of Favaro.
Also Nina should have lost her voice earlier, she is more likable when she shuts up.

PS: I actually liked Charioce when he revealed his goal to actually kill Bahamut and justified everything else with it. But the ending felt anti climactic. The epic fight before and now "poof-poof dead" and oh yeah he even stayed king. Like yeah ... he should have died together with Nina.
Comander-07Oct 1, 2017 10:51 AM
"This emotion is mine alone.
It is for Madoka alone." - Homura
or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica.
Oct 1, 2017 10:48 AM
Offline
Jul 2017
41
https://cutie-bowiex.tumblr.com/post/165937358839/decided-to-address-a-few-points-some-keep-bringing << Read this post to give a better understanding of Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul.

Oct 1, 2017 10:50 AM
Offline
Mar 2016
1481
Oh so Charioce is still alive and a Hero and he still gets Nina to his bitch, FUCK.

Kaisar now a Zombie, double fuck.
Oct 1, 2017 11:03 AM

Offline
Mar 2017
30
Zelev said:
Lol at all the salty people. Not gonna lie, I didn't even like Genesis. I thought Virgin Soul was an improvement in the first half, but the second half has serious writing issues.

1) What was the point of all that build up on Jeanne's character? She got powers, started a war, killed Kaiser by accident, and then she didn't really do anything.
2) What was the point of all that build up on Azazel's character? He literally did nothing in the second half. Him and Jeanne got sidelined for no reason even though they were the main focus in some episodes. Makes no sense. It's pretty obvious the writer didn't know what to do with them.
3) Zombie Kaiser? Really? In theory, can't Rita bring back everyone that died? The hell?
4) Now that I think about, Favaro and Kaiser also got sidelined.

..Even though the second half has flaws, I still think it was (overall) an improvement on Genesis. Although, that's not saying much.


The funny thing is both characters are connected to Mugaro/El deeply and then writers decided to kill him off lol. His death caused Jeanne to rally everyone who hates the king and Azazel to convince Lucifer to fight. I don't know if the writers just wanted to unite everyone again to fight the Bahamut since the story should be about raging on Bahamut (yeah, the title). The title should be changed to Shingeki no Charioce. Azazel escaped on this one because of 'Mugaro magic' lol.
Oct 1, 2017 11:07 AM
Offline
Sep 2014
52
yaya_90 said:
https://cutie-bowiex.tumblr.com/post/165937358839/decided-to-address-a-few-points-some-keep-bringing << Read this post to give a better understanding of Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul.


Even if it's interrsting all your argument are pure speculation.
You can't use fallacious argument to justify a story .
Oct 1, 2017 11:15 AM

Offline
Jan 2011
1662
Well.....it wasn't as good as Genesis.

It was fairly solid upfront but kind of turned into a shit show.
Oct 1, 2017 11:32 AM

Offline
Dec 2014
495
Shingeki no Ballroom is finally over....boy it was painful to get through the second half. What even happened after the rag demon arc? It wasn't that bad before all the dancing started..Sure there was no Favaro; but at least there wasn't a super forced love story that I didn't care about, and that overshadowed the true main characters' stories.
The only redeeming quality of this season were the few action episodes it had. Sequel? No thanks.
Oct 1, 2017 11:37 AM
Offline
Jul 2017
41
Kilvann said:
yaya_90 said:
https://cutie-bowiex.tumblr.com/post/165937358839/decided-to-address-a-few-points-some-keep-bringing << Read this post to give a better understanding of Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul.


Even if it's interrsting all your argument are pure speculation.
You can't use fallacious argument to justify a story .


There is evidence from the show itself where is the speculation here exactly? "fallacious argument?" you are free to agree or disagree but I stated some points to clarify things.

Oct 1, 2017 11:43 AM
Offline
Sep 2014
52
yaya_90 said:
Kilvann said:


Even if it's interrsting all your argument are pure speculation.
You can't use fallacious argument to justify a story .


There is evidence from the show itself where is the speculation here exactly? "fallacious argument?" you are free to agree or disagree but I stated some points to clarify things.


English is not my main langage by fallacious i mean that even if it's evidence for you it's still an interpretation of the story, you don't have factual proof of what you are saying in your article.

ps : i wasn't trying to be rude
Oct 1, 2017 11:54 AM

Offline
Sep 2017
18
In my opinion, the series began to fall flat during the climax. When Alessand killed Mugaro, I felt like there was so much potential to be had with his death. His death could have led the Gods into a crumbling defeat, that could possibly spawn a far more interesting sequel, as the Demons commit a civil war afterwards from the help of Lucifer and Azazel. If they had more episodes and didn't bring back the redundant plotline involving Bahamut as the main final boss battle of the series, things would have been much better for this series. I really adored the episodes right before they revealed Charioce's true intentions, because the series was kept on a good role, showcasing more of the characters and building up to a hype battle. But in the end, it ended up being moreso disappointing than anything else. Hopefully, they can explore more in the third season. For now, I'll just keep my rating to a 8/10, because it does a lot of good things that helps me overlook it's bad ending.
Oct 1, 2017 12:35 PM

Offline
Feb 2015
524
It happened!

The NinaxChris ship sailed, Amira visited, Bahamut was defeated once again and a zombie Kaisar was revived.

I expected the last episode to be a little more chaotic but overall the anime was good.
Oct 1, 2017 12:39 PM
Offline
Jul 2017
41
Kilvann said:
yaya_90 said:


There is evidence from the show itself where is the speculation here exactly? "fallacious argument?" you are free to agree or disagree but I stated some points to clarify things.


English is not my main langage by fallacious i mean that even if it's evidence for you it's still an interpretation of the story, you don't have factual proof of what you are saying in your article.

ps : i wasn't trying to be rude


It's alright. Nope, It's not speculation It's evidence from the show and I presented many evidence and scenes in my other posts. There are some small points that may be speculation but the entire post is not and I based them on both Genesis and Virgin Soul.

Oct 1, 2017 12:50 PM
Offline
Oct 2016
54
After episode 12 passed I found myself thinking that writers are taking this slowly because they have something very good for the end.... But nothing and I repeat NOTHING could prepare me for this atrocity. Amount of stuff that makes zero sense/bullshit is too damn high. I hope I'll get an amnesia soon so I can forget about this....
Oct 1, 2017 1:00 PM

Offline
Jun 2014
1188
GangsterCat said:
bahamut died just like that
charioice get away with everything after he did bunch of shitty nonsense that has nothing to do with his plan and got happy ending
demon and human become peaceful after what human did to them lmao
rita turn kaisar into zombie, but El? or is it mindless zombie and rita just want sex doll? lol


Bahamut's death was truly anticlimatic; if it was a 15 minute intense dramatic fight, I would have given this show a 7, but nope. I kept hoping for a saving grace, but it never came.

Charioce did not have a truly happen ending though. He can never communicate with Nina.

Looks like Rita did get a sex doll with a hint of intelligence lol
Oct 1, 2017 1:01 PM

Offline
Jun 2014
1188
Hannah_Ana said:
Charioce lost his eyes, and Nina lost her voice. That's fitting. Charioce does not deserve to see with his own eyes how the people in his kingdom are thriving. As for Nina, she's much more likeable when she's quiet.

I was hoping El would rise from the dead and be the deus ex machina.

The ending dance with Charioce and Nina was absolutely beautiful.

Zombie Kaisar seems to be intellectually disabled. I knew Rita wasn't going to let him stay dead for long.


lol well said!!
I wish Favaro quoted you hahaha
Oct 1, 2017 1:35 PM
Offline
Jul 2015
127
Mocchiii said:
Jagh said:

That's because MAL is full of children that see the world in black and white. They think the concepts of good and evil actually exist. And think that their morals are the correct ones.


I mean I like this comment. Harsh :)

Ahhhh ok, glad I asked. Text can be hard sometimes lol.
Oct 1, 2017 1:43 PM

Offline
Mar 2017
30
irteris said:


deadoptimist said:

And nothing was done to explain just why Nina insisted so much on her relationship with him. It was actually ok for her to choose love over other stuff - she was a 17 y.o. girl and she wanted to date, not war or politics, she had kept her decisions personal for the most part too, so her running to the king's help could be a beautiful scene, something like a revolt of a neutral character. But we had to see why she valued that love so much for that to work. And personally, I didn't. .


When Favaro told her to choose between the asshole king and the world and she answers, without an ounce of hesitation that she chose him... man that is really disappointing. I get that she's a teenager in love with her hormones maxed but SERIOUSLY this is the fate of the f*cking world we talking about. you mother, family, your friends, everybody is less important than that one asshole you KISSED ONCE FFS! That's why I was hoping them both to die on the dromos, it fitted the theme of her choosing him over the world.


For the record, Nina did not stop Charioce from using Dromos to kill Bahamut so does it really matter he chose him? When she said his name I thought she was going to stop him for the purpose of saving him and forget Bahamut killing off everyone (I immediately thought 'what a stupid choice' but...)instead she supported him by having a will to die with him. This may not be correct but maybe Nina at that time, although she knows Charioce's actions before are despicable, thought that right decision would be to believe in him at that particular moment. Kaisar thought so too. In that situation, only Charioce has the means to stop Bahamut and that he's responsibility, of course.

Or maybe I am reading too much into the scene. Nina is crazy in love with him undeniably and she could have decided solely based on that feeling.

Who knows what the writers have in mind while writing this ugh. Really wanted to save this story, like my brain is literally finding every little detail just to salvage this fucking show. This was supposedly to be an epic anime having so much potential. Ugh this is frustrating.
Oct 1, 2017 10:11 PM

Offline
Nov 2013
82
Was watching this with my bro and we're really just disappointed with the ending OTL

Charioce didn't get his just-deserts AT ALL.
And it's... slightly annoying D; Especially since Kaisar went and got himself killed (and then zombified.)

Overall the whole season was nice, but in the end Nina's and Charioce's relationship kinda got annoying. Amira's and Favaro's relationship seemed to have been much better built and was more realistic : <

Ah well.
Won't be watching it again but I don't regret it.

Genesis was better 8V
Oct 1, 2017 10:38 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
201
This anime was the perfect example of how amazing art, effects, backgrounds and fighting scenes can't save a poorly-written story, with uninteresting characters and repetitive themes in its story. The ending was just as bad as the entire second half, I'm glad it ended: 3/10, probably one the most disappointing anime of the year for me, considering how much I liked the prequel.
"Doubting everything that you take on... That is very important. Open your own eyes, clear out your ears, and look and listen to the world... And think using your own brain. After you've doubted everything, there is a possibility of something real to believe in. To believe in something, doubt everything."

Oct 1, 2017 11:57 PM
Offline
Sep 2017
3
Feels like the show runners completely forgot what the viewers liked about the first season, and replaced it all with random characters just to get the story moving and feeling different. Well it worked, but the result was alienating the original viewing audience while bringing in a whole different audience, resulting in a lot of conflicting opinions. If anything, the finale tried to rectify the situation by giving both audiences what they wanted. The anti-Nina audience got to see Nina lose her voice, which will probably lead to her main character status going back to Favaro. Whereas the pro-Nina audience got to see Nina and the King get a happy ending of sorts, with both alive and happy. As someone who was against the treatment of the original cast being made background characters with little screen time, the finale has made me at least want to watch a season 3 with the hope that the original cast will return and the Nina supporters can be satisfied that she got her happy ending. Lets hope S3 happens so that we can see a real conclusion to Favoro's journey.
Oct 2, 2017 1:13 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
1260
Been rewatching some scene from S01 on YouTube, and noticed some stuff I completely forgot about. I always found that Nina obsessing so much over her dances with Charioce felt a bit too forced, but that changed when I came across this scene:

Another thing that really stands out is this scene is the music and the overall atmosphere in the inn. It feels more authentically medieaval, but it also adresses one of my early points of critique on S02.

I've always said, from around S02E05 or something, that the world felt "off". There was a king, nobles were mentioned (and appeared sporadically), but there was no courtly life. In fact, the entire metropolic capital of Anatae felt lifeless, as did the rest of the world. "A core without a periphery" I called it. It was forgivable, because it allowed more focus (and budget) on the characters that mattered and the story. That said, the above scene from S01 made me realise that it (S01) did not have that flaw. The inn's, the city, every place Favaro and Kaisar visited, felt like it was inhabited or used to be inhabited by a thriving population that went about their daily business. Meanwhile S02 only has a baker (with massive plot armour), that seems to have been forcibly inserted precisely to compensate for this lack of life, and create the impression that Nina & Co. have a home in Anatae.

yaya_90 said:
https://cutie-bowiex.tumblr.com/post/165937358839/decided-to-address-a-few-points-some-keep-bringing << Read this post to give a better understanding of Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul.


Good post, but lol, a reference would have been appreciated:

"I'm a middle schooler bartender!"
- Mishima Hitomi
Oct 2, 2017 3:05 AM
Offline
Apr 2017
27
Well, for me it’s not that Charioce basically wins in the end but the way the story frames it that is the problem. My favorite style of literature is grim dark fantasy (books by Martin, Abercrombie, Bakker, Lawrence and so on). In these works there are practically no real heroes, everyone is gray, our protagonist do terrible things, good people suffer monstrous fates and villains far worse than Charioce actually triumph in the end. But endings of these works are meant to be thought provoking, meant to make the reader uncomfortable, to rattle our sense of morality, to make us see how life is hard and often unfear. The story doesn’t try to sugarcoat the actions of its characters. Virgin soul is bending over backwards and jumping through hoops to excuse Charioces actions and it has harmed the story and most of its characters. One blatant example is what is done with Els death. Charioce gave the order for El to be killed on sight. He never recants the order; he confirms it several times, even torments Jeanne with it. The only reason Alessand does it is because he knows it will please the king and the onyx knights. Charioce is as guilty as Alessand, yet Alessand is made a scapegoat and Charioce completely washed of any wrong doings. Even worse, Favaro is made to go out of character and basically turned into mouthpiece for Charioce propaganda. And very serious issues like slavery, oppression, genocide, circle of hatred, racism, and tyranny are just hand waved away at the end. The scene where demons are still doing backbreaking work for humans for a pittance (they are still wearing rags) is downright insulting. Instead they should have shown humans helping the demons and gods rebuild their respective homes. There is no way that the gods and demons would just let all this slide without any reparations. At the very least Charioce would be forced to abdicate. Even humans would not regard Charioce as a hero once Jeanne made it known he was the one to release Bahamut in the first place. It would also make sense for there to be a heir prepared to replace Charioce, he did plan to die. So have some young cousin sit on the throne with Jeanne as mentor/regent. She is respected by both gods and humans and can facilitate lasting peace. She is now also connected with Azazel. It was Els wish to bring peace to the world, something that Janne can get Azazel to get behind. And voila, the characters of Jeanne, Azazel and El are not pointless in the end, there is a relatively logical way to bring about proper peace in the future and Nina and Charioce can have their bittersweet ending living together in Ninas village or something.
Couple this ending with shallow romance, plot holes, misused characters, anticlimactic defeat of Bahamut and all the other issues people have brought up on the forum and this has becomes a bad show despite the very promising start, just like Kado which I also had the misfortune of watching this year :(
Oct 2, 2017 3:41 AM
Offline
Sep 2008
6
mnedel said:
Virgin soul is bending over backwards and jumping through hoops to excuse Charioces actions and it has harmed the story and most of its characters.


Other than the example you brought up, the issue also lies with nearly everyone of the cast projecting their image onto Charioce and trying to find good in a character that is all the time stoic and unmoving. In the end those projections become reality with Charioce trying to destroy the ultimate evil in this universe, therefore being redeemed. This was quite disappointing as I hoped for everyone's projections to be smashed instead of confirmed, as it is the case in most good literature.

Even worse, Favaro is made to go out of character and basically turned into mouthpiece for Charioce propaganda. And very serious issues like slavery, oppression, genocide, circle of hatred, racism, and tyranny are just hand waved away at the end.


I feel the same and, in the end, am reminded of teenage fanfic writing and not of a professional story. Instead of having the characters act the way they are by letting them deal with the world you put them in, the writer(s) decided to bend the rules of the world to fit the characters or leave major issues unresolved.

Oct 2, 2017 4:31 AM
Offline
Aug 2017
8
Out of every anime couple I'v ever seen and I have seen some f*cked up anime couples chiroic and nina is the absolute worst at the ending I was hoping nina would finally just f*ck over and die with her mass murdering f*ck boi but no "happy ending la la land" I actually hate nina more than chiroic I didn't care if chiroic survived and only nina died that heartless one night stand didn't even cry when her friends died
nina: oh mugaro just died yeah happens all the time no big deal nina: Well there goes kaisar no biggie and the reason I called nina a one night stand is because trust me it would not last with chiroic first it was azazel then kaizar now chiroic and did you notice the second she moved from guy to guy the previous crush would die and she wouldnt mourn btw the grammar in this is god awful I'm just too damn pissed to correct my typing right now
Oct 2, 2017 4:33 AM
Offline
Aug 2017
8
Mouloxas said:
Genesis does NOT have a sequel. It never got one. Don't you dare say otherwise.

Baiting for a season 3 of this crap??? Mappa, just don't...

I feel you man there was no sequel
Oct 2, 2017 4:52 AM

Offline
Jan 2014
905
What the fuck was that??? What a load of bullshit.

This show does not exist. PERIOD.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Oct 2, 2017 5:37 AM
🥊 CHAMPION 🥊

Offline
Apr 2016
23507
We will have a new seaon, with a Zombie-Kaiser!!! kekeke
Oct 2, 2017 5:51 AM
Offline
Jul 2016
393
WhyThoe said:
Mouloxas said:
Genesis does NOT have a sequel. It never got one. Don't you dare say otherwise.

Baiting for a season 3 of this crap??? Mappa, just don't...

I feel you man there was no sequel


Yeah, tell me about it. People here are literally protecting fantasy Hitler and i can't understand why? I mean, he didn't even achieve anything in the end, and yet, he is regarded as a hero. He practically broke Bahamut's seal just to seal him again. WTF? Don't even get me started on how Jeanne and Azazel completely forgot about killing him afterwards. Or heck, even some random demon or angel or human for that matter. They had a scene near the end where they showed all the races helping each other out, where they mentioned that things aren't really peaceful between them, they still can't forgive, let bygones be bygones. AND YET, NO ONE SEEMS TO HAVE A PROBLEM WITH THE TYRANT RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERYTHING??? WTF X2? They sure had no problem killing Alessand like that, that's for certain. The writer decided to focus on king genocide (who changed personalities every 2 episodes for no reason and somehow ended up with no personality whatsoever) and couldn't even make his actions at least somewhat meaningful. You've killed the Bahamut anime franchise anyways, at least see out the story you intended to write FFS. Nooooo, let's destroy the already nonexistent horrible storyline for the sake of cash grabbing sequels. Who knows, people liked the first season, maybe it will sell? If not, the game will sell? Maybe Manaria friends will sell?

Oh and hey, let's kill off one of our most iconic characters, Kaisar, and have him spout some inconsequential nonsense about how death is so peaceful, maybe we will convince people that the king is a good guy. And let's not even show his best friend Favaro react to his death or something. Nooooo, let's just show Favaro hearing Kaisar's voice after the credits for sequel bait. And let's turn Kaisar into a zombie and render the impact of his death completely pointless. Even Favaro was trying to brainwash us about the king and how he's actually a good guy... Let's not even talk about the show's general mood and direction...

Let's also have Nina (aka: horny teenage dragon) tell Favaro that she chooses to save the king (for some freaking reason) and not the world in order to create parallels with Favaro's situation with Amira (the romance bits were one of the few things that weren't good in Genesis, so why even bother do that?) from season 1. And yet they somehow both make it out just fine and get their happy ending, thus completely destroying any meaning the scene with Favaro and Nina could have held... I don't even know what the hell Virgin Soul was supposed to be in the end...

And these are my complaints for the final episode only... There would be no end if i started talking about the entirety of this series...
MouloxasOct 2, 2017 12:15 PM
Oct 2, 2017 7:23 AM
Offline
Jul 2017
41
There was a mistranslation in Kaisar's last words. He didn't say to Charioce "It's so peaceful" he said "Bring true peace" in Japanese and the eng sub got that wrong. The line makes much more sense now.

Pages (7) « First ... « 2 3 [4] 5 6 » ... Last »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Stark700 - Apr 14, 2017

118 by ilNico »»
Sep 27, 8:28 PM

Poll: » Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul Episode 20 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Stark700 - Sep 1, 2017

99 by latght »»
Dec 12, 2023 4:06 PM

» When does this epic series return?

NexCore - Apr 7, 2022

8 by GraviticF7L »»
Oct 7, 2023 7:20 PM

Poll: » Shingeki no Bahamut: Virgin Soul Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Stark700 - Jun 30, 2017

112 by HagePotPotato »»
Sep 21, 2023 3:45 PM

» A Question..

L-Lawliet7 - Feb 9, 2023

2 by Aotfangirl »»
Feb 15, 2023 6:16 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login